Jump to content

Rahul W's rating predictions


Rahul W

Recommended Posts

Hey guys!

I've got about £8 million to spend and fancy going shopping at the Wonderkid Factory. I was between probably Wirtz, Gravenberch or Cherki. How would you rank these 3?

Are there any others I'd be better trying to get ahead of them?

For some context I have: Fofana, Nuno Mendes, Camavinga, Bellingham, Pedri, Szoboszlai, Reyna, Daka, Veron, M Lacroix, Musah, Arezo and a number of the really young players kindly recommended by you guys.

Thanks in advance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi everyone, I'm new to the forum but I've been playing since 2016.

this is my squad in a competitive world with 35 managers (including 15 Italian friends).

are my predictions right? what do you think?

GK ONANA (Ajax) 25/91   stay

GK GOLLINI (Atalanta) 26/88   stay

GK MVOGO (PSV) 26/86   1 up

Def LENGLET (Barca) 25/92     stay / -1

def DE LIGT (Juventus) 21/92    stay

Def UPAMECANO (RB Lipsia) 22/91    stay

Def KOUNDÉ (Sivilla) 22/90    +1 

Def ROMERO (Atalanta) 23/88 +1

Def DEMIRAL (Juventus) 23/88   stay

Def KOCH (Leeds) 23/88   stay

RB PAVARD (B. Monaco) 25/91   +1 

RB HATEBOER (Atalanta) 27/90   stay

RB PORRO (Sporting CP) 21/86  +1/2

LB CHILWELL (Chelsea) 24/90  +1 

LB R.GOSENS (Atalanta) 26/90  +1

LB DIMARCO (Hellas Verona) 23/85  +2

MF DE JONG (Barca) 23/92  stay

MF ZAKARIA (B. Mönchengladbach) 24/91  stay

MF BENTANCUR (Juventus) 23/91  -1

MC GORETZKA (B. Monaco) 26/93  stay/+1

MC KAMARA (O. Marsiglia) 21/89   +1

MC VALVERDE (Real Madrid9 22/91   stay

MC AOUAR (O. Lione) 22/90   stay

AMF D. VAN DE BEEK (M. UTD) 24/91   -1

AMF MADDISON (leichester) 24/ 91   stay or +1

AMF HAVERTZ  (Chelsea) 21/91  stay

AMF GREALISH (Aston Villa) 25/91  stay

LW THURAM (B. Mönchengladbach) 23/90  stay

LW J. HARRISON (Leeds) 24/85   +2 

RW F. TORRES (M. City) 21/90   stay

RW KULUSEVSKI (Juventus) 21/88  stay

CF FELIX (At. Madrid) 21/91   stay

CF OSIMHEN (Napoli) 22/89  stay

CF EN NESYRI (Sevilla) 23/89  +1

CF KEAN (PSG) 21/88   +1 or +2

Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, Stuarty said:

Hey guys!

I've got about £8 million to spend and fancy going shopping at the Wonderkid Factory. I was between probably Wirtz, Gravenberch or Cherki. How would you rank these 3?

Are there any others I'd be better trying to get ahead of them?

For some context I have: Fofana, Nuno Mendes, Camavinga, Bellingham, Pedri, Szoboszlai, Reyna, Daka, Veron, M Lacroix, Musah, Arezo and a number of the really young players kindly recommended by you guys.

Thanks in advance.

I would take Wirtz before his likely +2.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, Stuarty said:

Hey guys!

I've got about £8 million to spend and fancy going shopping at the Wonderkid Factory. I was between probably Wirtz, Gravenberch or Cherki. How would you rank these 3?

1. Wirtz

2. Cherki

3. Gravenberch

No2 and No3 was tough to decide between.

Are there any others I'd be better trying to get ahead of them? Yes. Anyone from theze

Facundo Torres, Emil Roback, Shola Shoretire, Pablo Gavi, Angsar Knaff, Luka Romero, Nicola Rovella, Rensch, Devyne, Luka Netz, Albert Tjaaland and Liam Delap.

For some context I have: Fofana, Nuno Mendes, Camavinga, Bellingham, Pedri, Szoboszlai, Reyna, Daka, Veron, M Lacroix, Musah, Arezo and a number of the really young players kindly recommended by you guys. That's a strong foundation you got going on there amico. 😀

Thanks in advance.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/15/2021 at 7:19 PM, Kieran_S91 said:

One of the worst FA cup finals I’ve seen but you just knew VAR would be a huge talking point 🤣

675EF827-2480-44C0-80A9-0299609A79FC.thumb.jpeg.5489c572fc5368d37cb12c87b2b0c21e.jpeg

97420730-DB75-4217-ADE2-F17D4D8F920F.thumb.jpeg.e403a3d006d9fcf53ead376d9c29993f.jpeg

 

Don't think it's a handball? It hits his knee first onto to his arm and he looks Offside imo 😂

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, sirmarkhughes said:

I would take Wirtz before his likely +2.

