Rahul W's rating predictions

[SomeNextGuy 31]

Tuanzebe a dead buy? 

[Soccahappy 8,912]

5 hours ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

No its Barca's one (on loan at Real Betis I think) sorry for the confusion

He's on track for a rise too, so he is a yes also.

3 hours ago, RobboEFC said:

Frenkie De Jong or Ruben Dias? 

Surprising but I'd say Ruben Long Term.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ps Upload of France spreadsheet shortly

[Soccahappy 8,912]

Previous tables on pages 777, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784.785,786,787, 788, 789, 790, 791,792,793, 794,795,796,797,798,799,800,801,803,804,805.806,807,808,810,811,812,813,814.816,817,818,819,821,822,823,824,825,8826,827,828,829,830,831.832,833,834,835.836,837,839,841,842,844,845,855,856,857.860,864,866, 867.868,871,872,873,875,876,877,878,880,914,955,988. 1003,1008,1016, 1023.1026,1030, 1032,1042, 1045, 1047, 1055 , 1057, 1060, 1063, 1065, 1068, 1082, 1083, 1085, 1087, 1089, 1092, 1095, 1098, 1103,1106,1109,1118 ,1121, 1124 1126, 1132, 1138, 1141, 1147, 1152, 1153, 1155, 1157, 1158,1159 , 1160 , 1161,1163, 1165, 1169, 1174,1175,1176, 1180, 1187,  1189, 1197, 1210, 1211, 1212,1222, 1225, 1226,1227, 1236, 1239, 1240,NEW SEASON 1294 1303, 1307, 1309Prem , 1311P, 1316P  1318P, 1321P,  1323P, 1327Milan,  1355P 1361P 1365P 1368P 1370P 1371P 1376P  1378P 1380Germany  1384Ger(2)1389Ger 1394Italy 1396Prem 1398P  1405Pr 1406pr 1411pr 1414pr , 1419pr  1423Italy1425 Italy 1427 It, 1431 Italy, 1433Spain, 1435Spain, 1437Spain, 1439Spain,, 1441Spain, 1448 Prem, 1449 Prem 1452 Prem 1455 Prem1458 Prem, 1461 Prem 1464 Prem 1466 Prem 1469 Prem 1472 Prem  1475 Prem French 1519,  French 1521, French 1525, French 1528 French 1530 French 1537 French 1539   Be careful of Be careful of the reddish boxes where SM rate the higher rated players by Performances rather than stats.

Minutes will vary game by game and league position also helps a lot. Anything over 0% indicates likely riser, higher the better/safer. Negative percentages don't predict a drop just less chances of a rise. The more games played the more accurate the predictions will become.

I am concentrating mainly on Younger under 89 rated players as these are more consistent risers and more profitable, Goal keepers are dealt with by SM in a completely different way, which is why I mostly also ignore Gk's 

Update for French Review in May:-

Sorry, Dennis Appiah with -38.4% obviously isn't going to rise +2 it's typo please ignore.

It must look a big drop for Kolo Muani from +82.6% to +41.6%, BUT it's not him, he had a plus 7 last time so the "Climb" this time is higher, not his stats, which are as good as the last review.

Thanks for the Forum’s interest and support for the Spreadsheet, which is greatly appreciated, Cheers Socca 😀

 

[Mike0007 54]

Bruno Guimaeres plus Curtis Jones for giving away Tonali?

Will any of the above 3 be getting a rise in the summer? If so, what would it be approximately?

 

Edited February 23 by Mike0007

[Nameless 741]

Has Berardi reached his max?

Is he getting linked to a bigger club?

[Milanista1 1,856]

15 hours ago, alexavierdenelle said:

Alaba (me) trade with jose gimenez + ruben dias + 23 M is a good deal? thanks

Yes it's looks a great long term deal. 

9 hours ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

Luca PELLEGRINI ,Noussair MAZRAOUI or Emerson? who is best? worth trying to get all three?

Thanks again

I would choose Barca's Emerson because he's having another very good season at Real Betis (currently their 3rd best player). I'm sure he'll give very stiff ("behave") competition to Sergio Dest next season for that RB spot. 😀

 

6 hours ago, RobboEFC said:

Frenkie De Jong or Ruben Dias? 

