Kev 721 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 4 hours ago, Tharanidharan said: Who are all expecting -1/-2 in winter review? Kindly provide "YES/NO" and if YES, "-1/-2/-3" for each player. 1.) Miranda deserves to stay but will probably get -1 2.) Felipe Luis stay 3.) Dani Alves -1 4.) Milner stay 5.) Iniesta -2 but not sure when he'll get reviewed next 6.) Rossi -1 at least, possibly -2 but that would be harsh since he got -3 in the summer 7.) Fernandinho stay 8.) Robben -1 9.) Zlatan -1 10.) Giroud -1 Thanks in advance ☺ My estimates in bold. 2 hours ago, Mickbor59 said: Courtois stay 93? If it's yes sell courtois and buy becker(+1?) Or moraes(+1) or kepa(+1)??? He'll stay for now but I'd probably keep him for now and see how he does this season. 1 1 Tharanidharan and Soccahappy reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Middle_Finger 657 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 2 hours ago, Mickbor59 said: Courtois stay 93? If it's yes sell courtois and buy becker(+1?) Or moraes(+1) or kepa(+1)??? Curtois will stay but if you have the opportunity to buy Becker or Moraes absolutely go for it. 1 Soccahappy reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nofoff 195 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 6 hours ago, Tharanidharan said: 1.) Bellerin vs Vrsaljko? 2.) I could sell one in Seri - Illarramendi - Allan - Who should it be? 3.) Perisic vs Forsberg? 4.) Rodrigo Moreno vs Immobile? 5. a.) Hector vs Rose? 5. b.) Is Hector expecting -1 in upcoming review? 6.) Is Otamendi - a safe option to buy? 7.) Keep or Sell - a.) Pablo Sarabia b.) Wilshere c.) Lanzini d.) Cutrone e.) Dolberg Thanks in advance ☺ 5 hours ago, Abdul Rahman Khalifeh said: Exactly the same as Abdul but I'd also keep hold of Sarabia. Having a good season so far 2 Soccahappy and Tharanidharan reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Divir 46 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 On 10/25/2016 at 7:13 AM, Sir Rahul said: GERMANY BUNDESLIGA Bayern: Kimmich +1 to 93 Dortmund: Alcacer +1 to 90 Akanji +1 to 89 Diallo +1 to 88 Wolf +1 to 88 Sancho +3 to 86 Zagadou +4 to 84 Bruun Larsen +7 to 82 Schalke: Burgstaller +1 to 89- yes Kehrer +2 to 88- yes Harit +1 to 88- yes Stambouli +1 to 88- yes McKennie +2 to 80- +5 to 83 Fahrmann +1 to 90- nope Oczipka +1 to 89- nope Caligiuri +1 to 90 Riether -1 to 82 Reese +2 to 80 Nubel +2 to 80 Hemmerich +1 to 78 Hoffenheim: Uth +1 to 89- yes Vogt +1 to 89- yes Kaderabek +1 to 88- yes Schulz +1 to 87- yes Grillitsch +1 to 87- +2 to 88 Geiger +4 to 86- +3 to 85 Akpoguma +1 to 84- +2 to 85 Polanski -1 to 86- -2 to 85 Posch +5 to 82- +3 to 80 Baumann +1 to 89- nope Hubner +1 to 89- nope Kramaric +1 to 90 Amiri +1 to 89 Gnabry +1 to 89 Gimber +3 to 80 Mees +2 to 80 Kobel +1 to 78 Maric -2 to 78 