Yeah I was thinking Wirtz too before his rise. Thanks mate!

8 minutes ago, Milanista1 said:

 

Thank you Milanista my friend! I have a few of some of the ones you mentioned, but not others, so time to go shopping! 😁

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Bobbinz86Zena said:

Hi everyone, I'm new to the forum but I've been playing since 2016.

this is my squad in a competitive world with 35 managers (including 15 Italian friends). Mamaamia!

are my predictions right? what do you think? Near enough right.

GK ONANA (Ajax) 25/91   stay

GK GOLLINI (Atalanta) 26/88   stay +1 imo.

GK MVOGO (PSV) 26/86   1 up

Def LENGLET (Barca) 25/92     stay / -1

def DE LIGT (Juventus) 21/92    stay

Def UPAMECANO (RB Lipsia) 22/91    stay

Def KOUNDÉ (Sivilla) 22/90    +1 /stay

Def ROMERO (Atalanta) 23/88 +1

Def DEMIRAL (Juventus) 23/88   stay

Def KOCH (Leeds) 23/88   stay

RB PAVARD (B. Munich) 25/91   +1 

RB HATEBOER (Atalanta) 27/90   stay

RB PORRO (Sporting CP) 21/86  +1/2

LB CHILWELL (Chelsea) 24/90  +1 

LB R.GOSENS (Atalanta) 26/90  +1

LB DIMARCO (Hellas Verona) 23/85  +2

MF DE JONG (Barca) 23/92  stay/+1 Not sure (yet) though

MF ZAKARIA (B. Mönchengladbach) 24/91  stay

MF BENTANCUR (Juventus) 23/91  -1/stay

MC GORETZKA (B. Munich)😀  26/93  +1

MC KAMARA (O. Marsellie) 21/89   +1 Not too sure, probably +1

MC VALVERDE (Real Madrid) 22/91   stay

MC AOUAR (O. Lyon) 22/90   stay

AMF D. VAN DE BEEK (M. UTD) 24/91   -1 Not sure.

AMF MADDISON (Leicester 24/ 91   stay or +1 Probably stay (for now).

AMF HAVERTZ  (Chelsea) 21/91  stay

AMF GREALISH (Aston Villa) 25/91  stay

LW THURAM (B. Mönchengladbach) 23/90  stay

LW J. HARRISON (Leeds) 24/85   +2 he deserves to be higher rated = such an underrated player.

RW F. TORRES (M. City) 21/90   stay

RW KULUSEVSKI (Juventus) 21/88  stay/+1

CF FELIX (At. Madrid) 21/91   stay

CF OSIMHEN (Napoli) 22/89  stay/+1

CF EN NESYRI (Sevilla) 23/89  +1

CF KEAN (PSG) 21/88   +1 or +2

Welcome Bobbinz86Zena! I have made my edits to your post. No offence intended by editing the team names. ☺

Glad to have you on board m8. I remember back when I (mainly) read through this thread before finnaly joining the group, I should have done it much sooner.

So to those of you who haven't joined us yet - what are u waiting for!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Stuarty said:

Hey guys!

I've got about £8 million to spend and fancy going shopping at the Wonderkid Factory. I was between probably Wirtz, Gravenberch or Cherki. How would you rank these 3?

Are there any others I'd be better trying to get ahead of them?

For some context I have: Fofana, Nuno Mendes, Camavinga, Bellingham, Pedri, Szoboszlai, Reyna, Daka, Veron, M Lacroix, Musah, Arezo and a number of the really young players kindly recommended by you guys.

Thanks in advance.

All very close to call but I would say Wirtz, Cherki/Gravenberch.

2 hours ago, Bobbinz86Zena said:

Hi everyone, I'm new to the forum but I've been playing since 2016.

this is my squad in a competitive world with 35 managers (including 15 Italian friends).

are my predictions right? what do you think?

