Jump to content

Rahul W's rating predictions


Recommended Posts

14 minutes ago, Mike0007 said:

Armando Broja or Bryan Reynolds?

Also, how do you guys rate Yari Verschaeren? Potential ceiling?

Tough to say

Not sure mate

6 minutes ago, Jose7 said:

+1 for Neuhaus? 

Doucoure +1 for Everton or very unlikely?  

Yes

Very unlikely

2 minutes ago, bavarac91 said:

Is Bellerin stuck on 90, he is my first choice rb for a long time 😕 thanks

Yes, I don't think he is a 91 level RB

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 36.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Sir Rahul

    3881

  • Kieran_S91

    2962

  • Soccahappy

    1515

  • Milanista1

    1281

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Hi all, As you have seen, I have not really been active over the past few months other than updating my preds. It's just been me phasing out of the forum. Now that the reviews are done, I can say

Just noticed this thread has crossed 1 million views, 23k odd replies, 930 pages.  I know this is 3 and a half years old but I never intended for this to monopolise the forum back then (I would h

Page 200- didn't think we'd get here when I started this casually- thanks all

Posted Images

AUSTRALIA A-LEAGUE

Adelaide United:

Javi Lopez 83 (-3, 2 Dec 2020)

(Tomi Juric 81)

Michael Jakobsen 78 (-4, 29 Nov 2020)

Pacifique Niyongabire 63 (+3, 29 Nov 2020)

 

Brisbane Roar:

Masato Kudo 80

Tom Aldred 78 (+3, 27 Nov 2020)

Jay O'Shea 77

Jamie Young 77

Macaulay Gillesphey 75 (+2, 27 Nov 2020)

Jai Ingham 73

Riku Danzaki 70 (loan)

 

Central Coast Mariners:

Michal Janota 79

Gianni Stensness 73 (+3, 1 Dec 2020)

 

MacArthur FC:

Benat Etxebarria 83 (-3, 20 Nov 2020)

Markel Susaeta 82 (-1, 1 Dec 2020)

(Tommy Oar 82)

Matt Derbyshire 80 (-2, 1 Dec 2020)

Andre Fomitschow 80 (?)

Loic Puyo 78

Antonis Martis 67

 

Melbourne City:

Ryan Shotton 82

(Jamie MacLaren 82) (+2, 27 Nov 2020)

Adrian Luna 82 (-1, 26 Nov 2020)

Richard Windbichler 82

Florin Berenguer 82

Craig Noone 78

 

Melbourne Victory:

(Robbie Kruse 82) (-1, 1 Dec 2020)

Rudy Gestede 80

Marco Rojas 80

Adama Traore 80 (-3, 1 Dec 2020)

Storm Roux 79

Jacob Butterfield 78

Callum McManaman 78

Elvis Kamsoba 75 (+5, 1 Dec 2020)

Max Crocombe 73

 

Newcastle Jets:

Joe Ledley 78

Steven Ugarkovic 78 (on loan from Western Sydney Wanderers)

Roy O'Donovan 78

 

Perth Glory:

Bruno Fornaroli 83

Diego Castro 83

Sebastian Langkamp 82 (-1, 21 Dec 2020)

Darryl Lachman 80 (-2, 29 Nov 2020)

Andy Keogh 80 (-2, 29 Nov 2020)

Dane Ingham 75

 

Sydney FC:

(Luka Brattan 82)

Kosta Barbarouses 82

Milos Ninkovic 82 (-1, 26 Nov 2020)

Alexandre Baumjohan 80

Deyvison Bobo 80 (-1, 27 Jul 2020)

(Adam Le Fondre 80)

 

Wellington Phoenix:

Ulises Davila 80

Tomer Hemed 80

David Ball 77

 

Western Sydney Wanderers:

Nicolai Muller 83 (-3, 1 Dec 2020)

(James Troisi 82) (-1, 29 Nov 2020)

Jordan Mutch 80

Simon Cox 78 (-2, 1 Dec 2020)

Ziggy Gordon 78

Patrick Ziegler 78 (-2, 30 Nov 2020)

Daniel Georgievski 78 (-2, 1 Dec 2020)

Graham Dorrans 76 (-4, 11 Oct 2020)

 

Western United:

Victor Sanchez 83 (-3, 4 Dec 2020)

Besart Berisha 80

Andrew Durante 80

Filip Kurto 80 (+2, 27 Nov 2020)

Alessandro Diamanti 80

Tomoki Imai 78

Ivan Vujica 76

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 11/20/2020 at 9:08 AM, Kieran_S91 said:

SWIKI REPORT (20/11/20)

Very lazy day today for SM only 1 and a half pages but some important players to note.

