Jump to content
Sir Rahul

Rahul W's rating predictions

Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, tupac_healy said:

@Sir Rahul no rise predicted for Kimmich or Gnabry? 

I remember Kimmich being there a few weeks ago. Guess he was removed due to Bayern's position?

 

1 hour ago, kratick said:

agreed. But giving up martial +Xhaka for Dembele is a little too aggressive i think

Guess it depends how he is in midfield. I can see the temptation but think in the right hands Martial's rating could be right up there.

3 minutes ago, Humble Ninja said:

Who out of Jorginho, Martial, and Witsel are most likely to rise?

Jorginho followed by Witsel then Martial a distant last due to United's position IMO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/4/2018 at 10:06 PM, Real Xabi said:

You mean Huesca's Pulido +1 to 86?  He's currently 85.  

Do you think Vinicius will go up at all?  What about Nacho?  He's gotten more playing time with all the injuries ALWAYS playing well when he's called up.

I think Vinicius will get a small rise. Not played much but has four assists for them - second only to Bale at the time of this tweet. Of course, the quality of the opposition he has faced is much lower and has barely played in the league but think his Castilla minutes added to his first team stuff will get him to 84/85 at a push.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5 December 2018 at 10:20 PM, Soccahappy said:

Have to admit it was disappointing that only one forumer (Middlefinger) replied to the 7? posts on the French Review page461. On reflection, Bad Idea of mine to overwhelm these pages with Rows and Columns of data. It also takes up a lot of time and effort on my part, so the following will benefit me as well 🙂

I've resolved not inflict these stats on u in future. By the time the next review comes round I'll simply say which players are going up. Hopefully by then I will also be able to estimate by how much they will rise (by working it into my spreadsheet).

I'm also terribly disappointed by SM's handling of the reviews so far and hope this doesn't continue into the Top Half of the Bundisliga Clubs. It probably won't. If it does continue there might be a few less of us playing SM by the time the big5 is reviewed again next summer. ATB Socca.

With the French review ppl got what they needed. I am sure ppl reads your explanation and charts and some of the questions come from it as well. No reason to get disheartened your input is appreciated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Damien1990 said:

I can't see Martial rising this season with the position United are at in the league. Bit harsh as he has scored against every single one of the current top 7 teams he has faced this season (with the exception of Spurs as he wasn't selected for that match).

Number of top 7 teams scored against this season:

5 - Martial
3 - Aubameyang
2 - Hazard, Kane, Lacazette, Sterling
1 - Mitrovic, Wilson
0 - Aguero, Mane, Murray, Richarlison, Salah, Sane, Sigurdsson
 

I'd say Dembele is way more likely to rise despite playing less and scoring fewer goals because Barcelona are top and not 8th like United.

martial rise to 91 in 2-3 weeks, wait and see

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Damien1990 said:

I can't see Martial rising this season with the position United are at in the league. Bit harsh as he has scored against every single one of the current top 7 teams he has faced this season (with the exception of Spurs as he wasn't selected for that match).

Number of top 7 teams scored against this season:

5 - Martial
3 - Aubameyang
2 - Hazard, Kane, Lacazette, Sterling
1 - Mitrovic, Wilson
0 - Aguero, Mane, Murray, Richarlison, Salah, Sane, Sigurdsson
 

I'd say Dembele is way more likely to rise despite playing less and scoring fewer goals because Barcelona are top and not 8th like United.

Thanks for all the reply’s, decided to keep the duo after all considered 👍🏼

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, The punch said:

martial rise to 91 in 2-3 weeks, wait and see

No way.. SM need their headchecked on logic. Im a utd season ticket holder. He is amazing talent but to qualaify for rating increase he needs to be in first team club! Be in the national team mix at least! United in 8th!

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, HoochyKoochy said:

No way.. SM need their headchecked on logic. Im a utd season ticket holder. He is amazing talent but to qualaify for rating increase he needs to be in first team club! Be in the national team mix at least! United in 8th!

 

6

What does this bit mean? If you mean he needs to be a first team regular, he is. He was called up for France last national break but ended up going home with injury. I agree with you about United in 8th being a big issue.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, kratick said:

The duo. Don't see Dembele rising in the near term and Martial at least has as much chance of rising based on current form. Xhaka will retain 91. Unless you see Dembele as a long term riser, the duo is better based on the current situation

💯 dembele will rise at winter

xhaka and martial won’t 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Fulvio1988 said:

Any chance for Yerry Mina to reach 90 (+1) at this review?

No 

6 hours ago, Troianos77 said:

If any of you had to choose two between: Gagliardini, Rodri Hernandez, Allan, Vecino which would you all choose?

Allan and Rodri Hernández 

6 hours ago, Humble Ninja said:

Who out of Jorginho, Martial, and Witsel are most likely to rise?

Jorginho has good chance than other two 

3 hours ago, Milanista1 said:

Buenos Dias. Good day fellow managers.

Who to sell: Youri Tielamans, Pelligrini (Roma) or Golovin (As Monaco)? 

Tough to pick one. I'd keep all. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Milanista1 said:

Buenos Dias. Good day fellow managers.

