Jump to content

Toby S

  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Toby S

  1. 19 hours ago, Ben C said:

    I’d take the duo if they would both start in your side. If you already have a solid XI keep Mbappe as he’s better than both.


    20 hours ago, LauraAFCA said:

    Generally speaking it's a good deal, for me it would depend on the importance of cash and the depth of your team. Mbappe is one of a kind and the most talented out of the three, but the players offered are generous replacements and if the money gives your club a good boost, it's an excellent deal. So rationally it's a good deal to accept unless you're club already has plenty of depth, emotionally it depends on how much you value having potentially the best player in the world in your team 😉 


    On 10/29/2020 at 11:32 AM, Kieran_S91 said:

    This is hard.

    Id be fairly happy with both deals, I can see Goretzka being 94 in the future he’s such a good player and progressed so well.

    Sky is the limit for Sancho but Mbappe is one of the best players in the world. Its really tricky I’ve probably not helped you at all 😂

    Maybe it comes down to depth against Mbappe.


    On 10/29/2020 at 10:03 AM, Soccahappy said:

    Depends whether u need depth PLUS BIG CASH. Think the offer is generous tho, probably most managers would accept this for Mbappe BUT if U already have a top team and plenty of Cash - YOU WOULDN'T! 


    13 hours ago, Milanista1 said:

    He has enough talent to hold his rating for the next few years. And, I doubt the duo will go up in their current rating anytime soon.


    34 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said:


    Depends what the cash can get you, it's a good duo but Mbappe is Mbappe haha


    Think i've quoted and liked everyones comment who gave an opinion so thank you.

    For clarification I would be giving cash + sancho + goretzka for mbappe. The duo are in my first XI and if all things go well will both be 93 by end of the season (and sancho is a huge goalscorer and assist merchant for my team)...but then Mbappe is Mbappe, likely to be the highest rated player on SM eventually and would be my striker for the rest of time.

    Really not easy as its the biggest transfer i've ever considered and would ever likely do. I don't need the cash but the other manager has asked for those two players specifically.

  2. 3 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said:

    Quite competitive - but I have 88s in all positions and none of his players jump out to me as options

    If Jorginho was an option as a straight swap or with just a bit of cash I'd probably take him as thats a +4 to your midfield and I imagine he'll keep his rating. I don't think anyone else is worth it personally, but if you're happy keeping JPH then do that as he's only going to increase in rating.

  3. 1 hour ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

    When its close like this decision I always look at the stats in the gameworld itself. How have the others performed? if they are nowhere near Aguero then keep him, dont break what isnt broken, a year or -1 isnt going to suddenly mean no goals. once a goal scorer always a goal scorer. even at 93 I bet he will still be prolific. Dzecko is in two of my game worlds and huntelaar in a smaller world is 4 points off my top players and much much older but still outscores everyone in the league. Only thing you will lose out on is possible cashing in value, but hopefully you win something and get 10m for that and there is your player  cash loss gone


    1 hour ago, The punch said:

    lukaku can easily up to 94 this season


    1 hour ago, Kieran_S91 said:

    Personally I would buy Auba because I don’t see him dropping anytime soon and he’s just signed a new contract with Arsenal.

    I see your logic with Lukaku but I don’t know when/if he will rise to 94 at Inter. Could depend on Inter’s season plus him bagging 20+ goals (very possible though)

    Also with Auba you have a player who can play on either wing whereas Lukaku is an out and out central striker.


    18 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said:

    Like mentioned above, look at GW stats.

    I expect Aguero to drop at some stage this season. I might get Auba if he gets goals in your GW.

    Thanks for your replies everyone, the players mentioned are ones that aren't currently owned by a manager so their goals/game isnt that good as they usually have poor players around them, although I remember Auba being a goal machine for a managed team a couple of seasons ago. Yeah I'm not too bothered by the cash loss if Aguero were to go down as like SW19 said i can make it back in a good cup run.

    Auba is a good choice @Kieran_S91 because of the wing options you're right there too :D 

    This hasn't made my decision any easier haha, I'm going to keep Aguero for a little bit and mull it over as I need to purchase a defender too


  4. Currently in a predicament, Aguero is my main striker and won golden boot this season and my highest ever league finish but i am expecting him to get a decrease due to age and lack of playing time at some point...problem is the only strikers 93+ who are available are Aubamayang, Lukaku and Immobile.