The Netherlands 🇳🇱 (Eerste Divisie)

4 players edited MVV Maastricht, 2 players edited FC Den Bosch, 5 players edited FC Eindhoven.

Random edits of importance:

Yousouffa Moukoko turned 16 today which means he’s eligible for Dortmund’s first team. He will definitely get a chance this so is this a premature rise for the teenage sensation? Only time will tell.

Marcus Fross was among the edits he may see a small rise because he’s been performing well for club and country.

Moises Caeciedo another player who has been performing well for club and country and could see a rise.

Joe Bursik a player who Stoke see as a future replacement for Jack Butland, he’s currently on loan at Doncaster Rovers and gets regular call ups for England u21s. He also could see a small rise.

My guess....

Youssoufa Moukoko - 67 -> 70

Marcus Forss - 77 -> 78-80

Moises Caecido - 76 -> 80

Joe Bursik - 75 -> 77/78

Tough to call considering.

Single player edits: Boston River SC, Bahia, Gremio, Avai FC, Luton Town, Tombense FC, ENPPI, SKA Khabarovsk, Locomotive Tbilisi, Cruzeiro, Albinegros De Orizaba, Hearts (Harry Cochrane)

Nice +6 for Caicedo today 

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Soccahappy said:

Duo! It's not a good deal taking De Ligt even if he plays. The duo have a value, a trading value if nothing else it's a backward step. Cash or player values are the lifeblood of the team. I would try every other club in your Gw and see if U can get a better trade for these 2 players or other players. Show him u don't like the deal.

If that doesn't work, try the De Ligt deal again in a different way. If nothing works, wait for another situ. He may comeback, he may see one of your other players that rises in the next review, Take your time, "play hardball"  and "things change".... Aouar gets a big move to a big club, De Ligt gets a long injury in the game or real world, anything can happen that changes the picture. If a deal is bad, don't take it...

Thanks Socca. He initially asked me Pavard + Lucas Hernandez, but that was a no way because I only have two LBs. I tried lots of different bids but nothing, until he opened to Pavard + Aouar, that seems the only way to get De Ligt. Damn, if only I weren't a Juventus supporter... 😅

P.s. the post you liked was about another gameworld and I kept my players.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Jose7 said:

+1 for Neuhaus? 

Doucoure +1 for Everton or very unlikely?  

Neuhaus +1

Doucoure I doubt very much, Everton have definitely dropped off since their opening few games of the season.

1 hour ago, bavarac91 said:

Is Bellerin stuck on 90, he is my first choice rb for a long time 😕 thanks

Yes, hasn’t lived up to the hype in my opinion due to injuries etc and Arsenal aren’t particularly doing great at the minute.

He was brilliant when he first burst on to the scene many years ago.

23 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said:

Nice +6 for Caicedo today 

I missed that 😂

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Hello guys, 

Would you give VVD for kimmich + kounde? My opinion is to profit from this offer and accept it! :)

Thanks!

As yet I've never been tempted by any offer for VVD but this comes very close, he's desperate so ask for added cash and then double it and see if he accepts. This is only a strategy if cash is important in your Gw

1 hour ago, Mike0007 said:

Armando Broja or Bryan Reynolds?

Also, how do you guys rate Yari Verschaeren? Potential ceiling?

Broja definitely. 

Verschaeran can only go up +1 at Anderlecht. Refer to @thorgan lesar for higher than that....

1 hour ago, bavarac91 said:

Is Bellerin stuck on 90, he is my first choice rb for a long time 😕 thanks

He could eventually get 91 but not likely unless Arsenal become contenders for Top4. Their form for Arteta has declined recently so not likely at all ATM.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Nameless said:

Why is N'Dicka of Frankfurt not playing? Is he still value for money?

https://bulinews.com/news/6050/frankfurt-be-without-evan-ndicka-for-weeks

1 hour ago, TMCosta said:

I have Switzerland 14/10/2019 and Austria 16/05/2019 but not 100% sure. Timewise makes sense Chile, Colombia and then Big 5.