Who to sell: Youri Tielamans, Pelligrini (Roma) or Golovin (As Monaco)? 

 

 

 

Bono estente, good day to you. 

That depends what you need for your team really. If you can get a good replacement for Tielemans then I'd maybe look to exchange him. There are good alternatives out there. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, tupac_healy said:

@Sir Rahul no rise predicted for Kimmich or Gnabry? 

I removed Kimmich due to Germany/Bayern struggles

19 hours ago, SanchoJr said:

Martial and Xhaka for Ousmane Dembele??

Thoughts please!

if you need the depth duo, else the single player

18 hours ago, Fulvio1988 said:

Saul Niguez for Son and Kovacic?

Thoughts please!

if you need the depth duo, else the single player

14 hours ago, Fulvio1988 said:

Any chance for Yerry Mina to reach 90 (+1) at this review?

no

11 hours ago, Troianos77 said:

If any of you had to choose two between: Gagliardini, Rodri Hernandez, Allan, Vecino which would you all choose?

Rodri and Allan

11 hours ago, Humble Ninja said:

Who out of Jorginho, Martial, and Witsel are most likely to rise?

Jorginho

8 hours ago, Milanista1 said:

Buenos Dias. Good day fellow managers.

Who to sell: Youri Tielamans, Pelligrini (Roma) or Golovin (As Monaco)? 

hmm, maybe Tielemans

2 hours ago, crociato87 said:

Kimmich +1?

50/50

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, crociato87 said:

Kimmich +1?

He should be on same level as Alaba but very rarely works that way and also one of Bayern’s best players consistently for a while now. Probably end of season due to teams struggles.

hard to say he’s not of that calibre if he was to get the 93 this week though

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Tharanidharan said:

Saul Niguez or Dele Alli? 

Eric Dier vs Fabinho vs Weigl vs Rabiot - Ranking for position of DM pls. 

Saul

Tough. Rabiot, Fabinho, Dier, Weigl atm

48 minutes ago, Floodstreet2017 said:

He should be on same level as Alaba but very rarely works that way and also one of Bayern’s best players consistently for a while now. Probably end of season due to teams struggles.

hard to say he’s not of that calibre if he was to get the 93 this week though

yes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/25/2016 at 12:13 PM, Sir Rahul said:

GERMANY BUNDESLIGA

Dortmund:

Burki +1 to 90

Alcacer +1 to 90

Akanji +1 to 89

Kagawa -1 to 89

Toprak -1 to 89

Diallo +1 to 88

Wolf +1 to 88

Rode -1 to 87

Sancho +4 to 87

Hakimi +1 to 86

Zagadou +4 to 84

Bruun Larsen +7 to 82

 

Gladbach:

Hazard +1 to 90

Plea +1 to 90

Wendt +1 to 89

Kramer -1 to 89

Stindl -1 to 89

Raffael -1 to 89

Hofmann +1 to 88

Strobl +1 to 87

Neuhaus +3 to 86

Traore -1 to 86

Beyer +5 to 78

 

Frankfurt:

Gacinovic +1 to 88

Rebic +1 to 88

Hasebe +1 to 88

Abraham +1 to 88

Da Costa +2 to 87

Jovic +2 to 87

De Guzman +1 to 87

Ronnow +1 to 86

Muller -1 to 86

Fabian -1 to 86

Stendera -1 to 86

Torro +2 to 85

N'Dicka +6 to 84

 

Leipzig:

Ilsanker +1 to 89

Augustin +1 to 88

Saracchi +3 to 87

Mukiele +1 to 87

Mvogo +1 to 87

Laimer +1 to 87

Konate +3 to 86

Cunha +6 to 83

 

Bayern:

Neuer -1 to 94

Muller -1 to 93

Boateng -1 to 93

Hummels -1 to 93

Robben -1 to 92

 

Hoffenheim:

Baumann +1 to 89

Kaderabek +1 to 89

Grillitsch +1 to 89

Schulz +1 to 88

Szalai +1 to 87

Nordtveit -1 to 87

Joelinton +4 to 86

Posch +4 to 84

Nelson +3 to 83

Hoogma +2 to 82

Kobel +2 to 80

 

Bremen:

Veljkovic +1 to 88- yes

Gebre Selassie +1 to 88

Max Eggestein +1 to 88

Moisander +1 to 88

Osako +1 to 88

Sahin -1 to 88

Bargfrede +1 to 86

Plogmann +3 to 73

Kapino -2 to 83

Friedl +2 to 82

Drobny -3 to 80

Sargent +4 to 77

Toure +3 to 76

Barry -2 to 76

Mbom +3 to 73

 

Hertha Berlin:

Duda +2 to 87- yes

Lazaro +1 to 88- yes

Darida -1 to 88- yes

Maier +3 to 86- yes

Pekarik -1 to 86- yes

Esswein -1 to 85- yes

Mittelstadt +1 to 83- yes

Dilrosun +10 to 80- +13 to 83

Jarstein +1 to 88

Kraft +1 to 84

Torunanigha +1 to 83

Korber +1 to 77

Dardai +2 to 75

Kade +3 to 73

Friede +3 to 73

Kiprit +3 to 73

Kurt -3 to 73

 

