Rahul W's rating predictions

[Sir Rahul 5,543]

7 hours ago, MShahid said:

Thoughts on odriozola?

Wrong career choice to move to Madrid (but Hakimi is gone so who knows now?). Carvajal still too strong though.

6 hours ago, gyanthecat said:

Totally unnecessary for Olmo, but I think he would have risen eventually, he's got pure class. I don't like Schick particularly, and I don't see him rising, but let's see when he goes back to Roma.

Surprised about Haaland and Hazard, too (maybe they'll review them tomorrow), but allow me to disagree: Hakimi is one of the Dortmund players who most deserves to rise. Let's see if it happens tomorrow, or then will have to wait for the Inter review.

Yes, "generous" is not the right word, and I agree there probably is an algorithm behind the reviews. Considering that it should work with objective data, I would really like to know which factors they take into account, besides playing time.

For the same reason, if it is a machine reviewing the leagues, I don't see why they cannot do it more often, including minor leagues, and several long due ones.

Me. I used to be a decent CB, but since lockdown I haven't played a single minute. So, perhaps, 92 might be "generous".  

fair enough mate

5 hours ago, Kierans91 said:

Is there a chance Hakimi will get reviewed with Inter?

David Luiz.

Haha, no seriously I don’t think there is any maybe Pavard and Gomez with how Generous SM are being at the minute.

Neither deserve it in my opinion though, Pavard at a push.

Yeah would be overkill like Rahul said plus he’s 20 years old.

Plenty of time for him.

yeah that's right (about Hakimi), probably 

5 hours ago, Garof said:

What do you think about Dolberg?
Should I get him in a swap deal with Vanheusden?

I would but Dolberg seems a mid table player at best

4 hours ago, topofthebilly said:

Thoughts on james tarkowski ?

I think he has been playing very well so far . So I would think a rise to 89 surely is possible for him ?

90 would be a stretch as he is playing for Burnley ?

Feel he is capped at 88 at Burnley

4 hours ago, TMCosta said:

Im thinking in a +2 to Adama...very possible no?

Possible yes

3 hours ago, Damien1990 said:

Havertz is already 91. Needs a move to hit 92.

Indeed

3 hours ago, Jaachinma said:

Blaise Matuidi to stay or drop?

Stay

2 hours ago, The punch said:

anychance for pavard +2? last up in 2018... 3970 mins this season with bayern, how come he didn't get up in winter ?

Not sure why he didn't, but anyways 91 is fine for now. 92 in winter.

2 hours ago, thorgan lesar said:

Impressive that you know this..

haha, I manually searched on the game

1 hour ago, Soccahappy said:

Didn't know Leipzig had bought Josep Martinez, 22yo  82  for 2.5m.

Obviously backup for Gulacsi long term.

Question for everyone: Who will be the Biggest Transfer in cash terms this coming August to .... when does it End? 

NOT counting transfers already known and from ? to ? has to be right to to win.

Sancho to United for 100 mil +/-

1 hour ago, BrodiePT said:

Who would you choose from these?

Kounde (Sevilha) or Hermoso (Atl. Madrid) or Ake (Bournemouth) ?

Martial (Man. United) or Richarlison (Everton) or Correa (Lazio) or Morata (Atl. Madrid) ?

Ake worth the risk as he should move, Bournemouth going down

Martial 

36 minutes ago, TMCosta said:

Dominik Greif, Gaetan Coucke, Nordin Jackers, Ivo Grbic, Dusan Markovic, Fabian Ehmann

Is this the correct order?

Trust Thorgan on this

[Kierans91 2,090]

55 minutes ago, TMCosta said:

Dominik Greif, Gaetan Coucke, Nordin Jackers, Ivo Grbic, Dusan Markovic, Fabian Ehmann

Is this the correct order?

Similar to Thorgan but I would go:

Greif - Coucke - Grbic - Jackers - Markovic - Ehmann

Side note.....Unfortunately for Ehmann he lost his place in the team after lockdown for Aris, I had him down as rising to 80 by the end of the season but that looks unlikely now. 

[Soccahappy 6,325]

2 hours ago, Kierans91 said:

Unlikely to happen but I’ve seen some rumours this morning.