    Feel like Selling Aguero for Lukaku is the best choice due to age but I also don't see Auba getting a decrease any time soon. Even is Aguero does get a -1 then he's still higher than Lukaku and equal with Auba.

    What would you do?

  5. On 8/3/2020 at 9:02 AM, Kierans91 said:

    Manchester City’s Jamie Bynoe-Gittens (15) will leave summer with Dortmund leading the race, they see his pathway similar to Jadon Sancho’s.

    Real Madrid and PSG are also keen on him but both won’t be as good for his development in my opinion.

    Excellent talent and another UK player leaving these shores to try a different culture 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿



    (Un)Patiently waiting for SM to add him to the database as he's gonna be a hot one for a lot of people :D

  6. Bit of a rogue one because of his age but do any of you guys think that Vardy would be in for a +1. Currently EPL top scorer, ahead of Aguero Salah Kane Auba who are all 94/95 (I appreciate some of these have had injuries). For the past couple of years he's always been up there in the goals and only a 92 (and only went up in january), so I think it's worth the thought...

  7. 5 minutes ago, Fabino said:

    Monde de jeu très compétitif. La meilleure équipe est imbattable avec messi Ronaldo neymar mbappe vandiyck ramos etc...

    J'aimerais réduire un peu ma masse salariale.

    Si robertson est blessé Ricardo pereira peur jouer aussi à gauche.

    Milik je ne peux pas le vendre pour le moment car je viens de l'acheter.

    De vrij devrait avoir +1 Et hummels -1

    Selling sandro walker and sarabia will give you an extra 300k a week wage budget straight away so you could start with those three and see how the finances are doing after that? 

    My only thought about selling De Vrij over Hummels was that De Vrij is always predicted to get a +1 but he never seems to actually get it :D But he is younger and Hummels will get a -1 eventually. Again it all depends on if you rate having a 93 rated CB right now in your team who will probably become a 92, or having a 91 rated CB who may become a 92.

  8. 12 minutes ago, Fabino said:

    I have 28 players

    becker 95 nubel 88

    carvajal 92 walker 92 r.pereira 91 emerson 86

    robertson 93 sandro 92 davies 88

    hummels 93 gimenez 92 lenglet 92 devrij 91 e.alvarez 86 bastoni 85

    kroos 95 verratti 94 henderson 92 Arthur 92 tonali 87

    A.traore 88 sarabia 91 eriksen 94 son 93 aubameyang 94 Icardi 93 milik 90

    I would like to reduce my workforce to 21 players..who to sell?

    I think sell sarabia Walker sandro hummels nubel 


    nice squad you've got going for you!

    However, it depends, do you just want to get rid of people or are you trying to raise funds for new players, or reduce wage bill?

    I'd sell Sarabia, Walker, Sandro like you said as you've got good players in those positions already.

    I'd also get rid of Milik (your attack is stacked) and De Vrij (Hummels is +2 ratings so depends how competitive your GW is really). Furthermore, I'd get rid of Nubel and buy a cheap 70 rated GK so you have two GK's in your team if you want money although Nubel is due to take over from Neuer in a couple of years i believe (I believe GK's can't get injured in SM??)

    Also worth thinking about cover if you have injuries - take LB for example, are you happy to play Davies (88) if Robertson gets injured for 6 weeks etc.

  9. On 6/30/2020 at 11:29 AM, Toby S said:

    Hi all with brazilian league in review i thought I'd share brazilian youth players i have in my team that either did well in the U17 World Cup recently(ish) or were suggested for me to buy on here. I presume that some of them will get upgrades but can't confirm:

    Talles Magno (18) - Vasco De Gama

    Kai Jorge (18) - Santos

    Damasceno Renyer (16) - Santos

    Gabriel Veron (obvious one)(17) - Palmeiras

    Vinicius Tobias (16) - SC Internacional

    Miguel Silveira (17) - Fluminense 70 -> 73 today

    If anyone picks these guys up I hope they get upgraded :D 


  • Create New...