Jump to content

Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread? I'd probably sell Ruiz, Dante, Smalling. Maybe P/E Smalling he would be quite a good value.

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread? Can't think of an 86, 87s atm, But Cristian tello 85>87, Ahmed Musa 85>87, Lacazette 85>88 (he's rose now so...) El Shaarawy 86>88, Oscar + Isco although th

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Youth team any help for who to keep or sell? i need to cut some wages. i know it is a huge list, but i really apreciate your help.

ĆOSIĆ, Uroš D© 20 84

4.0M -

LdE

OBLAK, Jan GR 20 84

4.0M -

LdE

ONAZI, Ogenyi MD,M,MO© 20 84

3.9M 18 Mai

LdE

WOLSKI, Rafal MO(DEC) 20 84

3.9M 7 Jul

Inf

EZEKIEL, Imoh A© 19 84

3.9M -

LdE

BOAKYE, Richmond A© 20 84

3.7M -

LdE

VICO, Fede M(E),MO(EC) 18 83

3.3M -

LdE

MUNIESA, Marc D(EC) 21 84

3.0M 1 Jun

Pro

NINKOVIĆ, Nikola M,MO© 18 82

2.7M -

LdE

DIER, Eric D(DC),MD© 19 82

2.6M 12 Jun

Pro

KLAUS, Felix M,MO(D) 20 82

2.5M -

Inf

TRIGUEROS, Manu MO(DEC) 21 83

2.3M -

LdE

DJORDJEVIC, Luka A(DEC) 18 81

2.0M -

LdE

LUNDSTRAM, John M(EC) 19 81

2.0M 13 Mai

LdE

BOILESEN, Nicolai D(EC) 21 82

1.9M -

Pro

LUKASIK, Daniel MD,M© 22 82

1.8M -

LdE

ROJAS, Marco MO(DEC),A(DE) 21 82

1.8M 31 Mai

LdE

HENLEY, Adam D(DE) 18 80

1.7M -

LdE

ANTONIS, Terry M©,MO(DC) 19 80

1.6M -

Inf

MAUPAY, Neal A© 16 80

1.6M -

LdE

JEAN, Corentin A(DEC) 17 80

1.6M -

LdE

AFFANE, Amin MO(DEC) 19 80

1.6M 2 Jun

LdE

ESGAIO, Ricardo D,MD,M,MO,A(D) 19 80

1.5M 13 Jun

Pro

BIDWELL, Jake D,MD,M(E) 20 79

1.1M -

LdE

QUIÑONES, Héctor D,MD,M(E) 21 80

1.1M -

LdE

JEDVAJ, Tin D© 17 78

980m -

LdE

JONNY, Otto D(D) 19 78

930m 4 Jun

LdE

CAVALLARO, Juan M,MO© 18 78

920m -

LdE

FERNANDES, Bruno M,MO© 18 78

920m 13 Mai

LdE

SERRANO, Álex M,MO© 18 78

920m -

LdE

FORMILIANO, Fabricio D(EC) 20 78

910m -

LdE

AL MUWALLAD, Fahad A© 18 78

880m -

LdE

FERREIRA, Brian MO,A(DEC) 18 78

880m -

LdE

NETFULLIN, Ravil MD,M© 20 78

870m -

LdE

PAZIO, Adam D,MD,M(E) 20 78

870m 4 Jun

LdE

AKSENTIJEVIĆ, Nikola D,MD(D) 20 78

870m -

LdE

RUIZ, John A(DEC) 19 78

860m -

LdE

GALHARDO, Rafael D,MD,M(D) 21 78

680m 28 Jun

LdE

ARRIZABALAGA, Kepa GR 18 77

680m -

LdE

VARELA, Bruno GR 18 77

680m -

LdE

MEYER, Max MO(DEC) 17 77

670m -

Inf

BAŠIĆ, Josip M,MO(D) 17 77

670m -

LdE

AKÉ, Nathan D(EC),MD© 18 77

650m -

LdE

RODRÍGUEZ, Gianni D,MD,M(E) 18 77

650m -

LdE

ZIELINSKI, Piotr M©,MO(DEC) 18 77

650m -

LdE

KOSOVIĆ, Nebojša MO(DEC) 18 77

650m -

LdE

CABALCETA, Erick D© 20 77

640m -

