Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Hyina

The Squad Advice Thread

Recommended Posts

Everyday literally hundreds of new threads are submitted, with people asking just one question: 'This is my squad, who should I keep/sell?'

To make the forum tidier, I've started this thread designated to help EVERYONE's squad problems :)

However, we need people, not just me or a couple of others, to make this thread active so pepple will no longer create new threads with only one problem. If everybody can help then that would be great ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Here goes:

(a real question btw :P)

Please could you cut 51 (:eek::o) players from the following:

Neuer

Hart

Courtois

Butland

Branescu 75

Coentrao

Alba

Enrique

Aurtenetxe

Fabio

Bertrand

Martins 78

Rodriguez

Shaw

Van der Wiel

Raphael

Jantschke

Jenkinson

Douglas Pereira 82

Miao 80

Romario 75

Pique

Kompany

Hummels

Subotic

Badstubber

De Vrij 86

Ogbonna 84

Zouma 83

Lascelles 78

Good 77

Jones

Lucas Fernando

Romeu

Caio 75

McClean

J. Lukaku 77

Yaya

J. Martinez

Sahin

Marchisio

Moutinho

KPB

Wilshere

Koke 86

Maher 86

Verratti 85

Obiang 75

Fabregas

Sneijder

A. Thiago

Kovacic

Iniesta

Ozil

Gotze

Pastore

D. Costa

Ramirez

Perisic

Sigurdssun

Isco

Draxler

Bernard

Mastriani

Cristoforo

Powell

Di Maria

Cazorla

J. Rodriguez

De Bruyne

Oxlade Chamberlain

Griezzmann

Deulofeu

Bueno

Andrade

Rooney

Cavani

Neymar

Reus

Destro

Zaha

Markovic

Niang

Vaz Te

Angelo Henriquez

S. Rosa 75

S. Sosa 75

S. Silva 75

Watt 75

Gomez

Lewandowski

Damiao

Martinez

Rhodes

Serderov 75

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Here goes:

(a real question btw :P)

Please could you cut 51 (:eek::o) players from the following:

Neuer

Hart

Courtois

Butland

Branescu 75

Coentrao

Alba

Enrique

Aurtenetxe

Fabio

Bertrand

Martins 78

Rodriguez

Shaw

Van der Wiel

Raphael

Jantschke

Jenkinson

Douglas Pereira 82

Miao 80

Romario 75

Pique

Kompany

Hummels

Subotic

Badstubber

De Vrij 86

Ogbonna 84

Zouma 83

Lascelles 78

Good 77

Jones

Lucas Fernando

Romeu

Caio 75

McClean

J. Lukaku 77

Yaya

J. Martinez

Sahin

Marchisio

Moutinho

KPB

Wilshere

Koke 86

Maher 86

Verratti 85

Obiang 75

Fabregas

Sneijder

A. Thiago

Kovacic

Iniesta

Ozil

Gotze

Pastore

D. Costa

Ramirez

Perisic

Sigurdssun

Isco

Draxler

Bernard

Mastriani

Cristoforo

Powell

Di Maria

Cazorla

J. Rodriguez

De Bruyne

Oxlade Chamberlain

Griezzmann

Deulofeu

Bueno

Andrade

Rooney

Cavani

Neymar

Reus

Destro

Zaha

Markovic

Niang

Vaz Te

Angelo Henriquez

S. Rosa 75

S. Sosa 75

S. Silva 75

Watt 75

Gomez

Lewandowski

Damiao

Martinez

Rhodes

Serderov 75

I would cut these' date=' and then some. Not sure though :P[/color']

AND 2000th post WOOTS

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Here goes:

(a real question btw :P)

Please could you cut 51 (:eek::o) players from the following:

Neuer

Hart

Courtois

Butland

Branescu 75

Well you don´t need 3 keepers. But if you want to sell after their rises i suggest to keep Neuer as your number one keeper. Courtois as a reserve and an amazing keeper and Butland for a big rise in the future.

