Jump to content

Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread? I'd probably sell Ruiz, Dante, Smalling. Maybe P/E Smalling he would be quite a good value.

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread? Can't think of an 86, 87s atm, But Cristian tello 85>87, Ahmed Musa 85>87, Lacazette 85>88 (he's rose now so...) El Shaarawy 86>88, Oscar + Isco although th

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Can someone help me a hand with selecting the players i should sell from this lot?

Leali Nicola

Timo Horn (Sell ?)

Lukas Raeder (sell I think?)

Shaw Luke

Sead Kolasinac (sell?)

Nicolas Murru (sell ?)

Günter Korray

Diego Reyes

Eric Dier (sell ?)

Alberto Masi

Laporte Aymeric

Wallace Oliveira

Gustavo Luis (sell?)

Crisetig Lorenzo (sell ?)

Höjbjerg Pierre

Paul Pogba

Kovacic Mateo

Adam Maher

Nick Powell

Olsen Patrick (sell ?)

Stendera Marc

Lucas Piazon

Max Meyer

Serge Gnabry

Mitchell Weiser

Angelo Henriquez

Weihrauch Patrick (sell ?)

Stepinski Mariusz (sell ?)

Gianni Bruno (sell ?)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Can someone help me a hand with selecting the players i should sell from this lot?

Leali Nicola

Timo Horn (Sell ?)

Lukas Raeder (sell I think?)

Shaw Luke

Sead Kolasinac (sell?)

Nicolas Murru (sell ?)

Günter Korray

Diego Reyes

Eric Dier (sell ?)

Alberto Masi

Laporte Aymeric

Wallace Oliveira

Gustavo Luis (sell?)

Crisetig Lorenzo (sell ?)

Höjbjerg Pierre

Paul Pogba

Kovacic Mateo

Adam Maher

Nick Powell

Olsen Patrick (sell ?)

Stendera Marc

Lucas Piazon

Max Meyer

Serge Gnabry

Mitchell Weiser

Angelo Henriquez

Weihrauch Patrick (sell ?)

Stepinski Mariusz (sell ?)

Gianni Bruno (sell ?)

my sells in Bold

Link to post
Share on other sites

Riferimento: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Can someone help me with this young players? Keep or sell?

Nicolae Vasile

Kevin Mbabu

Kevin Akpoguma

Niklas Sule

Vladimir Rankovic

Selim Kayaci

Shadrach Eghan

Alex Pritchard

Gyliano Van Velzen

Gnaly Cornet

Hector Villalba

Patrick Weirauch

Stefano Beltrame

Arnold Garita

Thanks in advance :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

in a complete full game world, where players are traded for crazy prices, and money is so important. I would sell these players know that there is enough youth is still present in my team, (I don't buy 90+ players, only yough and see them grow up, this gives me more satisfaction) and still I can compete in front,...despite the sale of these players (1STE place +12 points on the second,despite the few 90 + players I have, you do not need,just the good better talent yough) ...or should I keep these players some time provisionally,and perhaps miss out the offered purchase bids, frankly no player is put on the transfer list, but the offered purchase bids are high, is to consider ... have no concerns in my team, almost end of season 5,team Fc Porto, From the start in the frist season.

keep or sale

Isla mauricio 30.5 M.

Otamendi 27 M.

Alvaro Pereira 27M.

Guarin Freddy 20M.

Capoué Etienne 28M.

Fernando Reyes 25M.

Belhanda Younes 35M. OR 192.5m cash in,have 60M in the bank.

My 1ste team +the most importent youth players from, have some more talent younger from 75 to 82.