If City and Ruben remain on 🔥then I reckon he'd be the better long-term player to have. Ruben Dias has future captain written all over him - City seemed to have now replaced Vincent Kompany.

However he's still early in his City career. 

6 hours ago, LaLiga said:

Hi!  Opinions. Who has better future (95/94/93...)?

1: De Light/Upecano - 2: Ferran/Thuram/Jota 3: Werner/Rashford/Coman 

Regards, Thank you

Not too sure about peak ratings, yet I'll hazard a guess for my chosen player. 

1. Upamecano: 93-94.

2. Jota: 93 (if he can help to revive Liverpool, he's currently on limited gametime as well). 

3. Rashford: 93-94

[Kieran_S91 7,423]

1 hour ago, Nameless said:

I am a supporter of current concern system.

Say you have a big squad and you had to play your level 2 concern player instead of another player (who will now grow concern). If only 20 matches were all it needed no player would reach level 3 let alone level 5. 

And if someone has a small squad then it's just poor management. 

May be there are scopes to tweak things but I am a supporter of current concern system. 

Fair enough, I think concerns should be a thing but it’s not realistic how it currently is IMO.

52 minutes ago, SomeNextGuy said:

Tuanzebe a dead buy? 

I’d say so, Lindelof and Maguire is clearly Ole’s first choice pairing and Bailly is in the equation when fit.

9 minutes ago, Mike0007 said:

Bruno Guimaeres plus Curtis Jones for giving away Tonali?

Will any of the above 3 be getting a rise in the summer? If so, what would it be approximately?

 

Duo

I think Curtis Jones is guaranteed a rise somewhere in the region of 85 -> 87.

5 minutes ago, Nameless said:

Has Berardi reached his max?

Is he getting linked to a bigger club?

Definitely think he’s peaked at Sassuolo in terms of rating. Don’t know about any links.

[Mike0007 54]

1 minute ago, Kieran_S91 said:

Fair enough, I think concerns should be a thing but it’s not realistic how it currently is IMO.

I’d say so, Lindelof and Maguire is clearly Ole’s first choice pairing and Bailly is in the equation when fit.

Duo

I think Curtis Jones is guaranteed a rise somewhere in the region of 85 -> 87.

Definitely think he’s peaked at Sassuolo in terms of rating. Don’t know about any links.

I also have the option of getting Bruno Guimaeres plus Baumgartner plus Kudus/Gallagher for giving away Tonali.

Should I go for that or just Bruno Guimaeres plus Curtis?

[Kieran_S91 7,423]

8 minutes ago, Mike0007 said:

I also have the option of getting Bruno Guimaeres plus Baumgartner plus Kudus/Gallagher for giving away Tonali.

Should I go for that or just Bruno Guimaeres plus Curtis?

Tough either are great options!

If you were to do the trio I would go for Kudus between him and Gallagher.

[danitz 4,774]

I do not understand the updates of the Mexican league. They are not taking into account the results of the "opening" tournament where Leon was the champion and Unam second. Alan mozo is in the ideal 11 of the tournament and they raise it only +1 to 83. ???

[gAv Gav 1,263]

I don't have any 90 players. My strikers are two 85's.

Giroud for my Luca Netz? Or should I hold out?

 

[Alyril 5]

Since he’s just scored against Lazio...

What do you think Musiala’s ceiling is and how quickly will he get there? Extra bumps in the next couple of reviews too?

[Kieran_S91 7,423]

1 hour ago, gAv Gav said:

I don't have any 90 players. My strikers are two 85's.

Giroud for my Luca Netz? Or should I hold out?

 

I’d say it depends if your in SM for the long term. Giroud will only be a good option for the next season or 2 whereas Luca Netz is a huge talent for the future.

Personally I would hold out but I always invest in youth.

7 minutes ago, Alyril said:

Since he’s just scored against Lazio...

What do you think Musiala’s ceiling is and how quickly will he get there? Extra bumps in the next couple of reviews too?