LdE

CUMMINS, Adam D© 20 77

640m -

LdE

FOKOBO, Fabrice D(DC),MD© 19 77

630m -

LdE

KANE, Todd D,MD,M(D) 19 77

630m -

LdE

ROMANÒ, Andrea M© 19 77

630m -

LdE

ROZZI, Antonio A(DC) 18 77

620m -

LdE

BEL HASSANI, Iliass MO(DEC) 20 77

620m 1 Jun

LdE

MINAMINO, Takumi A© 18 77

620m 4 Jun

LdE

WILLIE, Barbosa A© 19 77

610m 3 Jun

LdE

HASSAN, Ahmed A© 20 77

590m -

LdE

RAFINHA, Lima A(DEC) 20 77

590m 26 Jun

LdE

KING, Seejou D(DE),MD© 21 77

520m 17 Mai

LdE

MCGINTY, Sean D(EC) 19 76

440m 2 Jun

LdE

VELÁZQUEZ, Emiliano D© 19 76

440m -

Inf

PERICA, Stipe A(DEC) 17 76

430m -

LdE

LUMU, Jeroen MO,A(DE) 17 76

430m -

LdE

VELA, Josh M© 19 76

420m -

LdE

REILLY, Callum MO(DEC) 19 76

420m 3 Jun

LdE

DE TOMÁS, Raúl A© 18 76

420m -

LdE

DULJEVIĆ, Haris MO(DE) 19 76

420m 6 Jun

LdE

RITZMAIER, Marcel M(EC) 20 76

410m 2 Jun

LdE

CÉSAR, Renato A(DEC) 19 76

400m -

LdE

SERDEROV, Serder A© 19 76

400m -

LdE

GALVÁN, Martín MO©,A(DEC) 20 76

390m -

LdE

LOPES, Marcos M(E),MO(EC) 17 75

300m -

LdE

LOBANTSEV, Miroslav GR 17 75

300m 27 Mai

LdE

CAPILLA, Eneko M© 17 75

300m -

LdE

MINA, Santi A© 17 75

300m 18 Jun

LdE

BRODIĆ, Fran A© 16 75

300m 5 Jul

LdE

CRECCO, Luca MO(E),A(EC) 17 75

300m 7 Jul

LdE

THORLÁKSSON, Indridi Áki M(DEC) 17 75

300m 16 Jun

LdE

SCHRIJVERS, Siebe A© 16 75

300m -

LdE

STENDERA, Marc M,MO© 17 75

300m 21 Jun

LdE

MCLAUGHLIN, Ryan D,MD(D) 18 75

290m 28 Mai

LdE

GÓMEZ, Julio MO(DEC) 18 75

290m 27 Mai

LdE

ESPERICUETA, Jorge M,MO© 18 75

290m -

LdE

SILVA, Jonathan D(DEC) 18 75

290m -

LdE

MIHAJLOVIĆ, Stefan A© 18 75

290m 3 Jun

LdE

PONDE, Cristian A© 18 75

290m 24 Jun

LdE

HOWIESON, Cameron MO© 18 75

290m 5 Jun

LdE

SIMUNOVIC, Jozo D(EC),MD© 18 75

290m 4 Jun

LdE

ASHONG, Nii Nortey D(E) 18 75

290m -

LdE

JEFFREY, Anthony M,MO,A(E) 18 75

290m 1 Jun

Inf

MITRITA, Ionuţ MO© 18 75

290m -

LdE

AKPOGUMA, Kevin D(DEC) 18 75

290m 25 Jun

LdE

MAMUTE, Yuri A© 18 75

290m -

LdE

CAMPBELL, Adam A© 18 75

290m 3 Jun

LdE

FINNBOGASON, Kristján Flóki A© 18 75

290m 21 Jun

LdE

MONTICONE, Mattia D© 18 75

290m 24 Jun

LdE

KĘDZIORA, Tomasz D(DC) 18 75

290m 4 Jun

LdE

HODŽIĆ, Armin A© 18 75

290m 24 Jun

LdE

TAVARES, Ricardo D(EC) 18 75

290m 19 Jun

LdE

CURTI, Nicolò D© 18 75

290m -

LdE

LABIDI, Zakarie A(EC) 18 75

290m -

LdE

LENZ, Christopher D(EC) 18 75

290m 15 Jun

LdE

VARELA, Jim MD,M© 18 75

290m -

LdE

NGANDO, Axel M,MO© 19 75

280m -

LdE

GLADESTONY, Estevão MD,M© 19 75

280m 24 Jun

LdE

AGUIRRE, Alan D(D) 19 75

280m 1 Jun

LdE

PRCIĆ, Sanjin MO(DEC) 19 75

280m -

LdE

