Bundesliga Ratings Discussion

[Preppens 10,217]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

ok' date=' new example

Di Maria>Reus?[/quote']

I think they'll both be 93 very soon with Reus the one more likely to achieve a 94. There are way better examples out there, but I'm starting to understand where you are trying to get at with this.

La liga and the top sides has for a long time been rated a lot higher then Bundesligas dito. But I think it's slowly being evened out as Bundesliga (irl) is getting better and better.

I think it's just that they didn't want to rise a lot of players in the big sides in bundesliga too much in just one review, which I can agree with, but I think it's slowly changing on SM.

By looking at Bayern's performance, tranfers and likely transfer targets, I believe atleast Bayern will catch up with Real and Barcelona rating wise (Bar the 97-98-99 rating as they are for the absolute best in the world, which will take a while for any player from any league to overtake from Iniesta, Messi and Ronaldo).

[123_ABC 9,305]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Yeh i dont think reus n di maria was a good example, people are forgetting its only reus first season in a club capable of winnin trophies, di maria has been with madrid for a few seasons. Everything takes time n reus will eventually get it.

[Mia San Mia 7,151]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Yeh i dont think reus n di maria was a good example' date=' people are forgetting its only reus first season in a club capable of winnin trophies, di maria has been with madrid for a few seasons. Everything takes time n reus will eventually get it.[/quote']

Spot on.....

[123_ABC 9,305]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Spot on.....

Cheers, one more thing is sm definitely started to rate bundesliga more by rising gotze n hummels n the cl success will do good things.

[Mr E 3,117]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

I have a question regarding the 2 German teams. If Bayern win the champions league will we see this?

Dante-->93

Kroos-->93

Mandzukic-->92

Boeteng-->91

Schweinsteiger-->95

Lahm-->95

Muller-->94

Shaqiri-->90

And if Dortmund win will we see this?

Gotze-->94

Lewandowski-->93

Reus-->93

Subotic-->92

Schmelzer-->91

Kuba-->92

[VatreniUnited 3,738]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

I have a question regarding the 2 German teams. If Bayern win the champions league will we see this?

Dante-->93

Kroos-->93

Mandzukic-->92

Boeteng-->91

Schweinsteiger-->95

Lahm-->95

Muller-->94

Shaqiri-->90

Apart from Mandzukic(MSM might give a better opinion) and Boateng I think all is possible though I will not surprise at all if Dante just get +1

And if Dortmund win will we see this?

Gotze-->94

Lewandowski-->93

Reus-->93

Subotic-->92

Schmelzer-->91

Kuba-->92

Same with above' date=' undecided about Gotze, but Lewa, Subotic, & Schmelzer most deserve to rise imo[/b']

Bolded above.

[123_ABC 9,305]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

I have a question regarding the 2 German teams. If Bayern win the champions league will we see this?

Dante-->93

Kroos-->93

Mandzukic-->92

Boeteng-->91

Schweinsteiger-->95

Lahm-->95

Muller-->94

Shaqiri-->90

And if Dortmund win will we see this?

Gotze-->94

Lewandowski-->93

Reus-->93

Subotic-->92

Schmelzer-->91

Kuba-->92

We wont be seeing the bold ones imo but the rest Id say yes.

[Anri 8,068]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

I have a question regarding the 2 German teams. If Bayern win the champions league will we see this?

Dante-->93 yes

Kroos-->93 no

Mandzukic-->92 yes

Boeteng-->91 no

Schweinsteiger-->95 even if they dont this guys deserves it

Lahm-->95 no

Muller-->94 definitely yes

Shaqiri-->90 yes

And if Dortmund win will we see this?

Gotze-->94 it's to early' date=' isnt it ?

Lewandowski-->93 probably 94 if they win CL

Reus-->93 yes

Subotic-->92 yes

Schmelzer-->91

Kuba-->92 yes

[/quote']

My answers on the right

[Mr E 3,117]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

My answers on the right

We wont be seeing the bold ones imo but the rest Id say yes.

Bolded above.

Thanks for the input guys, Id say Dante, Mandzukic and Gotze are the least likely

[Raz. 13,637]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

I have a question regarding the 2 German teams. If Bayern win the champions league will we see this?

Dante-->93 92

Kroos-->93 Yes

Mandzukic-->92 Stay

Boeteng-->91 Yes

Schweinsteiger-->95 Yes

Lahm-->95 Yes

Muller-->94 Yes

Shaqiri-->90 Yes

And if Dortmund win will we see this?

