Jump to content


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Pedworgan2

  1. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... My Yann M'Vila for Javi Martinez? Also is Javi likely to keep his CB position? It would be quite useful but I don't know how much he is featuring for Bayern/where he is playing.
  2. Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013 Well said, I voted Gotze 92 for all it is worth
  3. Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013 I was surprised at the generosity of these changes, but I don't entirely agree with the view that SM used to take time in rising players and now it has changed. When teams were reviewed more regularly they were more strict with waiting to rise players. In that sense they were less hasty but at the same time, young players have often been risen very quickly in the past. Aguero got 94 in no time which is incredibly high for a 20/21 year old which he was at the time and although he was good I imagine there would be some complaints if someone replicated his achievements and rose that fast at such a young age again. Fabregas went to 95 by the time he was 21/22 having only won 1 FA cup, SM do seem to raise on how naturally talented they seem at a young age as well as just statistical achievements I think. Pato went to 92 very quickly. Messi as brilliant has he was managed mid nineties after only a season or so of regular football for Barca. I thought most of the changes were justified. Gotze I predicted 92 and +2 was a bit fast but for those who watch him it is obvious he has the talent to go a lot higher and SM seem to rise players sometimes based on perceived ability/potential, be it justified or not. Piszczek I expected 91 and maybe Subotic +1 assuming they are done with Dortmund now. I will be interested to see how the Spanish and English changes go now. I've only been playing the game for 3 years but I can say that there used to be a lot more higher rated players when I started playing (Gerrard 97, Kaka 97 Torres 96, Drogba 96, Eto'o 96, Rooney 96, Maicon 96, Terry 95, Lampard 95, to name a few. There certainly seemed a lot more 93+ players than in the past couple of years. It is possible SM is raising the average again.
  4. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Ok thanks guys i'll take the duo then.
  5. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Would people accept Luis Suarez + Isco for their David Silva?
  6. Re: What's the highest Marco Reus can rise to? The Bundesliga review is not finished yet, I am sure Gotze will rise in the next few days.
  7. Re: Hazard vs Muller...... Very hard decision. On current form and rating i'd take Muller, but I think Hazard is more talented and could rise higher in the future.
  8. Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013 Oh, thanks, I can see it now. Well maybe it will be done by tomorrow.
  9. Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013 I'm not seeing Dortmund or Bayern on the updates, hopefully they are done by the weekend though in time for matches.
  10. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Thiago Alcantara or Shaqiri? Position not very important.
  11. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... I kind of agree with John, rawket and Jkerrs here. I'd rather have Gotze than Neymar but if Isla would be in your first team plans then it is a fair deal. Also it depends what you need. If your first team is avg 95 and you are loaded with stars in all positions then i'd just keep Gotze, but if you have loads of midfield backup but are in desperate need for a striker then take the deal.
  12. Re: kagawa I'd expect him to get +1 in the next few weeks.
  13. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Busquets' date=' chance of 95 and solid for many years at his high rating most likely. Hamsik. Ozil definitely if you have cover. Very nice piece of business' date=' a good chance at a +1 in the next few weeks. Nastasic as he will probably match Wanyama's rating very soon and plays for the bigger team in the much better league and will rise faster and higher until Wanyama moves.
  14. Re: Gotze deal Keep Gotze, you won't regret it.
  15. Re: Gotze vs Hazard Yeah, seriously he could win the next 3 or so considering he is only 25. Maybe he'll get an injury one year and give someone else a chance. XD
  16. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... No definitely not!
  17. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Fantastic deal for you. Vidal is a quality player but Reus alone I think can surpass his rating' date=' Gundogan as others say is an added bonus. After a week or so 92=90+87 is likely to be 92=92+89 so the rating gap will be short lived. I would take Hummels in terms of potential, I think all are brilliant though and you won't really go wrong swapping Puyol for any of them tbh. Yes, from what I gather from the French experts VDW isn't setting the world on fire. Dante I've seen a handful of times but he has looked very solid, the German forumers rate him highly as well and he is due a rise. He will probably reach 91 by the end of the season if he keeps it up.
  18. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Hummels for me.
  19. Re: Riferimento: Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...
  20. Re: Riferimento: Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Thanks Marek by the way I have one more question. I actually tried to bid Hamsik for Kroos to start with but my chairman wouldn't allow me to (literally Hamsik value was a couple hundred thousand above max bid I was allowed for Kroos). The other guy now offered Kroos for my Hamsik and I accepted but I don't know if it will go through because of the chairman values. Has anyone come across this before, if so will the deal still go through? Thanks.
  21. Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread... Been offered Kroos for my Hamsik, Neither would start so i'm thinking Kroos has a good shot at 92 in the next couple of weeks and can go higher than Hamsik long term. I Don't watch either very often but I have barely ever seen Hamsik play so i'm not totally sure about his ability although I would guess he can reach 93 maybe. Should I accept?
  22. Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013 I agree Gotze should get 92, although he has been performing arguably at a level above that, he missed too much of last season to get a rise. This season's performances deserve +1 though so 92 it should be.
  • Create New...