BURKE, Graham A© 19 75

280m 13 Jun

LdE

BABUNSKI, David MO© 19 75

280m -

LdE

COUTINHO, Douglas A(DEC) 19 75

280m 6 Jul

LdE

BOURDIN, Pierre D(EC) 19 75

280m -

LdE

HEYLEN, Michael D© 19 75

280m 30 Jun

LdE

GANZ, Simone A© 19 75

280m -

LdE

CALDEIRA, Matheus GR 19 75

280m 24 Jun

LdE

SAMUEL, Dominic A© 19 75

280m 16 Mai

LdE

HUWS, Emyr MD,M© 19 75

280m -

LdE

SAVILLE, George D(EC),MD© 19 75

280m 1 Jun

LdE

GIBBS, Joey A© 20 75

270m -

LdE

NGOO, Michael A© 20 75

270m -

LdE

GIVA, Pulgas A© 20 75

270m 16 Jun

LdE

GRILL, Lukas D© 20 75

270m 19 Jun

LdE

KÖZ, Cüneyt D(DC) 20 75

270m -

LdE

CARRUTHERS, Samir MO(DEC) 20 75

270m -

Inf

MOJICA, Harrison Arley MO,A© 20 75

270m -

LdE

MUSONDA, Lamisha M,MO© 21 75

270m 2 Jun

LdE

BAEK, Sung-dong MO(DEC) 21 75

270m -

LdE

ÁLVAREZ BALANTA, Éder D(EC) 20 75

270m 30 Jun

LdE

PRITCHARD, Alex M,MO© 20 75

270m -

LdE

CORNET, Gnaly MO(DE),A(DEC) 16 74

200m 14 Jun

LdE

DE GIROLAMO, Diego MO©,A(EC) 17 74

190m -

LdE

POTTS, Brad D(D),MD© 18 74

190m -

LdE

KOVACIC, Miro M© 18 74

190m 12 Jun

LdE

WALLACE, Jed M(DEC) 19 74

180m 24 Jun

LdE

VUČINIĆ, Jovan A(DEC) 21 74

170m -

LdE

LUKOVIĆ, Andrija D,MO(D),MD,M(DC) 18 72

50m 3 Jun

LdE

COLCLOUGH, Ryan MO(DE),A(DEC) 18 70

10m 3 Jun

LdE

SAINTE-LUCE, Kevin M,MO(D) 20 70

10m -

LdE

VERGARA, Jherson D© 18 67

10m 9 Jul

LdE

DERICI, Okan

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Andre hoffmann 83 rated german under 20 DM' date=' OR Alves Jadson under 20 brasilian DM.. who has more potential or are they both worth trying to get.[/quote']

If you have the money then take a punt on the pair of them.

I prefer Hoffmann at present, he is playing in possibly the best league in the world, granted for a mid table side, but he is young and at a club where he will get plenty game time and hopefully progress as a consequence.

Jadson from what little I know about him is a decent prospect however unlike many on here who just spout a name without probably ever watching him play or giving a reason why they have chosen that player I will be honest and never seen him play, but I have read a little about him.

Go for Hoffmann for the reasons I have already stated, however if you have the cash get both as they will both undoubtedly rise further so will, if nothing else make you a tidy profit.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Looks like I'm the only one brave enough to do it then :P

Youth team any help for who to keep or sell? i need to cut some wages. i know it is a huge list' date=' but i really apreciate your help.

