Jump to content

koplfc

Members
  • Posts

    11,892
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from Milanista1 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Chris Basham not even getting a +1 is a travesty. I know he had a handsome rise mid-season but he was by far one of Sheffield United's best players. 
    If Jack Grealish can get a 90 (+5 over the course of the season) by being a standout player in a side that only just avoided relegation, then why can't Baldock, Egan, O'Connell and Basham atleast be minimum 88 for finishing 20 points ahead... 
  2. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from BrodiePT in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    All hype. Thats the problem with ratings being based off soccerwiki, more people are going to put a +1 on Grealish than they will on Basham. 
     
    Grealish has spent the past 6 months being linked with Arsenal and Manchester United, meanwhile Chris Basham signed a contract extension with... that average side from Yorkshire. 😏😏
  3. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from Hrodulf in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Chris Basham not even getting a +1 is a travesty. I know he had a handsome rise mid-season but he was by far one of Sheffield United's best players. 
    If Jack Grealish can get a 90 (+5 over the course of the season) by being a standout player in a side that only just avoided relegation, then why can't Baldock, Egan, O'Connell and Basham atleast be minimum 88 for finishing 20 points ahead... 
  4. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from RieceM96 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    All hype. Thats the problem with ratings being based off soccerwiki, more people are going to put a +1 on Grealish than they will on Basham. 
     
    Grealish has spent the past 6 months being linked with Arsenal and Manchester United, meanwhile Chris Basham signed a contract extension with... that average side from Yorkshire. 😏😏
  5. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from Kieran_S91 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    All hype. Thats the problem with ratings being based off soccerwiki, more people are going to put a +1 on Grealish than they will on Basham. 
     
    Grealish has spent the past 6 months being linked with Arsenal and Manchester United, meanwhile Chris Basham signed a contract extension with... that average side from Yorkshire. 😏😏
  6. Like
    koplfc reacted to RieceM96 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Because that was Sheffield United first season back in the premier league.
    They don't deserve anyone over 87 clearly lol
    Whereas Aston Villa just avoided Relegation by 1 point in their first season back. So Grealish is fully deserving of his 90 to be on par with Danny Ings who also carried Southampton when their season looked bleak at the 9-0 defeat. Only scored 22 goals and got 2 assists lol 
     
    Also
    Vestergaard 1400 minutes drops from 88 to 87 
    Jack Stephens stays at 86 with 2400 minutes xD great CB 
    Holgate gets +2 to 87 with 2000 minutes ( good player I know ) 
    Basham stays at 86 with 3200 minutes( one of their best players)
    Baldock 86 with 3400 minutes ( absolute joke )
    Coleman drops to 88 with 1800 minutes( not the same player anymore)
    I know the ratings arent based on just minutes but Baldock, Stephens and Basham should be on par with Holgate. They're all very good players and I don't think Holgate played better than them tbh 
    But Holgate has played 1200 minutes less than Basham, Baldock.
    Everton had the worst finish out of Southampton,Sheff United 
    No consistency and very unfair to certain players 
  7. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from gAv Gav in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Yeah get Atal or Telles. 
    Atal can play right-back too. 
  8. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from Hrodulf in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Does anyone reckon the mls is ever going to get reviewed this side of Christmas? 😑😐😐😑
  9. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from Rahul W in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Don’t think they’ll just skip the mls? Hope they take into consideration minutes from last season when hey do. Known them overlook historic minutes from previous seasons before.
     
