Jump to content

samfarrow

Members
  • Content Count

    33
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Reputation Activity

  1. Haha
    samfarrow reacted to RobboEFC in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Richarlison
  2. Haha
    samfarrow reacted to Cvilhete in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    You’ve had a shocker mate
  3. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from TMCosta in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Haaland done it in CL, Jovic can’t do it in La Liga. Hope this helps
    Felix carries more weight than these two put together and then some. If it’s a competitive GW and you can get a player like Felix that’s a very small price to pay. He’ll come good believe me
    Very very tight, Lautaro just for me
    Matip > Dias for a start so definitely don’t give Kabak as well
    Not at all, Firmino 94 now or in the summer
    Both deserve a rise. Unsure whether they’ll get one.
    Liverpool hype definitely helps Wijnaldum’s cause
    Fabinho every day of the week, twice on Tuesdays 
    I’d say Roca just, purely because he has lay a position that top level clubs demand and reportedly has a buyout clause of about €25 mill
  4. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Haaland done it in CL, Jovic can’t do it in La Liga. Hope this helps
    Felix carries more weight than these two put together and then some. If it’s a competitive GW and you can get a player like Felix that’s a very small price to pay. He’ll come good believe me
    Very very tight, Lautaro just for me
    Matip > Dias for a start so definitely don’t give Kabak as well
    Not at all, Firmino 94 now or in the summer
    Both deserve a rise. Unsure whether they’ll get one.
    Liverpool hype definitely helps Wijnaldum’s cause
    Fabinho every day of the week, twice on Tuesdays 
    I’d say Roca just, purely because he has lay a position that top level clubs demand and reportedly has a buyout clause of about €25 mill
  5. Like
    samfarrow reacted to KERSPALT! in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Kane over KdeB for me, unless it's short term and KdeB gets a +1 to 96.
    KdeB might be better, in my opinion anyway, but Kane has age on his side if you're looking long term.
  6. Like
    samfarrow reacted to KERSPALT! in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    That's exactly the point, he's younger. Two years is about 6 seasons in SM. If you're in a competitive league once a player hits 29/30 it becomes difficult to move them on.
  7. Haha
    samfarrow reacted to olivier 1 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Sm's new rating system: review 3 players/day and add 1 player from RB Leipzig  🤮
  8. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Gladbach have NOT been completed, they’ve done Elvedi (CB) and nothing else - they also started La Liga yesterday. At the time player went through Soccer Wiki Gladbach were top of the league (last to review)...
  9. Like
    samfarrow reacted to Sir Rahul in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Used to do it bit by bit yes, I'm not in any GW currently so it's more difficult for me to track when I do have some free time. That being said, hope I can return to doing them for the summer preds.
  10. Like
    samfarrow reacted to Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Well I totally agree swansea I will be up in arms if he gets less than 84 😫
    Another upload below:-
    Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be. Remember ATM we are only a dozen plus games into Big 5 Leagues.
    Previous predictions on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784.785,786,787, 788, 789, 790, 791, 792...793 (Three!) 794, 795, 796...

    Didn't realise until this morning England Premiership clubs are playing midweek and weekend matches this week. So slight change in plan I'll get the new England stats I need into my spreadsheet starting late sunday into monday and do it in one big go.  Then hopefully France MIGHT be near finishing and England MIGHT be 2nd. From now until then I'll use each day making progress on the other the other Leagues in case it's NOT England. 
    So More tomorrow B4 6pm if I'm not delayed, but am out at some point in the day so might be delayed again. 
    Thanks again for all your support, sorry for the upload glitches around midday. Think I've got an answer for that one now ie "split it into 2 and it doesn't go crazy"...Also had some stats still in there for 2 players from last seasons games for relegated Guingamp, please ignore them, I've deleted them from my spreadsheet.
    Ps Forgot to mention SW showed players going thru today from. Lille, Lyon, Nantes, Rennes and Reims. Also on his own, Adama Traore who I've got as a +2. I wonder if it's SM doing that trick of anticipating good risers ahead of time, u could call them front-Runners 😊
     
