Jump to content

Leaderboard


Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation since 12/04/2019 in Posts

  1. 12 points
    olivier 1

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    As Germany normally follows the French review, here is my prediction. Cheers
  2. 10 points
    Soccahappy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Another upload update below:- Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be. Remember ATM we are only a dozen plus games into Big 5 Leagues. I am concentrating mainly on Younger under 89 rated players as these are more consistent risers and more profitable, Goal keepers are dealt with by SM in a completely different way, which is why I also ignore Gk's. Ok a few updates. Unfortunately most of the Real top clubs don't have many that fit the criteria ratings or age wise, but Bayern, Tottenham. Atletico have a few between them. Think, Winks should get his in view of his International caps and playing more regular for Spurs recently, so haven't red that box, Mascarell might also. More tomorrow hopefully, interesting also to see which french risers SM like in the morning. I'll have to take time off soon to get christmas cards, gifts, family etc sorted... Usual thanks for all the great support, much appreciated Forumers. I've been denied likes & thanks for 24hours again, happens regularly must be Scrooge season at SM 😟😩☹️ Never Mind 😃
  3. 9 points
    Sir Rahul

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Used to do it bit by bit yes, I'm not in any GW currently so it's more difficult for me to track when I do have some free time. That being said, hope I can return to doing them for the summer preds.
  4. 9 points
    Soccahappy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    More examples of French Players risers so far etc. I WILL be doing a "best of France list" when French review is totally finished:- Obviously NOT 100% correct but i wasn't expecting that. Interesting as u can see Gnagnon dropped -1. I actually sold both him and Gelin because I thought from these stats neither would rise. It actually saved me 3million as u see, a benefit I hadn't even thought about! The Red boxes warning saved me from buying Traore or Bourigard, tho I did think Traore would rise. Disappointed Diallo didn't go up +4 or +5. I must think of a way to ammend the formula where it predicts 81's and 84's which SM so seldom use, in contrast to 80, 82, 83 and 85. Shouldn't be difficult, but I leave all these thoughts til after BIG5 Review is totally finished. Very disappointed CAMAVINGA got a really mean +3. Hoping to get another upload at some point today but I will be watching Chelsea while Recording Leeds and I think there's another big match at 5pm as well! So it may be late tho I have started it already. Otherwise tomorrow... Hope u find the above interesting... Also gonna see if SM have given me some more "Likes and Thanks" to spread yet!
  5. 9 points
    Soccahappy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Well I totally agree swansea I will be up in arms if he gets less than 84 😫 Another upload below:- Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be. Remember ATM we are only a dozen plus games into Big 5 Leagues. Previous predictions on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784.785,786,787, 788, 789, 790, 791, 792...793 (Three!) 794, 795, 796... Didn't realise until this morning England Premiership clubs are playing midweek and weekend matches this week. So slight change in plan I'll get the new England stats I need into my spreadsheet starting late sunday into monday and do it in one big go. Then hopefully France MIGHT be near finishing and England MIGHT be 2nd. From now until then I'll use each day making progress on the other the other Leagues in case it's NOT England. So More tomorrow B4 6pm if I'm not delayed, but am out at some point in the day so might be delayed again. Thanks again for all your support, sorry for the upload glitches around midday. Think I've got an answer for that one now ie "split it into 2 and it doesn't go crazy"...Also had some stats still in there for 2 players from last seasons games for relegated Guingamp, please ignore them, I've deleted them from my spreadsheet. Ps Forgot to mention SW showed players going thru today from. Lille, Lyon, Nantes, Rennes and Reims. Also on his own, Adama Traore who I've got as a +2. I wonder if it's SM doing that trick of anticipating good risers ahead of time, u could call them front-Runners 😊
  6. 4 points
    Sounds almost as bad as Badiashile's rise. Whoever is in charge of the Ligue 1 review needs to get sacked.
  7. 4 points
    Well, we're currently at Ligue 1 and looks like it's Serie A next. Then you have PL, Bundesliga and La Liga in no particular order. They inexplicably skipped the second divisions of the top 5 (except England) so hopefully they will be after top 5. Then you have Argentina, Holland and Portugal in no particular order. Just a prediction judging by how they've done it before. It will be some time. Ramsey for sure.
  8. 3 points
    Milanista1

