Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by SportingPM

  1. I think this is an important aspect of the game that would be easy to solve ! and is currently not working, so I am going to continue to post examples of the current mess. In one of my gameworlds I am trying to buy a player from an unmanaged club, value 2m. As per the new (old) system the external club values my rubbish players two or even three times what my chairman values them at BUT for example I offer rubbish player 1 (my chairman value 500k) values at 1m and rubbish player 2 (my chairman value 1.4m) value 3.0m. So I make an offer their chairman values the deal at 4m for a player he valu
  2. Just a note to add to this. In one of my gameworlds which is very competitive and the classic case where it is almost impossible to buy a decent player for cash. Victor Moses was recently bought by unmanaged ColoColo for 9.2m but his value in their squad now is 4.1m . This situation of players values needs to be sorted out otherwise there is no chance of the transfer market working properly.
  3. I have recently lost out on two transfers of players from unmanaged clubs where at the moment the bid was accepted my bid was the highest when taking into account the value I could see of the players offered by another manager in part exchange. But after the transfer had gone through I saw that the unmanaged club valued the player offered in part exchange much higher, so my bid was turned down. I then experimented with offering deals to a few unmanaged clubs with my players in part exchange. In every case the chairman of the unmanaged club valued my player at exactly the value he appears to
  4. As I understand it at the moment there are four valuations on each player. 1. The value in your squad - visible in the players info, stats etc 2. Chairmans valuation - Which you only ever see when you offer a player in PX and is nearly always far higher than the players value in your squad. 3. Other chairmans valuation - Which you only see when you offer your player to them in a PX deal. 4. The value a player actually takes on when he moves to the other club, often higher than the value the chairman of that club put on the player for the purposes of the deal. I can see that there is a ben
  5. The Southampton review was bizarre. Fonte gets a +2 Toby Alderweireld gets +1 but Clyne and Bertrand get nothing. If anything Clyne was the standout from that back 4 and for Bertrand to be on 88 while the two CB's are 90 is just crazy. Bertrand has won the Champions league !!! I thought that stuff was supposed to matter on SM
  6. Is Aleix Vidal ging to rise? I know he got a +1 in April but considering the rises other Sevilla players got he deserves 89 at the very least surely
  7. Can anyone explain to me why Totti drops 91 to 90 after a season of 1751 minutes 8 goals 6 assists but Mario Gomez stays on 91 after 1401 minutes 4 goals 2 assists. It is blindingly obvious Totti is the better player right now but he drops !
  8. What do people think of these aging forwards in serie A ? Gomez -1 Cassano -1 Totti - stay Klose - stay Thanks
  9. Does anyone think correa will get a rise? I think I'm right in saying some if his outstanding libertedores performances were after his last rise. Then he got the move to madrid. I know he hasn't played a minute of league football since then, but he has been outstanding when he has player for Argentina ( under 20s admittedly) I think he's a huge talent, just curious to know what people think.
  10. Re: -||Eredivisie Ratings II - 12/13 Winter Predictions Up! - by BRNL||- Do you think Depay will get to 90 this review? I know he got a +1 quite recently but he did more this season than Eriksen did when he got a 90 in the Dutch league...
  11. Re: Shkelzen GASHI money maker! I would love to know what people make of Gashi now !! his stats look like he could go from being just a money maker to quite a serious player. He definitely deserves a rise and judging by some of the other players in the swiss league I think he deserves a +3 to 88 any thoughts ?
  12. Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread I guess he is exactly the kind of player who gets shafted by the current rating system. Ok Lille are not doing that well but nor are ac Milan, Manchester United etc etc. i guess the 89 to 90 jump is the hardest one if you are playing for a bD team. But I would have thought that being voted keeper of the year in France and being short listed for African player of the year might tip the balance. Does anyone know if those personal accolades count for ratings increases in a concrete way in the way that winning trophies does?
  13. Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread What do people think of Enyeama ? Goalkeeper of the year in Francd for 2014 but didnt get a rise in the last review !
