Jump to content

Rahul W's rating predictions


Recommended Posts

Hello, my friends! I was off for some business yesterday, so I couldn't check the forum too often, and wasn't able to thank some of you who mentioned me in your posts. I am flattered, consider you thanked! :D

Also, since I got a new PC, I am having trouble logging into my account - it says that I enter the wrong password. Even though I had a couple of beers at night, I'm pretty sure I entered the correct one. The only way I am able to access my account now, is by resetting the password every time I want to log in. Is there any webmaster or admin who could help me with this issue?

Other than that, I will publish a recap of my Bundesliga predictions in my next post, and start right away with Spain. SM wastes no time! Cheers!

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 31.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Sir Rahul

    3349

  • Kieran_S91

    2083

  • Milanista1

    1200

  • Soccahappy

    1174

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Hi all, As you have seen, I have not really been active over the past few months other than updating my preds. It's just been me phasing out of the forum. Now that the reviews are done, I can say

Just noticed this thread has crossed 1 million views, 23k odd replies, 930 pages.  I know this is 3 and a half years old but I never intended for this to monopolise the forum back then (I would h

Page 200- didn't think we'd get here when I started this casually- thanks all

Posted Images

1 hour ago, Limo said:
Hi fellas,
 
I probably have to get rid of one of these... maybe two... who d'you think?
 
Saul
Havertz
Sancho
Auoar
Felix
Halaand
Zaniolo

Very hard but probably Zanilolo even though he was immense on his return from injury..

Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry for the bit of shameless self-promotion guys but I have recently started a page on Instagram where I write scout reports and provide updates on U-23 Footballers from around the world, would really appreciate it if you could check it out and give it a follow (@football_talents_worldwide) 

https://www.instagram.com/football_talents_worldwide

Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Vib said:

Sorry for the bit of shameless self-promotion guys but I have recently started a page on Instagram where I write scout reports and provide updates on U-23 Footballers from around the world, would really appreciate it if you could check it out and give it a follow (@football_talents_worldwide) 

https://www.instagram.com/football_talents_worldwide

Sorry I meant to like your post but fat fingered and clicked on sad.

I will change it when I get a reaction back.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is a recap of my Bundesliga predictions. I am proud to have been able to guess the exact value for some not so easy risers (and also stayers, hence not included in the list), but clearly I still need to improve my calculation model. Any feedback is very welcome! Cheers :)

Heidenheim: (not reviewed)

David Otto    76 to 80   +4   (loaned from Hoffenheim)   +2 to 78
Dorsch    77 to 83   +6
Mohr    75 to 77   +2
 

Stuttgart:

Kobel    83 to 85   +2   (loaned from Hoffenheim)   yes
Nathaniel Phillips    76 to 82   +6   (loaned from Liverpool)   no
Karazor    80 to 83   +3   +2 to 82
Wamangituka    80 to 83   +3   +2 to 82
Clinton Mola    73 to 78   +5   +3 to 76
Roberto Massimo    76 to 78   +2   no
Orel Mangala    83 to 84   +1
   +2 to 85

Arminia Bielefeld:

Hartel    82 to 85   +3   +2 to 84
Pieper    82 to 85   +3   +1 to 83
Seufert    78 to 80   +2   no
Kunze    73 to 77   +4   +3 to 76
Lucoqui    73 to 75   +2
   +3 to 76

Paderborn:

Vasiliadis    83 to 84   +1   no
Kilian    78 to 80   +2
   yes 

Fortuna Dusseldorf:

Kastenmeier    73 to 83   +10 (or +9 to 82)   +7 to 80
Kelvin Ofori    70 to 73   +3   yes

Werder Bremen:

Friedl    83 to 85   +2   no
Sargent    83 to 84   +1
   no

Augsburg:

Ruben Vargas    85 to 87   +2   +1 to 86
Framberger    80 to 83   +3   +2 to 82
Niederlechner    86 to 88   +2   +1 to 87
Richter    86 to 87   +1   no
Uduokhai    85 to 86   +1   yes

Koln:

Hector    90 to 89   -1   no
Bornauw    83 to 86   +3   +2 to 85
Ismail Jakobs    73 to 82   +9   +10 to 83
Katterbach    76 to 80   +4   +6 to 82
Thielmann    73 to 77   +4   +3 to 76
Ehizibue    83 to 86   +3   +2 to 85
Czichos    83 to 85   +2   yes

Mainz:

Niakhate    87 to 88   +1   no
Quaison    87 to 88   +1   no
Baku    83 to 86   +3   +2 to 85
Leandro Barreiro    76 to 80   +4   +6 to 82
Burkardt    76 to 77   +1   no
Zentner    83 to 85   +2   yes
Szalai    87 to 86   -1   yes
Stefan Bell    87 to 85   -2   -1 to 86

Schalke 04:

Oczipka    88 to 89   +1   no
Juan Miranda    78 to 82   +4   (on loan from Barcelona)   no
Jonjoe Kenny    85 to 88   +3   (on loan from Everton)   no
Caligiuri    90 to 89   -1   yes
Gregoritsch    89 to 88   -1   yes
Nastasic    90 to 89   -1   yes
Sané    89 to 88   -1   no
Burgstaller    88 to 87   -1   yes
Schubert    82 to 83   +1   no
Matondo    80 to 83   +3   yes
Stambouli    88 to 87   -1   no
Kabak    85 to 86   +1   +2 to 87
Kutucu    80 to 82   +2   yes
Boujellab    76 to 80   +4   +2 to 78
Timo Becker    73 to 78   +5   +3 to 76
Bozdogan    73 to 76   +3   no
Malick Thiaw    70 to 73   +3   yes

Union Berlin:

Gikiewicz    83 to 86   +3   (reviewed for Augsburg)   +2 to 85
Trimmel    82 to 86   +4   +3 to 85
Friedrich    85 to 86   +1   no
Andersson    85 to 86   +1   +2 to 87
Andrich    82 to 85   +3   yes
Lenz    82 to 84   +2   yes
Bulter    82 to 85   +3   (moved to Magdeburg)   yes
Keven Schlotterbeck    82 to 83   +1   (moved to Freiburg)   +2 to 84
Ryerson    77 to 78   +1   yes

Hertha Berlin: 

Plattenhardt    88 to 87   -1   yes
Grujic    87 to 88   +1   no
Lukebakio    86 to 87   +1   yes
Klunter    83 to 86   +3   no
Torunarigha    83 to 85   +2   yes
Boyata    86 to 87   +1   yes

Eintracht:

Dost    89 to 88   -1   no
Hinteregger    88 to 89   +1   yes
Hasebe    87 to 88   +1   no
Kamada    86 to 88   +2   +1 to 87
N'Dicka    86 to 87   +1   yes
Djibril Sow    86 to 87   +1   no
Paciência    86 to 87   +1   no

Freiburg:

Gunter    87 to 88   +1   no
Schmid    86 to 87   +1   no
Hofler    86 to 87   +1   no
Holer    85 to 87   +2   +1 to 86
Lienhart    85 to 86   +1   no
Keitel    75 new player   76 new player

Wolfsburg:

Weghorst    89 to 90   +1   no
Pongracic    83 to 85   +2   yes
Pervan    82 to 83   +1   no
Gerhardt    88 to 87   -1
   yes

Hoffenheim:

Baumann    88 to 89   +1   no
Bebou    87 to 88   +1   no
Skov    87 to 89   +2   +1 to 88
Posch    86 to 88   +2   +1 to 87
Baumgartner    78 to 85   +7   yes
Geiger    85 to 86   +1   no
Maximilian Beier    67 to 73   +6
   +8 to 75

Bayer Leverkusen:

Hradecky    89 to 90   +1   no
Tapsoba    82 to 86   +4   +5 to 76
Diaby    86 to 87   +1   +2 to 88
Sinkgraven    85 to 86   +1   no
Wirtz    70 to 78   +8
   +7 to 77

Borussia Monchengladbach:

Stindl    89 to 88   -1   no
Thuram    88 to 89   +1   yes
Lainer    88 to 89   +1   yes
Neuhaus    88 to 89   +1   yes
Benes    85 to 86   +1
   no

Leipzig:

Forsberg    91 to 90   -1   yes
Kampl    91 to 90   -1   yes
Nkunku    88 to 89   +1   +2 to 90
Laimer    88 to 89   +1   +2 to 90
Mukiele    88 to 89   +1   yes
Angeliño    87 to 88   +1   no
Tyler Adams    85 to 86   +1   no

Borussia Dortmund:

Sancho    91 to 92   +1   yes
Hakimi    90 to 91   +1   no
Reus    93 to 92   -1   no
Hazard    90 to 91   +1   no
Akanji    90 to 91   +1   no
Guerreiro    90 to 91   +1   yes
Schulz    90 to 89   -1   yes
Haaland    88 to 90   +2   yes
Zagadou    86 to 87   +1   yes
Reyna    76 to 80   +4   yes
Morey    73 to 78   +5   +3 to 76

Bayern Munchen:

Lewandowski    96 to 97   +1   no
Coutinho    94 to 93   -1   yes
Gnabry    92 to 93   +1   no
Pavard    90 to 91   +1   yes
Davies    88 to 90   +2   yes
Zirkzee    75 to 80   +5   +7 to 82

Link to post
Share on other sites

Here I am again! I like La Liga much more than Bundesliga (and I am talking about smaller teams, I am not a fan of big sharks anyway), so it will definitely be more interesting for me to try and predict this league.

At SM they decided they are going to be fast now, and review half of the world in the same time it took them to do Argentina only. So, some of the players in my list were already reviewed in the last couple of days, my bad.

But I won't be fooled again by them, so here are a couple of promoted teams - waiting for the playoffs to know the third one - the relegated ones, and those up to the 15th place. Hope to be safe for a couple of days, at least.

As usual, enjoy responsibly! :D 

Cadiz:

Carcelen    80 to 83   +3   yes
Sergio Gonzalez    76 to 80   +4   +2 to 78
Javi Duarte    73   new player

Huesca:

Alvaro Fernandez    80 to 83   +3
Miguelon    82 to 83   +1   (loaned from Villareal)
Sergio Gomez    78 to 80   +2   (loaned from Dortmund)   yes
Kike Hermoso    70 to 75   +5

Espanyol:

David Lopez    88 to 87   -1
Victor Sanchez    87 to 86   -1
Naldo    87 to 86   -1
Victor Gomez    80 to 82   +2
Campuzano    80 to 82   +2
Pipa    78 to 80   +2

Mallorca:

Iddrisu Baba    82 to 84   +2

Leganés:

Awaziem    83 to 84   +1
Ruibal    82 to 83   +1   (loaned from Real Betis)
Javier Avilés    76   new player
Manu Garrido    73   new player
Mourid    73   new player

Celta Vigo:

Ruben Blanco    86 to 87   +1
Iago Aspas    91 to 90   -1
Olaza    85 to 87   +2
Aidoo    86 to 87   +1
Fontán    75   new player
Sergio Bermejo    73   new player

Deportivo Alavés:

Burke    83 to 84   +1
Borja Sainz    76 to 80   +4
Abdallahi Mahmoud    73   new player
Paulino de la Fuente    70   new player

Real Betis:

Fekir    91 to 90   -1
William Carvalho    90 to 89   -1
Iglesias    89 to 88   -1
Robles    86 to 87   +1
Emerson    86 to 87   +1   (loaned from Barcelona)
Edgar Gonzalez    78 to 82   +4 
Dani Martin    78 to 80   +2

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Cvilhete said:

peoples thoughts on SMS from lazio getting a +1?

Stay, Lazio’s poor form and drop in the table will probably end a potential rise.

13 minutes ago, Arun said:

How many days before the Chairman accepts my offer for a player with level 5 Concerns who has requested a transfer?

Too long, I think it’s 4 to 5 days or something like that which I hate because it always gives a chance for other managers to bid haha.

6 minutes ago, gAv Gav said:

Messi or Lewa + Kimmich

If the duo will play first team then I would go for Lewa and Kimmich because it will strengthen your team as a whole.

Link to post
Share on other sites
40 minutes ago, Arun said:

How many days before the Chairman accepts my offer for a player with level 5 Concerns who has requested a transfer?