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Thank you for getting back to us. Long-term: Kane Short-term: Lewandoski. Lewa could just possibly hit 97 at the end of this season (merely by his individual performances/achievements with B.M), but I doubt it as with BM not dominating as much this season (which is nice to see), and SM's unfairness towards some players (which isn't nice to see). No no.. That would be too harsh of SM as he's still young and unfortunately has a long term injury. Although we must consider that SM are not as predictable these days which really sucks for all of us (especially for the likes of Soccahappy/Sir Rahul and the other hard working managers who share their predictions on here).😕
  9. 2 points
    oronzodd

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    sorry but IMO your comment is pointless. the point is: why SM did review only those few ajax player before the whole eredivisie? why SM didn't review also inter, salzburg, benfica given that all those teams are actually also in first position in portugal, austria and italy and third in their champions league group? why you need to use the word whining to someone that just like many others in this forum is exposing the bad timing in SM review of ajax best players?
  10. 2 points
    vitor_mfc

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Says the guy who is doubting a teams ratings after game... What did you expect? For them to be playing at the same level after losing their two best/most influential players? They are 1st on Eredivisie and were 3rd on their CL group, just one point behind the 1st and 2nd. Stop whining for no reason.
  11. 2 points
    PSG and Marseille for sure I think Lyon and Rennes were (poorly) reviewed already Don't know about Nantes though
  12. 2 points
    i had him and got rid of him
  13. 2 points
    KERSPALT!

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I'd take Kane. Lewa is unreal but this is SM, if you're playing the long game you need to get Kane. Bayern are doing crap so it's hard to see an already highly rated player rise again. I could see only two players rising for Bayern, Gnabry and A Davies. The rest will stay with some dropping.
  14. 2 points
    Soccahappy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Yes TMC 2 errors in 1 from me! First I missed he had risen this morning and previously I'd missed giving him his last game's minutes. I've added them now below. Thanks for letting me know:- So maybe I can't change the 0% point yet, I'll wait and see if N'Soki gets a rise tomorrow... BTW am going to post another Upload hopefully b4 6pm (should do), Thanks again TMC
  15. 2 points
    Milanista1

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Too soon. I think this early into the season only Fab really deserves the rise to 93.
  16. 2 points
    Don’t think Coutinho will get a drop tbh, has done enough to keep his 94
  17. 2 points
    Elizeu Campos

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Please predict at least the top 5 clubs of the big leagues, always help a lot in planning. Thanks for the hard work.
  18. 2 points
  19. 2 points
    zsp2