ĆOSIĆ, Uroš D© 20 84

4.0M -

LdE

OBLAK, Jan GR 20 84

4.0M -

LdE

ONAZI, Ogenyi MD,M,MO© 20 84

3.9M 18 Mai

LdE

WOLSKI, Rafal MO(DEC) 20 84

3.9M 7 Jul

Inf

EZEKIEL, Imoh A© 19 84

3.9M -

LdE

BOAKYE, Richmond A© 20 84

3.7M -

LdE

VICO, Fede M(E),MO(EC) 18 83

3.3M -

LdE

MUNIESA, Marc D(EC) 21 84

3.0M 1 Jun

Pro

NINKOVIĆ, Nikola M,MO© 18 82

2.7M -

LdE

DIER, Eric D(DC),MD© 19 82

2.6M 12 Jun

Pro

KLAUS, Felix M,MO(D) 20 82

2.5M -

Inf

TRIGUEROS, Manu MO(DEC) 21 83

2.3M -

LdE

DJORDJEVIC, Luka A(DEC) 18 81

2.0M -

LdE

LUNDSTRAM, John M(EC) 19 81

2.0M 13 Mai

LdE

BOILESEN, Nicolai D(EC) 21 82

1.9M -

Pro

LUKASIK, Daniel MD,M© 22 82

1.8M -

LdE

ROJAS, Marco MO(DEC),A(DE) 21 82

1.8M 31 Mai

LdE

HENLEY, Adam D(DE) 18 80

1.7M -

LdE

ANTONIS, Terry M©,MO(DC) 19 80

1.6M -

Inf

MAUPAY, Neal A© 16 80

1.6M -

LdE

JEAN, Corentin A(DEC) 17 80

1.6M -

LdE

AFFANE, Amin MO(DEC) 19 80

1.6M 2 Jun

LdE

ESGAIO, Ricardo D,MD,M,MO,A(D) 19 80

1.5M 13 Jun

Pro

BIDWELL, Jake D,MD,M(E) 20 79

1.1M -

LdE

QUIÑONES, Héctor D,MD,M(E) 21 80

1.1M -

LdE

JEDVAJ, Tin D© 17 78

980m -

LdE

JONNY, Otto D(D) 19 78

930m 4 Jun

LdE

CAVALLARO, Juan M,MO© 18 78

920m -

LdE

FERNANDES, Bruno M,MO© 18 78

920m 13 Mai

LdE

SERRANO, Álex M,MO© 18 78

920m -

LdE

FORMILIANO, Fabricio D(EC) 20 78

910m -

LdE

AL MUWALLAD, Fahad A© 18 78

880m -

LdE

FERREIRA, Brian MO,A(DEC) 18 78

880m -

LdE

NETFULLIN, Ravil MD,M© 20 78

870m -

LdE

PAZIO, Adam D,MD,M(E) 20 78

870m 4 Jun

LdE

AKSENTIJEVIĆ, Nikola D,MD(D) 20 78

870m -

LdE

RUIZ, John A(DEC) 19 78

860m -

LdE

GALHARDO, Rafael D,MD,M(D) 21 78

680m 28 Jun

LdE

ARRIZABALAGA, Kepa GR 18 77

680m -

LdE

VARELA, Bruno GR 18 77

680m -

LdE

MEYER, Max MO(DEC) 17 77

670m -

Inf

BAŠIĆ, Josip M,MO(D) 17 77

670m -

LdE

AKÉ, Nathan D(EC),MD© 18 77

650m -

LdE

RODRÍGUEZ, Gianni D,MD,M(E) 18 77

650m -

LdE

ZIELINSKI, Piotr M©,MO(DEC) 18 77

650m -

LdE

KOSOVIĆ, Nebojša MO(DEC) 18 77

650m -

LdE

CABALCETA, Erick D© 20 77

640m -

LdE

CUMMINS, Adam D© 20 77

640m -

LdE

FOKOBO, Fabrice D(DC),MD© 19 77

630m -

LdE

KANE, Todd D,MD,M(D) 19 77

630m -

LdE

ROMANÒ, Andrea M© 19 77

630m -

LdE

ROZZI, Antonio A(DC) 18 77

620m -

LdE

BEL HASSANI, Iliass MO(DEC) 20 77

620m 1 Jun

LdE

MINAMINO, Takumi A© 18 77

620m 4 Jun

LdE

WILLIE, Barbosa A© 19 77

610m 3 Jun

LdE

HASSAN, Ahmed A© 20 77

590m -

LdE

RAFINHA, Lima A(DEC) 20 77

590m 26 Jun

LdE

KING, Seejou D(DE),MD© 21 77

520m 17 Mai

LdE

MCGINTY, Sean D(EC) 19 76

440m 2 Jun

LdE

VELÁZQUEZ, Emiliano D© 19 76

440m -

Inf

PERICA, Stipe A(DEC) 17 76

430m -

LdE

LUMU, Jeroen MO,A(DE) 17 76

430m -

LdE

VELA, Josh M© 19 76

420m -

LdE

REILLY, Callum MO(DEC) 19 76

420m 3 Jun

LdE

DE TOMÁS, Raúl A© 18 76

