Jump to content

Rahul W's rating predictions


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 38.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Sir Rahul

    4149

  • Kieran_S91

    3430

  • Soccahappy

    1623

  • Milanista1

    1358

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Hi all, As you have seen, I have not really been active over the past few months other than updating my preds. It's just been me phasing out of the forum. Now that the reviews are done, I can say

Just noticed this thread has crossed 1 million views, 23k odd replies, 930 pages.  I know this is 3 and a half years old but I never intended for this to monopolise the forum back then (I would h

Page 200- didn't think we'd get here when I started this casually- thanks all

Posted Images

Also because i didn't want to mess the posts, i need another help from you. I'm in a very big competitive world. I reached the full squad and i must sell some players to make space for other with a higher perspective. I will put some ss here with my team, i have like 254 players. If someone can take a look and give me some advice, i will be thankful!

Screenshot_20201024-222211.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222218.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222224.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222230.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222258.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222303.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222309.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222314.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222320.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222337.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222325.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222342.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222347.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Hello guys,

I have Oihan Sancet and an athletic club fan wants him. He is have this list with young players. Do you recomand some players from here or should i keep O.Sancet?

Screenshot_20201024-221002.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-221010.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-221017.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-221025.jpg

Oyen, Koumetio, Zeballos, Tagir, Badji, Evanilson, Aguilar, Ait-Nouri and Fuchs

Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Also because i didn't want to mess the posts, i need another help from you. I'm in a very big competitive world. I reached the full squad and i must sell some players to make space for other with a higher perspective. I will put some ss here with my team, i have like 254 players. If someone can take a look and give me some advice, i will be thankful!

Screenshot_20201024-222211.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222218.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222224.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222230.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222258.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222303.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222309.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222314.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222320.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222337.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222325.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222342.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222347.jpg

Aaa lot of players haha... ermm

Clark, O’Brien, Zhu, Crowley, Dickman, Carter, Ross, Billing, Clarkson, Longstaff, Graham, Letard, Dowell.

Sooo many players their haha. I’m not sure about some of those players but the ones I’ve listed above I would sell.

Maybe sell Linetty too considering you have plenty of depth in midfield.

Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Also because i didn't want to mess the posts, i need another help from you. I'm in a very big competitive world. I reached the full squad and i must sell some players to make space for other with a higher perspective. I will put some ss here with my team, i have like 254 players. If someone can take a look and give me some advice, i will be thankful!

Screenshot_20201024-222211.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222218.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222224.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222230.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222258.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222303.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222309.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222314.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222320.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222337.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222325.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222342.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222347.jpg

That's alot of players lol

First of. You really only need 2 GKs

Pick your 30 man squad

Pick 50-70 youths you want to keep who are well hyped, playing loads , you see them having a future in your starting 11/bench 

You have Regullion as LB. You are sorted for LB. You would ideally only need 3 or 4 LBs now. You have Hickey aswell 

Your squad is young and in their peak years already. Which is good and it will take forever for others to displace them

You have players who will never reach those heights for 5+ years .

Sell what Kieran said 

Sell Ereda aswell

Sell pretty much players who are 23-27 and are only rated 80-84

If they become amazing you will know to go and buy back . But you shouldn't worry if you have already kept 50-70 youths who are already talented

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, Kieran_S91 said:

Aaa lot of players haha... ermm

Clark, O’Brien, Zhu, Crowley, Dickman, Carter, Ross, Billing, Clarkson, Longstaff, Graham, Letard, Dowell.

Sooo many players their haha. I’m not sure about some of those players but the ones I’ve listed above I would sell.

Maybe sell Linetty too considering you have plenty of depth in midfield.

Yeap..a lot, it's a real war of bids when a young player appear and most of them i bid x2 price to be sure i have a chance to take him....and even so it's not guaranteed that i will take him. I'm trying to buy what i can...and after a while to make sell it if he is not too good or doesn't have a bright future. I know that a lot of them will not become regular/exceptional players but if in the final i will be satisfied to have 30-40 good players.

 

22 minutes ago, RieceM96 said:

That's alot of players lol

First of. You really only need 2 GKs

Pick your 30 man squad

Pick 50-70 youths you want to keep who are well hyped, playing loads , you see them having a future in your starting 11/bench 

You have Regullion as LB. You are sorted for LB. You would ideally only need 3 or 4 LBs now. You have Hickey aswell 

Your squad is young and in their peak years already. Which is good and it will take forever for others to displace them

You have players who will never reach those heights for 5+ years .

Sell what Kieran said 

Sell Ereda aswell

Sell pretty much players who are 23-27 and are only rated 80-84

If they become amazing you will know to go and buy back . But you shouldn't worry if you have already kept 50-70 youths who are already talented

 

Thanks man,i know that more of 70-80% of them will not have a great future but i try to have as many as possible good players...and in the end if i have 5-7 good goalkeepers (this was just an example)...i will sell them...or put in others deals with other players.