90+ at Bayern easily!

I think he could be 89/90 by the end of next season, he’s not getting a huge amount of minutes but features almost every game for Bayern and is highly thought of by the coaching staff there. This being said I would imagine his reviews may go like this.

End of this season - 82 -> 85/6

Next winter - 85/6 -> 87/8

End of next season - 87/8 -> 89/90

This is minus injuries of course.

[Cdog 5]

Sterling or Latauro Martinez 

who has the higher rating potential

thanks

 

[Soccahappy 8,912]

3 hours ago, Mike0007 said:

Bruno Guimaeres plus Curtis Jones for giving away Tonali?

Will any of the above 3 be getting a rise in the summer? If so, what would it be approximately?

 

Duo definitely

3 hours ago, Nameless said:

Has Berardi reached his max?

Is he getting linked to a bigger club?

Probably. He has had links in the past but nothing seems to happen. Linked himself with Barcelona or said he'd like to play for them. 8goals four assists this season but If u can find a good transfer swap I'd do it rather than wait.

2 hours ago, Mike0007 said:

I also have the option of getting Bruno Guimaeres plus Baumgartner plus Kudus/Gallagher for giving away Tonali.

Should I go for that or just Bruno Guimaeres plus Curtis?

Think Curtis just makes the duo better than the trio, but it's close.

1 hour ago, gAv Gav said:

I don't have any 90 players. My strikers are two 85's.

Giroud for my Luca Netz? Or should I hold out?

 

Giroud as a target man plays well for me on SM. Yes he's short term but a world Cup winner 😀

[Milanista1 1,856]

4 hours ago, Mike0007 said:

Bruno Guimaeres plus Curtis Jones for giving away Tonali? Yes. 

Will any of the above 3 be getting a rise in the summer? If so, what would it be approximately?

C. Jones = +2

B. Guimaeres +1 (happen Lyon reach top 2, he must gather enough minutes aswell). 

 

 

4 hours ago, Nameless said:

Has Berardi reached his max?

I reckon his max rate at Sass would be a 91. However to get there he really needs to be pushing Sass into Europe again or at least win an Italian cup/reach a final. Although, there are calls on Soccerwiki to bump him up to a 91 already.

I reckon it'll be more dependant on where Sass finish the season more than owt else. He's currently there best performing player so he's doing well enough to be in with a shot of a rise. 

Is he getting linked to a bigger club?

I haven't heard or seen of anything. I beleive he was out injured during Jan's transfer window, the injury must of took the transfer heat of, of him. He's contracted till June 2024 with a 30M buy-out clause.

I wouldn't have mind seeing him at Milan if we could shift Samu out of the team. But (unfortunately) he's a Merda fan - it's partially why he rejected Jube back when Sass first qualified for the EL. He wanted to play in the EL with Sass. 🙂

 

2 hours ago, gAv Gav said:

I don't have any 90 players. My strikers are two 85's.

Giroud for my Luca Netz? Or should I hold out? I would do the trade. 

 

Hopefully with Giroud as your TM you'll be a stronger goal threat to your opposition. If you require tactical advice when playing with a lone striker do PM me. 

1 hour ago, Alyril said:

Since he’s just scored against Lazio...

What do you think Musiala’s ceiling is and how quickly will he get there? Extra bumps in the next couple of reviews too?

Kierans_S91 answered you very well enough. 

49 minutes ago, Cdog said:

Sterling or Latauro Martinez 

who has the higher rating potential

thanks

 

Playing in (what looks) the stronger team in a better league for a better manager.  

[Kieran_S91 7,423]

On 9/24/2020 at 6:00 PM, Kieran_S91 said:

Jamal Musiala

Age - 17

Club - Bayern Munich

Position - CAM

Nationality - England

As most of you guys know on the forum I’ve mentioned Musiala a lot on the thread since back in July when I posted about players born between 2003-2005 players to watch for.

Ive been waiting for the right time to do a report and I think after his cameo tonight in which he scored his first professional goal it was the right time to do so.