Coentrao

Alba

Enrique

Aurtenetxe

Fabio

Bertrand

Martins 78

Rodriguez

Shaw

Van der Wiel

Raphael

Jantschke

Jenkinson

Douglas Pereira 82

Miao 80

Romario 75

Pique

Kompany

Hummels

Subotic

Badstubber

De Vrij 86

Ogbonna 84

Zouma 83

Lascelles 78

Good 77

Jones

Lucas Fernando

Romeu

Caio 75

McClean

J. Lukaku 77

Yaya

J. Martinez

Sahin

Marchisio

Moutinho

KPB

Wilshere

Koke 86

Maher 86

Verratti 85

Obiang 75

Fabregas

Sneijder

A. Thiago

Kovacic

Iniesta

Ozil

Gotze

Pastore

D. Costa

Ramirez

Perisic

Sigurdssun

Isco

Draxler

Bernard

Mastriani

Cristoforo

Powell

Di Maria

Cazorla

J. Rodriguez

De Bruyne

Oxlade Chamberlain

Griezzmann

Deulofeu

Bueno

Andrade

Rooney

Cavani

Neymar

Reus

Destro

Zaha

Markovic

Niang

Vaz Te

Angelo Henriquez

S. Rosa 75

S. Sosa 75

S. Silva 75

Watt 75

Gomez

Lewandowski

Damiao

Martinez

Rhodes

Serderov 75

I managed to keep 45 players max. My factors were: Club they play, Minutes they have, How much they can rise in the future and more...

And selected some that you might manage to get significant gains with their rises, like Ogbonna (not a first team players in your squad but you can sell him and win lots of money)

If you need details on the squad, give me a call;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

I would cut these' date=' and then some. Not sure though :P[/color']

AND 2000th post WOOTS

Well done! And you did it on here too! :D

You see that's my problem, once I cut about 30 then it becomes incredibly difficult... :/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

I managed to keep 45 players max. My factors were: Club they play' date=' Minutes they have, How much they can rise in the future and more...

And selected some that you might manage to get significant gains with their rises, like Ogbonna (not a first team players in your squad but you can sell him and win lots of money)

If you need details on the squad, give me a call;)[/quote']

Cheers buddy, much appreciated :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

I've highlighted in red players I'm thinking of selling, agree?

Neuer

Hart

Courtois

Butland

Branescu 75 - 1

Coentrao

Alba

Enrique - 2

Aurtenetxe

Fabio - 3

Bertrand

Martins 78 - 4 (I heard a lot of good stuff about this kid

Rodriguez - 5 (him too)

Shaw

Van der Wiel

Raphael

Jantschke

Jenkinson

Douglas Pereira 82 - 6

Miao 80 - 7 Romario 75 - 8 (Though I heard from some that he'll be the next Brazilian RB...)

Pique

Kompany

Hummels

Subotic

Badstubber

De Vrij 86 - 9 (future dutch CB?)

Ogbonna 84 - 10 (apparantly the next Italian CB?)

Zouma 83

Lascelles 78 - 11 (don't know how good he is, heard much hype)

Good 77 - 12

Jones - 13 (thinking of selling the new O'shea)

Lucas Fernando

Romeu

Caio 75 - 14

McClean - 15

J. Lukaku 77 - 16 (how good is this kid?)

Yaya

J. Martinez

Sahin - 18 (is his recent good form temporary or is he just getting back to his old self?)

Marchisio

Moutinho

KPB - 19

Wilshere

Koke 86

Maher 86

Verratti 85

Obiang 75 - 20

Fabregas

Sneijder - 21 (Looking to pe him off while he is high rated)

A. Thiago

Kovacic

Iniesta

Ozil

Gotze

D. Costa - 22

Ramirez - 23

Perisic - 24

Sigurdssun

Isco

Draxler

Bernard

Mastriani - 25

Cristoforo - 26

Powell

Di Maria

Cazorla

J. Rodriguez

De Bruyne - 27 (never watched him play, really talented or hyped up?)Oxlade Chamberlain

Griezzmann

Deulofeu

Bueno - 28

Andrade

Rooney

Cavani

Neymar

Reus

Destro

Zaha

Markovic

Niang

Vaz Te - 29

Angelo Henriquez

S. Rosa 75 - 30

S. Sosa 75 - 31

S. Silva 75 - 32

Watt 75 - 33

Gomez

Lewandowski - 34

Damiao

Martinez - 35

Rhodes - 36

Serderov 75 - 37

Just another 15 to go.... :confused:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Hay need help with my squad

Its a youth oriented team, but is there anyone i should sell to replace with players e.g. erkisen, damaoi, alex sandro, m'vila..

If they are not the cream of the crop i dont want them :P Thanks

(just testing the thread ;))

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Hay need help with my squad

Its a youth oriented team' date=' but is there anyone i should sell to replace with players e.g. erkisen, damaoi, alex sandro, m'vila..