Jota or Pasalic? Who should I buy?

Takes 4-5 days

Pasalic

32 minutes ago, gAv Gav said:

Messi or Lewa + Kimmich

Duo would improve your team better

Link to post
Share on other sites

Birmingham retiring Bellingham's #22 after one season (44 games) might be one of the worst club decisions ever 😂

--

Fun fact from Twitter:

There are still seven outfield players who are on course to play all 3420 minutes of the Premier League season: George Baldock, Conor Coady, Harry Maguire, Declan Rice, James Tarkowski, Virgil van Dijk & James Ward-Prowse. Would be the most since at least 2005-06.
Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, ForzaVictory said:

Illan Meslier as many have said has a chance of being number 1 next year, in any case a must buy in any competitive gameworld.

Mateusz Klich will be at least 86 maybe 87 by the end of next year. Luke Ayling also pretty much guaranteed 86 bar injury - also a gem for your fantasy football teams next year ;)

In my opinion the best buy in the championship would be Antonee Robinson. Hopefully moves on to a side he gets game time next year. Feel he has potential to be a starting LB at a big club from what I've seen.

Keep an eye on where Eze ends up been consistently good this year. Both could end up at West Ham.

Spence at Middlesbrough seems to be getting linked with moves to Premier League teams so could be one to watch too.

Link to post
Share on other sites
24 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said:

Not going to sit here and lie to you saying he’s world class because I don’t know, first I’ve heard of him personally.

Quick search of soccerway shows he’s spent time playing with Altay SK’s senior team.

63 rated so he’s not much of a gamble haha.

24 minutes ago, Nameless said:

There's no way a young player signing for Juventus should even get a mention. 

I actually find this exciting, the amount of English players going abroad at the moment to experience a different culture fills me with hope of our national team eventually winning something.

I think that too many English players are comfortable sitting in the reserves of a premier league team on thousands of pounds a week.

This shows to me that this young lad is willing to go to different countries to try and make it.

I hope that other Englishman on the forum feel the same way and thought I would share my findings, don’t see what the harm is.

He’s actually classed as one of the best players at Chelsea in his year group as well.

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Kierans91 said:

Not going to sit here and lie to you saying he’s world class because I don’t know, first I’ve heard of him personally.

Quick search of soccerway shows he’s spent time playing with Altay SK’s senior team.

63 rated so he’s not much of a gamble haha.

I actually find this exciting, the amount of English players going abroad at the moment to experience a different culture fills me with hope of our national team eventually winning something.

I think that too many English players are comfortable sitting in the reserves of a premier league team and thousands of pounds a week.

This shows to me that this young lad is willing to go to different countries to try and make it.

I hope that other Englishman on the forum feel the same way and thought I would share my findings, don’t see what the harm is.

He’s actually classed as one of the best players at Chelsea in his year group as well.

I said it in tongue in cheek way. Absolutely no harm. 

I agree with most things you said but name me one juve player that made it in last decade. Moise Kean and they let him go. 

Don't literally take the decade part. I actually don't know how long it has been and who was the last juve youth player to make it before Kean. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, HAWKERS said:

Should I swap my Allan Saint Maxim for Leander Dendoncker ? Nope

Any other 89s that might rise to 90 that I could swap him for as well ? 

As Kierans91 mentioned before:

L. Ocompos and S. Bergwijn. 

Thanks

 

17 hours ago, Damien1990 said:

Yep. In a gameworld I'm in, someone offered me him for Sergi Roberto a few months ago. Snapped his hand off. Now have Mbappe, Sterling, Sancho and Pulisic in the one squad.

Really? He must have been drunk. 😀

S. Roberto is a squad player at best, he's never really impressed me at Barça. 

 

14 hours ago, Divir said:

Would anybody prefer him over Felix?

C. Pulisic > Felix

His recent performances will no doubt get him up to Felix's rating and (soon enough) probably beyond that - if he continues like this into next season. 

9 hours ago, JBS said:

Rafael Leao or Calvert-Lewin? 

R. Leao has great potential, he just needs more time and opportunities to impress. Should reach up to DCL in no time if Milan can continue going up. 

