Jump to content

Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?


Toro De Líbano
 Share

Recommended Posts

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

Question about Matteo Ferrari. Could his move to Besiktas affect his rating before the official time for the Turkish changes or is he safe until then?

Hi Didi. Matteo Ferrari is a safe 90. He was an everpresent last season for the impressive Genoa in the Serie A and he has now moved to Besiktas. He has since started all of Besiktas League games to date and generally, Besiktas are one of the bigger clubs in Turkey. His 90 is safe, although I will rule out a rise for him, with him not being involved with the Azzurri anymore. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

Here are some players which I bought as risers and I want to know if they have reached their peak?

Leroy Fer

Nicolas Bertolo

Stijn Schaars

Lars Bender

Sven Bender

Thanks for any help.

Schaars probably has just about reached his full potential so is one you could look at selling if he is surplus to requirements.

Fer is a definite keeper and will continue to rise in the next few dutch changes I suspect.

Both Lars and Sven will likely get further risers so I would certainly keep them until the next changes and re-evaluate. Not convinced they are long-term keepers like Fer.

Cannot really comment on Bertolo as I don't know too much about him and haven't seen enough of him either :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

Schaars probably has just about reached his full potential so is one you could look at selling if he is surplus to requirements.

Fer is a definite keeper and will continue to rise in the next few dutch changes I suspect.

Both Lars and Sven will likely get further risers so I would certainly keep them until the next changes and re-evaluate. Not convinced they are long-term keepers like Fer.

Cannot really comment on Bertolo as I don't know too much about him and haven't seen enough of him either :)

So Fer could overtake Schaars this change or perhaps the one after? I was told somewhere that Schaars could reach 90

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showpost.php?p=731823&postcount=1

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showpost.php?p=566965&postcount=1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

So Fer could overtake Schaars this change or perhaps the one after? I was told somewhere that Schaars could reach 90

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showpost.php?p=731823&postcount=1

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showpost.php?p=566965&postcount=1

Schaars could, but I think the emergence of other Dutch midfielders may have pushed him down the pecking order internationally. I'd suspect 89 would be a maximum he'd reach. Fer will likely be one of his successors in the coming years (this change is too early but perhaps the next).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

Schaars probably has just about reached his full potential so is one you could look at selling if he is surplus to requirements.

Fer is a definite keeper and will continue to rise in the next few dutch changes I suspect.

Both Lars and Sven will likely get further risers so I would certainly keep them until the next changes and re-evaluate. Not convinced they are long-term keepers like Fer.

Cannot really comment on Bertolo as I don't know too much about him and haven't seen enough of him either :)

I'm inclined to agree about Schaars although I do think he's a good chance at 89 or even 90 if he manages to get into the dutch NT for WC2010 but I doubt he'll ever get beyond that.

Lars Bender will be a german international within the next 2 years imho. Sven I'm not so sure about but both are very good and future 90s imho.

Fer has been discussed in depth, definitely a keeper and top talent.

Bertolo is a class act, but has been a troublesome character in the past. No doubting his skill, it's more his attitude I'm worried about. Should be interesting to see how he goes at Palermo this season. It's a good sign that he's moved to europe, let's wait and see if he can seize the opportunity! :rolleyes:

Without knowing your team, and taking age and league into consideration, I'd probably offload Schaars if I needed cash. I personally think all of them will rise further this season. :eek:

Herby

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

TURAN, Arda 90

MARCELO,90

BOJAN, 89

BEN ARFA 89

RAKITIC, 89

DEFOUR, 89

KUZMANOVIC, Zdravko 89

DENILSON, 89

WITSEL, Axel 89

ACOSTA, Lautaro 88

GIOVINCO, Sebastian 88

DRENTHE, Royston 88

EVANS, Jonny 88

VELA, Carlos 87

PALOSCHI, Alberto 84

RAMSEY, Aaron 84

CORK, Jack 81

NEED 2 RAISE FUNDS!!!

any help..these are my fringe players who 2 sell?and who 2 keep?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

TURAN' date=' Arda 90

[b']MARCELO,90

BOJAN, 89 [/b]

BEN ARFA 89

RAKITIC, 89

DEFOUR, 89

KUZMANOVIC, Zdravko 89

DENILSON, 89

WITSEL, Axel 89

ACOSTA, Lautaro 88

GIOVINCO, Sebastian 88

DRENTHE, Royston 88

EVANS, Jonny 88

VELA, Carlos 87

PALOSCHI, Alberto 84

RAMSEY, Aaron 84

CORK, Jack 81

NEED 2 RAISE FUNDS!!!

any help..these are my fringe players who 2 sell?and who 2 keep?

Most of them are very good young talents, but in terms of SM, I'll suggest you at least keep those in bold

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

The following players are at unmanaged clubs in my setup :

RB

Vedran Corluka

Rafinha

Jorge Fucile

CB

Diego Lugano

Naldo

Alessandro Gamberini

Mathieu Bodmer

Gonzalo Rodriguez

Diego Godin

DM

Mahamadou Diarra

Anatoliy Tymoschuk

CF

Pavel Pogrebnyak

Alvaro Negredo

I need one of each, so who would you recommend out of these?

Thanks in advance. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

The following players are at unmanaged clubs in my setup :

RB

Vedran Corluka

Rafinha

Jorge Fucile

CB

Diego Lugano

Naldo

Alessandro Gamberini

Mathieu Bodmer

Gonzalo Rodriguez

Diego Godin

DM

Mahamadou Diarra

Anatoliy Tymoschuk

CF

Pavel Pogrebnyak

Alvaro Negredo

I need one of each' date=' so who would you recommend out of these?