420m -

LdE

DULJEVIĆ, Haris MO(DE) 19 76

420m 6 Jun

LdE

RITZMAIER, Marcel M(EC) 20 76

410m 2 Jun

LdE

CÉSAR, Renato A(DEC) 19 76

400m -

LdE

SERDEROV, Serder A© 19 76

400m -

LdE

GALVÁN, Martín MO©,A(DEC) 20 76

390m -

LdE

LOPES, Marcos M(E),MO(EC) 17 75

300m -

LdE

LOBANTSEV, Miroslav GR 17 75

300m 27 Mai

LdE

CAPILLA, Eneko M© 17 75

300m -

LdE

MINA, Santi A© 17 75

300m 18 Jun

LdE

BRODIĆ, Fran A© 16 75

300m 5 Jul

LdE

CRECCO, Luca MO(E),A(EC) 17 75

300m 7 Jul

LdE

THORLÁKSSON, Indridi Áki M(DEC) 17 75

300m 16 Jun

LdE

SCHRIJVERS, Siebe A© 16 75

300m -

LdE

STENDERA, Marc M,MO© 17 75

300m 21 Jun

LdE

MCLAUGHLIN, Ryan D,MD(D) 18 75

290m 28 Mai

LdE

GÓMEZ, Julio MO(DEC) 18 75

290m 27 Mai

LdE

ESPERICUETA, Jorge M,MO© 18 75

290m -

LdE

SILVA, Jonathan D(DEC) 18 75

290m -

LdE

MIHAJLOVIĆ, Stefan A© 18 75

290m 3 Jun

LdE

PONDE, Cristian A© 18 75

290m 24 Jun

LdE

HOWIESON, Cameron MO© 18 75

290m 5 Jun

LdE

SIMUNOVIC, Jozo D(EC),MD© 18 75

290m 4 Jun

LdE

ASHONG, Nii Nortey D(E) 18 75

290m -

LdE

JEFFREY, Anthony M,MO,A(E) 18 75

290m 1 Jun

Inf

MITRITA, Ionuţ MO© 18 75

290m -

LdE

AKPOGUMA, Kevin D(DEC) 18 75

290m 25 Jun

LdE

MAMUTE, Yuri A© 18 75

290m -

LdE

CAMPBELL, Adam A© 18 75

290m 3 Jun

LdE

FINNBOGASON, Kristján Flóki A© 18 75

290m 21 Jun

LdE

MONTICONE, Mattia D© 18 75

290m 24 Jun

LdE

KĘDZIORA, Tomasz D(DC) 18 75

290m 4 Jun

LdE

HODŽIĆ, Armin A© 18 75

290m 24 Jun

LdE

TAVARES, Ricardo D(EC) 18 75

290m 19 Jun

LdE

CURTI, Nicolò D© 18 75

290m -

LdE

LABIDI, Zakarie A(EC) 18 75

290m -

LdE

LENZ, Christopher D(EC) 18 75

290m 15 Jun

LdE

VARELA, Jim MD,M© 18 75

290m -

LdE

NGANDO, Axel M,MO© 19 75

280m -

LdE

GLADESTONY, Estevão MD,M© 19 75

280m 24 Jun

LdE

AGUIRRE, Alan D(D) 19 75

280m 1 Jun

LdE

PRCIĆ, Sanjin MO(DEC) 19 75

280m -

LdE

BURKE, Graham A© 19 75

280m 13 Jun

LdE

BABUNSKI, David MO© 19 75

280m -

LdE

COUTINHO, Douglas A(DEC) 19 75

280m 6 Jul

LdE

BOURDIN, Pierre D(EC) 19 75

280m -

LdE

HEYLEN, Michael D© 19 75

280m 30 Jun

LdE

GANZ, Simone A© 19 75

280m -

LdE

CALDEIRA, Matheus GR 19 75

280m 24 Jun

LdE

SAMUEL, Dominic A© 19 75

280m 16 Mai

LdE

HUWS, Emyr MD,M© 19 75

280m -

LdE

SAVILLE, George D(EC),MD© 19 75

280m 1 Jun

LdE

GIBBS, Joey A© 20 75

270m -

LdE

NGOO, Michael A© 20 75

270m -

LdE

GIVA, Pulgas A© 20 75

270m 16 Jun

LdE

GRILL, Lukas D© 20 75

270m 19 Jun

LdE

KÖZ, Cüneyt D(DC) 20 75

270m -

LdE

CARRUTHERS, Samir MO(DEC) 20 75

270m -

Inf

MOJICA, Harrison Arley MO,A© 20 75

270m -

LdE

MUSONDA, Lamisha M,MO© 21 75

270m 2 Jun

LdE

BAEK, Sung-dong MO(DEC) 21 75

270m -

LdE

ÁLVAREZ BALANTA, Éder D(EC) 20 75

270m 30 Jun

LdE

PRITCHARD, Alex M,MO© 20 75

270m -

LdE

CORNET, Gnaly MO(DE),A(DEC) 16 74

