Pat's Euro League (ID 338046) - with side rules

[georgie34 89]

43 minutes ago, Middle_Finger said:

I am averse to rewarding div2 n 3 winners. I understand your point for rewarding all the division winners. But here's my point of view. Now the squad value limit is 400m. Say a team from division 2 wins the league and is rewarded extra 5m. So that totals to 405m for that team and still 400m for other div1 clubs? That's not fair now is it? Hence rewards only div1 winner makes more sense and means less complications. Getting promoted to division 1 and 2 is a reward in itself. The rest I agree with

to be fair a very valid point. It would seem unfair a team in Div 2 or 3 getting a bonus when 3rd place in Div 1 gets nothing

[georgie34 89]

I do agree with Michael in that it simply is a small incentive for the teams lower down

[georgie34 89]

we still have another week to put something in place, plenty of time

[Middle_Finger 704]

1 hour ago, dhruv5588 said:

Georgie34 this was my explanation to both Michael and dhruv5588;  Just say a team from div3 gets back to back promotions. That's 10m advantage. And for say I have mane and he increases taking my value over 400m but less than 405m. Dude I lose higuain/bonnucci/buffon that's a huge advantage to other teams. I suggested pat to revise the max squad value to 410 for div1 405 for 2 and 400 for 3. That way if a club from div 2 is rewarded its still 410m. 

[Middle_Finger 704]

1 hour ago, georgie34 said:

I do agree with Michael in that it simply is a small incentive for the teams lower down

Just say a team from div3 gets back to back promotions. That's 10m advantage. And for say I have mane and he increases taking my value over 400m but less than 405m. Dude I lose higuain/bonnucci/buffon that's a huge advantage to other teams. I suggested pat to revise the max squad value to 410 for div1 405 for 2 and 400 for 3. That way if a club from div 2 is rewarded its still 410m. 

[dhruv5588 271]

11 minutes ago, Middle_Finger said:

1 hour ago, dhruv5588 said:

Georgie34 this was my explanation to both Michael and dhruv5588;  Just say a team from div3 gets back to back promotions. That's 10m advantage. And for say I have mane and he increases taking my value over 400m but less than 405m. Dude I lose higuain/bonnucci/buffon that's a huge advantage to other teams. I suggested pat to revise the max squad value to 410 for div1 405 for 2 and 400 for 3. That way if a club from div 2 is rewarded its still 410m. 

2 things.

1. if div 3 team got back to back promotion then that team deserved it and I think its still tough for that div.3 team in div 1 because all top players are occupied.

2. Rule of "selling top player due to riser in squad takes value above 400" that need to review/rethink. Manager must not loose their 94 rated player just because 85-86 rated player rose to 88-89 suddenly. Instead of that he must sell any player and bring back the squad value under 400 again.

[Middle_Finger 704]

1 minute ago, dhruv5588 said:

2 things.

1. if div 3 got back to back promotion then he deserved it and I think its still tough for that div.3 team in div 1 because all top players are occupied.

2. that rule of "selling top player due to riser in squad takes value above 400" that need to review/rethink. Manager must not losse their 94 rated player just because 85-86 rated player rised to 88-89 suddenly. Instead of that he must sell any player and bring back the squad value under 400 again.

Ok we are all too using too much of our brain especially me :).  Let's just keep it to rewards discussion for season 1. And the only question is should div2 and 3 be rewarded for gaining promotion.

And for the point you make dhruv Dortmund, Napoli, atletico, etc are in div 2 and 3. All the teams are good in this GW. have a look at zenits squad better than mine if you take age as a factor too.

[Jerry Hatrik 14]

Seems a tad silly not to reward the Div 2 and 3 champions IMO

Why not just give them some money?     to spend on players

Keep the original caps limit (for both) for a couple of seasons and see how it goes.

 

 

[georgie34 89]

4 hours ago, dhruv5588 said:

2 things.

1. if div 3 team got back to back promotion then that team deserved it and I think its still tough for that div.3 team in div 1 because all top players are occupied.

2. Rule of "selling top player due to riser in squad takes value above 400" that need to review/rethink. Manager must not loose their 94 rated player just because 85-86 rated player rose to 88-89 suddenly. Instead of that he must sell any player and bring back the squad value under 400 again.

This is the core rule of this GW - i could not possible change it

I love the idea of managers having to take into account their budget. Spending wisely and making sure that if players rise they stay within the budget. Selling any player is no punishment. Selling their best player is harsh i would agree, but it ensures every manager is paying attention all of the time..........or at least they should be!

[georgie34 89]

6 days and counting...........i wish we could delete pre-season 

[georgie34 89]

Guys i am looking at setting a date where all clubs MUST be under both caps for clarity more than anything. I think before KO of Game 1 is not going to happen so I want views on a date. ie before KO of Game 5 for example???

[Jerry Hatrik 14]

I would suggest an extra day ... before Game 6.

For Juventus maybe a whole season  lol

 

[Middle_Finger 704]

On 8/20/2016 at 4:11 PM, dhruv5588 said:

With no external bids(yet) and long pre season have knocked the exitement a bit.

[georgie34 89]

Not too long now boys. It's painstakingly slow, but we are getting closer to kick off 

[georgie34 89]

SM have brought back Use TM, Use Playmaker etc options

Thank you SM

[Middle_Finger 704]

On 8/24/2016 at 11:33 PM, georgie34 said:

SM have brought back Use TM, Use Playmaker etc options

Thank you SM

You will need more than that to beat me !! Start praying !!!! ?

[georgie34 89]

End of season rewards at the top of page 1

[Huddo 2,959]

Great stuff - looks good!!

[dhruv5588 271]

8 hours ago, georgie34 said:

End of season rewards at the top of page 1

nice...!! From season 2 you have to mention current squad cap of each team there to keep record of it.

[georgie34 89]

4 hours ago, dhruv5588 said:

nice...!! From season 2 you have to mention current squad cap of each team there to keep record of it.

No problem, easy done!

[Middle_Finger 704]

On 8/24/2016 at 11:33 PM, georgie34 said:

SM have brought back Use TM, Use Playmaker etc options

Thank you SM

You will need more than that to beat me !! Start praying !!!! ?

[Middle_Finger 704]

Dhruv since u doubted, this is from my another GW!!

 

[georgie34 89]

Bayern suffer (Pat will suffer more) a horrible loss to Juventus. The Italians were dominant from start to finish and fully deserved their 2-0 win. 

Plenty of transfer dealings to be done before the next fixture with the externals on their way?

[georgie34 89]

here come the external bids!!!

accept, accept, accept

[georgie34 89]

bye bye

Lewandowski, Boateng, Alaba, Sanches, Rafinha