Jump to content

Rahul W's rating predictions


Recommended Posts

4 hours ago, crvena_zvezda said:

A strange move, to go and sit on the bench. Although maybe he has been told he'll get matches in the FA Cup or Europa League.

He gone from warming one bench to warming another 😂

Maybe he just fancied the bright lights of London. I’m sure something must have gone on behind the scenes.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 41.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Sir Rahul

    4444

  • Kieran_S91

    3875

  • Soccahappy

    1740

  • Milanista1

    1470

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Hi all, As you have seen, I have not really been active over the past few months other than updating my preds. It's just been me phasing out of the forum. Now that the reviews are done, I can say

Just noticed this thread has crossed 1 million views, 23k odd replies, 930 pages.  I know this is 3 and a half years old but I never intended for this to monopolise the forum back then (I would h

Page 200- didn't think we'd get here when I started this casually- thanks all

Posted Images

SWIKI REPORT (23/01/21)

28 PAGES TODAY! 😲 and if I didn’t know much about South America I do now. So many teams from Colombia, Peru, Uruguay Paraguay and Ecuador.

Mexico with a lot of edits along with South Korea Eastern European teams and the lower leagues of England, so pretty much what seems like every team in World!

Theres also what I think could be a bunch of random risers of which I will post my predictions below. Anyway let’s get started.

Mexico 🇲🇽 (Multiple leagues)

UNAM - 2
Atlas - 1
Monterrey - 1
Pachuca - 1
Mazatlan FC - 3
Deportivo Toluca - 6
Correcaminos UAT - 2
Celaya FC - 1
Club Leon - 1
Guadalajara - 2
Cruz Azul - 1
Santos Laguna - 1
Club America - 2
Necaxa - 3
FC Juarez - 1
Venados FC - 1
Atletico San Luis - 2
Tigres UNAL - 1
Club Puebla - 1

Uruguay 🇺🇾

Defensor Sporting - 1
CA Rentistas - 1
Club River Plate - 1
Deportivo Maldonado - 1
Boston River SC - 1

Paraguay 🇵🇾 

12 De Octubre - 6
Club Olimpia - 2
Cerro Porteno - 1

Colombia 🇨🇴

Millonarios - 2
CD La Equidad - 2
Alianza Petrolera - 2
America De Cali - 2
Atletico Bucaramanga - 7
Rionegro Aguilas - 1
Atletico Nacional - 1
Deportivo Cali - 2
Bogotá FC - 1
Boyaca Chico - 5
Deportivo Pereira - 7
Deportivo Pasto - 2
Envigado - 2
Independiente Medellin - 3
Cucuta Deportivo - 1
Jaguares De Cordoba - 5
Patriotas Boyaca - 2
Junior FC - 1
Llaneros FC - 1
Coyotes De Tlaxcala - 2

Peru 🇵🇪 

Carlos A. Mannucci - 5
Deportivo Municipal - 1
Ayacucho FC - 2
Sporting Cristal - 3
Alianza Universidad - 2
Sport Huancayo - 1
Club Cienciano - 3
Carlos Stein - 2
Universidad Tecnica De Cajamarca - 1
Academia Cantolao - 2

Ecuador 🇪🇨 

El Nacional - 3
SD Aucas - 1
Guayaquil City - 2
Independiente Del Valle - 5

Leonel Claudinho - 80 -> 82+
Kouadio Kone - 78 -> 80
Christos Tzolis - 80 -> 82
Nuno Mendes - 78 -> 82

Selection of TRANSFER edits

Brandon Austin - Orlando City (Loan)
Krepin Diatta - AS Monaco
Arkadiusz Milik - Marseille (Loan)
Fikayo Tomori - AC Milan (Loan)
Maty Ryan - Arsenal (Loan)

Thanks for reading guys

Cheers Kieran 😁

Link to post
Share on other sites

Adarabioyo's review is so harsh, very poor from SM. He's played every minute available to him so far, and in the games he's played he's got 12 points from 14 games, which is about the rate of points that Brighton have got. He's performed really well, and has been a huge upgrade on Tim Ream and Michael Hector who are both still rated higher than him. In those 14 games, they've conceded 16 goals (1.14 p/g) as opposed to the 11 goals conceded in the 4 games before he came in to the side (2.75 p/g). 