200m 14 Jun

LdE

DE GIROLAMO, Diego MO©,A(EC) 17 74

190m -

LdE

POTTS, Brad D(D),MD© 18 74

190m -

LdE

KOVACIC, Miro M© 18 74

190m 12 Jun

LdE

WALLACE, Jed M(DEC) 19 74

180m 24 Jun

LdE

VUČINIĆ, Jovan A(DEC) 21 74

170m -

LdE

LUKOVIĆ, Andrija D,MO(D),MD,M(DC) 18 72

50m 3 Jun

LdE

COLCLOUGH, Ryan MO(DE),A(DEC) 18 70

10m 3 Jun

LdE

SAINTE-LUCE, Kevin M,MO(D) 20 70

10m -

LdE

VERGARA, Jherson D© 18 67

10m 9 Jul

LdE

DERICI, Okan

I haven't heard of 70% of them, but the Blue and bolded are the ones you must keep. :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

If you have the money then take a punt on the pair of them.

I prefer Hoffmann at present' date=' he is playing in possibly the best league in the world, granted for a mid table side, but he is young and at a club where he will get plenty game time and hopefully progress as a consequence.

[/color']

Before you even start, no I'm not singling you out again :P I quote anyone who says something I disagree with, sort of ;)

My argument (just 1 line really): IMO, right now the Bundesliga is even less competitive than La Liga (you don't see Barcelona buying Casillas, Ronaldo, or Ramos off Real Madrid do you?), how can it be possibly the best league in the world? :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Before you even start' date=' no I'm not singling you out again :P I quote anyone who says something I disagree with, sort of ;)

My argument (just 1 line really): IMO, right now the Bundesliga is even less competitive than La Liga (you don't see Barcelona buying Casillas, Ronaldo, or Ramos off Real Madrid do you?), how can it be possibly the best league in the world? :)[/quote']

Yeah,so if RvP went to United it means that PL isn't the best league in the world,or what?God,some of you make me laugh sometimes and you just managed to do that.Accept it or not,Bundesliga is the best financial league at the moment and is finally paying off.

Get Hoffmann..Can play as CB aswell

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Yeah' date='so if RvP went to United it means that PL isn't the best league in the world,or what?God,some of you make me laugh sometimes and you just managed to do that.Accept it or not,Bundesliga is the best financial league at the moment and is finally paying off.

Get Hoffmann..Can play as CB aswell[/quote']

Put that here:

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showthread.php?t=157823

and I will counter all your points ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Looks like I'm the only one brave enough to do it then :P

I haven't heard of 70% of them' date=' but the [b']Blue and bolded[/b] are the ones you must keep. :)

Hyina thank you for encouraging me , i'll add some i know from this list .