 

I think SM only did the top teams there recently so yes, hope they go back to them after Uruguay and Australia

Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Emy Ionescu said:

1.Pervis Estupinan + Lisandro Martinez/C.Romero for R.Guerrerio? Any of this deals are ok for Guerreiro? 

2. Pervis Estupinan for Jacob Bruun Larsen + F.Stefanovic + G.Busio.

Thanks!

1) Duo with Romero.

Guerreiro is stuck at 91 unless Dortmund can get some silverware or he plays out of this world.

Estupinan has been average at best this season but he’s talent and Romero is better than Martinez in my opinion.

2) Trio although I don’t like the sound of Jacob Bruun Larsen 😂

Link to post
Share on other sites

Upload of 3 French Clubs with lot's of risers on @jaybee thread players to watch 2021 etc, Monaco, Montpellier and Nantes today, Page 6 at the bottom, link below:-

https://forum.soccermanager.com/topic/170999-ligue-1-players-to-watch-202021/page/6/?tab=comments#comment-3246241

Cheers Socca 😄

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/28/2020 at 2:30 AM, Kieran_S91 said:

Folarin Balogun

Age - 19

Club - Arsenal

Position - Forward

Nationality - England

CAF187B5-468C-4498-BC50-0D0960288BE4.jpeg.a1804636c2985be0b91fb515c068e90c.jpeg

Born in New York, New York. Balogun is another teen with multi nationality and has played for both England and USA at youth level. He can also chose Nigeria but as of yet has not played for them.

Folarin likes to use his pace to get in behind defences and has a great eye for goal often showing how deadly he is in one on one situations against the goalkeeper. Not just a speed merchant Balogun has also shown that his has dribbling qualities by producing some pretty brilliant solo runs.

At just 19 he’s still got much to learn on the football field but that hasn’t stopped clubs from interest, in which sums of around 8 million have been branded for his services.

He’s developing nicely at the gunners but I would like him to try and pursue a move for some senior game time whether it’s in the Championship or the premier league.

In recent times he’s showed his desire to leave Arsenal due to the lack of senior football opportunities which is good to see in a young man.

SM rating - 70

Value - 340k

Folarin Balogun (19) scores his first senior goal for Arsenal!

INSTANT IMPACT!!

Subbed on 81:25 ▶️
Goal on 82:02

Report above from my English talents thread.

Nice turn and finish

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

On 11/23/2020 at 5:16 PM, Sir Rahul said:

Birmingham have just signed Alen Halilovic!

Finnaly got rid of him! I'm sure he'll fit in well with Aitor Karanka's defensive, narrow, counter-attacking tactics at Birmingham City. 😀

AK was previously Jose's assistant during his time at Real Madrid. 

On 11/24/2020 at 8:44 PM, erdingerpfc said:

Which players would you recommend from Sassuolo,Sociedad and Milan,who should rise?

I would + Haugue, Boga, Locatelli and Gabbia - who could also rise next year. 

On 11/25/2020 at 12:03 PM, Toby S said:

I have a quick tactical question, so I'm playing against someone in the league with team (Messi is now firmino) and tactics:image.png.51f1b526a1d6702ff2842a0afa049c5d.pngimage.png.98cc19ae089ec10114c2bae4e63a8299.png

I play 4-2-3-1B and he has a better defence and midfield than me (mine are 92 across the board) but same rated attack and GK, how would you attack? Would you try and attack down both flanks to take advantage of no full backs? I usually just play mixed attacking and have lost to him twice this season already :(

I would use 2 defensive arrows on your 2 DM/CM's, and put an attacking arrow on both your fullbacks for the duration of the game. 

Use a normal mentality, attack down both flanks, use a mixed passing style, press fast and all over. Your AM is your Playmaker and your lone striker is your targetman.

Put a tick for all the Instructions, apart from counter-attack (because your team will sit back too often) and don't use the off-side trap. 

These kind of tactics seems to work reasonably well for me against stronger 💪 opposion - not sure how it'll work for you. 

On 11/25/2020 at 12:59 PM, Bukɑ said:

I have Bernardo Silva and Saul

Who should I sell to get Gnabry?

🔭 🤔 He seems to have disappeared this season. 

 

10 hours ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Hello guys, 

Would you give VVD for kimmich + kounde? My opinion is to profit from this offer and accept it! :)

Thanks!

LT = Duo 

ST = VVD

8 hours ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Another transfer that i need your opinion. Should i give Bernardo Silva for Klostermann + Sabitzer? From my opinion i think it's too little to accept it, and i will add also S.Dodo/H.Wolf (from his list) for this deal.