Oblak - Atleti to Chelsea - 110 million 😳😳😳

^ this will probably be unlikely but apart from this I would say....

Kai Havertz - Leverkusen to Chelsea - 70 million.

Transfermarkt  have Josep martinez transferred for 2.5m to Leipzig, done??

1 hour ago, BrodiePT said:

Who would you choose from these?

Kounde (Sevilha) or Hermoso (Atl. Madrid) or Ake (Bournemouth) ?

Martial (Man. United) or Richarlison (Everton) or Correa (Lazio) or Morata (Atl. Madrid) ?

Hermoso (tho if Ake goes alongside Maguire he will rise as I think he could thrive at a BIG Club)..

and Martial who is now showing much better form in an improving ManU

[Soccahappy 6,325]

Update for Spain Review below:-

Previous tables on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784.785,786,787, 788, 789, 790, 791,792,793, 794,795,796,797,798,799,800,801,803,804,805.806,807,808,810,811,812,813,814.816,817,818,819,821,822,823,824,825,8826,827,828,829,830,831.832,833,834,835.836,837,839,841,842,844,845,855,856,857.860,864,866, 867.868,871,872,873,875,876,877,878,880,914,955,988. 1003,1008,1016, 1023.1026,1030, 1032, 1042. 1045  Be careful of the Reddish boxes where the higher rated players are more inclined towards performances rather than stats.

Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be.

I am concentrating mainly on Younger under 89 rated players as these are more consistent risers and more profitable, Goal keepers are dealt with by SM in a completely different way, which is why I mostly also ignore Gk's 

A lot more RED BOXES which I get nervous about as only about less than 40% pay-Off as they are stat based predictions and SM do these higher rated players on what successes they've had and top performances.

Thanks for your Interest and Support for my Spreadsheet predictions, much appreciated Cheers Socca 😀

 

[Toby S 73]

Swap Nkunku (obviously been upgraded today) for Valverde??

Guess my question is who do you think is better and has higher potential

[Kierans91 2,090]

Grady Diangana (22) Illan Meslier (20) and Said Benrhama (24) three players who I think will have big seasons in the premier league in 2020/21.

I mentioned on the previous page that Meslier is signing permanently for Leeds United which is a massive bonus for the club.

He’s currently rated at 80 on SM which would rise substantially next season if he is a starter which I would imagine he will be.

I actually heard a quote the other day saying that ‘it’s like having Glenn Hoddle in goal with how good he is on the ball’ his distribution is brilliant.

 

Grady Diangana alongside Pereira is a big reason West Brom are just one game away from being promoted back to the big time.

Grady along with Benrahma I’ve mentioned in the hope that they do move/stay in the premier league I know there are rumours of Diangana moving to Ajax or Celtic but staying at West Ham would still be a good option for the player.

Grady’s rating on SM is 82 and I can see that rising to 84 if West Brom get promoted, I have no doubt that he will be playing in a top division next season somewhere in Europe.

 

Finally there is no surprise and it’s been well documented on this forum that Benrahma is too good for the Championship and that’s why I see him playing in the EPL next season, plus the speculation helps haha.

He’s a player with immense dribbling talent and has contributed so many goals this season along side top goal scorer in the Championship Ollie Watkins who is another ready for the big leagues.

Benrahma is rated at 84 and could probably rise to 85 if Brentford get promoted but he should go beyond that next season with a move away from Brentford.

 

I know a lot of you know these players on the forum, I think these talents have a big season ahead in 2020/21.

[Kierans91 2,090]

2 minutes ago, Toby S said:

Swap Nkunku (obviously been upgraded today) for Valverde??

Guess my question is who do you think is better and has higher potential

Valverde!!

Potential 91 but I think 90 is right for now 🙂

[Soccahappy 6,325]

11 minutes ago, Toby S said:

Swap Nkunku (obviously been upgraded today) for Valverde??