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Yes, today they did Nimes, Toulouse and Metz
  20. 2 points
    LOL 92 yep but it is the same
  21. 2 points
    Inter: Handanovic stays/+1 to 91/2 Bastoni 83+2/3 to 85/6 De Vrij 91 stays/+1 to 91/2 B. Valero 89-1 to 88 Sensi 88+1 to 89 Candreva 88+1 to 89 L. Martinez 89+1/2 to 90/1 S. Esposito 75+2 to 77 Lukaku 92 stays/+1 to 92/3 Juventus: Szczesney 91 stays/+1 to 91/2 Buffon 90-1 to 89 De Ligt 91 stays/+1 to 91/2 Bentancur 90 stays/+1 to 90/1 Mandzukic 92-1 to 91 Ronaldo 99 to 98 Lazio: Strakosha 89 +1 to 90 Acerbi 89 +1 to 90 Luiz Felipe 86+1/2 to 87/8 Patric 84 +1 to 85 Lazzari 88+1 to 89 Berisha 88-1 to 87 Correa 89+1 to 90 Immobile 92 stays/+1 to 92/3 if he won’t get now with 17 goals and 5 assist he’ll never have Cagliari: Pellegrini 80 +3/4 to 83/4 Pisacane 85+1 to 86 Cacciatore 85+1 to 86 Cigarini 86+1 to 87 Oliva 80+2 to 82 Nainggolan 92 stays-1 to 92/1 Joao Pedro 87 +1/2 to 88/9 Cagliari is the real surprise of Serie A, is difficult predict something, furthermore has many players that are old, so I don’t know if Cigarini, Cacciatore or Pisacane will have a rise Roma: Mancini 88+1 to 89 Cetin 78 + 2 to 80 Florenzi 91-1 to 90 Zaniolo 88+1 to 89 Veretout 89 stays/+1 to 89/90 Kluivert 86+1/2 to 87/8 Z.Celar 70+3 to 73 Atalanta: Gollini 87 + 1 to 88 Sportiello 87-1 to 86 Carnesecchi 75+3 to 78 Bettella 73+3 to 76 Del Prato 75+3 to 78 Djimsiti 86 + 1 to 87 Gosens 87 +1/2 to 88/9 great season for him Pasalic 87+1 to 88 Napoli Meret 87 + 1 to 88 Luperto 83+1 to 84 Di Lorenzo 87 +1/2 to 88/9 Ghoulam 90 -1 to 89 Hysaj 90 -1 to 89 Elmas 85 + 1/2 to 86/7 Parma: Iacoponi 83 +2 to 85 Dermaku 82 + 1 to 83 Hernani 85+1 to 86 Kulusevski 80+4 to 84 Hellas Verona: Silvestri 82+2 to 84 Rramani 83+2 to 85 Kumbulla 76+4 to 80 Zaccagni 83 + 2 to 85 Faraoni 84+1 to 85 Pessina 83 +1/ 2 to 84/5 Amrabat 83+2/3 to 85/6 Salcedo 73 + 7 to 80 Torino: Sirigu 89 + 1 to 90 Bremer 82 + 2 to 84 Aina 86 +1 to 87 Laxalt 89-1 to 88 Berenguer 85 +1 to 86 Millico 73 + 3 to 76 Milan: T. Hernandez 87 + 1 to 88 L. Duarte 83+2 to 85 Pobega 73 + 3 to 76 Bologna: Tomiyasu 83 + 2 to 85 Svanberg 83 + 1 to 84 Orsolini 86 + 1 to 87 Destro 87 -1 to 86 Fiorentina: Dragowski 83 + 3 to 86 Lirola 87 + 1 to 88 Castrovilli 82 + 4 to 86 Pulgar 88 + 1 to 89 Sottil 77 +3 to 80 Vlahovic 78 + 4 to 82 Sassuolo: Muldur 82+1 to 83 Kyriakopoulos 78+3 to 81 Traore 85+1 to 86 Boga 85+2 to 87 Caputo 86+1 to 87 Lecce: Rafael 83 + 1 to 84 Lucioni 82 + 2 to 84 Calderoni 82+2 to 84 Petriccione 83 + 1 to 84 Majer 80+3 to 83 Udinese: Scuffet 85 – 1 to 84 Musso 86 +1 to 87 Becao 83+2 to 85 Jajalo 83+2 to 85 Sema 83 + 2 to 85 Teodorczyk 87-1 to 86 Sampdoria: Murillo 89 – 1 to 88 Vieira 82 + 2 to 84 Depaoli 85 + 1 to 86 Bonazzoli 82 + 1 to 83 Genoa: Radu 85 + 1 to 86 Ghiglione 80 + 4 to 84 Romero 86 + 1 to 87 Agudelo 78+4 to 82 Koaume 86 + 1 (not sure, he has a long injury) Pinamonti 83+2 to 85 Cleonise 70 + 3 to 73 SPAL: Igor 82 +1 to 83 Tomovic 83 +1 to 84 Reca 82 +2 to 84 Strefezza 76 +4 to 80 Brescia: Joronen 83 +1/+2 to 84/85 Chancellor 81 +2 to 83 Sabelli 83 +1 to 84 Mateju 82+1 to 83 Cistana 82 +2 to 84 Mangraviti 73 + 3 to 76 Tonali 85 +1 to 86 big talent Balotelli 90 -1 to 89 he hasn’t good performances, he scored only twice for the last team of the classification
  22. 1 point
    Gumball

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    What would i have expected? I would have expected SM to be sensible enough to wait till the group stages are over before they bloat out the hyped up hipster dream of the champions league. And don't mention the eredivisie. Those type of ratings have never been given in relation to the eredivisie. They never have in this game and they shouldn't either. They are completely champions league related. And you've just proven my point about how stupid their ratings rise were. "What did you expect? For them to be playing at the same level after losing their two best/most influential players?".....no, i didn't, and they haven't. But they've still been pumped up even further rating wise regardless haven't they
  23. 1 point
    Gumball