If they are not the cream of the crop i dont want them :P Thanks

(just testing the thread ;))[/quote']

Keep Ter Stegan

Keep all you fullbacks except for PILYPAS (whom I've never heard of)

Keep your CBs xcept for BITINAS, YAGO, Chalobah

In CM/DM, I'd sell Campana, Rode, Jadson, Barraca, Abdullah, GORETZKA, Caio

AM/Wing: sell Klaasen, Ismail, Fischer, Lukoki

Fwd-wise: sell ZYHALOV, LONGO, LIBERTAZZI, LUMU, BOSETTI, CABALLERO

I won't pretend to know them all, if they are intended short term money makers then I'd keep till they rise and then sell.

Romario (Brazilian RB 76) is someone I'd try to get, also some players in my squad below, there are some nice gems there, if there are some you haven't got they might be good buys ;)

Hope this helped. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Keep Ter Stegan

Keep all you fullbacks except for PILYPAS (whom I've never heard of)

Keep your CBs xcept for BITINAS' date=' YAGO, Chalobah

In CM/DM, I'd sell Campana, Rode, Jadson, Barraca, Abdullah, GORETZKA, Caio

AM/Wing: sell Klaasen, Ismail, Fischer, Lukoki

Fwd-wise: sell ZYHALOV, LONGO, LIBERTAZZI, LUMU, BOSETTI, CABALLERO

I won't pretend to know them all, if they are intended short term money makers then I'd keep till they rise and then sell.

Romario (Brazilian RB 76) is someone I'd try to get, also some players in my squad below, there are some nice gems there, if there are some you haven't got they might be good buys ;)

Hope this helped. :)[/quote']

very helpful :D

Most of the random ukrainians were just to raise cash, but here i go with the makeover! :D repped

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

I need a bit of housekeeping on my squad. Below are players who aren't transfer banned. Buy, sell or keep?

Goalkeepers

Valdes

Defenders

Alba

Alves

Mascherano

Pique

Van Rhijn

Juan

Marquinhos

Curti

Briseno

Midfielders

Busquets

Xavi

Thiago

Fabregas

Iniesta

Vogt

Weiser

Verratti

Praet

Ward-Prowse

El Kaddouri

Adryan

Wingers

Redmond

Niguez

Moses

Ocampos

Andrade

Forward

Messi

Sanchez

Villa

Ba

Romarinho

Polo

Henriquez

Lumu

Dongou

Torres

Rhodes

Longo

Yesil

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

I need a bit of housekeeping on my squad. Below are players who aren't transfer banned. Buy' date=' sell or keep?

[u']Goalkeepers

[/u]Valdes

Defenders

Alba

Alves

Mascherano

Pique

Van Rhijn

Juan

Marquinhos

Curti

Briseno

Midfielders

Busquets

Xavi

Thiago

Fabregas

Iniesta

Vogt

Weiser

Verratti

Praet

Ward-Prowse

El Kaddouri

Adryan

Wingers

Redmond

Niguez

Moses

Ocampos

Andrade

Forward

Messi

Sanchez

Villa: pe him off for a good deal, like a 92+ 91/2

Ba

Romarinho

Polo

Henriquez

Lumu

Dongou

Torres

Rhodes

Longo

Yesil

Hey, I'd sell the ones in bold, keep everybody else ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Why on earth would you sell Rhijn/Praet/Weiser/Polo/Longo/Lumu and especially Rhodes?

Considering his other players, he simply doesn't need them.

Especially Rhodes? Championship just got reviewed like 2 weeks ago, sure he's scoring goals but it'll be 5-6months before he rises again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

I need a bit of housekeeping on my squad. Below are players who aren't transfer banned. Buy' date=' sell or keep?

[u']Goalkeepers

[/u]Valdes sell

Defenders

Alba

Alves

Mascherano

Pique

Van Rhijn

Juan sell

Marquinhos

Curti sell

Briseno

Midfielders

Busquets

Xavi

Thiago

Fabregas

Iniesta

Vogt

Weiser

Verratti

Praet

Ward-Prowse

El Kaddouri

Adryan

Wingers

Redmond

Niguez

Moses

Ocampos

Andrade

Forward

Messi

Sanchez sell

Villa

Ba sell

Romarinho

Polo

Henriquez

Lumu

Dongou

Torres

Rhodes

Longo

Yesil

Those are my opinion

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Hay need help with my squad

Its a youth oriented team' date=' but is there anyone i should sell to replace with players e.g. erkisen, damaoi, alex sandro, m'vila..