Guess my question is who do you think is better and has higher potential

88 presently for a just 90 rated? BUT YES  Valverde more future potential tmm

[topofthebilly 48]

Fikayo TOMORI , this guy is a proper talent I'm sure but he has not really played enough after last review to justify a proper rise  ? He only played 2 matches after the last review and was benched in all other games . Also Chelsea seems to be mainly using Kurt Zouma in the back lately .

I don't think it is a proper buy right now . What do you guys think of him ?

 

[Soccahappy 6,325]

How stingy can u be? How is it that I get this everyday? SM should definitely increase the amount the give out so we can all spread more happiness around?

SM are testing me. Can it be they want me to become SoccaUnhappy? ........... Nah not Possible!

Socca IS Appy!

Here come old flat-top, he come grooving up slowly
He got ju-ju eyeballs, he's one holy roller
He got hair down to his knees
Got to be a joker, he just do what he please

ahhh feel better now....It's getting better... getting so much better all the time....😀

[Kierans91 2,090]

31 minutes ago, topofthebilly said:

Fikayo TOMORI , this guy is a proper talent I'm sure but he has not really played enough after last review to justify a proper rise  ? He only played 2 matches after the last review and was benched in all other games . Also Chelsea seems to be mainly using Kurt Zouma in the back lately .

I don't think it is a proper buy right now . What do you guys think of him ?

 

Better options currently and I think he’s a bit expensive for what he is, 10 million for an 87 rated player who may not rise for another 6 months.

Pau Torres is a better option for almost half the price.

Just now, Soccahappy said:

How stingy can u be? How is it that I get this everyday? SM should definitely increase the amount the give out so we can all spread more happiness around?

SM are testing me. Can it be they want me to become SoccaUnhappy? ........... Nah not Possible!

Socca IS Appy!

Here come old flat-top, he come grooving up slowly
He got ju-ju eyeballs, he's one holy roller
He got hair down to his knees
Got to be a joker, he just do what he please

ahhh feel better now....It's getting better... getting so much better all the time....

Its because you use your likes on a like for a like basis, because people love your content so much you can’t match the amount of likes you receive 😂 

I don’t think there should be a restriction to be honest or if so make it much higher.

Im sure it’s capped, I’m pretty sure I only hand out 5 or 6 likes per day then I get that image.

[Soccahappy 6,325]

47 minutes ago, topofthebilly said:

Fikayo TOMORI , this guy is a proper talent I'm sure but he has not really played enough after last review to justify a proper rise  ? He only played 2 matches after the last review and was benched in all other games . Also Chelsea seems to be mainly using Kurt Zouma in the back lately .

I don't think it is a proper buy right now . What do you guys think of him ?

 

I definitely think he's being under-used but will prove himself given more opportunity. Zouma tries hard but I reckon the future is Tomori.

18:34PM: This post hidden why??? Are they trying to ... No I won't say it...

[Barrow173 1]

Wirtz
Fabio Silva
Stevanovic
Reyna
Beyaz
Eric Garcia

 

I have many high rated players and it's causing João felix to get concerns so think I'm going to sell him, which are the best 2 from this list

[Soccahappy 6,325]

9 minutes ago, Kierans91 said:

Better options currently and I think he’s a bit expensive for what he is, 10 million for an 87 rated player who may not rise for another 6 months.

Pau Torres is a better option for almost half the price.

Its because you use your likes on a like for a like basis, because people love your content so much you can’t match the amount of likes you receive 😂 

I don’t think there should be a restriction to be honest or if so make it much higher.

Im sure it’s capped, I’m pretty sure I only hand out 5 or 6 likes per day then I get that image.

Hear what you say Kieran and you are right.  I'm sure It would be better spreading more around. I remember in the "Good Old Days 10years ago" we used to see posts with over 50 reactions. Am I remembering or dreaming? Those times were great and have to say with u and SIR and a number of relatively new forumers it glides along quite well just lately.... Pleased to say.

[Id rather be in SW19 186]

3 minutes ago, Soccahappy said:

Hear what you say Kieran and you are right.  I'm sure It would be better spreading more around. I remember in the "Good Old Days 10years ago" we used to see posts with over 50 reactions. Am I remembering or dreaming? Those times were great and have to say with u and SIR and a number of relatively new forumers it glides along quite well just lately.... Pleased to say.

