Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
andyturner

Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????  

  1. 1.

    • Thomas Muller
      9
    • Mario Gotze
      12


Recommended Posts

I'm currently managing bayern muchinch in a german championship with broiussa dortmund being managed and i'm wanting gozte

Would swapping Muller for Gotze be a good deal for me as will he over take muller in rating over the next few years?

If not muller ho else would you part-exchange from these players:

modric

di maria

van persie

fabregas

Y toure

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

i'm wanting gotze and currently have muller' date=' would it be a good deal for me to part-exchange muller for gozte? :confused:[/quote']

ah.didnt read the post..I read just the title.

Get gotze then.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

Lol' date=' all I can say is as bad as it might seem to some people, its just what I think. I know many will disagree though. [/b']

Yh it's your opinion mate ;)

Can't change that no matter how hard I try :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

Lol' date=' all I can say is as bad as it might seem to some people, its just what I think. I know many will disagree though. [/b']

Muller isnt doing brilliant atm and Gotze will EASILY surpass him.He's simply at his peak atm with 93..in ohter way Gotze will easily hit 93 even at Dortmund.Why?Because Gotze is a better player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

so offering muller for gotze is a good deal if the other manager will accept

Muller isnt doing brilliant atm and Gotze will EASILY surpass him.He's simply at his peak atm with 93..in ohter way Gotze will easily hit 93 even at Dortmund.Why?Because Gotze is a better player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

Muller isnt doing brilliant atm and Gotze will EASILY surpass him.He's simply at his peak atm with 93..in ohter way Gotze will easily hit 93 even at Dortmund.Why?Because Gotze is a better player.

Muller hasn't peaked IMO. He is only 22. Also how is 20 and 11 goals in all games this season bad? Its not that bad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

He isnt but for a long time he'll be a 93...his peak is 94 anyway.

Gotze peak is the sky.

We will see. I know he is a good player but Muller for now is better and the difference wont be much in the future. Both are excellent players though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

I'd prefer to have Gotze but wouldn't do the deal yet unless you can get something else in the deal (a useful amount of cash or a half decent player). Giving away a young 93 who can rise further for a significantly lower rated and only slightly younger other player doesn't make sense.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

I'd prefer to have Gotze but wouldn't do the deal yet unless you can get something else in the deal (a useful amount of cash or a half decent player). Giving away a young 93 who can rise further for a significantly lower rated and only slightly younger other player doesn't make sense.

Gotze is about 2 and a half years younger and only 2 ratings behind, he could gain that deficit by the next few rating changes, if he hadn't got injured he would have been 92 by now and he's returning this week :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

thanks for your all your help and i've made the offer to the manager and we'll just have to wait and see if he thinks that he's getting the better deal or not, it's a shame that he's a manager that doesn't reply back to messages or offers quickly, as i offered pecro part-ex earlier in the season and he didn't make any changes to the offer or reject in about 3 weeks so i took the offer away

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

Gotze is about 2 and a half years younger and only 2 ratings behind' date=' he could gain that deficit by the next few rating changes, if he hadn't got injured he would have been 92 by now and he's returning this week :D[/quote']

but people are going on like Muller doesnt have a chance in hell in the next few changes to get 94. Also I would pretty much rule out 92 in the next changes for Gotze because Dortmund might take it easy on him from his return. Muller might not be having an excellent season but it could change. Its possible isnt it? Bayern are a good team and play good in the CL plus Muller does well with Germany so while Gotze might be the better player, Muller's chances of rising haven't come to an end. I'd rather keep Muller cause I'd be having a 93 rated player, possibly 94 for a lot longer. He'd be more useful to my team for a number of SM seasons. Also 2 and a half years younger means nothing when the older player is only 22.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

but people are going on like Muller doesnt have a chance in hell in the next few changes to get 94. Also I would pretty much rule out 92 in the next changes for Gotze because Dortmund might take it easy on him from his return. Muller might not be having an excellent season but it could change. Its possible isnt it? Bayern are a good team and play good in the CL plus Muller does well with Germany so while Gotze might be the better player' date=' Muller's chances of rising haven't come to an end. [/b']I'd rather keep Muller cause I'd be having a 93 rated player, possibly 94 for a lot longer. He'd be more useful to my team for a number of SM seasons. Also 2 and a half years younger means nothing when the older player is only 22.

I hate to admit it :( but you're right ;)

Muller is only 22, a starter for the best NT in the world IMO and one of the best clubs in the world, he has the potential to get to the mid 90s

I agree with Dortmund letting him have it easy from his return, his back ups have played really well and Low needs him for the Euros so they won't risk him playing too much, however Gotze will get 92 before Muller gets a 94 and if Muller gets 94 he will be in the same bracket as the likes of Ozil, Xabi Alonso which he doesn't deserve, Gotze can hit 93 before Muller hits 94, and by that time only 2-3 SM seasons will finish so it's not a huge loss ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

I hate to admit it :( but you're right ;)

Muller is only 22' date=' a starter [b']for the best NT[/b] in the world IMO and one of the best clubs in the world, he has the potential to get to the mid 90s

I agree with Dortmund letting him have it easy from his return, his back ups have played really well and Low needs him for the Euros so they won't risk him playing too much, however Gotze will get 92 before Muller gets a 94 and if Muller gets 94 he will be in the same bracket as the likes of Ozil, Xabi Alonso which he doesn't deserve, Gotze can hit 93 before Muller hits 94, and by that time only 2-3 SM seasons will finish so it's not a huge loss ;)

Spain is the best NT in the world.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Thomas Muller for Mario Gotze?????

I hate to admit it :( but you're right ;)

Muller is only 22' date=' a starter for the best NT in the world IMO and one of the best clubs in the world, he has the potential to get to the mid 90s

I agree with Dortmund letting him have it easy from his return, his back ups have played really well and Low needs him for the Euros so they won't risk him playing too much, however Gotze will get 92 before Muller gets a 94 and if Muller gets 94 he will be in the same bracket as the likes of Ozil, Xabi Alonso which he doesn't deserve, Gotze can hit 93 before Muller hits 94, and by that time only 2-3 SM seasons will finish so it's not a huge loss ;)[/quote']

I think it comes down to personal preference as you're right when you say its not a huge loss because it wont be in the end. Personally though 3 SM seasons is something to take into consideration.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...