If they are not the cream of the crop i dont want them :P Thanks

(just testing the thread ;))[/quote']

loads to sell, the lathuainia's, hewitt, torro, caballero, lumu, batshuayi, zyhalov, libertazzi,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Thanks' date=' for my q and others' too

I was hesitant over merte/koschelny as Merte is one of my favourite defenders. :)[/quote']

ye same i like him alot, hes starting to settle at arsenal, its just his pace thats the problem

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Alright, I've got a LOT of problems/queries, any help would be appreciated :D:

1. Keep Neuer or Hart? I got Hart recently and now I can't decide who to sell between them two :confused:

2. Carrying on the keeper issue, I have Courtois and Butland in the same team, whom do I keep, both?

3. Rank in order of 'best to have on SM' please :o: Jenkinson, VDW, Raphael, Douglas P, Romario, Jantsche

4. Who do I ABSOLUTELY need to keep out of: L.Shaw, Coentrao, Alba, Bertrand, Rodriguez (argentine LB prodigy apparently), Martins (Portugal LB prodigy lol)

5. I have too many CBs, out of these who will NOT be a great CB: Badstubber, Ogbonna, De Vrij, Zouma, Kompany, Pique, Hummels, Subotic, Good, P.Jones

6. Out of these good talents, who would you definitely NOT SELL: Lucas Fernando, Romeu, Lukaku (LM), McClean, Verratti, Koke, KP Boateng, Maher, Wilshere, A.Thiago, G.Ramirez, D.Costa, Sigurdssen, Bernard, Isco, Perisic, Draxler, Giuliano, Kovacic, Powell, J.Rodriguez, De Bruyne, Ox, Griezzz, Deulofel, Reus, Zaha, Niang, Markovic, Destro, Andrade, Lewandowski, Damiao, J Martinez, Lacina Traore.

7. Would you do Aurtenetxe + Deulofel for Alaba?

8. Would you do Deulofel + Markovic for Montoya?

9. Would you sell Phil Jones + Lewandowski + money for Falcao? Or just Gomez in a straight swap? Plus would you give Lewandowski + Powell/another good talent in list above for Jovetic?

8(?) Draxler + Perisic or Oscar?

That's enough for now, or this post will be too long to read :o

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

1. Keep Neuer or Hart? I got Hart recently and now I can't decide who to sell between them two :confused:

Keep Neuer mate. Plays for a similar team as City and for a greater national team. As young as Hart and to me one of the best keepers. Keep Neuer

2. Carrying on the keeper issue, I have Courtois and Butland in the same team, whom do I keep, both?

I don´t see the point of having two keepers. But if you want to win cash keep Butland! If you want to keep a reserve keeper to replace Neuer or Hart in the future keep Courtois. Keep Butland for cash or Keep Courtois for proper replacement

3. Rank in order of 'best to have on SM' please :o: Jenkinson, VDW, Raphael, Douglas P, Romario, Jantsche

Jantsche, Van der Wiel, Jenkinson, Raphael, Douglas P, Romario. The last players already rose and he will rise only a months from now. So sell him as you can get better talents. Jantsche will be a top RB both for his team and his national team. Jenkinson is an amazing talent and he will get some big rises in a future.

4. Who do I ABSOLUTELY need to keep out of: L.Shaw, Coentrao, Alba, Bertrand, Rodriguez (argentine LB prodigy apparently), Martins (Portugal LB prodigy lol)

Sell Shaw, Martins and maybe Bertrand although he will rise 85+.

5. I have too many CBs, out of these who will NOT be a great CB: Badstubber, Ogbonna, De Vrij, Zouma, Kompany, Pique, Hummels, Subotic, Good, P.Jones.

They are all good:p But maybe Vrij, Good and Phil Jones although he is Def/Mdef:( Not sure about this players above. They are all good CB.

6. Out of these good talents, who would you definitely NOT SELL: Lucas Fernando, Romeu, Lukaku (LM), McClean, Verratti, Koke, KP Boateng, Maher, Wilshere, A.Thiago, G.Ramirez, D.Costa, Sigurdssen, Bernard, Isco, Perisic, Draxler, Giuliano, Kovacic, Powell, J.Rodriguez, De Bruyne, Ox, Griezzz, Deulofel, Reus, Zaha, Niang, Markovic, Destro, Andrade, Lewandowski, Damiao, J Martinez, Lacina Traore.

Well i will do "au contraire":D Sell McClean, Boateng, Perisic, Markovic, Andrade, Lacina Traore because i don´t think the will rise in the next reviews and one more time you have more talented players out there

7. Would you do Aurtenetxe + Deulofel for Alaba?

I am not sure. They are both top talents. Aurtenetxe can rise to 89 and Delofeu can rise to +85, but Alaba is a beast:). I would do the deal though

8. Would you do Deulofel + Markovic for Montoya?

No mate. Keep those players. Montoya is not a big talent

9. Would you sell Phil Jones + Lewandowski + money for Falcao? Or just Gomez in a straight swap? Plus would you give Lewandowski + Powell/another good talent in list above for Jovetic?