Gotze-->94 100%

Lewandowski-->93 2000%

Reus-->93 300%

Subotic-->92 100%

Schmelzer-->91 92

Kuba-->92 90%

Answers there pal

[Anri 8,068]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Dante less likely to hit 93 ? He is part of the best defence in the world...

[Raz. 13,637]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Dante less likely to hit 93 ? He is part of the best defence in the world...

I think the jump from 90 to 93 within a season is too much for Dante.

[Anri 8,068]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

I think the jump from 90 to 93 within a season is too much for Dante.

Well l think it's possible lf they win the cup and CL

[123_ABC 9,305]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Although it would be a suprise, he wouldnt be the first to get from 91 to 93 in one go. Bayern are lacking a top rated cb unlike many other top clubs so it might happen.

[filipousis 247]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

I have a question regarding the 2 German teams. If Bayern win the champions league will we see this?

Dante-->93 92 IMO

Kroos-->93 could be but with the injury' date=' 92 is ok[/b']

Mandzukic-->92 why not he scores for fun

Boeteng-->91 I cant see that coming, but could be

Schweinsteiger-->95 he deserves it

Lahm-->95 sure

Muller-->94 also sure

Shaqiri-->90 could be

And if Dortmund win will we see this?

Gotze-->94 a little too early, but he's a 94 player for sure

Lewandowski-->93 yes

Reus-->93 absolutely yes

Subotic-->92 he deserves it

Schmelzer-->91 if not 92

Kuba-->92 IMO 91 is quite good for him

my thoughts in bold

[Niero 26]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

I think they'll both be 93 very soon with Reus the one more likely to achieve a 94. There are way better examples out there' date=' but I'm starting to understand where you are trying to get at with this.

La liga and the top sides has for a long time been rated a lot higher then Bundesligas dito. But I think it's slowly being evened out as Bundesliga (irl) is getting better and better.

I think it's just that they didn't want to rise a lot of players in the big sides in bundesliga too much in just one review, which I can agree with, but I think it's slowly changing on SM.

By looking at Bayern's performance, tranfers and likely transfer targets, I believe atleast Bayern will catch up with Real and Barcelona rating wise (Bar the 97-98-99 rating as they are for the absolute best in the world, which will take a while for any player from any league to overtake from Iniesta, Messi and Ronaldo).[/quote']

Good answer.

I just want to see what you people think about this.

Hope you are right about it's going to change coz Bundesliga is one of the best leagues in the world

I understand it will take time and thats a good thing, but it need to change.

Hope Dortmund and Schalke will continue doing fine in CL to prove that German fotboll are great

[Glenn Hysén 1,123]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Can Hummels grab a 94 if Dortmund goes all the way in CHL?

[Raz. 13,637]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Can Hummels grab a 94 if Dortmund goes all the way in CHL?

Honestly?He shouldn't.He is quite far from a 94 level,at least this season he was.He was injuried for many times aswell..

[123_ABC 9,305]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Can Hummels grab a 94 if Dortmund goes all the way in CHL?

Nar, not possible. Maybe if dortmund won the bundesliga for a 3rd year running but it wont happen.

[Raz. 13,637]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Nar' date=' not possible. Maybe if dortmund won the bundesliga for a 3rd year running but it wont happen.[/quote']

Even if Dortmund was doing that..still no.He simply wasn't good enough.I'd rather give a 94 to Dante

[123_ABC 9,305]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Even if Dortmund was doing that..still no.He simply wasn't good enough.I'd rather give a 94 to Dante

You wouldnt if Bayern were 2nd though would you? I think if Dortmund were 1st it would be a result of hummels and co playing excellent.

[Glenn Hysén 1,123]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Honestly?He shouldn't.He is quite far from a 94 level' date='at least this season he was.He was injuried for many times aswell..[/quote']

Nar' date=' not possible. Maybe if dortmund won the bundesliga for a 3rd year running but it wont happen.[/quote']

Thanks guys!

And when even Dortmunds biggest fan says he can't reach it this season it must be dead certain

[123_ABC 9,305]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Thanks guys!

And when even Dortmunds biggest fan says he can't reach it this season it must be dead certain

Yeh he watches more than me to be fair, cant argue wih that.

[Glenn Hysén 1,123]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

Yeh he watches more than me to be fair' date=' cant argue wih that.[/quote']

And he usually sees the whole world through yellow and black eyes

[J.R 1,544]

Re: Bundesliga Ratings 2012/2013

why is Tadas Kijanska loaned out from dortmund on wiki ????