I really rate Dara O'Shea, but he's got the same upgrade, even though he's played less than 70% of possible Premier League minutes for West Brom (as opposed to Adarabioyo's 100%), hasn't performed nearly to the same level and is in a side below Fulham in the league.

I hope that's also not an indication that Conor Gallagher is to be given the same treatment, and won't be given a rise, even after his performances this season.

Antonee Robinson's is poor as well, again he's performed out of his skin, and none of that seems to matter to him. I wonder if the three of them would have been given there deserved ratings if they'd have joined before the start of the season? Most likely. Whether a player joins a club in July, or on deadline day shouldn't effect how they're rated as a footballer. By that token, Matty Cash's performances won't matter for anything and he'll only get 86. 

I get for the lower leagues why minutes matter more than anything else, but for the Premier League you could watch some of the games and give the guys performing out of there skin a little bit of credit. For all the talk about how you want to revolutionize the game, and add 30 different features to it, just focus on paying a little bit of attention to the biggest league in the world so that Dennis Odoi isn't rated higher than Tosin Adarabioyo. 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, Sir Rahul said:

I think Isco will drop tomorrow. Surely. And will head towards 90 in summer unless he leaves Madrid (unlikely) or gets gametime (unlikely under Zidane). Doesn't seem to be good enough anymore.

I'd go for Upamecano unless this is a short term deal.

 

13 hours ago, Kieran_S91 said:

Upamecano for me.

Isco a few years back was a brilliant player unfortunately he barely plays now and seems to be on the decline.

Almost had him but Isco dropped before the deal could be completed, and it's off now😂

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Lost soul said:

 

Almost had him but Isco dropped before the deal could be completed, and it's off now😂

Unfortunate 😔

48 minutes ago, Scrooll0706 said:

What do you think of possible deal like:

Gerard Moreno + Smith Rowe(or Yeremi Pino) for Rafael Leao

or 

Neuhaus for Leao

which side you think will be better?

Duo

Neuhaus

15 minutes ago, Danilo said:

I have 1.3M, which player or players do you recommend to take that increases his rating in premier league? maybe someone with a high rise

Luke Thomas - 76 -> 80 (700k)

Max Kilman - 78 -> 82 (400k)

Pascal Struijk - 73 -> 78 (500k)

Tyrick Mitchell - 75 -> 80 (800k)

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Kieran_S91 said:

SWIKI REPORT (23/01/21)

28 PAGES TODAY! 😲 and if I didn’t know much about South America I do now. So many teams from Colombia, Peru, Uruguay Paraguay and Ecuador.

Mexico with a lot of edits along with South Korea Eastern European teams and the lower leagues of England, so pretty much what seems like every team in World!

Theres also what I think could be a bunch of random risers of which I will post my predictions below. Anyway let’s get started.

Mexico 🇲🇽 (Multiple leagues)

UNAM - 2
Atlas - 1
Monterrey - 1
Pachuca - 1
Mazatlan FC - 3
Deportivo Toluca - 6
Correcaminos UAT - 2
Celaya FC - 1
Club Leon - 1
Guadalajara - 2
Cruz Azul - 1
Santos Laguna - 1
Club America - 2
Necaxa - 3
FC Juarez - 1
Venados FC - 1
Atletico San Luis - 2
Tigres UNAL - 1
Club Puebla - 1

Uruguay 🇺🇾

Defensor Sporting - 1
CA Rentistas - 1
Club River Plate - 1
Deportivo Maldonado - 1
Boston River SC - 1

