Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 6.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

You should see a doctor mate, it's amazing what they can do for you these days  

Some of the stuff you see on here is honestly absurd, this second time i've now seen you have a go at someone because of ratings lol, if people come on here and provide threads for the benefit of hund

With regards to @hoochy koochy's post, I agree that this has become a catch-all thread for deals, buy/sell/keep and new players etc. I can understand why people would post questions that are unrelated

Posted Images

Couple of questions. 

Everton Felipe, worth keeping or sell now he got his increase? Is he likely to move and progress?

Secondly, was Menezes Ramon overlooked because he moved to Maccabi Tel Aviv on loan and therefore not part of a Brazil review or, did he get reviewed and not get an increase? I was expecting 82 for him at least. 

Is Santos Dodo worth getting as a future star, I know he just rose, but any idea on his future prospects, 82 at his age is promising. But is he worth picking up as a future world class player?

Also predictions on this review for Monteiro Rafael, Felipe Pablo, and Rafael Vaz please. 83's all round?

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, EnglishPirlo said:

Couple of questions. 

Everton Felipe, worth keeping or sell now he got his increase? Is he likely to move and progress?

Secondly, was Menezes Ramon overlooked because he moved to Maccabi Tel Aviv on loan and therefore not part of a Brazil review or, did he get reviewed and not get an increase? I was expecting 82 for him at least. 

Is Santos Dodo worth getting as a future star, I know he just rose, but any idea on his future prospects, 82 at his age is promising. But is he worth picking up as a future world class player?

Also predictions on this review for Monteiro Rafael, Felipe Pablo, and Rafael Vaz please. 83's all round?

It's very likely that it's due to him being out on loan. Would predict 82/83 for him as well.

Rafael to 80/82. Pablo and Vaz should get at least 82.

As for Felipe and Dodo, I don't know too much about them and can't really comment much.

59 minutes ago, Ciuzz said:

Barberan Maycon gained value, from 600k to 1,4mln.....big rise coming?

Don't think that indicates much, think he'll still rise according to the prediction made

49 minutes ago, Hail Mary said:

What rise would you expect for Christian Cueva (85) and Jonathan Copete (84)?

Think Cueva might get a +1 and Copete to 85/86

Not only did Juninho get a poor +1 instead of an +3 but they also forgot to give him his LB position as well despite playing there in 10 games. He should be 85 D(LC) #Justiceforjuninho 

I think it's because most regulars in the team are at 83 and one season of playing regularly doesn't really warrant him to be rated above players who have been playing regularly for seasons

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, EnglishPirlo said:

How about Luiz Felipe at Santos? He had a permanent starting spot before he did his knee ligaments near the end of the season in November. Due back 1 or 2 months. Surely the amount he played for the runner-up in Serie A before his injury are worth an increase. Any prediction for an increase? 

Should get to 82/83

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/04/2017 at 4:09 PM, arsenalrocs said:

Kessie, Dahoud, Davinson Sanchez, Henrichs, Fornals

CMs who should eventually get to 88: Gagliardini, Locatelli, Spinazzola, Marcos Llorente

Other positions: Mbappe, Dolberg, Kimpembe, Vallejo, Diop, Oyarzabal

I'm sure there are many other players who could get to 88 but it would be difficult to list all of them.

Spinazzola isn't a CM.

On 12/04/2017 at 4:22 PM, arsenalrocs said:

Cyprien should still get a rise, +1.

Think Coric is more likely to stay than to get a +1 especially if Dinamo don't win the league this year. Highly rated and has already played for the Croatian national team. Also, recently nominated for the European Young Player of the Year Award. Doubt he'll win it with the likes of Mbappe and Donnarumma in the mix as well but still a sign of his talent. Can see him getting 90 but it'll probably be around 2-3 years later.

98 players were nominated for that award, wouldn't look much into it. But Coric is a great talent, hope he moves to a bigger league in the summer.