  10. Thanks
    koplfc got a reaction from Fraser in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    I'd keep them all till the Eredivisie had been reviewed as they should all rise a little bit. However I have highlighted the ones id keep until the start of next season to see if they'd get moves to other clubs or continue playing till the end of this season.
    Michael Sadilek had been dropped in recent weeks before xmas, if he can get back into the starting lineup between now and the end of the season you could certainly consider keeping him. 
    Other players worthy of a mention are Danilho Doekhi, Abdou Harroui and Bryan Smeets. 
  11. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from thorgan lesar in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Great signing if he can replicate what he did in Austria.
     
    potentially another Lewandowski in the making.
  12. Thanks
    koplfc reacted to RobboEFC in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Yes, Walkers overrated. As soon as Barca sack the fraud Valverde De Jong will get back to his best
  13. Haha
    koplfc reacted to JAMancini in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    If Ozil kept level 94 for 4 years with Arsenal stinking.
  14. Thanks
    koplfc got a reaction from Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    +1 or 2 for Davide Faraoni? 
  15. Thanks
    koplfc reacted to Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Upload below:-
    Previous predictions on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784.785,786,787, 788, 789, 790, 791,792,793, 794,795,796,797, 798, 799,800, 801,803, 804.805, 806, 807. Be careful of the Reddish boxes where the higher rated players are more inclined towards performances rather than stats.
    Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be. Remember ATM we are a dozen plus games into Big 5 Leagues.
    I am concentrating mainly on Younger under 89 rated players as these are more consistent risers and more profitable, Goal keepers are dealt with by SM in a completely different way, which is why I also ignore Gk's