Paraguay 🇵🇾 

12 De Octubre - 6
Club Olimpia - 2
Cerro Porteno - 1

Colombia 🇨🇴

Millonarios - 2
CD La Equidad - 2
Alianza Petrolera - 2
America De Cali - 2
Atletico Bucaramanga - 7
Rionegro Aguilas - 1
Atletico Nacional - 1
Deportivo Cali - 2
Bogotá FC - 1
Boyaca Chico - 5
Deportivo Pereira - 7
Deportivo Pasto - 2
Envigado - 2
Independiente Medellin - 3
Cucuta Deportivo - 1
Jaguares De Cordoba - 5
Patriotas Boyaca - 2
Junior FC - 1
Llaneros FC - 1
Coyotes De Tlaxcala - 2

Peru 🇵🇪 

Carlos A. Mannucci - 5
Deportivo Municipal - 1
Ayacucho FC - 2
Sporting Cristal - 3
Alianza Universidad - 2
Sport Huancayo - 1
Club Cienciano - 3
Carlos Stein - 2
Universidad Tecnica De Cajamarca - 1
Academia Cantolao - 2

Ecuador 🇪🇨 

El Nacional - 3
SD Aucas - 1
Guayaquil City - 2
Independiente Del Valle - 5

Leonel Claudinho - 80 -> 82+
Kouadio Kone - 78 -> 80
Christos Tzolis - 80 -> 82
Nuno Mendes - 78 -> 82

Selection of TRANSFER edits

Brandon Austin - Orlando City (Loan)
Krepin Diatta - AS Monaco
Arkadiusz Milik - Marseille (Loan)
Fikayo Tomori - AC Milan (Loan)
Maty Ryan - Arsenal (Loan)

Thanks for reading guys

Cheers Kieran 😁

I've used all my reactions, so thanks and awesome work.

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, Soccahappy said:

Spreadsheet Results for Spain

Re-Sp-Sht-Spain-Athle-Atletic1.png

Pretty good result Risers and Profits 😀

Very good profit 🙂

Felix was 28 million before his rise so 4 million profit for him, the only reason I know this is because I’ve bought him recently from an external club.

8 minutes ago, lemontrees said:

I've used all my reactions, so thanks and awesome work.

Thank you, I was scrolling through the pages thinking when will this end, Sooooo many pages. It’s not bad when you have lots of pages from a certain league but when it’s spread out it’s ridiculously time consuming 😂

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, Patron said:

Otávio is being one of the best players of FC Porto this season. Unfortunately to FC Porto he is in the last year of contract and he will most likely leave at the end of the season. Reports that Milan, Inter and Sevilla are interested on his services. In my opinion he is a good investment on SM and a very interesting sign to a big club on free transfer.

Wolves are also said to be in the running. Nuno knows the player as they were at Porto together, and Wolves clearly need new blood.

Link to post
Share on other sites
39 minutes ago, Kieran_S91 said:

Very good profit 🙂

Felix was 28 million before his rise so 4 million profit for him, the only reason I know this is because I’ve bought him recently from an external club.

Thank you, I was scrolling through the pages thinking when will this end, Sooooo many pages. It’s not bad when you have lots of pages from a certain league but when it’s spread out it’s ridiculously time consuming 😂

Yeah If I have bought any player then the spreadsheet records the price I bought him at, and I don't change it if SM fluctuate that figure, as they do from time to time. That's why it's different to your profit margin Kieran. You wouldn't believe how often I see these changes up and down. Also Correa as u see I recorded no profit for his rise at all.

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, swanseajack said:

Adarabioyo's review is so harsh, very poor from SM. He's played every minute available to him so far, and in the games he's played he's got 12 points from 14 games, which is about the rate of points that Brighton have got. He's performed really well, and has been a huge upgrade on Tim Ream and Michael Hector who are both still rated higher than him. In those 14 games, they've conceded 16 goals (1.14 p/g) as opposed to the 11 goals conceded in the 4 games before he came in to the side (2.75 p/g). 

I really rate Dara O'Shea, but he's got the same upgrade, even though he's played less than 70% of possible Premier League minutes for West Brom (as opposed to Adarabioyo's 100%), hasn't performed nearly to the same level and is in a side below Fulham in the league.

I hope that's also not an indication that Conor Gallagher is to be given the same treatment, and won't be given a rise, even after his performances this season.

