Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
EdMoses

The Greatest - Nominations Thread

Recommended Posts

Some of you may have visited the thread that Mudito set up regarding the best player of all time, if you haven’t I suggest you head over and vote from the selection he has presented, here’s the link

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showthread.php?t=109722

However the thread started a debate about who should or shouldn’t be on the list. To that end I have decided to produce my own poll - inspired by Mudito - with a difference.

In an attempt to be a little more “definitive” if indeed on can be definitive about a subject open to opinion, I am asking for forummers to nominate their own top 10 players, in no particular order.

As soon as a player reaches 15 nominations he will be entered into the overall top 10. Once we have a completed top 10 we can then open up a poll for voting. It will be interesting to compare the results to Mudito’s findings – I have a feeling our top three will still be Maradona, Pele and Messi for instance.

Simply post a list of those ten players you regard as the best of this or any era. You’re all ugly enough to decide what defines that greatness, fell free to add details. But within your post please display an uninterrupted list of players 1 – 10. I shall get the ball rolling myself in a moment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Greatest - Nominations Thread

27 VOTES

27 Pele

27 Zidane

26 VOTES

26 Maradona

24 VOTES

24 Cruyff

18 VOTES

18 Ronaldo

18 Messi

14 VOTES

14 Beckenbauer

13 VOTES

13 Best

10 VOTES

10 Maldini

9 VOTES

9 Henry

8 VOTES

8 Xavi

7 VOTES

7 Eusebio

7 Marco Van Basten

7 Ronaldinho

7 Giggs

6 VOTES

6 Puskas

6 Yashin

5 VOTES

5 Platini

5 Di Stefano

4 VOTES

4 Gascoigne

4 Gordon Banks

4 C Ronaldo

3 VOTES

3 Gerrard

3 Dennis Bergkamp

3 Larsson

3 Zico

3 Schmeichel

3 Scholes

3 Del Piero

2 VOTES

2 Gullit

2 Bobby Charlton

2 Gerd Muller

2 Edgar Davids

2 Hagi

2 Iniesta

2 Moore

2 Cantona

1 VOTE

1 Ruud Van Nistelrooy

1 Owen

1 Baresi

1 Robert Pires

1 Dobrin

1 Jim Baxter

1 Kahn

1 Davie Cooper

1 Arthur Numan

1 Alan Shearer

1 Michael Mols

1 Brian Laudrup

1 Dennis Law

1 Paulo Di Canio

1 Socrates

1 Kenny Dalglish

1 Makelele

1 Van Persie

1 David Silva

1 Jairzinho

1 Garrincho

1 Heskey :)

1 Juninho Pernambucano

1 Gilmar

1 Alessandro Del Piero

1 Alessio Tacchinardi

1 Andrea Pirlo

1 Antonio Conte

1 Pavel Nedved

1 Gaetano Scirea

1 Gigi Buffon

1 George Weah

1 Roy Keane

1 David Beckham

1 Sir Tom Finney

1 Sir Stanley Matthews

1 David Nugent :)

1 Sir Bobby Charlton

1 Cafu

1 Thuram

1 Koeman

1 Deschamps

1 Figo

1 Baggio

1 Matthaus

1 Rivaldo

1 Romario

1 Stoichkov

1 Rooney

1 Garrincha

1 Schiaffino

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Greatest - Nominations Thread

Some of you may have visited the thread that Mudito set up regarding the best player of all time' date=' if you haven’t I suggest you head over and vote from the selection he has presented, here’s the link

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showthread.php?t=109722

However the thread started a debate about who should or shouldn’t be on the list. To that end I have decided to produce my own poll - inspired by Mudito - with a difference.

In an attempt to be a little more “definitive” if indeed on can be definitive about a subject open to opinion, I am asking for forummers to nominate their own top 10 players, in no particular order.

As soon as a player reaches 15 nominations he will be entered into the overall top 10. Once we have a completed top 10 we can then open up a poll for voting. It will be interesting to compare the results to Mudito’s findings – I have a feeling our top three will still be Maradona, Pele and Messi for instance.

Simply post a list of those ten players you regard as the best of this or any era. You’re all ugly enough to decide what defines that greatness, fell free to add details. But within your post please display an uninterrupted list of players 1 – 10. I shall get the ball rolling myself in a moment.

i liked the idea

but i think at the end ,as u said, it will be pele maradona messi although we can see a slight change in the top 10 nominees

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Respuesta: The Greatest - Nominations Thread

It's hard to choose just 10, but these are my chosen ones.

Cruyff

Maradona

Gullit

Zidane

Van Basten

Ronaldo

Pele

Beckenbauer

Yashin

di Stefano

I have not put any active player because they do not know if they're among them until they retire ...

Bye!!;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Greatest - Nominations Thread

IMO:

Pele

Best

Charlton

Zidane

Ruud Van Nistelrooy

Gascoigne

Giggs

Messi

Owen

Gerrard

Simply a set of players I've seen a lot of footage on or have thoroughly enjoyed watching in my time, no point me putting up names of players I've barely watched play or never even seen them at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Greatest - Nominations Thread

the future one: Eden Hazard ( :D )

________________________________________________

Zizou

Pele

Schmeichel

Maradona

Ronaldo(real one)

Maldini

Scholes

Giggs

Van Basten

Cruyff

you surprise me! i expected far more Man Utd players

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Greatest - Nominations Thread

the future one: Eden Hazard ( :D )

________________________________________________

Zizou

Hagi

Schmeichel

Maradona

Ronaldo(real one)

Pele

Scholes

Giggs

Van Basten

Dobrin

oohh wrote them too fast.I forgot to add a few.

Cruyff and Maldini out -> Dobrin maybe the best footballer I ever saw(totally forgot about him) and Hagi(the king....one of the best play-makers in history for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...