Jump to content
Sir Rahul

Rahul W's rating predictions

Recommended Posts

9 hours ago, Floodstreet2017 said:

Based on your predictions, Tolisso who has started 7 games in all competitions since the last round of changes will get a 92 as will Rudy?

Im not picking on anyone’s opinion but for me they aren’t even two of Bayern’s best midfielders. If they played every single minute of the season who is to say they are deserving of a higher rating. 

But you deemed Mbappe and Dembele not to to be worthy of a rating increase? I think both of the latter will definitely rise as both criminally underrated.

Dembele superstar potential and made 10 maybe 11 starts in all competitions since the last changes but you think Tolisso who is an ok player and made 7 starts will get 92? 

he probably won't. preds were done about a month back.

fair enough mate, you make good points.

9 hours ago, Gaelgoir said:

Just going to add my opinion cause I think Rahul was well within his rights to say what he did. 

I'm sure Rahul knows he doesn't get 100% right and he's never said he does. But it does take time and effort that alot wouldn't be able to do.

Asking people to stop posting multiple names that have already been given preds is fair I think. 

While debates I think are healthy, I've seen recently and not just in this prediction thread that people are being told their predictions are poor and so on. Maybe the posters who are critical should give the ratings a bash for us to see. I'd genuinly be interested in what they had to say and thought across the board. 

And finally I think I speak for most readers of the forum that we appreciate the hard work put in by rahul, monolithic and others. It's a great reference point to use while we research players.

yep thanks

9 hours ago, Soccahappy said:

Rahul, Monolithic & others are doing a great job on here & should be given nothing but respect & thanks.

Criticism however slight has a way of discouraging reviewers over time & in the end great forumers disappear. It's happened b4, many times & many, many are long gone & much missed.

cheers

9 hours ago, SanchoJr said:

Looks like I've joined the thread at a fragile time 😬

Just hoping somebody could point me in the right direction to see Rahul's most reasent predictions for top 5 leagues?

much appreciated 👍🏻

first page, cheers

9 hours ago, Tharanidharan said:

Hello all, in one of the Gameworlds I play, one manager is selling N'ZONZI at 20M.

 I've now two options -

1.) I can sign him without any competition (or) 

2.) Find some other CM from external. But I've a problem. I've very low budget and I'm pretty sure I might lose to rich clubs. Following are players available in external market :

VECINO, A. HERRERA, JOAO MARIO, WIJNALDUM, KRAMER, SORIANO

  

Kindly advise me whether to go for safe option (N'ZONZI) or go to war with rich clubs.

Will N'Zonzi stay at 91 till next review? 

 

Rating predictions for Joao Mario - Can he keep his 91?

I know he had a terrible season but any chance he might improve next season? Is he a safe bet?

Wijnaldum would be good, if not N'Zonzi. but depends where he goes in summer.

Mario may not keep, again future is uncertain.

8 hours ago, Tharanidharan said:

@Sir Rahul is this the latest one (May 2018) or old one?  Because the post says 25th October 2016?

is updated as mentioned earlier

8 hours ago, domP said:

is there a potential decent/good low cost RB if i say:

Ruben Aguilar (Montpellier)

Fankaty Dabo (Chelsea on loan to VItesse)

Kingsley Ehizibue (Zwolle)

Tyronne Ebuehi (Den Haag)

Vyacheslav KARAVAEV (Vitesse)

Martin AGUIRREGABIRIA (Alaves)

Ebuehi off to Benfica apparently 

Dabo could get 83

Aguirregabiria set for a decent rise too

6 hours ago, thorgan lesar said:

I'm not unhappy. I'm defending @Sir Rahul

haha cheers

8 hours ago, TMCosta said:

Martin Montoya...he really gonna get 89? Im not so confident...and i want to sell him.

maybe, can't guarantee

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, thorgan lesar said:

Sorry, but I have also a little list.

It's mind-breaking :), but how should my midfield be next season ?