GK ONANA (Ajax) 25/91   stay

GK GOLLINI (Atalanta) 26/88   stay

GK MVOGO (PSV) 26/86   1 up

Def LENGLET (Barca) 25/92     stay / -1

def DE LIGT (Juventus) 21/92    stay

Def UPAMECANO (RB Lipsia) 22/91    stay

Def KOUNDÉ (Sivilla) 22/90    +1 

Def ROMERO (Atalanta) 23/88 +1

Def DEMIRAL (Juventus) 23/88   stay

Def KOCH (Leeds) 23/88   stay

RB PAVARD (B. Monaco) 25/91   +1 

RB HATEBOER (Atalanta) 27/90   stay

RB PORRO (Sporting CP) 21/86  +1/2

LB CHILWELL (Chelsea) 24/90  +1 

LB R.GOSENS (Atalanta) 26/90  +1

LB DIMARCO (Hellas Verona) 23/85  +2

MF DE JONG (Barca) 23/92  stay

MF ZAKARIA (B. Mönchengladbach) 24/91  stay

MF BENTANCUR (Juventus) 23/91  -1

MC GORETZKA (B. Monaco) 26/93  stay/+1

MC KAMARA (O. Marsiglia) 21/89   +1

MC VALVERDE (Real Madrid9 22/91   stay

MC AOUAR (O. Lione) 22/90   stay

AMF D. VAN DE BEEK (M. UTD) 24/91   -1

AMF MADDISON (leichester) 24/ 91   stay or +1

AMF HAVERTZ  (Chelsea) 21/91  stay

AMF GREALISH (Aston Villa) 25/91  stay

LW THURAM (B. Mönchengladbach) 23/90  stay

LW J. HARRISON (Leeds) 24/85   +2 

RW F. TORRES (M. City) 21/90   stay

RW KULUSEVSKI (Juventus) 21/88  stay

CF FELIX (At. Madrid) 21/91   stay

CF OSIMHEN (Napoli) 22/89  stay

CF EN NESYRI (Sevilla) 23/89  +1

CF KEAN (PSG) 21/88   +1 or +2

Welcome! 😁

Agree with Milanista for the most part.

2 hours ago, Mike0007 said:

Got an offer of getting Caleta Car plus Milot Rashica/Maximilian Arnold/Igor Zubeldia for giving Sofiane Diop.

Take it or leave it?

If take, which duo should I take?

Caleta Car + Maximilian Arnold main reason for Arnold is UCL football next season at Wolfsburg.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, WishShadow said:

Should i give Goretzka for Bernardo Silva? 

Based on performance, yes. But I worry that Goretzka is a little injury prone to achieve his full potential. Silva's problem is a really stacked Man City team. 

5 hours ago, Stuarty said:

Hey guys!

I've got about £8 million to spend and fancy going shopping at the Wonderkid Factory. I was between probably Wirtz, Gravenberch or Cherki. How would you rank these 3?

Are there any others I'd be better trying to get ahead of them?

For some context I have: Fofana, Nuno Mendes, Camavinga, Bellingham, Pedri, Szoboszlai, Reyna, Daka, Veron, M Lacroix, Musah, Arezo and a number of the really young players kindly recommended by you guys.

Thanks in advance.

Wirtz, Cherki, Gravenherch.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Mike0007 said:

Got an offer of getting Caleta Car plus Milot Rashica/Maximilian Arnold/Igor Zubeldia for giving Sofiane Diop.

Take it or leave it? Take.

If take, which duo should I take? Caleta and Maximilian.

I agree with Kieran.

And, if Wolfsburg have a very good run in next seasons CL Maximilian Arnold could even rise further. 

6 hours ago, Stuarty said:

Yeah I was thinking Wirtz too before his rise. Thanks mate!

Thank you Milanista my friend! I have a few of some of the ones you mentioned, but not others, so time to go shopping! 😁

If you have any change 💰 left over after your shop do let me know - I can reccomemd some more cheaper youth that may be worth picking up (even as risers), as long as you don't go into a negative balance though. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

SWIKI REPORT (18/05/21)

Normal service resumed this morning with 16 pages to look through, more Czech Republic and a lot of edits from the USL in America. Some wonderful team names in the USL too, like Long Island Rough Riders 😂

Also worth mentioning that Pape Sarr for Metz is among the edits, potential random rise incoming? I would prefer them to wait till the French review which is only round the corner. Predicted rise 76 -> 82.

Czech Republic 🇨🇿 

FC Pisek - 1
1.FK Pribram - 3
FC Zlin - 1
SK Slavia Praha - 1
SFC Opava - 2
FK Blansko - 1
Ceske Budejovice - 2
SK Benesov - 1

USA 🇺🇸 (USL Championship)

Memphis 901 - 7
Portland Timbers 2 - 1
El Paso Locomotive - 4
Miami FC - 6
Birmingham Legion - 3
Charleston Battery - 4
Colorado Springs Switchback - 2
California United - 1
Las Vegas Lights - 4
North Carolina FC - 2
Austin Bold - 2
Louisville City - 1
Indy Eleven - 2
New York Cosmos - 12
Tampa Bay Rowdies - 3
Tulsa Roughnecks - 4
Saint Louis FC - 3
San Antonio FC - 1
Pittsburg Riverhounds - 3
Sacramento Republic - 1
Phoenix Rising FC - 2
Orange County SC - 2 
OKC Energy - 4
Oakland Roots - 4
FC Tucson - 2
Forward Madison - 3
North Texas SC - 1
Tormenta FC - 2
Long Island Rough Riders - 1
Jacksonville Armada - 2
Richmond Kickers - 4
Greenville Triumph SC - 1

Thanks for reading and have a great day

Cheers Kieran 😁

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Kieran_S91 said:

SWIKI REPORT (18/05/21)

Normal service resumed this morning with 16 pages to look through, more Czech Republic and a lot of edits from the USL in America. Some wonderful team names in the USL too, like Long Island Rough Riders 😂

Also worth mentioning that Pape Sarr for Metz is among the edits, potential random rise incoming? I would prefer them to wait till the French review which is only round the corner. Predicted rise 76 -> 82.