  14. I manage Rushden and Diamonds in a competitive gameworld. Obviously managing a small team is quite tough and every penny counts. You are trying to buy good players to improve your team but as soon as you buy a player with a higher rating it decimates the value of half your squad! Is there any way of predicting what impact it will have on the ret of your squad when you buy a particular player. Below is an example of something that just happened to me. I recently bought Robinho for my team. Here are the Values of the other members of my squad who play in a position he can play before and and a
  15. Re: Riferimento: Re: Liga BBVA Ratings Predictions thread De Rossi is one of the best examples of the unwritten rules of sm/sw ratings where you get points for being famous. We all know all about the super hyped young guys and there is the exact same issue with the aging stars taking way too long to drop. I get the problem that they don't want to drop a previously world class player prematurely. But I had thought this was going to be one of the reasons forthe change to the I scheduled ratings changes. The fact is in real life players can go from world class to not getting picked at mediocr
  16. Re: Liga BBVA Ratings Predictions thread I half agree that Messi should stay, just thought I would throw that one out there as bait;) Although he is not as good as he used to be and that is a fact. Maybe Ron deserves the 99, the truth is I have never liked him as a player and I just think that the fact he has come up short at international level for his entire career should work against him. No matter what he achieves in his career for me he will be the man who lost twice! to Greece! in his own house on the way to not winning the Euro's. A funny story. A friend of mine was part of the crew
  17. Re: Liga BBVA Ratings Predictions thread Whats the consensus on the Barca boys dropping ? Messi -1 (maybe harsh but he isnt quite on the level he was) Iniesta -1 Busquets -1 Xavi -4 Pique -1 or 2 Alvez -2 Pedro -1 All these guys got their extremely high rating based on the way they were playing a long time ago now. A season winning nothing, none of them did anything serious in the world cup and they don't really look like winning anything this year (I know they are second and just behind real, but real had a pretty awful start to the season) I actually have a few of these guys in tea
  18. Re: Manager points/Best gameworld managers I dont really want to single people out here but I just looked at the 'best managers of all time' list in this particular gw and sitting top of the pile is someone who averages 1.89 points per game. and in 856 games has won a cup a shield and a charity shield!!!! a div 3 runner up spot and a div 2 play off win. Now I am going to come across bad here.... but that just isnt a terribly impressive record to me. Especially compared to the manager of another team who won div 3 then next season won div 2 one blank season then won div 1! That is the kind o
  19. Re: Manager points/Best gameworld managers I do mean that yes. And by the tone of your reply you probably don't think I have enough respect for hanging around. The truth is I do respect the managers who hang in there, I have been playing the game a few years and I really enjoy the game worlds that are competitive and where I have a good long running competition with particular managers. On the flip side I manage one team in a gw that had an ok ammount of managers when I started and now I am one of 2! so its pretty dull. However do I take it that you think the system is totally fine and nee
  20. If the concept of 'best managers' or manager points is going to exist in the game then it might as well mean something. At the moment more or less all it tells you is who has been playing the game longest. In one of the game worlds I am in the manager of leeds has managed to get a team containing Van Persie, Reus, De Gea and a host of other players rated 90 +, relegated to the third division. Yet he is rated as one of the top ten managers in the game. And this is a game world where 80+% of the teams are taken. The points system should be changed so that you get no points for just hanging ar
  21. Re: Memphis Depay Dilema I know you are all fascinated to find out what happened.... Well I changed my system to 3 5 2 in order to play Depay, I lost the first game drew the second but then went on a run of 12 wins and 3 draws from the next 17 games. I am in the final of the shield and 3 points off top spot in the league... So I guess I made the right call
  22. Re: English Premiership Rating Predictions Surely Ryan Bertrand deserved a +1 or will be reviewed as part of the Chelsea squad? I can never remember how that works with loaned players
  23. Re: English Premiership Rating Predictions Only Aguero has scored more goals than him this season, among prem strikers! o be fair I agree its a tough call knowing how quickly young players should rise, but the fact is that Kane is without any doubt better than Adebayor or Soldado right now, speaking of those two, whats the chance of a -5 for them?
  24. Re: Liga BBVA Ratings Predictions thread Will Xabi Prieto keep his 90? I just bought him for one of my clubs! Also what do people think of. Zaldua (Sociedad) Krychowiak Vidal (sevilla) K Navas (great world cup and end of last season, hasnt played much at Real !) DeMarcos (Bilbao) Cartabia (Cordoba) Looked amazing first few games then gone a bit quiet, but hes playing in a horrible team!) I think they are all contenders for a rise !!!
  • Create New...