I have just given 9 "thanks" before I ran out. Will see how many I can give tomorrow!

[Soccahappy 6,325]

5 minutes ago, Barrow173 said:

Wirtz
Fabio Silva
Stevanovic
Reyna
Beyaz
Eric Garcia

 

I have many high rated players and it's causing João felix to get concerns so think I'm going to sell him, which are the best 2 from this list

Eric Garcia is getting selected by Guardiola consistently recently. Looks as if he's wanted for this position next season rather than buying another Mangala etc Guardiola has bought a number of failing defenders CB's and l & Rb's at high prices. He's still a genius of course so I shouldn't complain.

[Kierans91 2,090]

2 minutes ago, Barrow173 said:

Wirtz
Fabio Silva
Stevanovic
Reyna
Beyaz
Eric Garcia

 

I have many high rated players and it's causing João felix to get concerns so think I'm going to sell him, which are the best 2 from this list

Potential wise I would say Wirtz + Reyna.

Both play for big clubs in Europe which will help there rating rise much quicker than the others.

Obviously Garcia plays for City but as of next season I think his game time could be limited with the talk of new defenders coming in.

3 minutes ago, Soccahappy said:

Hear what you say Kieran and you are right.  I'm sure It would be better spreading more around. I remember in the "Good Old Days 10years ago" we used to see posts with over 50 reactions. Am I remembering or dreaming? Those times were great and have to say with u and SIR and a number of relatively new forumers it glides along quite well just lately.... Pleased to say.

10 years ago there used to be more experts for each country it was fairly unique, it’s easier to trust someone who has inside knowledge of a particular country/league which is same with young talents in each country

I remember the Insider who was an expert on the Brazilian league, wonder where he is now.

Also if you have a question on the forum it can take a fairly long time for an answer but back then you could get an answer pretty much immediately.

Good to see you more active today though Socca 🙂

2 minutes ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

I have just given 9 "thanks" before I ran out. Will see how many I can give tomorrow!

This is good to know, much more than I thought actually 🙂

[Sir Rahul 5,543]

9 minutes ago, Barrow173 said:

Wirtz
Fabio Silva
Stevanovic
Reyna
Beyaz
Eric Garcia

 

I have many high rated players and it's causing João felix to get concerns so think I'm going to sell him, which are the best 2 from this list

Wirtz and Reyna I feel

53 minutes ago, topofthebilly said:

Fikayo TOMORI , this guy is a proper talent I'm sure but he has not really played enough after last review to justify a proper rise  ? He only played 2 matches after the last review and was benched in all other games . Also Chelsea seems to be mainly using Kurt Zouma in the back lately .

I don't think it is a proper buy right now . What do you guys think of him ?

Let's see what Lampard goes with at the start of next season. Chelsea have four CBs with strengths and flaws so finding the right combo is his challenge.

1 hour ago, Toby S said:

Swap Nkunku (obviously been upgraded today) for Valverde??

Guess my question is who do you think is better and has higher potential

I would, Valverde >

1 hour ago, Kierans91 said:

Grady Diangana (22) Illan Meslier (20) and Said Benrhama (24) three players who I think will have big seasons in the premier league in 2020/21.

I mentioned on the previous page that Meslier is signing permanently for Leeds United which is a massive bonus for the club.

He’s currently rated at 80 on SM which would rise substantially next season if he is a starter which I would imagine he will be.

I actually heard a quote the other day saying that ‘it’s like having Glenn Hoddle in goal with how good he is on the ball’ his distribution is brilliant.

 

Grady Diangana alongside Pereira is a big reason West Brom are just one game away from being promoted back to the big time.

Grady along with Benrahma I’ve mentioned in the hope that they do move/stay in the premier league I know there are rumours of Diangana moving to Ajax or Celtic but staying at West Ham would still be a good option for the player.

Grady’s rating on SM is 82 and I can see that rising to 84 if West Brom get promoted, I have no doubt that he will be playing in a top division next season somewhere in Europe.

 

Finally there is no surprise and it’s been well documented on this forum that Benrahma is too good for the Championship and that’s why I see him playing in the EPL next season, plus the speculation helps haha.