    All updated minutes! Enjoyed looking at Cologne and Union Berlin and adding them for first time. Fascinating where to put the zero% line taking into consideration 1 new club is presently 10th and other is 17th. Used Paderborn 19th as a guide and will be interesting to see how accurate to SM's judgement I am. Also enjoyed finding U Berlin has so many risers or new underrated players depending on how u look at it.
    Another busy day tomorrow but should be ok to do more German clubs, probably Mid table. Thanks again for your interest and great support, I really appreciate it. 
    Ps As per usual SWiki was slow with only a few, but it's usually that way at weekends. Right! Now to settle in and watch Arsenal v Man C match I've recorded!
  16. Like
    koplfc reacted to olivier 1 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    As Germany normally follows the French review, here is my prediction. Cheers
  17. Thanks
    koplfc got a reaction from JinxMillion in The 4 Nation Challenge   
    Re: The 4 Nation Challenge
    Returned after 15 months out. This time im at Real Betis.
    The market is DEAD. No deals have been for 4 turns at all.
    With that in mind ive listed Palacio, Gourcuff, Thiago, van der Wiel, Ansaldi, Khedira, Inler, Gonalons and Debuchy in the hope that this will spark some activity.
    Hopefully the addition of some new managers will do the same.
  18. Thanks
    koplfc reacted to Kev in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    All depends on how long term you're looking. Fabregas and Mahrez is a quick fix to increase the rating.
    The best offer there is Under and Ceballos though. Maybe go for that. But I'd try and keep Sancho unless you're way behind the other teams in terms of rating. 
    I've managed every team I want to at some point I think. From the likes of Truro City up to all the big guns. 
    I'm in 31 GWs so currently have big teams like PSG and Man Utd, and small teams like Levadia (Estonia) and Alianza (El Salvador).
    +1 most likely, but given that he's only 85 I think there's a chance he could get +2. 
    I'd be happy with both of those deals personally 👍
    It's probably not a bad time to cash in on him, but 5m over CV isn't a great deal. You seem to be well covered though. I guess it all hinges on what you can get with the 50m.
    Long term yes, but getting rid of a 94 who is still playing at the highest level means it's not exactly a no-brainer. If you have a strong team with a decent replacement for Sila there already then go for it. 
    Very unlikely while he's at Lyon, he's already their joint highest rated player. 
    If Fabregas keeps playing at Monaco this season he could keep his 91 for the next review at least, and Brooks is a real talent so I'd probably keep what you have for now. 
    If you can get a good trade for Wanyama then go for it. 
    100% Pacheco. Perin is only 2nd choice at Juve. 
  19. Thanks
    koplfc reacted to Kev in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    I'd go for it. Zidane likes Isco so he should get more games now. KDB is tough to get rid of, Christensen less so as he barely plays, but 3 solid 90+ players (at least 2 of whom could rise in the next couple of reviews) is a good deal. 
    Bergwijn has the possibility of hitting 90 at PSV, but it'll be ages until they're reviewed. 
    Pulisic is the great unknown here. He'll be at a club who aren't capped at 90, so could do well if he gets game time. Given that Bergwijn will (barring a big transfer) be stuck at 89 for almost a year, I think Pulisic is worth the risk at the moment. 
    I think there's Don't see why they'd have reviewed him ahead of the rest otherwise.
    Should get a rise, yeah. Probably +1.
    +1 I'd say.
    Pogba. Ndombele is good but Ox is just another Jack Wheelchair.
    Dybala, Sterling, Son.
    I'd say there's a very good chance of Son getting 93 next review.
    Pogba and Koke or Coutinho. I think Koke and Coutinho may have hit their top rating, but 94 is still excellent. 
  20. Like
    koplfc got a reaction from Rahul W in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    MLS seems to be very hit and miss... I expect Belgium will be a bit funny too. 
    Do we think Ashley Barnes has a shot at 88 if he manages to keep Burnley up? Recently just had his first international call up for Austria. Wouldn't be questioning it if Burnley were having a season close to what they did last year. 
    Also same question for Getafe's Nemanja Maksimovic and Damian Suarez? 87 or 88? 
  21. Thanks
    koplfc got a reaction from Middle_Finger in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Castillejo 🧐
  22. Haha
    koplfc got a reaction from TMCosta in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Castillejo 🧐
  23. Thanks
    koplfc reacted to hesselink in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Bednarek! He is beast! I know he is in the Southampton, but  he is one of the best prospects (DC) in Premier League already.
    Next review:
    Amian +1 (87) To be honest, i never watched him (just video highlights)
    Onguene +1 (83) Nothing special.
    N'Dicka +2 (85) I'm not impressed  with him, weak point of Eintracht. He is young & have time to improve his weakness.
    Bednarek +2/3 (85/86) Like I said, M O N S T E R. Top PL club material!
  24. Thanks
    koplfc reacted to Kev in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    I think I'd go for it. It's tough to predict who could get 97 or maybe even higher, but Mbappe would be the best bet for me. It depends on the GW though, if you're still expecting it to be going in 4 or 5 years time then Mbappe deffo, if not then Neymar will likely be the highest rated for a couple of years at least. 
    Werner can probably go higher eventually, but is a bit expensive at the moment. See if there are better options available. 
    No. Barely getting a game. 
    They basically mean nothing at all. I know people use them to test different tactics and formations, but I'm not even sure they're reliable for that. Definitely don't change fitness anyway. 
    Kunde Malong should get 86 for sure and has a chance of 87. 
    Santamaria 87 at most.
    Lea Siliki probably stay at 85. 
    Bobichon should hit 83, maybe 84 if he keeps starting games.
    Soumaré stay at 82.
    Ibrahima Sissoko 85, outside chance of 86.
    Just my opinions, others may disagree....
     
    Some rough estimates there if that helps. 
    Looking a bit 50/50 to me. Depends what part he plays in the next couple of months and what Barca win maybe. 
    I'd be going with Rodri there. 
  25. Thanks
    koplfc reacted to Kev in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    I think it's unlikely. 
    I'd sell I think. Can't see him rising again this season. 
    I'd guess 88, yeah. 
    Yes, interessant.
    Long term I think the most interessant out of those 3 is Gimenez, but it might be the winter review before he gets 92 because of injury. I'd probably exchange either of those for him looking long term. 
    Probably Meunier, has a slightly higher chance of rising I'd say. 
    Mendy + 1 - Pepe less likely because he's probably hit the squad cap at Lille. 
    Dumfries probably won't be reviewed until early next year unless he moves, so too early to predict really. 
    Bednarek is probably best long term. Probably +2 next review. 
    Hmm, only Son I'd say. Maybe Mane if they do get the league. 
×
×
  • Create New...