Czech Republic 🇨🇿 

FC Pisek - 1
1.FK Pribram - 3
FC Zlin - 1
SK Slavia Praha - 1
SFC Opava - 2
FK Blansko - 1
Ceske Budejovice - 2
SK Benesov - 1

USA 🇺🇸 (USL Championship)

Memphis 901 - 7
Portland Timbers 2 - 1
El Paso Locomotive - 4
Miami FC - 6
Birmingham Legion - 3
Charleston Battery - 4
Colorado Springs Switchback - 2
California United - 1
Las Vegas Lights - 4
North Carolina FC - 2
Austin Bold - 2
Louisville City - 1
Indy Eleven - 2
New York Cosmos - 12
Tampa Bay Rowdies - 3
Tulsa Roughnecks - 4
Saint Louis FC - 3
San Antonio FC - 1
Pittsburg Riverhounds - 3
Sacramento Republic - 1
Phoenix Rising FC - 2
Orange County SC - 2 
OKC Energy - 4
Oakland Roots - 4
FC Tucson - 2
Forward Madison - 3
North Texas SC - 1
Tormenta FC - 2
Long Island Rough Riders - 1
Jacksonville Armada - 2
Richmond Kickers - 4
Greenville Triumph SC - 1

Thanks for reading and have a great day

Cheers Kieran 😁

Pape Matar Sarr has a position change today :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/16/2021 at 4:03 PM, Kieran_S91 said:

I would give Saul + Traore, forget the minutes played Goretzka is a better player than Saul in my opinion.

Yes I would pay max for him. I would like to think he would move on from Palace eventually but at the time being he’s in a good place with game time etc.

would you do Neco williams and cash for Eze? struggling to get the deal done, he wanted Nuno mendes and cash for Eze but I soon put that offer in its place! Its weird he has asked for Neco as he wants a left back he said in previous message!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, TaielAlejandro said:

buy vlahovic?

sell romagnoli and buy pau torres? (or tapsoba?)

Yes, I would bid max if needed to get Vlahovic.

I would keep Romagnoli at the moment.

5 minutes ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

would you do Neco williams and cash for Eze? struggling to get the deal done, he wanted Nuno mendes and cash for Eze but I soon put that offer in its place! Its weird he has asked for Neco as he wants a left back he said in previous message!

Yeah, Neco Williams is good but for me he will forever be in TAA’s shadow at Liverpool so I think that’s a fair deal.

23 minutes ago, thorgan lesar said:

Pape Matar Sarr has a position change today :)

Cheers, never noticed that 😊

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, LauraAFCA said:

Zakaria for Odegaard and Lisandro Martinez? 

Duo

2 minutes ago, Hunter878 said:

Duvan Zapata 92? 

Unlikely in my opinion.

2 minutes ago, Fotis1992 said:

Lewa +1 if he break the record?

Potentially

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, TaielAlejandro said:

buy vlahovic?

sell romagnoli and buy pau torres? (or tapsoba?)

Vlahovic - Agree buy up to max price

Tempted but keep Romagnali

2 hours ago, WishShadow said:

Neuer stay?

Yes

1 hour ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

would you do Neco williams and cash for Eze? struggling to get the deal done, he wanted Nuno mendes and cash for Eze but I soon put that offer in its place! Its weird he has asked for Neco as he wants a left back he said in previous message!

Neco will probably be good but at this point in time Eze looks Eze the best

58 minutes ago, LauraAFCA said:

Zakaria for Odegaard and Lisandro Martinez? 

Duo for me

Keep this thread Free of Hostilities please. @Toby S I whole heartedly agree but I'd like @Kev to look at this please Kev

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Hunter878 said:

Duvan Zapata 92? 

It's unlikely (atm) at a cap restricted team. Considering It took Papu Gomez quite sometime to break the cap at Atalanta - It'll probably be the same for the other (few) Atalanta players as well, unless Atalanta can finish well season after season + progress further in the CL. 

6 hours ago, Fotis1992 said:

Lewa +1 if he break the record?

Possibly. He's been soooo gooooal good this season. 

Edited by Milanista1
re-worded.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...