Jump to content

vidic evra jon obi mikel


aadil12
 Share

Recommended Posts

all underated i think. mikel pushing ballack and mekelele out for a starting line up of chelsea up to 90/91 i think. evra pushing heinze out of a starting line up heinze is a world class lb but evra is better 92/93 i think. vidic superb all last season up to 94 i think. anyone agree.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: vidic evra jon obi mikel

all underated i think. mikel pushing ballack and mekelele out for a starting line up of chelsea up to 90/91 i think. evra pushing heinze out of a starting line up heinze is a world class lb but evra is better 92/93 i think. vidic superb all last season up to 94 i think. anyone agree.

I think you've got the general 'jist' correct, a couple of ratings need to be revised, however I think you've gone OTT on some of the ratings....

John Obi Mikel - Quality young midfielder who will be quality when he's older, however 90/91 is slightly steep. I think 89 is about right for now, an increase of two should reflect his improvement. I think he is 'as good as' the likes of Lucas Biglia, Enzo Maresca and Riccardo Montolivo (all 89 rated), rather than 'better than' the likes of those players.

Patrice Evra - Pacey left-wing-back who has replaced Heinze as Man Utd's left-sided man at the back. I like him as an attacker and I believe he is as good as Gael Clichy going forward, however he lacks quite a bit in the defensive department. I think his rating of 91 is good for now, unless he begins to improve defensively.

Nemanja Vidic - The rock at Man Utd's centre-back position, I agree that his rating should be increased to 94, however Jamie Carragher's rating would also have to increase to 94 minimum if Vidic was to be increased to 94.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: vidic evra jon obi mikel

I think you've got the general 'jist' correct' date=' a couple of ratings need to be revised, however I think you've gone OTT on some of the ratings....

John Obi Mikel - Quality young midfielder who will be quality when he's older, however 90/91 is slightly steep. I think 89 is about right for now, an increase of two should reflect his improvement. I think he is 'as good as' the likes of Lucas Biglia, Enzo Maresca and Riccardo Montolivo (all 89 rated), rather than 'better than' the likes of those players.

Patrice Evra - Pacey left-wing-back who has replaced Heinze as Man Utd's left-sided man at the back. I like him as an attacker and I believe he is as good as Gael Clichy going forward, however he lacks quite a bit in the defensive department. I think his rating of 91 is good for now, unless he begins to improve defensively.

Nemanja Vidic - The rock at Man Utd's centre-back position, I agree that his rating should be increased to 94, however Jamie Carragher's rating would also have to increase to 94 minimum if Vidic was to be increased to 94.[/quote']

Disagree Mikel is better than the players you listed,a 90 is fair,on a par with Modric..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: vidic evra jon obi mikel

On par with Modric' date=' maybe.....on par with Elano, Mavuba and Hargreaves, I can't see the comparison in quality.[/quote']

What Hargreaves better than Mikel??!!:eek: :eek: You are seriously having a laugh,I would rather Mikel than Hargreaves any day!

Elano is a different type of player,and yes Mikel is as good as Mavuba,if not better..

The only people who don't rate Mikel are just anti-Chelsea.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: vidic evra jon obi mikel

What Hargreaves better than Mikel??!!:eek: :eek: You are seriously having a laugh' date='I would rather Mikel than Hargreaves any day!

Elano is a different type of player,and yes Mikel is as good as Mavuba,if not better..

The only people who don't rate Mikel are just anti-Chelsea.[/quote']

Better than Hargreaves? Much better than Hargreaves?! (the way you make it sound)?! I think you're the one who's having a laugh! There's no such thing as anti-Chelsea, but I get the feeling that even Chelsea supporters (some of them who aren't biased) would agree that Hargreaves is better than Mikel!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...