Jump to content
timesle

Bundesliga Ratings Discussion

Recommended Posts

Sané 89, so coman 90 ?

 

Why should he? Coman must not get more than 89, just like Sané and Dele Alli. He wasn't any better than those two, he just happens to play for a bigger club. He's good, but he wouldn't get half of the gametime if Robben, Ribery and even Götze weren't  always injured during the season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why should he? Coman must not get more than 89, just like Sané and Dele Alli. He wasn't any better than those two, he just happens to play for a bigger club. He's good, but he wouldn't get half of the gametime if Robben, Ribery and even Götze weren't  always injured during the season.

 

really ? coman was fantastic in CL.  sané alli = 0 CL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is why I stopped using SW altogether.

2 players who start the season at 78: Dahoud and Christensen.

They played for the same club this season.

The latter had almost 1000 more minutes of game time than the former.

Dahoud ends the season at 87, while Christensen ends it at 86.

I'm sorry, but this is absolutely indefensible.

Hopefully things like these won't push me over the edge and make me leave SM for good, coz I'm gradually losing my interest in the game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought +3 for Elvedi was very tight.

 

 

I would have given him a +4, but a +5 wouldn't have shocked me.

Dahoud had like 350 more minutes than Elvedi this season.

Dahoud starts it at 78 and ends it at 87, while Elvedi starts it at 80 and ends it at 83.

A +9 vs a +3!!!  :o

Mindboggling stuff to say the least...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have given him a +4, but a +5 wouldn't have shocked me.

Dahoud had like 350 more minutes than Elvedi this season.

Dahoud starts it at 78 and ends it at 87, while Elvedi starts it at 80 and ends it at 83.

A +9 vs a +3!!!  :o

Mindboggling stuff to say the least...

and is it me?? or the fact that his value went up 600k only is really pissing me off!!! i mean Henrichs in 2 mill 19yrs 78 ,.and elvedi 2.8 19 yrs 83

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

really ? coman was fantastic in CL.  sané alli = 0 CL.

 

Really? Fantastic? The games i saw, especially with Benfica and Atlético, i didn't anything that fantastic. Oh, do you mean against Olympiacos? sureeeee!

 

Anyway, i think Brandt should've gotten a 88.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Really? Fantastic? The games i saw, especially with Benfica and Atlético, i didn't anything that fantastic. Oh, do you mean against Olympiacos? sureeeee!

 

Anyway, i think Brandt should've gotten a 88.

 

He played extremely well in the comeback win vs Juve (including assisting the goal that sent it to extra time)

 

and 

 

 

passlack worth getting?

wiegl worth getting? 88 or 89? And what is his potential as in bidding war

 

Definitely get Weigl, he's a class player, and grab Passlack if you can too

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have given him a +4, but a +5 wouldn't have shocked me.

Dahoud had like 350 more minutes than Elvedi this season.

Dahoud starts it at 78 and ends it at 87, while Elvedi starts it at 80 and ends it at 83.

A +9 vs a +3!!!  :o

Mindboggling stuff to say the least...

I thought +3 for Elvedi was very tight.

Yep. Hes even in the provisional euro squad. +3 very measly. Sure someone will say "oh at least he rose" - should we be thankful that people are doing their job, albeit poorly and half-assed?

Very poor. Henrichs deserved a +5. Elvedi deserved a +4 as min. Only one rating point but it does mean a lot to some GWs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im curious to see if Badstuder will get a drop.... even though he was injured!

  

I would say stay, But that didn't stop them dropping Strootman at Roma

Considering the others reviews I think tomorrow we'll have:

D.Costa 94/93. 93

Thiago 92. 92

Alaba 94. 93

Kimmich 88. 87

Coman 90/89. 89

Auba 93. 93

Ginter 90/89. 90 if even

Hummels 94. 94.

In light of other reviews more like less raising than you imagine

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

and why didn't karius get a +1 ????????????????????????

 

got him in most of my teams coz i was 90% sure he will rise..and sold my 89 keepers which i was i expecting to drop!!! i.e R.Zieler -.-

 

I fell you brother.

 

###### Kampl gets +1 to 90?

 

Why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?

Why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?

Why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?

Why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?

Why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?

 

Fuc(x)king rubbish!!!

Absolute rubbish. Didn't do anything. I sold him for 11m to external thinking 99% that he don't deserve a rise and won't. But not I suffer a 90 rated player and a 5m lose. :(

  

Considering the others reviews I think tomorrow we'll have:

D.Costa 94/93

Thiago 92

Alaba 94

Kimmich 88

Coman 90/89

Auba 93

Ginter 90/89

Hummels 94

Costa 93

Thiago, Alaba, Kimmich...ok

Coman 89

Auba should be 94. He's been better than Reus for the last 2 seasons.

Ginter 90

Hummels why?

Also Weigl 89

Chicharito 92 possible(of Kampl can rise 90 for no reason, Why can't he rise to 92)

Ribery 93

Robben 95

Burki 90

Mkhitaryan 93? Don't think so... Pjanic didn't got 93.

Götze 96 :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...