As for what you said in the last paragraph, if i will sell a good player it will be very difficulty to buy it again.... it's very competitive this game world. This is one of the main reason for following this topic because i want to see the new and talented players on the market and to try to buy it before of them...and even so it's hard. When a young prospect player appear it's an war for him like 10-12 bids for him at higher price. :)

Thanks again guys for your support, i learned a lot from this topic/thread and in turn i will try to help others in needs. ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

I was very grateful for the tactical advice that posters offered with my struggling team.

I know that there was previously a 'bible' of formations and counter formations thread, which I have been struggling to find.

I have found the below, which has been excellent in countering formations on a match by match basis:

 

Again, I know that this is not the forum for these questions (and I apologise), but does anyone know of threads which give good advice on instructions for countering teams? Specifically instructions.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Yeap..a lot, it's a real war of bids when a young player appear and most of them i bid x2 price to be sure i have a chance to take him....and even so it's not guaranteed that i will take him. I'm trying to buy what i can...and after a while to make sell it if he is not too good or doesn't have a bright future. I know that a lot of them will not become regular/exceptional players but if in the final i will be satisfied to have 30-40 good players.

 

Thanks man,i know that more of 70-80% of them will not have a great future but i try to have as many as possible good players...and in the end if i have 5-7 good goalkeepers (this was just an example)...i will sell them...or put in others deals with other players.

As for what you said in the last paragraph, if i will sell a good player it will be very difficulty to buy it again.... it's very competitive this game world. This is one of the main reason for following this topic because i want to see the new and talented players on the market and to try to buy it before of them...and even so it's hard. When a young prospect player appear it's an war for him like 10-12 bids for him at higher price. :)

Thanks again guys for your support, i learned a lot from this topic/thread and in turn i will try to help others in needs. ;)

I’m sure you know this already but Thorgan has a great thread on talents, could spend hours looking at young talents on there.

Good players who get added to the database will generally get mentioned on the forum so I would try to take advantage of that and put in max price bids for these players. Even more so if they are classed as ‘must buys’

I’m sure you do all these things but I just thought I would mention just in case you didn’t 🙂

Link to post
Share on other sites
18 hours ago, Lost soul said:

Hey! I'm looking to buy young wingbacks who could potentially rise to 93....

Here are my available options. Pick one each

Leftback- Lucas Hernandez/Theo Hernandez/ Lodi/ Cucurella/ Chillwell

I hope Milan keep rising/dont falter. Thus Theo will increase his rating in the future. 

Rightback- Gimenez/ Laimer/ AWB/Kounde 

🤔 I was uncertain...

Kounde is primary a CB - he may lose his RB position in the future.

And, I'm not too confident that Ginenez will get another rise any time soon. 

Right now I have Alba/Firpo, and Sergi Roberto/Emerson

So, getting a leftback is priority as I wanna get rid of Sergi Roberto. 

 

On 10/23/2020 at 8:11 PM, Patron said:

Yes, he is definitely worth to buying. I’m from Portugal, and since he arived we all realised that he is a great player with a huge potencial to grow. He wil not say to long in the Portuguese League and will be sold to big club in europe in the summer. 

Thank you. I have shortlisted him for the end of Nov - when his TB will be lifted. I just hope he doesn't make too much noise in the next month, and alert any vultures in my GW. ☺

13 hours ago, Nighch said:

Ousmane Dembelé worth buying in a competitive gameworld? I think he is a very good player but he is not playing regularly it seems

Only in a CGW I would buy him. Because he's still young-ish, and has time to live up to his potential/improve his overall game. 

11 hours ago, Mike0007 said:

Is VDB plus cavani a good deal for Immobile? (Immobile outgoing)

I personally feel it’s not good for me but just need a second opinion.

If not, Is Bruno plus cavani a good deal for Immobile? (Feel it is too much to ask for Immobile who’s aged 30 tbh) Or should I go for Bruno-Immobile swap?

Keep Bruno!

If VDB and Cavani aren't starters for you and C. Immobile will be - then  do the swap. 

11 hours ago, Lost soul said:

Do you reckon Pavard would be a better buy than AWB?

Ahaa: Pavar plays for a better performing team, has started the season better and has a higher chance of a +1 this season.

9 hours ago, Lost soul said:

Pick one to BUY- Bernardo Silva/ Saul Niguez/ Dybala/H Son

Tottenham are at near full strength, and have very good squad depth, so they should be strong contenders for a top 4 finish this season.  

Pick one to SELL- Lautaro/ Ousmane Dembele/ Arthur

If your midfield is stable/decent enough without Arthur's influence then sell - from what I see and read he's not (yet) impressed many fans at Juve, rather the opposite. AlthoughIf you require him in midfield then let go of O. Dembele.  

Young Backup Keeper- Unai Simmons(Athletic club) OR T. Strakosha(SS Lazio) OR M. Maignan( Lille) ?

 

 

 

8 hours ago, Kieran_S91 said:

Youssoufa Moukoko (15) can’t be stopped! 13 goals in 4 games!

724247C3-3776-4910-BAC5-44805DB65B26.thumb.png.fc0f92f5559df76025ca92c0000b6912.png

I hope you sent this to Favre as well.😀

 

6 hours ago, Kieran_S91 said:

I’ve seen some scorelines in football but Ajax v VVV Venlo takes some beating! Wow!

