Jump to content

EPL Rating Changes Thread


TomOwen
 Share

Recommended Posts

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

Good work tom

But id like to here some reasons why you think the biggest calamity the premiership has ever seen should be 87' date=' Yes he plays most weeks and that can warrant his current rating but his performances are abysmal, one of the worst prem players ever, Makes mistake after mistake even Alan Hansen and co said it about him after the liverpool game , he might of scored 2 in 2 recently but imo his performances are not a 87 rated player. But the rest are quite accurate imo :D[/quote']

Agree that he is one of the worst ever played in EPL, but he plays every week so I guess he should have an increase to 86 at least because he plays.

I know it's judge by performance but Wigan are 19th so you can appreciate his terrible performances.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

Kudos for your hardwork Tom:) ' date=' keep it up .

I wanna ask , i have posted this in many EPL ratings thread and i haven't received any replies .

will David Bentley have a positional change from AM/RM to RM/AM ??

thanks in advance .[/quote']

Yes i also think he should be a RM/AM but to be fair when has he played AM because i can't think of many games. :confused:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

Chelsea

Wayne Bridge - 89 - 91

Ferreira 88 -99

Carvalho 94 -95

Mikel 89 -90

Joe Cole - 92 -93

Shevchenko 93 - 92

Ballack 93 -92

Makelele 93 -91

Pizzaro 90 -89

Kalou 91 -92

Sinclair 82-85

I'm sure Ferreira won't go up to 99. :P

The other ratings are all accurate IMO, maybe 85 is a bit too high for Sinclair

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

Chelsea

Wayne Bridge - 89 - 91

Ferreira 88 -99

Carvalho 94 -95

Mikel 89 -90

Joe Cole - 92 -93

Shevchenko 93 - 92

Ballack 93 -92

Makelele 93 -91

Pizzaro 90 -89

Kalou 91 -92

Sinclair 82-85

I do not agree with all of yours .

Bridge to 91 ??? he has only played 5 games this season .

Carvalho to 95 ??? also worried by injuries and 9 games this season . I hear rumors that he will fall to 93 :eek: :eek:

I agree with Joe Cole and Mikel .

Shevchenko and Ballack were bound to fall this time but they are back playing and doing well .Especially Ballack .

Makelele down to 92/91

Pizarro might fall as well

Sinclair - not too sure , played only 9 games at QPR and around 4 at Chelsea .Could rise to 83-84

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

Everton's rating changes have already been posted but no one seems to have mentioned some positional changes;

Mikel Arteta is currently listed as an AM.

He's been playing mostly down the right or left this season so maybe should change to AM/W?

Steven Pienaar is currently an RM/AM.

So far he's featured down both flanks but mostly down the left so maybe W/AM?

Not too sure about these, really, both players have three positions (LM, RM and AM) but, obviously that can't be done :rolleyes:

They do definately need a change though...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

Charles N'zogbia has been one of Newcastle's best players this season if not the best. Amazing talent , rare technique . I've watched him in almost every game and his last game against Man. Utd , he was brilliant . He even had a solo run at the defense yesterday which if he scored was to be goal of the season .

N'zogbia has been a regular for Newcastle , 22 starts , 3 goals and 4 assists .

Can he rise to 89 or just an 88 for now ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

these are the players i think deserve an increase for definate:

Rio ferdinand to 95!

jamie o'hara to 85/86

michael johnson to 90

niko krancar to 90/91

cristiano ronaldo to 98

All Opinions Welcome.

Ha ha, perhaps you should review how the rating system works mate!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

I'm not going to talk about ratings. I'm just going to put some players on paper that really impressed over last couple of moths, and those who failed.

Impressed:

GK-

Green

Almunia

D-

Laursen

Corluka

Shorey (reading)

Mellberg

Lescott

Kaboul

Ridgewell

Omozusi (fulham)

Disitn

M-

Petrov

O’Hara

Bentley

Elano

Hunt (reading)

Dempsey (fulham)

F-

Torres

Jones (sunderland)

Yakubu

Adebayor

Santa Cruz

Agbonlahor

Anelka

Benjani

Young

Failed:

G-

Lehman

Jaaskelainen

D-

Nelsen (Birmingham)

Davis (derby)

Knight (villa)

M-

Ireland (city)

Essien

Wilhelmsson

Reo-coker

Kewell

Gilberto Silva

Gamst Pedersen

F-

Nugent

Zamora

Luque

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

I'm not going to talk about ratings. I'm just going to put some players on paper that really impressed over last couple of moths' date=' and those who failed.

Impressed:

GK-

Green

Almunia

D-

Laursen

Corluka

Shorey (reading)

Mellberg

Lescott

Kaboul

Ridgewell

Omozusi (fulham)

Disitn

M-

Petrov

O’Hara

Bentley

Elano

Hunt (reading)

Dempsey (fulham)

F-

Torres

Jones (sunderland)

Yakubu

Adebayor

Santa Cruz

Agbonlahor

Anelka

Benjani

Young

Failed:

G-

Lehman

Jaaskelainen

D-

Nelsen (Birmingham)

Davis (derby)

Knight (villa)

M-

Ireland (city)

Essien

Wilhelmsson

Reo-coker

Kewell

Gilberto Silva

Gamst Pedersen

F-

Nugent

Zamora

Luque[/quote']

agree with most but stephen ireland, i think hes had a good season. a regular in a high flyin man city team. scores a few goals and also is outstanding for his country and was their top scorer in the euro 2008 qualifying campaign. will almost certainly go up 1.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: EPL Rating Changes Thread

I'm not going to talk about ratings. I'm just going to put some players on paper that really impressed over last couple of moths' date=' and those who failed.

Impressed:

GK-

Green

Almunia

D-

Laursen

Corluka

Shorey (reading)

Mellberg

Lescott

Kaboul

Ridgewell

Omozusi (fulham)

Disitn

M-

Petrov

O’Hara

Bentley

Elano

Hunt (reading)

Dempsey (fulham)

F-

Torres

Jones (sunderland)

Yakubu

Adebayor

Santa Cruz

Agbonlahor

Anelka

Benjani

Young

Failed:

G-

Lehman

Jaaskelainen

D-

Nelsen (Birmingham)

Davis (derby)

Knight (villa)

M-

Ireland (city)

Essien

Wilhelmsson

Reo-coker

Kewell

Gilberto Silva

Gamst Pedersen

F-

Nugent

Zamora

Luque[/quote']

Luque is at Ajax or PSV one of them, he left Newcastle moons :eek: ago. :eek::rolleyes::D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...