  11. Thanks
    samfarrow got a reaction from Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    10/90 in favour of not rising 
    Don't think it's over the top at all. They're top of the Eredivisie, and whilst that may not be that impresive their CL campaigns are. Semifinal last year and unless results go horribly wrong last game day they'll reach the last 16 this time round. Ziyech's personal stats are even more impressive, 5 goals, 11 assists in 14 Eredivisie games and 2 goals, 4 assits in 5 CL games. Far too good to go unnoticed and I'm glad that SM now seem to be taking the clubs/leagues with a pinch of salt and rewarding the individual players with what they actually deserve
    Yeah goal every 132 mins in Prem is outstanding, the algorithm is likely to be a benchmark and work things out more objectively, I would expect a plus 2 at least, perhaps more
    I think SM have just answered your question haha
  12. Like
    samfarrow reacted to Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Tried a smaller section, that's better, used up a lot of time tho, maybe the usual, late tonight or tomorrow now! Below is up to date minutes as of today.


  13. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from Milanista1 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    10/90 in favour of not rising 
    Don't think it's over the top at all. They're top of the Eredivisie, and whilst that may not be that impresive their CL campaigns are. Semifinal last year and unless results go horribly wrong last game day they'll reach the last 16 this time round. Ziyech's personal stats are even more impressive, 5 goals, 11 assists in 14 Eredivisie games and 2 goals, 4 assits in 5 CL games. Far too good to go unnoticed and I'm glad that SM now seem to be taking the clubs/leagues with a pinch of salt and rewarding the individual players with what they actually deserve
    Yeah goal every 132 mins in Prem is outstanding, the algorithm is likely to be a benchmark and work things out more objectively, I would expect a plus 2 at least, perhaps more
    I think SM have just answered your question haha
  14. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from !¡BµKa🔑 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    10/90 in favour of not rising 
    Don't think it's over the top at all. They're top of the Eredivisie, and whilst that may not be that impresive their CL campaigns are. Semifinal last year and unless results go horribly wrong last game day they'll reach the last 16 this time round. Ziyech's personal stats are even more impressive, 5 goals, 11 assists in 14 Eredivisie games and 2 goals, 4 assits in 5 CL games. Far too good to go unnoticed and I'm glad that SM now seem to be taking the clubs/leagues with a pinch of salt and rewarding the individual players with what they actually deserve
    Yeah goal every 132 mins in Prem is outstanding, the algorithm is likely to be a benchmark and work things out more objectively, I would expect a plus 2 at least, perhaps more
    I think SM have just answered your question haha
  15. Haha
    samfarrow reacted to Gumball in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    They have to get through China first. 300 Billion people in China, 100 billion of them play footie, 50 billion of them play at a professional level, and it seems SM is determined to rate and add every......last.....one.....of them!!
  16. Thanks
    samfarrow got a reaction from Milanista1 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Coman all day long, fingers crossed he can keep fit because if he can he's got a real chance of featuring for France next summer. I do like Pulisic and think he has a lot but raw talent and Coman is streets ahead
    I personally wouldn't sell Pepe but defo depends on what your team is like quality/depth wise? That being said, without a doubt Olmo. Much, much better national side in which he has featured and scored (first team). Also much more consistent with a considerably higher ceiling imp
    Certainly deserves it, hope he does get it. If SM didn't like to be so gradual with 95% of players you could argue 88/89
    More than likely yes, 2 at most 
  17. Like
    samfarrow reacted to thorgan lesar in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Difficult one. Harit is doing well, but previous season wasn't his best. Olmo is only getting better and better by season, so based on that I take Olmo.
    Another difficult one but I go with Samuel Umtiti
  18. Like
    samfarrow reacted to JAMancini in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Umtiti
  19. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from Yuasa in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Coman all day long, fingers crossed he can keep fit because if he can he's got a real chance of featuring for France next summer. I do like Pulisic and think he has a lot but raw talent and Coman is streets ahead
    I personally wouldn't sell Pepe but defo depends on what your team is like quality/depth wise? That being said, without a doubt Olmo. Much, much better national side in which he has featured and scored (first team). Also much more consistent with a considerably higher ceiling imp
    Certainly deserves it, hope he does get it. If SM didn't like to be so gradual with 95% of players you could argue 88/89
    More than likely yes, 2 at most 
  20. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Coman all day long, fingers crossed he can keep fit because if he can he's got a real chance of featuring for France next summer. I do like Pulisic and think he has a lot but raw talent and Coman is streets ahead
    I personally wouldn't sell Pepe but defo depends on what your team is like quality/depth wise? That being said, without a doubt Olmo. Much, much better national side in which he has featured and scored (first team). Also much more consistent with a considerably higher ceiling imp
    Certainly deserves it, hope he does get it. If SM didn't like to be so gradual with 95% of players you could argue 88/89
    More than likely yes, 2 at most 
  21. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from TMCosta in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Coman all day long, fingers crossed he can keep fit because if he can he's got a real chance of featuring for France next summer. I do like Pulisic and think he has a lot but raw talent and Coman is streets ahead
    I personally wouldn't sell Pepe but defo depends on what your team is like quality/depth wise? That being said, without a doubt Olmo. Much, much better national side in which he has featured and scored (first team). Also much more consistent with a considerably higher ceiling imp
    Certainly deserves it, hope he does get it. If SM didn't like to be so gradual with 95% of players you could argue 88/89
    More than likely yes, 2 at most 
  22. Like
    samfarrow reacted to Soccahappy in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Another Upload below:-
    Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be. Remember ATM we are only about a dozen games into Big 5 Leagues.
    Previous predictions on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784.785,786,787, 788, 789, 790, 791, 792