 

Thanks!

(Right now) the duo would be the better option to take + it gives you more strength in depth.  

12 hours ago, hesselink said:

Koke back to 94, any chance?

Very little right now. However, A La Liga title or a CL winners  medal (this season) could return him back to a 94 in the Summer review. 😀

8 hours ago, bavarac91 said:

Is Bellerin stuck on 90, he is my first choice rb for a long time 😕 thanks

I presume so, especially if Arsenal don't put up a stronger title challenge/win a cup or two - with Hector gaining enough gametime and influence in games.  

8 hours ago, Jose7 said:

+1 for Neuhaus

Doucoure +1 for Everton or very unlikely?  With Everton losing ahead of steam I doubt he will get a rise (just yet). 

 

 

3 hours ago, Kieran_S91 said:

Lucas Digne suffers ankle ligament injury and will need surgery, this means a potential run of games for Niels Nkounkou who is only 70 rated.

If he’s not taken in your GW then he should be a good riser this season now.

 

Hey there Carlo,

Is Niels Nkounkou definitely in for a good amount of game-time? Or will Everton now be in for another LB during the winter window? 

🤔 And was it Jordan Pickford who caused the ankle ligament injury with a (80/20) challenge on Lucas Digne? 😀

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Kieran_S91 said:

SWIKI REPORT (26/11/20)

5 pages today mainly the top 2 teams in Uruguay.

Uruguay 🇺🇾 (Primera/Segunda)

18 players edited Liverpool De Montevideo and 19 players edited Montevideo Wanderers, 1 player edited CA Progreso, 1 player edited Danubio, 1 player edited CA Bella Vista, 1 player edited CA Villa Teresa, 1 player edited Central Espanol, 1 player edited Villa Espanola, 2 players edited Nacional

Australia 🇦🇺

6 players edited Melbourne City FC, 2 players edited Sydney FC, 1 player edited Brisbane Roar, 3 players edited Wellington Phoenix, 1 player edited Adelaide United

England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 (The Championship)

5 players edited Blackburn Rovers with Harvey Elliott among the edits, maybe a rise?

76 -> 80

France 🇫🇷 (National 1)

9 players edited Bastia, 5 players edited Stade Briochin, 1 player edited Troyes.

Single edits: Mainz, Botafogo PB, FC Lviv, Sud America, Rosario Central, Leeds United, Lens, Huracan, Spartans FCCoritiba and FK Baltika.

Brendan Aaronson among the edits again, I said it before and will say it again, potential rise incoming 78 -> 82

I think SM are just giving the top teams a major review in Uruguay

@TMCostawhat do you think?

Thats all for now guys

Cheers Kieran 😁

I'm new to all of this SMWiki edits and stuff. If I have understood correctly, Bruno Veglio will get a 70-75/8ish raise in a week time, am I right?

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, Milanista1 said:

Hey there Carlo,

Is Niels Nkounkou definitely in for a good amount of game-time? Or will Everton now be in for another LB during the Winter window? 

🤔 And was it Jordan Pickford who caused the ankle ligament injury with a (80/20) challenge on Lucas Digne? 😀

 

 

Firstly I applaud your sense of humour haha, not sure about if they will buy anyone in January apart from Isco 😲 that’s just a guess though.

But up and till then Niels should get good game time and has impressed whenever I’ve watched him this season.

Kickford probably did it in training 😂

8 minutes ago, JacobMOX said:

I'm new to all of this SMWiki edits and stuff. If I have understood correctly, Bruno Veglio will get a 70-75/8ish raise in a week time, am I right?

Yes you are correct but not all edits are for rating, some can be for positional changes and cosmetics.

In this case Bruno Veglio was among the edits and I believe he should rise anywhere in the region of 78-80.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mourinho has subbed on three youngsters for their first-team debuts in the 82th minute, 4-0 up - including Alfie Whiteman the back-up keeper (73 rated). No respect for Ludogorets 😂 Whiteman has previously made the bench in 7 league games (earliest Nov 2017), one CL game and two EFL cup games.

The others are Harvey White (67) - who made the bench first in the Project Restart game vs Utd - has made the bench four other times since. Might get a small bump to 70 because 67 feels a bit low.

And Dane Scarlett - 16 year old, not on the database yet. Should get added within a week, I'd say 65 or 67.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...