Thanks in advance. :)[/quote']

Rafinha, Godin, Tymoschuk and Negredo are the ones I would buy out of them:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

hi' date=' quick advice appreciated. I see anderson isn't getting much game time at man u and heard he had a fall out with sir alex. I've been offered 25m for him, could maybe squeeze it to 27 or 28m. I think i should deal, but just wanted second opinions. Thanks[/quote']

How about squeezing 30m from him? ;) I'd do the deal if I were you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

What abot my squad then?

FREY, Sebastien

DIEGO LOPEZ, Rodríguez

NEUER, Manuel

-----------------------------------------

TAIWO, Taye

MATHIEU, Jérémy

RAFINHA, Marcio

CASTRO, Gonzalo

BRUNO ALVES, Eduardo

GODÍN, Diego

PIQUE, Gerard

GONZALO, Rodríguez

THIAGO SILVA, Emiliano

----------------------------------------------------

RIERA, Albert

MICHEL BASTOS, Fernandes

RENATO AUGUSTO, Soares

YAYA TOURE, Gnégnéri

DIARRA, Alou

FELIPE MELO, Carvalho

HAMSIK, Marek

MISIMOVIC, Zvjezdan

GOURCUFF, Yoann

RAKITIC, Ivan

SESSEGNON, Stephane

------------------------------------------------------------

PATO, Alexandre

LISANDRO, López

GIGNAC, André-Pierre

GILARDINO, Alberto

DZEKO, Edin

Loaned out:

MOTTA, Marco

MOTTA, Thiago

CIGARINI, Luca

HULK, Givanildo Vieira

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

What abot my squad then?

FREY' date=' Sebastien

DIEGO LOPEZ, Rodríguez

NEUER, Manuel

-----------------------------------------

TAIWO, Taye

MATHIEU, Jérémy

RAFINHA, Marcio

CASTRO, Gonzalo

BRUNO ALVES, Eduardo

GODÍN, Diego

PIQUE, Gerard

GONZALO, Rodríguez

THIAGO SILVA, Emiliano

----------------------------------------------------

RIERA, Albert

MICHEL BASTOS, Fernandes

RENATO AUGUSTO, Soares

YAYA TOURE, Gnégnéri

DIARRA, Alou

FELIPE MELO, Carvalho

HAMSIK, Marek

MISIMOVIC, Zvjezdan

GOURCUFF, Yoann

RAKITIC, Ivan

SESSEGNON, Stephane

------------------------------------------------------------

PATO, Alexandre

LISANDRO, López

GIGNAC, André-Pierre

GILARDINO, Alberto

DZEKO, Edin

Loaned out:

MOTTA, Marco

MOTTA, Thiago

CIGARINI, Luca

HULK, Givanildo Vieira[/quote']

That's quite a good team. :)

No point in keeping 3 GKs, so sell Diego Lopez.

Try looking for a better RB than Castro, and maybe better LBs than Taiwo & Mathieu.

Get rid of Rakitic and look for a good RM or winger to give competition to Sessegnon. The rest of the squad looks fine.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

That's quite a good team. :)

No point in keeping 3 GKs' date=' so sell Diego Lopez.

Try looking for a better RB than Castro, and maybe better LBs than Taiwo & Mathieu.

Get rid of Rakitic and look for a good RM or winger to give competition to Sessegnon. The rest of the squad looks fine.[/quote']

Thanks, but aren't they risers and talents please post ASAP!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Players: Should I buy, sell or keep?

Thanks' date=' but aren't they risers and talents please post ASAP!!![/quote']

Okaaaaaaaaayyyyyy, impatient guy... :rolleyes:

FREY, Sebastien Stay the same.

DIEGO LOPEZ, Rodríguez Stay the same, probably. Sell.

NEUER, Manuel Rise by 1.

-----------------------------------------

TAIWO, Taye Good chance of rising by 1.

MATHIEU, Jérémy Rise by 1 if he becomes Valencia's no : 1 LB, as expected.

RAFINHA, Marcio Stay, with a slight chance of a +1 rise.

CASTRO, Gonzalo Can't see him regaining his 91. Sell.

BRUNO ALVES, Eduardo A chance of a rise to 93.

GODÍN, Diego Not sure if he'll rise. Will certainly keep his rating.

PIQUE, Gerard +1 rise.

GONZALO, Rodríguez Same as Godin.

THIAGO SILVA, Emiliano Likely to rise by 1.

----------------------------------------------------

RIERA, Albert Stay, I think.

MICHEL BASTOS, Fernandes Rise by 1.

RENATO AUGUSTO, Soares Should rise by 1. Classy player.

YAYA TOURE, Gnégnéri A +1 is likely.

DIARRA, Alou Stay, with a chance of a +1.

FELIPE MELO, Carvalho A +1 is certain.

HAMSIK, Marek Stay.

MISIMOVIC, Zvjezdan Rise by 1.

GOURCUFF, Yoann +1/+2

RAKITIC, Ivan Won't escape a -1 drop this time, hopefully.

SESSEGNON, Stephane Stay or rise by 1.

------------------------------------------------------------

PATO, Alexandre Don't know.

LISANDRO, López Stay.

GIGNAC, André-Pierre Rise by 1.

GILARDINO, Alberto Stay, I think.

DZEKO, Edin Rise by 1, at least.

Loaned out:

MOTTA, Marco Rise by 1.

MOTTA, Thiago Rise by 1 or 2, depending on appearances.

CIGARINI, Luca Rise by 1 if Napoli do well.

HULK, Givanildo Vieira Rise by 1 at least.

Should I buy Hulk and if so will he rise.

Absolutely, if you can get him. Don't forget he plays for the champions of Portugal, who also play regularly in the Champions League. He's bound to rise by at least 1 in the next changes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...