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Sadio will be 99 in one
  24. 1 point
    Soccahappy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Previous predictions on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784.785,786,787, 788, 789, 790, 791,792,793, 794,795,796,797, 798, 799,800. 801 Be careful of the Reddish boxes where the higher rated players are more inclined towards performances rather than stats. Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be. Remember ATM we are a dozen plus games into Big 5 Leagues. I am concentrating mainly on Younger under 89 rated players as these are more consistent risers and more profitable, Goal keepers are dealt with by SM in a completely different way, which is why I also ignore Gk's Upload of more Italian clubs:- Sorry a bit late, a few problems. Sorted hopefully now. BTW SWiki this morning had more going thru but NOT that many and some of them were for a few of the french clubs we have been talking about. I have a faint hope SM are doing a review of their recent mistakes on a few players.I doubt it BUT U never know. 🙄 Let's see where we are tomorrow or whenever they come thru. Thanks again for your interest and support. More tomorrow b4 6pm hopefully....
  25. 1 point
    Elizeu Campos

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    After seeing what they did in France I am pretty pessimistic about the upcoming updates. One of the worst updates I've ever seen for sure.😓
  26. 1 point
    AlfonDaddy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Don’t they still need to do Lyon, Nantes, Rennes, Marseille and PSG?? Monaco were done (poorly)
  27. 1 point
    thanks guys, really helpfull re Bruun Larson
  28. 1 point
    Milanista1

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I certainly believe Vardy and the majority of Leicester City's first eleven should deservedly rise. Thank you everyone for helping us keep this thread alive. Dzeko: I don't think he should drop this review as Roma have top 3 potential this season and at 33 years he is still going strong, and is very important to this Roma side. Maybe it would be better to keep Draxler+Rebic. Remember you are playing in a stronger league next term, therefore you will need your best players/best performing players in order to mount a challenge for the title. I reckon the BM manager is aware that the way you played last term you were getting better out of your two wingers whereas he didn't get much out of his Serge Gnabry. In this case it seems a risk to go for the under performimg Serge Gnabry, unless you can be certain that you will be able to bring the best out of him, only then I would go for Gnabry rather than keeping the other 2.... Troianos77 it sounds like you have kind of already made up your mind. The 4 I would keep are: Everton Soares, Thorgan Hazard, Richarlison and (especially) Moussa Dembele.
  29. 1 point
    Boubacar Kamara, Marseille, correct? If he doesn't get a rise i will eat a hotdog with mustard on it and that's just wrong. Ketchup all the way, baby. Mate, they haven't even reviewed Reims yet.
  30. 1 point
    They are nowhere near done with Ligue 1, relax. My guess is they made the changes 2 or so games ago and are rolling them out now according to this current league table that has obviously changed. Had they waited those 2 matches i'm sure the changes would have looked slightly different. Why the *censured lol* didn't they just review the second divisions before the top 5 like usual? I know, its because they are *censured lole* incompetent and were behind schedule, cause lazy, so just casually skipped it because it wasn't deemed important enough. Hey, soccerwiki: How about you stop adding pointless players from pointless leagues that noone will ever buy and focus on the leagues we are buying players from? Also, there is no need taking 2 weeks to roll out changes from one league so that you skip leagues we have waited over a *bleeeeeeeeep* year for to be reviewed. Thanks.
  31. 1 point
    Maarten Vandevoordt played for KRC Genk and did a good job. 17 years old, people. One to follow
  32. 1 point
    Milanista1

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    If he has a great Euro 2020 with Netherlands, then I certainly think he can get a +1. Lyon aren't doing as well this season so I doubt that he can break any knee caps till the Summer review (I mean some of the recent reviews haven't been that good either). He's having a decent season at LB (averaging just under a 7 in recent games), additionally he has also been involved with the national side too. Im guessing your GW is quite competitive, therefore I would certainly go for him as your S.Umtiti can be better deployed at CB. I would presume Jose Gaya is safe at 91 for a few years yet, because he only rose to 91 in July of this year, after having a very good individual season and winning the Cops Del Rey against Barcelona. He's still only 24 years old as well (seems like he's been around for sometime). Well (after checking SW) I guess he was added to the database back in Jan 2013 when he was 18 years young.
  33. 1 point
    Milanista1

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    -1/-2 If you really require another CB and C.Lenglet is the only good option available, then I'd go for him, otherwise Frankie all the way! If he's available I would certainly have in my youth squad. His ratings average per game this season is looking quite good: lhttps://www.whoscored.com/Players/344644/Show/Federico-Valverd e Plus I'm sure that Zidane rates him highly to be playing him more this season.
  34. 1 point
    congola