Antonee Robinson's is poor as well, again he's performed out of his skin, and none of that seems to matter to him. I wonder if the three of them would have been given there deserved ratings if they'd have joined before the start of the season? Most likely. Whether a player joins a club in July, or on deadline day shouldn't effect how they're rated as a footballer. By that token, Matty Cash's performances won't matter for anything and he'll only get 86. 

I get for the lower leagues why minutes matter more than anything else, but for the Premier League you could watch some of the games and give the guys performing out of there skin a little bit of credit. For all the talk about how you want to revolutionize the game, and add 30 different features to it, just focus on paying a little bit of attention to the biggest league in the world so that Dennis Odoi isn't rated higher than Tosin Adarabioyo. 

 

Say it again for the people at the back. 
 

It’s not hard to observe the performances of the PL and reflect quality in ratings. I completely understand why some leagues get the odd shaky review but surely the most widely broadcast league in the world with the most stat analysis should be done better.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Id rather be in SW19 said:

my florent da silva and lamptey & cash for sandro.? The manager thinks he can save the level 4 player so only Sandro up for grabs.

I think I might tell him to wait a week or so until Lamptey is reveiwed so I get a better deal/picture. Lamptey should be 5-6m on next reveiw. Not sure about da silva.....any thoughts?

Keep the duo in my opinion.

Florent Da Silva has recently made the bench for Lyon, very good talent with a big future. Hopefully he makes his senior debut this season.

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/25/2016 at 5:12 AM, Sir Rahul said:

SPAIN LA LIGA

Atletico Madrid:

Felix +1 to 91- yes

Correa +1 to 91- yes

Llorente +1 to 90- yes

Hermoso +1 to 90- yes

Costa -1 to 89- yes

Vrsaljko -1 to 87

Trippier +1 to 91

Sanchez +2 to 78

 

Real Madrid:

Hazard -1 to 94- yes

Isco -1 to 91- yes

Marcelo -1 to 90- yes

Diaz -1 to 88- yes

Vazquez +1 to 90

Valverde +1 to 91

Hernando +3 to 80

Garcia +2 to 78

Park +2 to 75

 

Barcelona:

Griezmann -1 to 93- yes

A good end to the La Liga review. Will give it tomorrow to see if there are any final changes before closing this.

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/25/2016 at 5:12 AM, Sir Rahul said:

ENGLAND PREMIER LEAGUE

Burnley:

Brownhill +2 to 86- +1 to 85

Westwood +1 to 87

Taylor +1 to 86

Gudmundsson -1 to 86

Cork -1 to 86

Long +2 to 85

Dunne +3 to 78

Benson +6 to 73

Pope +1 to 89

Cooney +3 to 70

 

Fulham:

Seri -1 to 87- yes

Robinson +2 to 85- +1 to 84

Adarabioyo +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Mitrovic -1 to 88

Lemina -1 to 87

Reid +1 to 86

Lookman +1 to 86

Reed +1 to 84

Fabri -1 to 82

Knockaert -1 to 85

 

West Brom:

O'Shea +3 to 83- yes

Ivanovic -1 to 86- -2 to 83

Johnstone +1 to 86

Gallagher +2 to 85

Ajayi +1 to 85

Sawyers +1 to 85

Townsend +2 to 84

Furlong +1 to 84

Diangana +1 to 84

Grant +1 to 84

Robinson +1 to 84

Austin -1 to 84

Grosicki -1 to 84

Edwards +2 to 82

Field +2 to 80

Harper +2 to 80

Palmer +3 to 76

Azaz +5 to 70

Griffiths +3 to 70

 

Sheffield United:

Ampadu +2 to 82- yes

Jagielka -1 to 84- -2 to 83

Ramsdale +1 to 86

Osborn +1 to 84

Robinson +1 to 84

Burke +1 to 84

Lowe +1 to 83

Bryan +1 to 77

Norrington-Davies +3 to 80

Coulibaly +5 to 78

Smith +3 to 73

They better do the bottom 4 review properly tomorrow.

