Jump to content

Leaderboard


Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation since 12/12/2018 in all areas

  1. 4 points
    Middle_Finger

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    SM is back! Reviewed over 20 players and touched 4-5 clubs.
  2. 4 points
    Kev

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I'd keep Casemiro for now, unless you can get a good replacement with that money. It's a surprise, maybe they haven't finished with them yet. Difficult to tell with the way SM are reviewing at the moment! Probably just down to Bayern not doing that well, also hasn't started several games. Think they'll follow Germany when SM have finished there in 2023 or whatever? Should be fine, yeah. I'd go for Kolasinac if you can. Rakitic the best of those 3. Not sure about rumoured moves just yet (anything more than mere speculation anyway), but the way he's going he could hit 92+ in a few years and bigger clubs will be keeping an eye on him for sure. Yeah, buy him. Premier League clubs, and especially someone like Liverpool, have a higher rating cap than most, and if SM was real time (rather than twice a year) then he's be higher than 87 now, hence the high price. He'll stay. Tough call. Partey can still rise and has a higher rating now, but Kessie is a few years younger and doing well. Depends on the current needs of your club, but I'd maybe just go for Kessie. Might be worth a punt as a free agent. He could well increase next review, but it won't be major. You'll make a profit either way. I use Ndombele as a central attacking mid in a 4-2-3-1 formation and he does well. You could fit the all in a team comfortably.
  3. 4 points
    nofoff

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    With you for most of that but think you're off on a couple things. Totally agree that a players 'preffered' position/attributes have no effect whatsoever on their performances in game. Also with you that it's the higher rated team that will win you games the majority of time. It's nowhere near 90% of the time though imo. Formations still come into play and so do things like 'attacking down both flanks' if a team is playing a narrow formation for example. There's some great 'counter formations' that I've found over a number of years playing the game (still working on a bunch of them) and although you can't perform miracles by using them, they do increase your chances of getting points from games when your team is out matched
  4. 3 points
    Damien1990

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Jesus was very lucky to get 92 last season. He is very young though so I'd keep and can see him possibly getting another undeserved rise in future. For me he's not on the level of Sterling or Sane yet.
  5. 3 points
    vitor_mfc

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    He was lucky to get 92, never mind a rating increase in near future, he was not even on the level of the young forwards that got 92 last season (Mbappe, Sane, Sterling) and this season proves it.
  6. 3 points
    hesselink

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Kessie - younger & playing more. Buy him, I expect to jump when Spanish review start. (like last year) +1 maybe #1 Allan - Best player. But, SM is not overly devoted to these players. Reality is one, SM is second. #2.1 Brozovic - i don't like him, but probably get +1 (WC performance) #2.2 Zielinski - finally plays regularly, I expect +1 at the end of the season #3 Pellegrini & Kessie - for me unconvincingly yet. Lucky, they're still young. Too soon for me. Luka Jovic. Yes. It depends on what kind of championship you play? Is money important, what is the competition? Is your starter or replacement? Hm, i would go for Eder Militao. He quickly emerged in Europe. D(C) - are always at a price! I'm skeptical about Neres, I doubt he could explode in a stronger club.
  7. 3 points
    Ersavitzs

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    No. Mario Hermoso maybe.
  8. 2 points
    1000dB

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    If soccerwiki is to be believed Spain's review will follow Italy. England would be the last review of the big 5.
  9. 2 points
    Soccahappy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Hi Kratick, Hope the above is helpful for you. Cap is easily explained, it is the highest rated player at any club (If he is 90 rated the Club cap is 90 rated UNTIL SM change it). It doesn't happen often but when SM increased Skhiri & Lecomt to 88 THIS review, they increased the Cap at Montpellier to 88) Re Profit ... Wages rarely are a problem if you sell for a profit and don't keep them too long. E.g Lets look at Hakimi 3million profit and his wages are 280k for 10 weeks, 560k for 20weeks BUT when you sell 10M Hakimi for an 11M Bid you make an EXTRA PROFIT of 1M and Only if you keep him say appx 40weeks do you start making LESS than the 3m original profit. That's why I particularly like young expensive players. So really you can ignore wages. Higher rated players also bring in higher margins sometimes as much as 32m player bid 38m (6m profit). Hope that helps...
  10. 2 points
    Soccahappy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I'm keeping him Hesselink. IMO yes he has lost his original flamboyance and become a little overawed with the players round him at the moment but this will pass. I'm confident he will mature into a great player and goal scorer for Man C in time. He's only 21. Just one page of the German review results from my spreadsheet. French review Profit ended up at 119m and Germany very similar 121m.
  11. 2 points
    kratick

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I had the same problem with Immobile. Fantastic in Serie A but really struggled in my team. Finally ended up trading him and realised it was a mistake. If you believe Jesus will get upgrades, keep him. Over many matches the goals will come.
  12. 2 points
    Middle_Finger