Gk=Patricio Rui-Leali Nicole-kapino stefano

Rb= (isla )Danilo luiz , De scigillico mattia,De Vrij,Vrsaljko,Öztürk Alpaslan.some few 75/80'

LB=(Alvaro )Alba jordi,Sandro Alex, Lucas Digne,Grimaldo Alex,

guerreiro Raphaël,Quinones Hector,lukaku jordan = All

CB=(Otamendi)Maicon,Mangala,Papadoupolos kry.,Nastasic,Jones Phil,Reyes Diego,Marquinhoss Correra,Laporte Aymeric, Iloria Tiago,some few others few 75-80'

DM-CM=(Guarin,Fernando,Capoué) Defour,Veratti,Kondogbia,kovacic,Ucan Salin,Cirigkiano ezequiel,Rodriquez José,some few others 75-80'

Am-CM=Moutinho,Asamoah,Maher,Preat Dennis,Rafinha Alcantara,Powell,some few others 75-80'

Wing Am= (Belhanda) Hazard (both) ,James,Dzagoev,Lucas Mauro,Isco,Shaqiri,Ramire Gaston,Draxler,Countinho,Deulofeu Gerard,Bruno Massimo,Andrade Victor,klevin Mateus,Iturbe juan,Bruma Armindo,Centurion,Aydran tavares,Piazon,Gnabry,Berardi Domenico,Lanzini manuel,Lopez nicolas,=all.

CF= Hulk,Falcao,Damiao Leandro,Jakson,Destro Mattia,

Borini,Kleber,Nelson Oliviera,Ferrerya Facundo,Wickham connor,Markovic lazar,Alcacer paco,Dongou Jean-marie,Betinho,Caballero Mauro some few others 75-78'.

Squad = just 90 players, most are purchased in the 1st season, yet the younger talents who are now 84-90 have become, and others who are still 75-82 in the other season.

Wages are still affordable, .... But not for long if the other continued to rise ...,will sell make some profit, buy again yougher 75'-78'.

Thanks.

My Personal opinion, sufficient back-up enough, nevertheless about Belhanda,(play verry well in my squad) Capoué and fernando 'm not sure ...? Guarin, isla, Otamendi cash in.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

in a complete full game world' date=' where players are traded for crazy prices, and money is so important. I would sell these players know that there is enough youth is still present in my team, (I don't buy 90+ players, only yough and see them grow up, this gives me more satisfaction) and still I can compete in front,...despite the sale of these players (1STE place +12 points on the second,despite the few 90 + players I have, you do not need,just the good better talent yough) ...or should I keep these players some time provisionally,and perhaps miss out the offered purchase bids, frankly no player is put on the transfer list, but the offered purchase bids are high, is to consider ... have no concerns in my team, almost end of season 5,team Fc Porto, From the start in the frist season.

[b']keep or sale[/b]

Isla mauricio 30.5 M.

Otamendi 27 M.

Alvaro Pereira 27M.

Guarin Freddy 20M.

Capoué Etienne 28M.

Fernando Reyes 25M.

Belhanda Younes 35M. OR 192.5m cash in,have 60M in the bank.

My 1ste team +the most importent youth players from, have some more talent younger from 75 to 82.

Gk=Patricio Rui-Leali Nicole-kapino stefano

Rb= (isla )Danilo luiz , De scigillico mattia,De Vrij,Vrsaljko,Öztürk Alpaslan.some few 75/80'

LB=(Alvaro )Alba jordi,Sandro Alex, Lucas Digne,Grimaldo Alex,

guerreiro Raphaël,Quinones Hector,lukaku jordan = All

CB=(Otamendi)Maicon,Mangala,Papadoupolos kry.,Nastasic,Jones Phil,Reyes Diego,Marquinhoss Correra,Laporte Aymeric, Iloria Tiago,some few others few 75-80'

DM-CM=(Guarin,Fernando,Capoué) Defour,Veratti,Kondogbia,kovacic,Ucan Salin,Cirigkiano ezequiel,Rodriquez José,some few others 75-80'

Am-CM=Moutinho,Asamoah,Maher,Preat Dennis,Rafinha Alcantara,Powell,some few others 75-80'

Wing Am= (Belhanda) Hazard (both) ,James,Dzagoev,Lucas Mauro,Isco,Shaqiri,Ramire Gaston,Draxler,Countinho,Deulofeu Gerard,Bruno Massimo,Andrade Victor,klevin Mateus,Iturbe juan,Bruma Armindo,Centurion,Aydran tavares,Piazon,Gnabry,Berardi Domenico,Lanzini manuel,Lopez nicolas,=all.