Musiala is a very talented individual who has shot through the youth system at Bayern after leaving Chelsea a year ago, his rise has been outstanding from joining to play in the u17s at Bayern he’s played at every age group through to the first team all within the space of a year.

Jamal reminds abit of Dele Alli, he’s a great dribbler of the ball and boasts a powerful shot, I think he could do with bulking up a little in the future though.

He also has a great mentality with many people at Bayern calling him ‘Ice cold’ because he doesn’t let anything get to him, he so composed even though he’s playing for an elite club at such a young age.

My hopes for Musiala this season are for him to keep his feet on the ground and to get as much experience as possible playing for the current best team in Europe.

Bayern’s coaching staff rate him very highly which should hopefully help with his progression, always great to have the full backing of your ability from some top coaches. 

I mentioned when he got added that Musiala is a MUST BUY and he certainly is that!

SM rating - 73

Value - 1 million

First spoke about Jamal Musiala (17) at the start of last year and his rise has been nothing short of impressive.

Tonight Musiala became the youngest ever Englishman to score in the Champions League, 5 days before his 18th birthday.

[RossieJ 2]

Who would you go for?

Arthur or Alli and Tonali

Thanks!

[Emy Ionescu 181]

31 minutes ago, RossieJ said:

Who would you go for?

Arthur or Alli and Tonali

Thanks!

Duo

[jaybee 879]

Who would you guys choose between Mingueza and Chris Richards if you could only sign one of them?

[crvena_zvezda 344]

2 hours ago, Kieran_S91 said:

First spoke about Jamal Musiala (17) at the start of last year and his rise has been nothing short of impressive.

Tonight Musiala became the youngest ever Englishman to score in the Champions League, 5 days before his 18th birthday.

I heard tonight on 5Live that he will deciding soon whether he wants to represent Germany or England. German media are confident that he'll choose Germany. Might even get a call up in the next international break.

[Kieran_S91 7,423]

3 hours ago, RossieJ said:

Who would you go for?

Arthur or Alli and Tonali

Thanks!

Duo

1 hour ago, jaybee said:

Who would you guys choose between Mingueza and Chris Richards if you could only sign one of them?

Chris Richards

40 minutes ago, crvena_zvezda said:

I heard tonight on 5Live that he will deciding soon whether he wants to represent Germany or England. German media are confident that he'll choose Germany. Might even get a call up in the next international break.

This is true, born in Stuttgart raised in the UK, thought I’d add that goal scoring record in before he changed nationality still true for at least a couple of weeks 😂

[The Finisher 140]

13 hours ago, Cvilhete said:

thoughts on goalkeepers on sm, is there much difference with performances and game averages from 90 on wards, is it worth paying the big money for the 92+s?

 

13 hours ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

ive never noticed much, I had a 78 GK with the rest of the team in low 90s and won the league. Was just trying it out to see if they made a difference, which it didnt

About to win the league by 10 points with a 95 GK, planning on switching to a 92 GK. This is encouraging, every team I've managed has always had a 94+ GK so I'm gonna test this out and see.

[The Finisher 140]

If Atl Madrid win the league, would Joao Felix rise to 92? I sold him some time ago because he wasn't performing how I expected irl, and Atl Madrid didn't seem like a good fit. Frustrating choosing between him, Sancho, and Havertz.

 

Also you think Dybala will keep his 93?

[Kieran_S91 7,423]

SWIKI REPORT (24/02/21)

5 pages this morning so a relatively slow day for SM with the continuation of Chile, Ireland and the back end of Mexico.

Chile 🇨🇱 

Colo Colo - 28
Deportes La Serena - 17
Coquimbo Unido - 1
Deportes Copiapo - 1
Universidad de Chile - 1
Deportes Colchagua - 1
San Antonio Unido - 1

Mexico 🇲🇽 

Club Puebla - 4
Cancun FC - 2
Club Queretaro - 1
Atletico San Luis - 2
Club Tijuana - 1
Tigres UANL - 1
Mazatlan FC - 2

Ireland 🇮🇪 

Sligo Rovers - 5
Dundalk - 1

Thanks for reading

Cheers Kieran 😁