Wolski ( a real talent , next year playing for Fiorentina )

Vergara ( linked to top clubs )

Rojas ( Recent move to Stuttgart , good talent )

Ahmed Hassan

Labidi

Muniesa

Dier

Boilsen

Esagio

Serrano

Raul De Thomas

Santi Mina ( good talent )

Peace out B)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Put that here:

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showthread.php?t=157823

and I will counter all your points ;)

You need valid points to counter mines which you don't have.Bundesliga is atm the most complete league in the world(Financial stability and Competition)...Talking ONLY about Competition PL is the best,financial stability/situation is Bundesliga.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Before you even start' date=' no I'm not singling you out again :P I quote anyone who says something I disagree with, sort of ;)

My argument (just 1 line really): IMO, right now the Bundesliga is even less competitive than La Liga (you don't see Barcelona buying Casillas, Ronaldo, or Ramos off Real Madrid do you?), how can it be possibly the best league in the world? :)[/quote']

Again you have misquoted me, who said anything about competitive?

Check the UEFA coefficients rankings at the start of the current season to see which league was ranked where, it read like this:

1: England

2: Spain

3: Germany

By January I think it was, La Liga were top with the Premier League down to third. Not sure what it will be at the end of the season but Bundesliga could well be ranked first.

I think buying players from your rivals is irrelevent when discussing which league is the best, the top two teams in Germany are the UCL finalists, out classed the top two teams in Spain with English sides not even at the races.

Another forumer (Ashtini I think) came up with a fantastic point in another thread stating whenever Bayern Munichs backs have been against the wall they went out and bought.

In the early 2000's when Bayern were dominating nobody expected Werder Bremen to win the title in 2003-04 so Bayern go out and spend, win two consecutive titles then 06/07 against the odds Stuttgart win.

Munich go out and spend again (Luca Toni etc) win the title, what happens the following season? Against all the odds Wolfsburg win the Bundesliga.

Bayern then win in 2009/10 then it was

Dortmund who win back to back titles with Bayern winning again this season.

My point being that whenever Bayern seem to be THE force in Bundesliga a team against all the odds has surprised everyone.

Can you say La Liga or the Premier League out the big three throw up surprises like the Wolfsburg, Stuttgart and Werder Bremen league title wins over the last 10 years?

The facts are there mate:

1: Coefficient rankings

2: Top two German teams in UCL final

3: Less predictable than the other big two leagues.

EPL over the last 10 years only winners are the ones you would class as the big 4 (granted Man City are only recently classed as one of the big 4) but then they only won it recently when they became a force.

La Liga over the last 10 years - Other than Valencia in 03/04 it has been either Real Madrid or Barcelona.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Hi, I got a big squad with lot of good player. Some of them is in their peak age. I need your advise which player I should sell or get rid of. It's really difficult to get all player happy. 3 of them already unhappy level 2. Need to kick out the other player based on their future potential / rating. Can you help me please to choose who should I get rid from my team?

Here is my players

Defender

Baines

Coentrao*

David Luiz

Badstuber

Vertonghen

Howedes

Piszczek

Rafael

Midfielder

Javi martinez

Vidal

Fellaini

Jack Wilshere

Bale

Di Maria*

Gotze*

Hazard

Ozil

Kagawa

Erik Lamela**

Isco Alarcon**

Iker Muniain

Lucas Moura

Griezmann

Forward

Benzema

Aguero

Jovetic

El-Shaarawy

Jackson Martinez**

* = unhappy level 2 because lacks of minutes play

** = unhappy because about being loaned out

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Hi' date=' I got a big squad with lot of good player. Some of them is in their peak age. I need your advise which player I should sell or get rid of. It's really difficult to get all player happy. 3 of them already unhappy level 2. Need to kick out the other player based on their future potential / rating. Can you help me please to choose who should I get rid from my team?

Here is my players

[u']Defender[/u]

Baines if doesn't move to United, sell

Coentrao*

David Luiz

Badstuber sell

Vertonghen

Howedes sell

Piszczek

Rafael

Midfielder

Javi martinez

Vidal

Fellaini sell

Jack Wilshere

Bale

Di Maria* sell

Gotze*

Hazard

Ozil

Kagawa

Erik Lamela** sell

Isco Alarcon**

Iker Muniain sell

Lucas Moura

Griezmann

Forward

Benzema sell

Aguero

Jovetic

El-Shaarawy

Jackson Martinez**

* = unhappy level 2 because lacks of minutes play

** = unhappy because about being loaned out

Aloe of great players shame to lose any, but of you have to sell, that's who I would cut

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...