Jump to content

John S

Members
  • Content Count

    1,948
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    10

Everything posted by John S

  1. Seriously SM, give TAA a 94 already.
  2. Maicon is still on the database. Check his rating history!
  3. Fabinho or Coutinho? Positions are irrelevant
  4. Looking to give Hummels to get L.Sane I have plenty of cover in both positions so positions are irrelevant. In my mind Hummels will only go downhill from now on but I am worried whether Sane is also stuck at 92 for the foreseeable future.
  5. Which side would you guys go for: Bale vs Laporte + Robertson No player would be a starter so a view on their potential over the next year or so would be very helpful
  6. Would you guys give Sergi Roberto for Milinkovic-Savic? I don't need either at the moment so my decision will be based purely on potential.
  7. Griezmann vs Salah vs Mbappe Who would you guys pick?
  8. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Not even close IMO. Keep Mascherano (and the cash). Dont even think to give Salah on top. Sterling is young' date=' promising, overhyped to a great extend at the moment but definitely dont go for him if that's what it takes to get him. Cant argue with an expert on Italian football as I havent seen him play for a long long time However, you could argue that provided he becomes a starter at Juve again, he has the "medium" to go higher than Parejo which is what the original question asked.
  9. Re: Serie A Rating Predictions Gilardino and Salah pretty much forced him out of the starting lineup after December/January. He could get a +1 if SM feel generous and I reckon 87 would suit him for now.
  10. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... I'd lean towards Asamoah. Even though he missed most of the season due to injury, when fit he should be able to start (a lot of games) at Juventus. Evra isnt getting any younger, Vidal, Pogba and Pirlo could very well depart too. As he can operate in all positions in the left flank, he should get plenty of game time as he used to do in the past. Parejo should rise after a great campaign this year but I feel his ceiling isnt much higher than 91, probably tops 92 if Valencia manage something notable in the CL.
  11. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... I like both but I feel Koke is slightly overhyped. De Bruyne has done great this season and with Belgium's current golden generation I dont feel Koke has an edge regarding NT football either. Another great season at Wolfsburg (who as you know will be in CL too next year) should earn him a move to a top team. A team that will play him this time
  12. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Darmian needs a move to hit the 90s but if he secures one to a big club, he will be much more valuable than Jese who seems to be behind in the pecking order at Madrid. Unless of Real Madrid's new manager overhauls the squad and he suddenly becomes a starter
  13. Re: Liga BBVA Ratings Predictions thread He should get a +1 minimum. He has been an undisputable starter for Sevilla since January and done excellently IMO.
  14. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... I would go for James Rodriguez. Quality wise I cant argue for or against either as you cant go wrong either way. Neither should you choose James because he is at a bigger club at the moment because you can then argue that Reus plays for the German NT. However, I would choose James because Reus seems to be injury prone. A bit unlucky in that regard but still injury prone (missed about half Dortmund's games this year) so I would give James the edge right now. Though I really hope that his injuries wont affect his long term career.
  15. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... I would definitely go for Lacazette. His situation seems much better right now' date=' Lukaku seems a bit lost at Everton. I would definitely keep/get the duo and the cash. I would be particularly reluctant to part with Griezmann. Verrati has massive potential but Matic should be the one to go 93+ therefore I would choose him right now. Sadio Mane for me. Both should be safe but provided you need to buy one desperately I would be pick Destro.
  16. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... I rate both equally, each for his own qualities. They are different players anyway. However, I would choose Griezmann. I am impressed by how well he has done this season and I really hope he stays at Atletico for at least another season. Isco still needs to displace Modric, Kroos or James which I dont see happening if all three keep fit.
  17. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Cahill should rise but not a certainty. Terry just got 92. Sterling and Benteke should stay. Reina is returning to Napoli where he should command a starting spot' date=' however, Oblak is a younger talented keeper who should and will be rated higher for much longer. Can see him doing similarly to Courtois if he gets the spot from Moya. I dont know a lot about Sinkgraven but from what I heard he is a decent prospect. Denis Suarez is a player I like and I can picture him returning to Barcelona one day. However, Luis Henrique has faith in Rafinha and gi
  18. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Mid to long term I would definitely go for Mane. Personally I would go for the second deal unless you desperately need a RB. Even though Lahm is a great player' date=' Thiago is a gem and he just needs a full season without injuries to set the world alight. Also, something must go terribly wrong for Depay not to make it at United. If you dont need a 92 rated player immediately, that is if your team is already good enough, I would take the risk and go for the two youngsters. Both had full seasons and did great. Especially Fekir. Godin Gundogan Thiag
×
×
  • Create New...