If you have an replacement for Jones and considering trading Falcão for Lewandoski i would do the deal. Falcão will hit 93 in the incoming spannish reviews. Currently Falcão is the best CF in the world.

Gomez in a straight swap is also good. Falcão might hit 93 and Gomez won´t get its 94 because is injured IMO.

+ Markovic as he is the smallest talent on your squad and already reviewed for serbia

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

Alright' date=' I've got a LOT of problems/queries, any help would be appreciated :D:

1. Keep Neuer or Hart? I got Hart recently and now I can't decide who to sell between them two :confused:

[b']

Hart. They are both quality goalkeepers who would be at the top of my list when buying a goalkeeper in SM. But what edges it for me is Hart has practically zero competition for his England spot and with the bottomless pit of money Man City has is destined to be part of a very successful club in the future. Whereas Germany have a lot of good, young goalkeeping talent and I could see Neuer's position under threat in the distant future.[/b]

2. Carrying on the keeper issue, I have Courtois and Butland in the same team, whom do I keep, both?

Courtois. He is a quality keeper who has proved himself on the European stage. Butland has a lot of hype post-Olympics but he is a much inferior keeper to Courtois.

3. Rank in order of 'best to have on SM' please :o: Jenkinson, VDW, Raphael, Douglas P, Romario, Jantsche

Raphael would be my pick.

4. Who do I ABSOLUTELY need to keep out of: L.Shaw, Coentrao, Alba, Bertrand, Rodriguez (argentine LB prodigy apparently), Martins (Portugal LB prodigy lol)

Absolutely need to keep Alba and Bertrand.

5. I have too many CBs, out of these who will NOT be a great CB: Badstubber, Ogbonna, De Vrij, Zouma, Kompany, Pique, Hummels, Subotic, Good, P.Jones

Not a great CB; Good, Ogbonna, De Vrij, P.Jones

6. Out of these good talents, who would you definitely NOT SELL: Lucas Fernando, Romeu, Lukaku (LM), McClean, Verratti, Koke, KP Boateng, Maher, Wilshere, A.Thiago, G.Ramirez, D.Costa, Sigurdssen, Bernard, Isco, Perisic, Draxler, Giuliano, Kovacic, Powell, J.Rodriguez, De Bruyne, Ox, Griezzz, Deulofel, Reus, Zaha, Niang, Markovic, Destro, Andrade, Lewandowski, Damiao, J Martinez, Lacina Traore.

Definitely do not sell; Verrati, Isco, Draxler, Ox, Deulofeu, Reus, Zaha, Niang, Lewandowski

7. Would you do Aurtenetxe + Deulofel for Alaba?

Alaba 100%.

8. Would you do Deulofel + Markovic for Montoya?

Deulofeu & Markovic.

9. Would you sell Phil Jones + Lewandowski + money for Falcao? Or just Gomez in a straight swap? Plus would you give Lewandowski + Powell/another good talent in list above for Jovetic?

Get Falcao. Best striker in the world.

8(?) Draxler + Perisic or Oscar?

Oscar. There's a buzz about Draxler and he could be quality but I think Oscar is less of a risk.

That's enough for now, or this post will be too long to read :o

Thanks

You have a quality squad. I envy some of the decisions you have to make particularly over your Goalkeeping talent!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: The Squad Advice Thread

I've got a squad which I've hit a wall with, struggling to think who to keep/sell. Any help would be good. I'm Atletico Madrid. It's only a new league which I won division 2 fairly easily in but a lot of the other teams have strengthened. It is quite a competitive league but I'm just looking for a few tips. Cheers.

FIRST TEAM

Radamel Falcao

Borges Willian

Clint Dempsey

Rio Mavuba

Joao Miranda

Diego Godin

Sebastian Giovinco

Moussa Dembele

Kevin Strootman

Dejan Lovren

Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa

Alvaro Dominguez

Filipe Luis

Jose Callejon

Adrian Lopez

Mario Suarez

Vurnon Anita

Joel Matip

Juanfran Torres

Thibaut Courtois (loan)

Michu Perez

Marc Andre Ter-Stegen

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain

Antonio Balzano

YOUTH

Stephen El-Shaarawy

Alexandre Lacazette

Jack Butland

Alexander Kacaniklic

Daniel Carvajal

Jurgen Locadia

Oliver Torres

Adrien Rabiot

Lewis MacLeod

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...