'6': Julian Weigl, Rodri Hernàndez & Diadie Samassékou

'8': Max Meyer, Youri Tielemans & Amadou Haidara

"10": Thomas Lemar & Giovanni Lo Celso

 

8 players for 3 positions is too much. The thing that I certainly want to know is "Has Rodri Hernàndez the potential to break through as nr.6 from Spain ?"

 

I don't want to lose Samassékou and Haidara, because the team that I have is RB Salzburg and I want a connection with the real RB Salzburg in my team.

Should I loan Haidara and/or Samassékou out or ... ?

Keep in mind that Houssem Aouar will rise for sure to 86/87 and with him I will have immediately another option. 

 

Thanks :)

I'd keep Rodri for now

6 hours ago, Gaelgoir said:

With Howedes possibly dropping from 91 to 90 and Hysaj likely to rise from 90 to 91. 

Is giving Howedes and 2m a good decision to get hysaj. Bearing in mind that left backs are like gold dust in the world

Hysaj

4 hours ago, Yuasa said:

Jose gimenez or bailly?

Bailly, but I am biased

4 hours ago, hesselink said:

Review of top 5, include review of players on loans outside these leagues?

nope not inclusive

3 hours ago, hesselink said:

Jorginho or Kolasinac+L.Vazquez?

Jorginho

3 hours ago, SpanishConq said:

I'm not asking for ratings. I know where to find those. Just wondering how people would rank these

Aaron Martin (Caricol), Nico Elvedi, Timo Baumgartl, Niklas Stark.

Probably in that same order, haha

2 hours ago, crvena_zvezda said:

Thanks guys, much appreciated.

And to add my opinion to the discussion, I also think it was a lack of respect. The predictions lists are created for people to refer to, its just laziness to post a list of tons of players.

Before anyone says about my list of 10 players, I was asking for opinions on them not ratings. ;)

thanks

1 hour ago, ProfeQuintero said:

Thoughts on Vinicius?  When he will rise?  Listed as Real Madrid player.  

Too expensive at 7mil?

no rise

1 hour ago, Hosein ElTimimi said:

When there are so many bids on a free agent player, is it completely random to which club the player will go?

Is having many players in my team pretending the player to come to my team?

there's an algorithm I don't understand

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Would you sell Mbappé right now for 37 M and get Salah for 28 M (he is incredibly free, not so crowded game world...) ?

Yeah, a bit of crazy selling Mbappé, but Salah...

I thought also I could wait after French review and try to earn more from Mbappé.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
50 minutes ago, lobanovski said:

Would you sell Mbappé right now for 37 M and get Salah for 28 M (he is incredibly free, not so crowded game world...) ?

Yeah, a bit of crazy selling Mbappé, but Salah...

I thought also I could wait after French review and try to earn more from Mbappé.

 
  •  

Are there any other players you could sell instead of Mbappe? He’s a rare talent and highest 91 I’ve ever seen at 18/19 years old. Probable 92 soon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, lobanovski said:

Would you sell Mbappé right now for 37 M and get Salah for 28 M (he is incredibly free, not so crowded game world...) ?

Yeah, a bit of crazy selling Mbappé, but Salah...

I thought also I could wait after French review and try to earn more from Mbappé.

 
  •  

nope, Mbappe

but not a bad deal either way

11 minutes ago, jonhyscp said:

Laporte 91 or stay?

stay

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh man, a big dog just quit and all his players are up for grabs. It is going to get real messy soon. Here is a list of the kind of players he had:

L.MESSI

T.KROOS

A.GRIEZMAN

D.DE GEA

V.MARCELO

A.VIDAL

K.BENZEMA

T.MÜLLER

Á.DI MARÍA

P.DYBALA

R.VARANE

A.SANDRO

N.KEÏTA

 

INSANE

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, shaoshao said:

Oh man, a big dog just quit and all his players are up for grabs. It is going to get real messy soon. Here is a list of the kind of players he had:

L.MESSI

T.KROOS

A.GRIEZMAN

D.DE GEA

V.MARCELO

A.VIDAL

K.BENZEMA

T.MÜLLER

Á.DI MARÍA

P.DYBALA

R.VARANE

A.SANDRO

N.KEÏTA

 

INSANE

Only that players? Where's the best of all times?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, jonhyscp said:

And who of this u contract for his place:
- Alessio Romagnoli;
- Stefan De Vrij;
- Emre Can; or
- Kostas Manolas?

hmm, maybe Manolas

12 hours ago, SpanishConq said:

Is it safe to assume vertonghen is good to stay at 92 for the next year or so? He's had a good year hasnt he?

yes safe

11 hours ago, JAMancini said:

Choose only 2:

Firmino, Mane or Icardi

 

Thanks!

Firmino Icardi

9 hours ago, shaoshao said:

Oh man, a big dog just quit and all his players are up for grabs. It is going to get real messy soon. Here is a list of the kind of players he had:

L.MESSI

T.KROOS

A.GRIEZMAN

D.DE GEA

V.MARCELO

A.VIDAL

K.BENZEMA

T.MÜLLER

Á.DI MARÍA

P.DYBALA

R.VARANE

A.SANDRO

N.KEÏTA

 

INSANE

amazing

7 hours ago, ProfeQuintero said:

I see that Rahul predicts Lewis Dunk for a rise to 87.  He started in 37 matches.

 

Any chance for 88?

Who is the better purchase?  Dunk or Timo Baumgartl 85–> 87?

don't see 88 happening

Baumgartl

5 hours ago, Franklyn said:

I need help. Should I swap my J.Bruma for Y.Gerhardt? 

Wolfsburg could be going down, honestly I don't prefer either

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Middle_Finger said:

Players that you predicted to get rise if their teams get relegated do you still think will get it? As in - 

X+5 but they got relegated will they still expect X to get +5?

For the big 5 leagues they should, not necessarily for the minor leagues though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 26/06/2017 at 9:08 PM, Sir Rahul said:

GREECE SUPER LEAGUE

AEK Athens:

Bakkakis +3 to 83- yes

Anestis +2 to 82- yes

Tsinsotas +2 to 80- yes

Kone -1 to 84- -2 to 83

Galanopoulos +2 to 80- +4 to 82

Christodoulopoulos +1 to 86

Araujo +1 to 86

Vranjes +1 to 85

Galo +1 to 84

Lopes +1 to 84

Bakasetas +1 to 84

Chygrynskiy +1 to 84

Hult -1 to 84

 

PAOK:

Prijovic +1 to 86- yes

El Kaddouri -1 to 86- yes

Canas -1 to 85- yes

Limnios +2 to 82- yes

Vierinha -1 to 87- -2 to 86

Pelkas +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Paschalakis +2 to 82- +3 to 83

Azevedo -1 to 84- -2 to 83

Matos +1 to 85

Crespo +1 to 85

 

Olympiakos:

Mirallas -1 to 88- yes

Ansarifard +1 to 85- yes

Nikolaou +4 to 80- yes

Martins -1 to 86- -2 to 85

Cisse +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Koutris +4 to 84- +2 to 82

Proto +1 to 86

Odjidja-Ofoe +1 to 86

not as generous with the top teams, no surprise.

Greece should be done tomorrow, Championship starting tomorrow too.

They did Blackburn today.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On Friday, May 11, 2018 at 10:27 PM, Hosein ElTimimi said:

When there are so many bids on a free agent player, is it completely random to which club the player will go?

Is having many players in my team pretending the player to come to my team?

I had recently won N'Golo Kante. With same amount of 37 million euros he has chosen mine team, because on the position of Kanté I have only E.Can and L.Torreira. He had better players. 

Mostly they chose the team where "they think" they have more minutes then the other

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×