    As usual watch out for the red or redish boxes in last column as Sm judge these by performances and importance rather than mainly rely on the spreadsheet stats formula. Am concentrating on France at the moment, not completely, but hope to have the bulk done by end of week. I am thinking of then giving a column of best risers in France to choose from. Then concentrate on England as the 2nd review of Big5, YES??
  23. Like
    samfarrow reacted to Milanista1 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    A.Hakimi can be quite poor defensivly, which B.Dortmund's loss against Bayern highlighted (amongst other things). For the longer-term I think your better of with Wan-Bissaka, although A.Hakimi has overall been the better player so far this season.
    I think you can keep him (he really needs a big move to show us better if he's the real deal). Maybe Zsp2 can give you a stronger opinion.
    Although if you really need the cash to fund your psychiatry appointments then I would certainly sell him. 😅
     Your constant non-sensical emojis on all my responses is getting quite 😒
     
  24. Like
    samfarrow got a reaction from Milanista1 in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Think they will drop him incrementally due to how good he has been. -1 fairly consistently I would imagine
    Yes. Seems to have stagnated a little. But players hold greated value than money so if there is no sufficient replacement always keep the player.
    Hakimi, AWB is very good but a limited footballer, Hakimi seems to almost have to all. Playing CL and performing very well is also massive (Hakimi).
    Deserves it. May get 88 in winter and then 89/90 in summer depending on his game time/perfomrance etc.
    Barella and Ndidi without a doubt
    He certainly desrves to but I don't think he will due to how SM tends to work, he last went up in Jan 2015 and went down in June 2018. Would be very surprising if he does but suppose they can only ignore his form for so long
    Keeper Pavard and Akanji, sell Meunier and Doucoure for me. Doucoure could be worth keeping if he gets a January move but Watford are a shambles at the moment.
    I would certainly keep, unless you need a first team replacement and there are higher rated players available
    I would certainly keep until he's back playing for at least a while, obviously depending on who else is available, any other CBs available?
    They both should and both could. Just whether SM would rather leave such a big rating change till the end of the season. Hope so though.
  25. Like
    samfarrow reacted to Sir Rahul in Rahul W's rating predictions   
    Hello all,
    Back for a short while. Was bored so did some preds. May pop every now and then to do a few more preds.
    Hope y'all are well.
    Cheers,
    Rahul
×
×
  • Create New...