Jump to content


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by CelticFaithful

  1. Re: Krasic or Valencia?

    I was comparing the fact that any good winger wants to hold the ball and run at players or run to the line and get the cross in. Valencia doesn't seem to want to want to have the ball. Maybe I am being harsh but I dont rate him at all.

  2. Re: Krasic or Valencia?

    Valencia's over-rated. You really rate him as 91 ? Crossing is "good". Can't dribble. He doesn't seem to want the ball passed to him unlike Ronaldo who ( even though I despise the man ) wanted the ball at every oppertunity to run at defenders, cut inside, get the cross in.

    Just because he's playing at MU ( despise this football club aswell ) doesnt mean hes going to be world class. He'll be an average player. Keep Krasic.

  3. Re: Valencia, Lennon Or Young?

    Nice to see that Young was completely dismissed there. Young has amazing talent and when he does move to a bigger club he'll get his deserved higher rating. And for England, he doesn't have as much competition as Lennon does on the right side so because Young can play left I can see him being a starter in 2-4 years.

    I still would choose Lennon but then Young as back-up. Not Valencia. Over-rated, can't dribble and his crossing is good. nothing more. nothing less.

  4. Re: Dani Alves

    Still show quality for Barca's attack' date=' but still too weak to defence. So,he'll stay at 94[/quote']

    And this justifies a 94 .. ? I feel these days over half the players over 92-93 dont deserve their rating. A 92-93 player should be a match-winner,a star that has proven it consistently in europe, his own leage and with his country. 90 + ratings are just passed out nowdays. Pato = 92 ... it says it all

  5. Re: Serie A - Analysis and Ratings

    I changed him today actually' date=' to 91--->91/90. He's been playing enough to keep his 91, but sometimes he's really bad when he gets the chance to play. It would be a bit risky if you signed, I would recommend you to [i']not[/i] sign him.

    Sorry, i checked the first post a few days ago and remembered it off that. Thanks for the advice. Now just gotta find another cm .. :confused:

  6. Re: fletcher??

    Just checked your IP' date=' you live in London area or just outside. . . . . good effort.

    The funny thing is i said you probably live 200 miles away, accorinding to AA route planner you live 174 miles away. minimum.[/quote']

    Rep for that. Made my day.

  7. Im looking for 2 Centrebacks that are 90 or over ( maybe 88-89 if they're young ) that are not necessarily rising, just playing well enough to keep their position.

    Recently bought Cordoba ( grr, didnt research him before i bought ) and now i want to use him as a sub and bring in 2 new Cb's.

    My Budget can stretch to about 25m ( maybe 30-40 if needed ) so its not necessarily big name players im after.

    Any help is appreciated.

  8. Re: Patrice Evra

    What club are u manage now??

    Celtic, but I've only one original player left ( Boruc ). The rest are sold.

    Ive not got players to offer really but i have accumulated cash and I was thinking is a 35m big too high ? Or too low ?

    What would be an reasonable price for the manager to let him go ?

  9. Re: Patrice Evra

    The manager is surely only interested in Player Exchange' date=' so it would be good if you could post your squad.

    By the way. It's seems to be rather a topic for the Player Assistance than for the Player Rating Predictions. Please use next time the right forum.[/quote']

    Thanks. Sorry about that.

  10. I need a new Lb and I'm willing to splash out so i was having a look through the list and Patrice Evra's name came up. I've been talking with the manager but he won't give me a set price for him. And I have no idea what to offer so I'm wondering if anyone can give me some help here. Thanks.

  11. Re: Who to buy for Lm ?

    but malouda turning 30 y/o? so play him 2 yrs.. sell again..

    or Mata? paying the odds..

    i mean decisions up to you.. i am just trying to give my best advices :P

    I think im going with Malouda. Thanks for all the advice. Really appreciate it.

  12. Re: Who to buy for Lm ?

    he is young and improving? he play reguarly starting with villa and silva..

    (91) and +1 in future?

    i mean he is a good choice to invest (21y/o) ' date=' rather you take him.. long term.. than malouda who is 30 y/o next year..

    he is defo worth it ? isnt it[/quote']

    I have a problem with prospects :P I tend to buy already-proven quality players rather than young hot prospects BUT he does sound promising ...

  • Create New...