Hack +1 to 77 Leverkusen: Tah +1 to 90- yes Bailey +2 to 89- yes Bellarabi -1 to 89- yes Retsos +1 to 87- yes Havertz +1 to 87- +2 to 88 Volland +1 to 90- nope Wendell +1 to 90- nope Kohr +1 to 88- nope Baumgartlinger -1 to 88- nope Ozcan -2 to 83 Leipzig: Gulacsi +1 to 89- yes Orban +1 to 89- yes Demme +1 to 89- yes Klostermann +2 to 87- yes Augustin +1 to 87- yes Laimer +1 to 86- yes Upamecano +1 to 88- +2 to 89 Konate +2 to 82- +3 to 83 Halstenberg +1 to 89- nope Lookman +3 to 85 Coltorti -3 to 80 Janelt +2 to 78 Diawusie +3 to 76 Stuttgart: Ascacibar +1 to 88- yes Baumgartl +2 to 87- yes Akolo +1 to 86- yes Pavard +1 to 87- +2 to 88 Ozcan +2 to 82- +3 to 83 Kaminski +1 to 86- nope Asano +1 to 84- nope Brekalo +2 to 84 Thommy +5 to 83 Sosa +4 to 82 Mangala +2 to 82 Werner -1 to 82 Grahl -2 to 78 Frankfurt: Hradecky +1 to 89- yes Haller +1 to 89- yes Chandler +1 to 87- yes Falette +1 to 87- yes Gacinovic +1 to 87- yes De Guzman -1 to 86- yes Wolf +4 to 86- +5 to 87 Rebic +1 to 86- +2 to 87 Jovic +1 to 83- +3 to 85 Boateng +1 to 89- nope Abraham +1 to 88- nope Salcedo +1 to 87- nope Mascarell +1 to 88 Fabian -1 to 87 Meier -2 to 86 Da Costa +2 to 85 Hrgota -1 to 85 Barkok +2 to 80 Zimmerman -2 to 80 Regasel -2 to 78 Amiri -4 to 63 Gladbach: Ginter +1 to 90- yes Elvedi +1 to 88- yes Zakaria +1 to 88- yes Herrmann -1 to 88- yes Cuisance +3 to 80- +5 to 82 Oxford +1 to 78- +3 to 80 Hazard +1 to 90- nope Jantschke -1 to 87- nope Wendt -1 to 88 Johnson -1 to 88 Traore -1 to 87 Strobl -1 to 86 Bobadilla -2 to 85 Sippel -2 to 83 Hertha Berlin: Weiser +1 to 89- yes Stark +1 to 89- yes Rekik +1 to 87- yes Selke +1 to 87- yes Ibisevic -1 to 87- yes Torunanigha +2 to 82- yes Lazaro +1 to 86- +2 to 87 Maier +5 to 82- +6 to 83 Jarstein +1 to 88- nope Skjelbred +1 to 88- nope Leckie +1 to 87- nope Klunter +2 to 85- nope Esswein -1 to 86 Kraft -2 to 83 Schieber -2 to 83 Mittelstadt +2 to 82 Baak +3 to 73 Dardai +3 to 73 Bremen: Veljkovic +2 to 87- yes M. Eggestein +2 to 87- yes Kainz +1 to 86- yes Pavlenka +2 to 87- +3 to 88 Friedl +2 to 77- +5 to 80 Junuzovic -1 to 87- nope Bargfrede +1 to 86- nope Bauer +1 to 86- nope Augustinsson +1 to 88 Langkamp -1 to 86 Rashica +1 to 85 Gondorf -1 to 84 Caldirola -2 to 83 J. Eggestein +1 to 78 Kruska -4 to 77 Pfitzner -4 to 76 Jakob +2 to 75 Feulner -5 to 75 Duffner -5 to 70 Augsburg: Gregoritsch +1 to 88- yes Finnbogason +1 to 88- yes Danso +2 to 84- yes Framberger +2 to 80- yes Max +1 to 88- +2 to 89 Khedira +2 to 86- +1 to 85 Opare +1 to 86- -2 to 83 Moravek -1 to 84- -2 to 83 Gouweleeuw +1 to 88- nope Caiuby +1 to 87- nope Heller +1 to 86- nope Ji -1 to 85 Kacar -1 to 83 Teigl -1 to 82 Callsen-Bracker -2 to 80 Janker -2 to 80 Parker -2 to 80 Geiger -3 to 80 Richter +2 to 77 Jakob +2 to 75 Hannover: Anton +2 to 87- yes Klaus +1 to 86- yes Fullkrug +2 