Mainz:

Quaison +1 to 86- yes

Donati -1 to 86- yes

Kunde Malong +3 to 85- yes

Muller +5 to 83- yes

Niakhate +2 to 85- +3 to 86

Mateta +2 to 85- +3 to 86

Baku +8 to 83- +7 to 82

Brosinski +1 to 87- nope

Latza -1 to 86- nope

Mwene +1 to 83- nope

Adler -1 to 85

Utah -1 to 85

Bussmann -1 to 82

Seydel +2 to 80

Parker -3 to 75

 

Augsburg:

Koo -1 to 87- yes

Khedira +1 to 86- yes

Stafylidis -1 to 86- yes

Gotze +2 to 77- yes

Richter +3 to 80- +5 to 82

Gouweleeuw +1 to 88- nope

Hahn +1 to 88- nope

Schmid +1 to 87- nope

Luthe +1 to 84- nope

Geifer +2 to 82- nope

Gregoritsch +1 to 89

Ji -2 to 83

Janker -2 to 78

Feulner -2 to 73

 

Wolfsburg:

Guilavogui -1 to 88- yes

William +1 to 87- yes

Weghorst +1 to 87- yes

Bruma -1 to 87- yes

Brekalo +2 to 86- yes

Blaszczykowski -1 to 86- yes

Ntep -1 to 86- yes

Rexhbecaj +2 to 77- +3 to 78

Roussillon +1 to 88- nope

Knoche +1 to 88- nope

Steffen +1 to 88- nope

Camacho -1 to 88- nope

Malli -1 to 88- nope

Mehmedi -1 to 86- nope

Pervan +2 to 82- nope

Bazoer -1 to 86

Dimata +2 to 85

Verhaegh -1 to 85

Jung -1 to 82

Osimhen +2 to 80

Stutter -2 to 73

Pellatz -5 to 73

 

Freiburg:

Gulde +2 to 85- yes

Koch +1 to 86- +2 to 87

Waldschmidt +2 to 84- +3 to 85

Sallai +2 to 84- +3 to 85

Hofler +1 to 87- nope

Frantz +1 to 87- nope

Gondorf +1 to 85- nope

Kubler +1 to 84- nope

Sierro +2 to 82

Fohrenbach +2 to 80

Drager +5 to 78

 

Leverkusen:

Havertz +1 to 89- yes

Wendell +1 to 90- nope

Volland +1 to 90- nope

Aranguiz -1 to 89- nope

Kohr +1 to 88- nope

Bellarabi -1 to 88- nope

Baumgartlinger -1 to 88- nope

Kirschbaum -2 to 80

Lomb +1 to 78

 

Schalke:

Konoplyanka -1 to 89- yes

Geis -1 to 87- yes

Mendyl +3 to 83- yes

McKennie +3 to 86- +2 to 85

Serdar +2 to 86- +1 to 85

Rudy -1 to 90- nope

Stambouli -1 to 87- nope

Nubel +2 to 82- nope

Harit +1 to 89

Samson -4 to 78

Langer -3 to 77

 

Nurnberg:

Behrens +1 to 85- yes

Leibold +1 to 84- yes

Muhl +3 to 83- yes

Valentini +1 to 83- yes

Ishak +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Bredlow +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Petrak +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Fuchs +5 to 78- +7 to 80

Knoll +3 to 80- +1 to 78

Margreitter +1 to 84- nope

Palacios +2 to 82- nope

Misidjan +2 to 85

Jager -2 to 80

Goden +3 to 73

 

Hannover:

Korb -1 to 86- yes

Maina +5 to 78- yes

Weydandt +4 to 77- yes

Muslija +3 to 77- +6 to 80

Anton +1 to 88- nope

Haraguchi -1 to 86- nope

Esser +1 to 85- nope

Asano +1 to 84- nope

Elez +1 to 84- nope

Bakalorz -1 to 84- nope

Felipe +1 to 83- nope

Prib -1 to 83- nope

Fullkrug +1 to 88

Tarnat +3 to 73

 

Dusseldorf:

Giesselmann +1 to 84- yes

Zimmermann +3 to 83- yes

Lukebakio +1 to 83- yes

Ducksch +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Rensing +2 to 84- nope

Zimmer +1 to 84- nope

Usami -1 to 84- nope

Raman +1 to 84

Hennings +1 to 84

Contento -1 to 84

Kujovic -2 to 80

Lambertz -5 to 75

 

Stuttgart:

Gomez -1 to 89- yes

Baumgartl +1 to 88- yes

Castro -1 to 88- yes

Beck -1 to 87- yes

Sosa +1 to 83- yes

Pavard +1 to 89- +2 to 90

Gonzalez +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Thommy +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Badstuber -1 to 87- nope

Didavi -1 to 87- nope

Ascacibar +1 to 89

Aogo -1 to 86

Grgic +2 to 82

Werner -4 to 78

Tomic +3 to 73

Kopacz +3 to 73

zzzzzZZZZZZ

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×