He’s a player with immense dribbling talent and has contributed so many goals this season along side top goal scorer in the Championship Ollie Watkins who is another ready for the big leagues.

Benrahma is rated at 84 and could probably rise to 85 if Brentford get promoted but he should go beyond that next season with a move away from Brentford.

 

I know a lot of you know these players on the forum, I think these talents have a big season ahead in 2020/21.

good stuff mate! I'd be surprised if Meslier stays starter though. Surely they find someone more experienced.

9 minutes ago, Soccahappy said:

Hear what you say Kieran and you are right.  I'm sure It would be better spreading more around. I remember in the "Good Old Days 10years ago" we used to see posts with over 50 reactions. Am I remembering or dreaming? Those times were great and have to say with u and SIR and a number of relatively new forumers it glides along quite well just lately.... Pleased to say.

thanks mate! the limited reactions is quite annoying 

[Soccahappy 6,325]

6 minutes ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

I have just given 9 "thanks" before I ran out. Will see how many I can give tomorrow!

Yes I've counted myself and had 8 one day and 10 the next. 

[Soccahappy 6,325]

5 minutes ago, Soccahappy said:

Eric Garcia is getting selected by Guardiola consistently recently. Looks as if he's wanted for this position next season rather than buying another Mangala etc Guardiola has bought a number of failing defenders CB's and l & Rb's at high prices. He's still a genius of course so I shouldn't complain.

 

16 minutes ago, Barrow173 said:

Wirtz
Fabio Silva
Stevanovic
Reyna
Beyaz
Eric Garcia

 

I have many high rated players and it's causing João felix to get concerns so think I'm going to sell him, which are the best 2 from this list

Ooops forgot u asked for two. Yes as Kieran says Wirtz and Reyna have really good futures, maybe Reyna as well as Garcia I really do have a feeling about Garcia but that might be because a close friend and opponent got there first.

[Kierans91 2,090]

49 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said:

good stuff mate! I'd be surprised if Meslier stays starter though. Surely they find someone more experienced.

Thanks mate, that’s a fair point hopefully they don’t though because I think he’s got the ability, it’s that good old saying ‘if you’re good enough you’re old enough’ haha

Think they need rid of Casilla as well.

[Soccahappy 6,325]

8 minutes ago, Kierans91 said:

10 years ago there used to be more experts for each country it was fairly unique, it’s easier to trust someone who has inside knowledge of a particular country/league which is same with young talents in each country

I remember the Insider who was an expert on the Brazilian league, wonder where he is now.

Also if you have a question on the forum it can take a fairly long time for an answer but back then you could get an answer pretty much immediately.

 

WOW Insider! he was unbelievable on any player in Brazil, Fell out with SM and had his own Website on Brazilian football, had website address at one time but don't think I have anymore, unfortunately I would love to have a look there again. If you look for it u might find it. Have to leave the computer soon myself.

[Soccahappy 6,325]

23 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said:

Wirtz and Reyna I feel

Let's see what Lampard goes with at the start of next season. Chelsea have four CBs with strengths and flaws so finding the right combo is his challenge.

I would, Valverde >

good stuff mate! I'd be surprised if Meslier stays starter though. Surely they find someone more experienced.

thanks mate! the limited reactions is quite annoying 

Words of Wisdom as usual SIR.

Re Meslier it is sensible to give him time by buying someone experianced BUT, BIG BUT Bielsa "is a law unto himself" he seems to stick by his players and put his faith in them. Meslier didn't make mistakes like Casila did and coped with the real pressure of these last weeks and came thru with flying colours. I wouldn't be surprised but maybe it's 50/50.

Btw Sir I had a post hidden not so long back on Tomori. Tiny post so perhaps BIG and TOO SMALL look like adverts ha! 😀

 

[Soccahappy 6,325]

36 minutes ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

I have just given 9 "thanks" before I ran out. Will see how many I can give tomorrow!

We should all keep count and then we'd know as SM just don't like to give much information out do they ("All community Driven" u know) Ha Ha! 🤫

[Aaaa 9]

Sergi roberto stay or drop and would you swap sergi roberto for valverde