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, gyanthecat said:

How do you guys rate Otávio (Porto)? Does he have the potential to rise further and/or move to a stronger team? (With all due respect to Porto, which is the team I root for in Portugal)

I mainly ask @TMCosta, but any opinion is welcome. :)

Not too sure

12 hours ago, Wave_Dweller said:

Which of these can you see as a future 92+?
Bastoni, Upamecano, Tapsoba, Kounde, Diego Carlos.

The first four, age counts against Carlos, unlikely to get that elite move to boost him to 92. 

13 hours ago, crvena_zvezda said:

A strange move, to go and sit on the bench. Although maybe he has been told he'll get matches in the FA Cup or Europa League.

Emirates bench is better than the Amex bench!

4 hours ago, swanseajack said:

Adarabioyo's review is so harsh, very poor from SM. He's played every minute available to him so far, and in the games he's played he's got 12 points from 14 games, which is about the rate of points that Brighton have got. He's performed really well, and has been a huge upgrade on Tim Ream and Michael Hector who are both still rated higher than him. In those 14 games, they've conceded 16 goals (1.14 p/g) as opposed to the 11 goals conceded in the 4 games before he came in to the side (2.75 p/g). 

I really rate Dara O'Shea, but he's got the same upgrade, even though he's played less than 70% of possible Premier League minutes for West Brom (as opposed to Adarabioyo's 100%), hasn't performed nearly to the same level and is in a side below Fulham in the league.

I hope that's also not an indication that Conor Gallagher is to be given the same treatment, and won't be given a rise, even after his performances this season.

Antonee Robinson's is poor as well, again he's performed out of his skin, and none of that seems to matter to him. I wonder if the three of them would have been given there deserved ratings if they'd have joined before the start of the season? Most likely. Whether a player joins a club in July, or on deadline day shouldn't effect how they're rated as a footballer. By that token, Matty Cash's performances won't matter for anything and he'll only get 86. 

I get for the lower leagues why minutes matter more than anything else, but for the Premier League you could watch some of the games and give the guys performing out of there skin a little bit of credit. For all the talk about how you want to revolutionize the game, and add 30 different features to it, just focus on paying a little bit of attention to the biggest league in the world so that Dennis Odoi isn't rated higher than Tosin Adarabioyo. 

 

I agree mate. It's quite harsh. As Gallagher is a loanee I think he'll be fine.

3 hours ago, Scrooll0706 said:

What do you think of possible deal like:

Gerard Moreno + Smith Rowe(or Yeremi Pino) for Rafael Leao

or 

Neuhaus for Leao

which side you think will be better?

Duo (with ESR)

Leao

3 hours ago, Danilo said:

I have 1.3M, which player or players do you recommend to take that increases his rating in premier league? maybe someone with a high rise

What Kieran said

2 hours ago, JackNUFC99 said:

What are peoples opinion on Brendan Aaronson, MLS to Salzburg. Future riser?

Definitely

1 hour ago, sharkdan said:

Griezmann hasn't played well and we know, but surely he isn't as strong as Dybala, they should have given him a - 1 too

Not too accurate to compare situations for me

52 minutes ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

my florent da silva and lamptey & cash for sandro.? The manager thinks he can save the level 4 player so only Sandro up for grabs.

I think I might tell him to wait a week or so until Lamptey is reveiwed so I get a better deal/picture. Lamptey should be 5-6m on next reveiw. Not sure about da silva.....any thoughts?

Lamptey should be reviewed in the next three days, so wait and see

Get Sandro if he will help your team

54 minutes ago, Ben C said:

Say it again for the people at the back. 
 

It’s not hard to observe the performances of the PL and reflect quality in ratings. I completely understand why some leagues get the odd shaky review but surely the most widely broadcast league in the world with the most stat analysis should be done better.

Agreed mate. I could do a better job for the PL especially - as I know enough to do the ratings fairly, watching a fair few games, following the rest on Twitter, reading articles etc

While my preds for the other leagues are not as in tune with the quality of performances, my PL preds certainly are.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...