CF= Hulk,Falcao,Damiao Leandro,Jakson,Destro Mattia,

Borini,Kleber,Nelson Oliviera,Ferrerya Facundo,Wickham connor,Markovic lazar,Alcacer paco,Dongou Jean-marie,Betinho,Caballero Mauro some few others 75-78'.

Squad = just 90 players, most are purchased in the 1st season, yet the younger talents who are now 84-90 have become, and others who are still 75-82 in the other season.

Wages are still affordable, .... But not for long if the other continued to rise ...,will sell make some profit, buy again yougher 75'-78'.

Thanks.

My Personal opinion, sufficient back-up enough, nevertheless about Belhanda,(play verry well in my squad) Capoué and fernando 'm not sure ...? Guarin, isla, Otamendi cash in.

You have way too many players... sell all of them apart from Otamendi (you don't have many players rated around 89 in that position) and Capoue.

You can afford to sell a whole lot more players too.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

You have way too many players... sell all of them apart from Otamendi (you don't have many players rated around 89 in that position) and Capoue.

You can afford to sell a whole lot more players too.

Couldn't agree more. No need for so many players. I'd keep just the two mentioned above.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

You have way too many players... sell all of them apart from Otamendi (you don't have many players rated around 89 in that position) and Capoue.

You can afford to sell a whole lot more players too.

Couldn't agree more. No need for so many players. I'd keep just the two mentioned above.

Ok thanks...both of you.

Note

You can consider this as a collection of players, but ultimately from about 88' leaving most players the team,and sure from about 89' still always end season , or if an attractive offer comes in..als now today and I look again to find younger talents from 75 to 82/84 higher I go not, only if that player also is ultimately a real FC PORTO player, and I really want him.

On the other hand I do not buy 90 + players, just Falcao I bought him when he was 90', Asamoah-Ilsa stil 89',Capoue 88' and so on,all the others have come, even before anyone was interested in these players, and with a much lower rating, that's the beauty of it that your work your scouting finally now supplies its merit, while others go for the 90 + players only, give me on this way more satisfying to see your players to grow up.There will always be a season, with more or less 88'-89 'players that is unpredictable,until the younger eventually break through ...to 92/94 is the final culmination ... whenever that may be.

Most players from 87 ' are loan out, and the world is complete, a very strong compition about seeking the youngh talents,so it is appropriate to keep some good yough players in your squad, but 90 is a lot,i know, but the number will be even lower end this season in a few weeks,but whit the available players i have now, I can sell the 88'-89' or 90' and wait patiently until again a top talent comes on the market from 75-80'

I'm not yet the bad person, most loaned players from 87' or 87'+, or as now, unexpectedly high bids ,after I made ​​my choice and normal Always end season , I will see who stays and who will leave , i look also to the club that have borrowed the player, and they have whit me the 1ste choice to buy the player,have never ask a price, even if a higher bid had come in from another club,will sale the player to the club who had loan him,if the do won't him.I let them bid on my players, no players made ​​is inaccessible, but every player has his price Minimum, more or less similar in real life.

The amount of the bid is freely for the club that the player wishes to buy my price that they know.

Most Managers in this world know this and they're satisfied with it ... is one of the few worlds that I own where there would be a very good link between the various managers, the leavers I can count on more or less both my hands .

No offense intended, it meant nothing I do appreciate yours opinion and would also not talk it right, but think you're very quickly at 80-90 players if you want to play really on young talent there are seasons with fewer players, and there are more but until now was 90 the maximum, the number will drop again,end season until there is more new young talent found .... everyone plays it his way, others go for only the 90 + players and do not buy young players, etc.

Thanks anyway.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Hey guys sorry about the cut/Paste job.

This is my youth squad in a Forum EC. Bolded ones are risers sold after TB ends.

Who should i offload? anyone who is likely to rise +3 or more as a short term cash generator can stay, and ofc anyone who could get 90 or is a real prospect.