Game hasn’t finished yet 😂

7672173F-A87A-4DF5-8925-1D16942C0E4E.thumb.png.d31bf70a18dbb6aef865a47bde4a1ab0.png
 

EDIT: 13-0 now. Traore with his 5th

😮 VVV. Playing very very very bad! 😀

4 hours ago, RieceM96 said:

Mad result lol.

 

Worth selling Kumbulla in a non competitive set up ? I'm Port Vale in div 4 with another mate and probably 6 other managers in top division. 

Is it worth holding onto or get around 6 million for him ?

 

He's at a club where he can now rise further. He's started his Roma career quite well. I hope he can continue, well that's after Milan do away with Roma first. ☺

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Evanilson (FC Porto), Brazilian, 21 years, scored in his debut in the portuguese league. He has already debuted in the Champions League against Manchester City and today was his first game in the starter team. He was also selected for the brazilian olympic team. Keep your eyes on this young player. Let’s see what he do in the next games.

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Lost soul said:

I'm new to this game and still am learning, could you explain why you would buy dembele ONLY in a CGW?

Because if you were playing in a non-CGW then I'm sure there would be more reliable wingers (real-life performance/injury wise) possibly available to you such a$:

L. Ocampos, F. Chiesa, C. Pulisic, D. Kulusevski, V. Junior, F. Torres ect...

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Lost soul said:

What do you guys think about Lenglet? I feel like SM overrates him, with a 92 rating, while he should probably be only 90/91 at best, or is it just me?

 

I honestly think he’s only 92 rated because of the club he plays for.

1 hour ago, JBS said:

Danilo Pereira +1?  Seems to be a first option with PSG.

I think if he keeps playing he’s got a good chance yes.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello guys,

I'm in a difficult situation. I gave to a friend Thomas Parthey + Matheus Cunha for Haaland. I know it very little what i gave to him but i want to balance the situation. 

I want to give him Timo Werner and to take at least one ore two players from his list (ss with his squad below). What is your opinion? 

 

Thanks! 😌

 

Screenshot_20201025-102528.jpg

Screenshot_20201025-102533.jpg

Screenshot_20201025-102543.jpg

Screenshot_20201025-102548.jpg

Screenshot_20201025-102553.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Hello guys,

I'm in a difficult situation. I gave to a friend Thomas Parthey + Matheus Cunha for Haaland. I know it very little what i gave to him but i want to balance the situation. 

I want to give him Timo Werner and to take at least one ore two players from his list (ss with his squad below). What is your opinion? 

 

Thanks! 😌

 

Screenshot_20201025-102528.jpg

Screenshot_20201025-102533.jpg

Screenshot_20201025-102543.jpg

Screenshot_20201025-102548.jpg

Screenshot_20201025-102553.jpg

Firstly I would keep Werner but I understand he is your friend so I would probably say Chiesa + Lodi or if you think it’s too much maybe Chiesa and Gosens, that way he gets to keep his first choice LB.

Or you could try Chiesa + and a couple of youngsters if he would go for that.

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Also because i didn't want to mess the posts, i need another help from you. I'm in a very big competitive world. I reached the full squad and i must sell some players to make space for other with a higher perspective. I will put some ss here with my team, i have like 254 players. If someone can take a look and give me some advice, i will be thankful!

Screenshot_20201024-222211.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222218.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222224.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222230.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222258.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222303.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222309.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222314.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222320.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222337.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222325.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222342.jpg

Screenshot_20201024-222347.jpg

Living proof why SM has to massively drop the squad cap. 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/24/2020 at 9:49 AM, Soccahappy said:

SWIKI REPORT TODAY: About 9 Pages I think mainly a small continuation of Poland and more England Lower Tiers but with an interesting finish? :-

Poland: 4 previous clubs mentioned all with 2 players edited, this may be the finish??

England Lower Tiers: Stockport  7 players edited   Maidenhead 12 players edited   Aldershot 15 players edited

Bromley 17 players edited  Boreham Wood  16 players edited   Barnet  7 players edited

Now the interesting bit? ... 

Denmark  Brondby  5 players edited and  FC Kobenhavn  11 players edited. 

So is this the start of Denmark Review???  I'm not 100% BUT I think it is The Denmark Review!

SWIKI REPORT TODAY: A small continuation of Poland and  England Lower Tiers but It is the weekend so only 2 and a bit pages to account for you, BUT it surely Does Confirm DENMARK is to be reviewed in a few days thru to SM:-

DENMARK: Aarhus GF  10 players added (also Aarhus GF had 9 players added in October 2019 - so SM's 12month theme continues)😃

Other than this Poland had a remnant: Rakow Cszestochowa had 4 players added and...

England Lower TiersTorquay 5 players added

Liverpool had Kamal Grabara edited

Glad to see Denmark and the 12month theme continuing. Can U believe SM is being consistent for a change! 😲

Cheers Socca 😃  

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...