To me DCL will remain at (mid-table) Everton for a some time: he signed an extension a few months back. 

5 hours ago, ToddR said:

Ante Rebic for ASM??

He's been Newcastle's main man this season, and with a move to a bigger club he'll probably get ahead of A. Rebic soon enough.

A. Rebic, no doubt has been impressive of late, but I'm still not convinced with him - he can be unpredictable at times. 

1 hour ago, Arun said:

How many days before the Chairman accepts my offer for a player with level 5 Concerns who has requested a transfer?

Jota or Pasalic? Who should I buy?

I reckon it's 4 days. 

Pasalic because Atalanta are in the CL, and are the better performing club in their league. 

1 hour ago, gAv Gav said:

Messi or Lewa + Kimmich

In my opinion the duo is the better side of the deal for the GOAT (aging) Messi. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Nameless said:

I said it in tongue in cheek way. Absolutely no harm. 

I agree with most things you said but name me one juve player that made it in last decade. Moise Kean and they let him go. 

Don't literally take the decade part. I actually don't know how long it has been and who was the last juve youth player to make it before Kean. 

Not really tongue in cheek, when you are basically saying my post is completely pointless.

Daniele Rugani, Ciro Immobile (goal machine) Claudio Marchisio - more high profile Juventus graduates.

Obviously some of these players got transferred in too Juventus’ youth team like Iling has, also less well known ones are: Pol Lirola (Fiorentina) Rogerio (Sassuolo) Falque (Genoa) Spinazzola (Roma) Aduero (Sampdoria) - all of these are currently playing and that’s just to name a few.

Not every academy player is going to make it big time, When I mention a player who I think has ability to become a decent player I haven’t got a crystal ball which tells me there going to be a ballon d’Or winner.

But this is not the reason I posted about Iling it was for the simple fact of him going abroad to try a different culture of football.

Bayern are a team who are looked upon as giving young players a chance which they do but there is only Alaba and Muller who have came through there academy system, who play regularly unless I’ve missed someone then I will eat my words.

In future don’t say anything because what was the point? What did you gain?

Link to post
Share on other sites

More updates for upcoming Big5 Spain Review below:-

Previous tables on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784.785,786,787, 788, 789, 790, 791,792,793, 794,795,796,797,798,799,800,801,803,804,805.806,807,808,810,811,812,813,814.816,817,818,819,821,822,823,824,825,8826,827,828,829,830,831.832,833,834,835.836,837,839,841,842,844,845,855,856,857.860,864,866, 867.868,871,872,873,875,876,877,878,880,914,955,988. 1003,1008,1016, 1023.1026,1030, 1032,1042, 1045, 1047, 1055  Be careful of the Reddish boxes where the higher rated players are more inclined towards performances rather than stats.

Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions should be.

I am concentrating mainly on Younger under 89 rated players as these are more consistent risers and more profitable, Goal keepers are dealt with by SM in a completely different way, which is why I mostly also ignore Gk's 

Predi-Vill-RMadr-Sevi1.png

Chukwueze above seems always to be treated well by SM when reviewed in contrast to his Stats(Somebody at SM likes him) so at -13% he might well still get another +1 so if u have him don't sell til after review. A usual warning a lot of RED BOXES above. El-Nesyri hasn't completed 90mins since first of March but still may get a +1.

Thanks for the interest and support, very much appreciated, Cheers Socca 😀

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Kierans91 said:

Samuel Iling Jr (16) 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 Arrived in Turin today ahead of a move from Chelsea to Juventus.

 

29A0EB1D-A171-4C53-9565-E41BDEA158C2.jpeg

Interesting move! It's good to see a lot of the English youngsters moving overseas.

Wanted to see how many are in the big European leagues now, there is:

Sancho, Amaechi, Lookman, Bennetts, Oxford, Mola, Musiala, Evans (Germany)

Panzo, Mavididi (France)

Edwards, Suliman (Portugal)

Cox, Madueke, Cox (Netherlands)

Colkett (Sweden)

Good sign for the country. Sancho has really been the trail blazer.

https://sg.soccerway.com/players/players_abroad/england/

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...