On 13/04/2017 at 2:03 AM, Soccahappy said:

Lets say this could be a bit of a mindbending puzzle :) As you probably know I do my own ratings but do have problems with those "In-betweeners". I would greatly appreciate Arsenal Rocks, Sir Rahul & also anyone else who might have an appreciation of the players on this list:- What I'm looking for is some kind of chance of.... :-

1) 100% +1 (or whatever else +2 etc) OR

2) This is what I really meant by Inbetweener, what is in your estimation the % chance of a rise e.g 60/40% for or 10/90% against etc etc...

I know these estimations are difficult (Particularly with SM rating them) but a general idea/ yardstick would be great.

% plays is either current or recent

Michail Antonio rated 88 Played 84.7% of available games but currently injured stay

Cancelo rated 89 Played 75.6% of available stay

Mario Gaspar 90 Played 96.8% of available stay

Roque Mesa 88 Played 89.1% of available stay

Gerhardt 88 Played 78.4% ditto stay

Tolisso 90 Played 80.4% ditto stay

Ginter 89 Played 77% ditto stay

Fazio 88 Played 90.1% ditto 89

Burgui 84 Played 54.1% ditto stay/85

Gerard Moreno 87 Played 95% ditto stay/88

Sergi Roberto 91 Played 71.2% ditto stay

Most grateful for any contributions

 

On 15/04/2017 at 10:51 PM, 1000dB said:

Your thoughts, please

 

AUGUSTINSSON, Ludwig 86 +1 don't think so

SAMIR, Caetano 83 +2/+3 86

JANKTO, Jakub 82 +2/+3 85/86

FORNALS, Pablo 86 +1 86/87

LABORDE, Gaëtan 83 +2 85

ZAMBO ANGUISSA, André 80 +2 83/84

MILINKOVIĆ-SAVIĆ, Sergej 88 +1 89

ORIGI, Divock 88 stay/+1 stay

THIAGO, Alcántara 92 +1 93

SANABRIA, Antonio 85 +1/+2 stay/86

HERNÁNDEZ, Lucas 86 +1 yes

SKHIRI, Ellyes 83 +2 85

MBENZA, Isaac 82 +2 84

MASCARELL, Omar 85 +1/+2 86

BODIGER, Yann 84 +1/+2 85

RONGIER, Valentin 83 +2 85

KEHRER, Thilo 77 +5 83

LATO, Toni 77 +3/+5 (if he keeps starting) 82/83

CALABRIA, Davide 80 +2/+3 (if he keeps starting) 83

HABERER, Janik 82 +2/+3 85

 

19 hours ago, Hail Mary said:

After yesterday I was sure they'd only give Felipe an +5, but more than happy with his +7. Nice +2 for Scarpa as well. Anyone who has played FM17 knows of his talent :D

Happy with the Felipe rise

--

Not going to answer anything else as it all looks well covered :) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Relatively new to game and new to forum. Looking for advice on whether to keep or sell players and whether they are likely to rise.

Not sure if this is right place to post but seems to be one of the more active threads.

T. Horn

Van Dijk

E Can

N Stark

I Gueye

T Bakayoko

M Oyarzabel

M Doria

J Ward Prowse

P Hojberg

N Amiri

A Coric


Thanks in advance.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, Dandie said:

Relatively new to game and new to forum. Looking for advice on whether to keep or sell players and whether they are likely to rise.

Not sure if this is right place to post but seems to be one of the more active threads.

T. Horn

Van Dijk

E Can

N Stark

I Gueye

T Bakayoko

M Oyarzabel

M Doria

J Ward Prowse

P Hojberg

N Amiri

A Coric


Thanks in advance.

 

I would keep all. A few of them are unlikely to rise but still worth holding onto.

I think Horn and Coric might need to move to continue rising but they're both doing well. Horn has just signed a contract extension so maybe you'll want to consider selling him. Coric will probably be picked up by a bigger club sooner or later.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...