If they are not gonna rise substantially soon or not future potential they are surplus

ARRIZABALAGA, Kepa GK 18 77

MURRU, Nicola D(L) 18 82

BOURDIN, Pierre D(LC) 19 75

KRYVTSOV, Serhiy D© 22 83

MASI, Alberto D© 20 82 (sell??? i thought a huge talent but apparently transferred to a rubbish low italian side?)

ELY, Rodrigo D© 19 78

BALASA, Mihai D(RC) 18 78

GOOD, Curtis D(LC) 20 77

KEMPF, Marc-Oliver D,DM© 18 77

HUERTA, Valber D(LC) 19 77

BAGNACK, Frank D© 18 75

VERGARA, Jherson D© 19 75

STONES, John D,DM,M® 19 82 (sell? game time at Everton or future?)

MANQUILLO, Javi D,DM,M® 19 80

KANE, Todd D,DM,M® 19 77

CHALOBAH, Nathaniel D,DM,M© 18 84

RODRÍGUEZ, José DM,M© 18 82

PATRIC, Gabarrón DM© 20 78

HUWS, Emyr DM,M© 19 75

WALLACE, Jed M(RLC) 19 74

POWELL, Nick M,AM© 19 80

DERFLINGER, Christian M,AM© 19 75

STENDERA, Marc M,AM© 17 75

EVANS, Lee M© 18 70

SARABIA, Pablo AM(RLC),F(RL) 21 85 (worht keeping?)

ROJAS, Marco AM(RLC),F(RL) 21 82

CRECCO, Luca AM(L),F(LC) 17 75

CORNET, Gnaly AM(RL),F(RLC) 16 74

MCMANAMAN, Callum AM(RL),F(RLC) 22 85 (will he get a move?)

JEAN, Corentin F(RLC) 17 80

BELTRAME, Stefano F(LC) 20 75 (ever gonna get a game at Juve?)

MAUPAY, Neal F© 16 80

INSIGNE, Roberto AM©,F(RLC) 19 77

SMITH, Matt F© 24 77

GIVA, Pulgas F© 20 75

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Hey guys sorry about the cut/Paste job.

This is my youth squad in a Forum EC. Bolded ones are risers sold after TB ends.

Who should i offload? anyone who is likely to rise +3 or more as a short term cash generator can stay' date=' and ofc anyone who could get 90 or is a real prospect.

If they are not gonna rise substantially soon or not future potential they are surplus

ARRIZABALAGA, Kepa GK 18 77

MURRU, Nicola D(L) 18 82

BOURDIN, Pierre D(LC) 19 75

KRYVTSOV, Serhiy D© 22 83

MASI, Alberto D© 20 82 (sell??? i thought a huge talent but apparently transferred to a rubbish low italian side?)

ELY, Rodrigo D© 19 78

[b']BALASA, Mihai D(RC) 18 78 [/b]

GOOD, Curtis D(LC) 20 77

KEMPF, Marc-Oliver D,DM© 18 77

HUERTA, Valber D(LC) 19 77

BAGNACK, Frank D© 18 75

VERGARA, Jherson D© 19 75

STONES, John D,DM,M® 19 82 (sell? game time at Everton or future?)

MANQUILLO, Javi D,DM,M® 19 80

KANE, Todd D,DM,M® 19 77

CHALOBAH, Nathaniel D,DM,M© 18 84

RODRÍGUEZ, José DM,M© 18 82

PATRIC, Gabarrón DM© 20 78

HUWS, Emyr DM,M© 19 75

WALLACE, Jed M(RLC) 19 74

POWELL, Nick M,AM© 19 80

DERFLINGER, Christian M,AM© 19 75

STENDERA, Marc M,AM© 17 75

EVANS, Lee M© 18 70

SARABIA, Pablo AM(RLC),F(RL) 21 85 (worht keeping?)

ROJAS, Marco AM(RLC),F(RL) 21 82

CRECCO, Luca AM(L),F(LC) 17 75

CORNET, Gnaly AM(RL),F(RLC) 16 74

MCMANAMAN, Callum AM(RL),F(RLC) 22 85 (will he get a move?)

JEAN, Corentin F(RLC) 17 80

BELTRAME, Stefano F(LC) 20 75 (ever gonna get a game at Juve?)