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    whats the latest with cavani? will he drop? will he go in January with PSG top heavy squad?
  35. 1 point
    TMCosta

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Ok maybe at the end of the season...50/50 then Its italy...shuffle mode
  36. 1 point
    @Kev It's been a while I mentionned a hidden post or something else. Don't know what you exactly did, but great work. Thanks for making it possible to talk about my passion: Belgian Football and less countries.
  37. 1 point
    Sir Louis Cower

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Atal to 88 despite playing for Nice while both Ganago and Badiashile only rose from 82 to 83. Okay I guess?
  38. 1 point
    Milanista1

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I beg to differ. He's certainly settled in better at his new club than the likes of Ndombele and Pepe have (who both cost as much if not more than Rodri). Plus hes had to fill in at CB as well due to City's injuries/frailties at the back. Going by that he should just about merit +1. Although I do admit he has had the off game here and there (Newcastle and Liverpool). Even so he did play very well in the recent game against Barcelona...... (😇sorry I meant Burnley). 😁
  39. 1 point
    Started 4 days ago.
  40. 1 point
    Elizeu Campos

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Worried about not seeing the name of Boubacar Kamara, and saddened not to see Dembele. About the predictions, great work. Keep going
  41. 1 point
    swanseajack

    HJK - British Youth Club (UNAC)

    Rating Changes Mikey Johnston, 78 > 80 A really welcome, but deserved rating increase for Mikey Johnston who was really harshly reviewed in the Scottish Premiership review. He was superb for Celtic for more than a year building up to the review, but an injury a few weeks before meant that the previous year was seemingly for next to nothing. I think SM understand how poorly they've reviewed him, as they rarely update Scottish players and since he's returned to the side and after just a couple of substitute appearances he's been given another rating increase. I still don't think it's at the level he deserves right now, as he's in Celtic's strongest eleven in my view, which should put him at a rating of at least 82 and pushing to be around the 84/85 mark within the next year, so hopefully he gets another rating change in time. It might take him to make his Scottish debut for him to get that next rating increase, which has been long overdue. This review puts him on the fringes of the first team, although if possible we'll look to loan him out where he's now likely to get a lot more regular football. Wing: James (85), Roberts (84), McNeil (83), L. Nmecha (80), Johnston (80), Middleton (76), Matondo (76)
  42. 1 point
    ryan giggs

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Marcus Rashford +1? Serge Gnabry +1? Ciro Immobile +1?
  43. 1 point
    AlfonDaddy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Interesting read. But I also checked and he’s not played a single Real Madrid game at RB since 13/14. Definitely should lose the RB
  44. 1 point
    TMCosta

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    Grow up. At least he is here helping.
  45. 1 point
    Soccahappy

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    A few more from Spreadsheet, below Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be. Remember ATM we are only about a dozen games into Big 5 Leagues. I am concentrating mainly on Younger under 89 rated players as these are more consistent risers and more profitable, Goal keepers are dealt with by SM in a completely different way, which is why I also ignore Gk's. The above is a snapshot of the situation as of TODAY. All these will change as minutes, goals, assists change week by week ALSO Club Position week by week makes a difference. So hopefully by review date all will be more accurate with the passage of time. Tielemans is already an 89 so he may need more games or more than +14% to get the 90. Previous predictions on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784,785 Thanks for your support Socca😀
  46. 1 point
    No, I didn't take him, had to pick and choose, as I didn't want to add too many players to my squad, because my wage bill is high.
  47. 1 point
    tryn2rtr

    Improve on Game Engine

    Haha. We've been begging for an improved match engine for years mate. And a host of other improvements. SM doesn't really care about any of it because we are all a bunch of saps that continue to play (and pay) despite our complaints. We don't leave, so they really aren't motivated to do much. It's really a farce.
  48. 1 point
    I think player ratings should be more in depth and tactics... The engine is online for crying out loud... Give us a good game... More tactical twists and technique should play a bigger role in the results
  49. 1 point
    Toby S

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    I don't watch Napoli, any chance of an Allan +1 like Rahul has planned or no?
  50. 1 point
    shangar

    Rahul W's rating predictions

    4 - German football has not done as well in Europe as in previous years. This tends to be taken in to account by SM.
×
×
  • Create New...