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    In SM everything works. Try Alisson and Ederson together.
  13. 2 points
    Cam Lucas

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    At 89 players arent too bad, i rotate through the cup games and the occasional bench appearance and as of yet no issues. Its when they hit 90 in my experience you cant keep 3x1 position happy.
  14. 2 points
    Kev

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    It seems ridiculous that he's 95 compared to other strikers in the PL, but it also seems unfair to drop him while he's scoring so much. Difficult to know what SM will do, I'd edge towards stay. He seems to be getting more game time under the new manager. It's down to whether you can get a decent alternative really. If it's purely a money making decision then might as well sell, can't see him rising this review. Pulisic looks like he'll be moving either in January or summer, and PL looks a likely destination. Not sure if that helps... He'll be linked with Man Utd, but they'll end up buying Danny Drinkwater instead. Militao has played for the Brazil national team already, and Porto are doing really well so could get good rises. That's more short term I guess, long term it's tough to call.
  15. 2 points
    Bear Alba

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Tough one. Lots of hype for both. Don’t think you can go wrong either way. Not seen much of militao. TMcosta’s your man for that. Watching Ajax in champs league Neres looks very skilful and knows where the goal is. Would prob go for him.
  16. 2 points
    TMCosta

    TMCosta X Files

    UKRAINE Name Club SM Value 1M MAX SM Rat 76 MAX Age 21MAX Minutes 1 Vladyslav Vakula Mariupol 200 k 68 19 1061 74 2 Vladyslav Dubinchak Arsenal Kyiv 340 k 75 20 1436 72 3 Vitaliy Mykolenko Dynamo Kyiv 340 k 75 19 948 68 4 Luis Felipe Zorya 220 k 70 21 720 63 5 Pimenta Martha FC Lviv 260 k 73 21 848 63 6 Pedro Fernando Shakhtar Donetsk 240 k 70 19 466 63 7 Mikola Musolitin Chornomorets Odessa 360 k 76 19 778 62 9 Bogdan Lednev Zorya 300 k 73 20 629 62 10 Yuri Romanyuk Chornomorets Odessa 340 k 75 21 810 60 11 Stefan Jevtoski Arsenal Kyiv 340 k 76 21 801 59 12 Maxime do Couto Olimpik Donetsk 220 k 73 21 628 59 13 Vladyslav Supriaha Dynamo Kyiv 300 k 73 18 197 57 14 Danylo Karas Arsenal Kyiv 240 k 73 21 584 57 15 Nazariy Rusyn Dynamo Kyiv 300 k 73 20 248 55
  17. 2 points
    Sir Rahul

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    true, at the rate they're doing this he'll have played 10 games at LB when they review
  18. 2 points
    hesselink

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I only think that if he continue to play more matches in that position - D(L) is not unrealistic.
  19. 2 points
    Sir Rahul

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    hmm, do you have cover for Casemiro? yep fullbacks don't really matter, as long as you have a decent one. ratings are usually 6-7, nothing more. yes may keep for now obviously Kessie lol no turns 20 next week, still has time on his side and is doing fairly well for his age Ndombele in real life, hmm. fourth option could work hmm, perhaps Allan Tough one, maybe Fabian maybe not so soon too soon but I have him so who's complaining yeah
  20. 2 points
    The punch

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    + sancho
  21. 2 points
    Tharanidharan

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Casemiro is a great DM. I'd would this deal only if I have proper cover for Casemiro or else hold on to him. He's worth 16M. Kessie
  22. 2 points
    Bear Alba

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Andreas skov Olsen. 18 years old. scored 11 goals in 19 appearances in his first season in the danish superliga. Efthymios koulouris. 22 years old. 11 goals in 12 games for Atromitos who are currently 2nd in the Greek super league.
  23. 2 points
    kratick

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I have to disagree here. Because I've tried many times to play Centre backs as wing backs for example some one like Gimenez who has a D(RC) against him as my right back and i've got really bad average performances from that. When i replace him with someone like Azpi or Carvajal and similarly Alaba or Sandro at LB positions, they have an immediate impact with many more assists. I think it makes a difference if the opponent is also playing the right guys in the right positions.
  24. 2 points
    kratick

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    It won't flag up as wrong. However the attributes of a DM is different from a CM. Check out the attributes in Soccerwiki of Kante vs a CM like mIlinkovic Savic. Kante has attributes like marking, tackling and long passing that are more useful for a DM than a CM. Even though you can play Savic as a DM, his performance won't be as consistent as someone like Kante
  25. 2 points
    Kev

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Ndombele I'd try and keep both, difficult to split them for me. Havertz is a way better score in Scrabble than Aouar though, so maybe he edges it. It does seem harsh. I was expecting the Argentinian review in January, but SM really need to speed up for that to happen. Could be Feb/March unless they sort it out. I think so. I'd sell in that scenario. Big chance that he'll drop I think. Unlikely, but he's still fairly young so not totally out of the question. Yes, go for that exchange.
×