RobboEFC

Depends on if anyone else is available in the league, ideally you wouldn't have either since Schmeichel is another player who's got a boost yet hasn't deserved it. He should've got the 91 rated back when Leicester won the league then got a downgrade in this review. Kepa will be 89 rated within a season

I don't agree with everyone who's saying De Geas drop was harsh, is it really a surprise SM don't keep him 95 rated in a team that's probably now got a rating cap after looking less and less like a top 6 side each year? He was always going to get a - 1 minimum, Henderson looking more and more like he will bench him next season has probably made SM even more critical.

Oh, I'd cancel the Hakimi deal and go in for Haaland then. Hakimi would be competing with F.Mendy, Marcelo and Carvajal to play. Mendy and Carvajal aren't easy to bench. While he could develop really well since he's only 21 the same can be said of Sane, I think in a few seasons he will be Citys best forward When the Rice transfer ban expires ask in here who to go for

Don't go for Umtiti or Rice Sane for Hakimi is a risk, I'd personally rather keep Sane. Hakimi is only on loan at Dortmund so will be competing with Carvajal while Sane when fit starts for City Go for Haland Also, this is the perfect thread to ask these questions

If gylfi doesn't get a - 2 this review.... 🤢He's been by far our worst player, worse than Delph and schneiderlin who both got downgrades

I've always liked him, Ramos would rather be sent off than concede a goal. He terrifies attackers. There was times when he'd get wound up and get sent off but majority of his fouls were intentional. Different cbs have different playstyles

I'm not judging players based on what they won...? In comparison it seems like the only thing you judge a defender on is red cards. Ramos has scored more goals than vvd, might as well write vvds career off now based on your logic

Sorry, I mentioned earlier when I was talking about Matip I meant this season, should've said that in the comment you replied to. Last season vvd was easily the best cb in the league, this season hes not been as good but people aren't focused on that since Liverpool are unbeaten. Matip only played 7 league games before injury but he was easily Liverpools best cb in all of those games

The whole point of the rating system and this thread is to compare current players with the best of the best since SM was created so we can predict rating changes. If you don't like that maybe don't talk on a thread based around predictions....? Should ratings be given out more generously because the quality in a certain position has dropped so there's a bigger gap between 1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc or should it be done like every other position? Next you'll be saying Salah deserves 98 Also, did I say matip carried vvd? I said he was Liverpools best defender till he got injured, stop being an idiot who twists words to suit there agenda

Jeez when did you start watching football, last year? He's good but you're comparing him to players who were at the level vvd is currently at for hundreds and hundreds of games. Ramos for example has been one of the best cbs in the world since 2009 or 2010, van djiks been at that level for 18 months ffs 😂😂😂

You mean the Chilwell who's been by far Leicesters worst player this season....? The one who registered something like 20 misplaced passes in a recent game when almost all of them were simple back passes? He's a completely different player to the one we all saw last season, genuinely wouldn't be surprised if someone like Chelsea buy him for stupid money only for him to be benched after a few weeks

Made his debut today, him and Holgate were the only standout players in a poor game. Both have a ton of potential, Holgate has been our best player the past 10 games while Gordons been our best u23

So based on your logic Modric last year deserved his huge boost? Balon d'or and other awards are part popularity contest, Ronaldo for example was third in the voting when over 2019 he wasn't better than players like Lewandowski, etc... Vvd is a brilliant cb but he's not in a league of his own like you make out, Koulibaly isn't far off him. Cannavaro, Maldini, and Carlos are some of the best players in those 2 positions we've ever seen in football. If Van djik was consistent then I agree he should get another +1,right now he's having a worse season than his first season at the top level. It's way too soon

Disagree with this, Ramos earned his rating for being one of the most consistent cbs in the world for years and years. While Ramos should've lost his 95 this review VVD doesn't deserve a 96 rating when he's not been as good this season as he was last season. A good example of this is until Matip got injured he was Liverpools best cb early on. SM used to be really critical of cbs when it came to ratings, if they still are they wouldn't give vvd a higher rating than Ramos, Vidic, etc ever got

Julien Masson has still not got the correct team when his transfer to Angers failed in July👀