MAUPAY, Neal F© 16 80

INSIGNE, Roberto AM©,F(RLC) 19 77

SMITH, Matt F© 24 77

GIVA, Pulgas F© 20 75

any1 help me for once?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Hello everyone! :D Wondered if i could have peoples opinions on these players, whether to buy, sell or keep them and expected ratings if possible? :)

RODWELL, Jack

CARVAJAL, Daniel

ATSU, Christian

POGBA, Paul

WILLEMS, Jetro

MCEACHRAN, Josh

WICKHAM, Connor

JESÉ, Rodríguez

ALCÁCER, Paco

WISDOM, Andre

BARKLEY, Ross

GRIMALDO, Álex

LUNDSTRAM, John

RAZAK, Abdul

ROBINSON, Jack

OMAR, Mascarell

GÜNTER, Koray

BAMFORD, Patrick

WALKER, Sam

MAMUTE, Yuri

COADY, Conor

VESELI, Frédéric

VOSE, Dominic

VERNA, Cristiano

Thanks in advance B)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Hello everyone! :D Wondered if i could have peoples opinions on these players' date=' whether to buy, sell or keep them and expected ratings if possible? :)

RODWELL, Jack STAY

CARVAJAL, Daniel 90 fast if he takes expected RB at RM, could go >94 depends on ability etc.

ATSU, Christian Stay

POGBA, Paul get +1/+2 near future great talent depends on chances/time at Juve

WILLEMS, Jetro Great player will rise in future

MCEACHRAN, Josh Stay/+1

WICKHAM, Connor Stay, touted as a big talented hasnt lived up to hype, still young

JESÉ, Rodríguez Promising, no time too soon though.

ALCÁCER, Paco 'Jewel of Valencia' Keep for now, wait and see

WISDOM, Andre Overrated

BARKLEY, Ross wait and see

GRIMALDO, Álex dont know

LUNDSTRAM, John dont know

RAZAK, Abdul dont know

ROBINSON, Jack dont know

OMAR, Mascarell dont know

GÜNTER, Koray Keep for now

BAMFORD, Patrick dont know

WALKER, Sam dont know

MAMUTE, Yuri Heard alot of good things

COADY, Conor Too early to say

VESELI, Frédéric SELL, released by man utd even i think?? (not sure on that)

VOSE, Dominic dont know

VERNA, Cristiano dont know

Thanks in advance B)

Opinions in quote. Bold Definately Keep. Red definately sell. Others i either dont know enough or 50/50.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Right guys

At the moment I have got a solid midfield, but I like to keep one eye on the future to make sure I maintain a strong side.

At the moment

DM

Alonso ( Worldclass but ageing )

Pirlo ( Worldclass but ageing, Will sell earlier than Alonso)

Javi Martinez ( Will be the long term DM after Alonso )

Gundogan ( Long term DM after Pirlo )

Ideally I want at least 3 DM since I do often play a formation of 5 midfielders such as 4-2-3-1 which uses 2 defensive midfielders.

Shall I purchase Illarramendi as a long term replacement to Alonso ?

Does anything think he may have the potential to hit a 93 on SM ? ( Havnt seen much of him, apart from YouTube )

Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Buy, Sell or Keep Thread?

Right guys

At the moment I have got a solid midfield' date=' but I like to keep one eye on the future to make sure I maintain a strong side.

At the moment

DM

Alonso ( Worldclass but ageing )

Pirlo ( Worldclass but ageing, Will sell earlier than Alonso)

Javi Martinez ( Will be the long term DM after Alonso )

Gundogan ( Long term DM after Pirlo )

Ideally I want at least 3 DM since I do often play a formation of 5 midfielders such as 4-2-3-1 which uses 2 defensive midfielders.

Shall I purchase Illarramendi as a long term replacement to Alonso ?

Does anything think he may have the potential to hit a 93 on SM ? ( Havnt seen much of him, apart from YouTube )[/quote']

It is too early to tell if he can hit 93+ just yet, but I'd say Illara's definitely worth buying.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...