to 86- +3 to 87 Bebou +1 to 86- +2 to 87 Fossum +2 to 84- +1 to 83 Schmiedebach -1 to 85- -3 to 83 Ostrzolek +1 to 87- nope Harnik +1 to 87- nope Tschauner +1 to 86- nope Bakalorz +1 to 86- nope Felipe +1 to 83- nope Sane +2 to 89 Esser -1 to 84 Bech -2 to 82 Hubers +3 to 73 Mainz: Diallo +2 to 87- yes Quaison +1 to 85- yes Serdar +2 to 84- yes Holtmann +1 to 83- yes Berggreen +1 to 83- yes De Jong -1 to 86- -2 to 85 Zentner +5 to 83- +4 to 82 Muller +1 to 77- +2 to 78 Brosinski +1 to 87- nope Gbamin +1 to 88 Donati -1 to 87 Adler -1 to 86 Ujah -1 to 86 Bussmann -2 to 83 Rodriguez -2 to 83 Bungert -2 to 83 Halimi +2 to 82 Seydel +1 to 78 Baku +5 to 75 Korczowski -2 to 75 Freiburg: Soyuncu +1 to 88- yes Petersen +1 to 88- yes Gunter +1 to 87- yes Koch +3 to 85- yes Kleindienst +1 to 83- yes Holer +1 to 83- yes Stenzel +2 to 87- +1 to 86 Schwolow +1 to 88- nope Haberer +1 to 87- nope Hofler +1 to 87- nope Terrazzino +1 to 86- nope Lienhart +1 to 84- nope Abrashi -1 to 85 Ignjovski -1 to 83 Flekken +2 to 82 Gikiewicz -1 to 82 Meffert -1 to 82 Kammerbauer +2 to 80 Neidermeier -3 to 80 Guedes -2 to 78 Klandt -3 to 75 Wolfsburg: Didavi +1 to 88- yes William +1 to 86- yes Uduokhai +2 to 85- yes Casteels +1 to 87- +2 to 88 Mehmedi -1 to 87- nope Itter +1 to 78- nope Bruma -1 to 88 Gerhardt -1 to 88 Knoche -1 to 87 Blaszczykowski -1 to 87 Wood -1 to 86 Verhaegh -1 to 86 Jung -2 to 83 Osimhen +2 to 78 Hamburger: Holtby -1 to 87- yes Hahn -1 to 87- yes Muller -1 to 87- yes Arp +3 to 80- yes Ito +1 to 77- +4 to 80 Jung +1 to 87- nope Diekmeier +1 to 87- nope Mathenia +1 to 86- nope Ekdal -1 to 86- nope Van Drongelen +1 to 83- nope Papadopoulos -1 to 88 Pollersbeck +1 to 83 Schipplock -2 to 83 Salihovic -3 to 80 Steinmann +1 to 78 Thoelke -2 to 78 Gouaida -2 to 78 Rexhbecaj +2 to 75 Koln: Hoger -1 to 86- yes Maroh -1 to 85- yes Clemens -1 to 85- yes Lehmann +1 to 87- -1 to 85 Ozcan +4 to 86- +2 to 84 Guirassy +2 to 84- +1 to 83 Hector -1 to 90- nope Jojic +1 to 86- nope Horn +1 to 84- nope Risse -1 to 86 Olkowski -1 to 84 Prokoph -2 to 75 Laux -2 to 73 Hornig -3 to 73 Kovacic -5 to 73 What about Hakimi? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nofoff 195 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 6 hours ago, TMCosta said: Ok TY im just gonna exchange them to make some cash Yeah I'd prob still do the same haha 1 TMCosta reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Sir Rahul 4,041 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 6 hours ago, Tharanidharan said: 1.) Bellerin vs Vrsaljko? 2.) I could sell one in Seri - Illarramendi - Allan - Who should it be? 3.) Perisic vs Forsberg? 4.) Rodrigo Moreno vs Immobile? 5. a.) Hector vs Rose? 5. b.) Is Hector expecting -1 in upcoming review? 6.) Is Otamendi - a safe option to buy? 7.) Keep or Sell - a.) Pablo Sarabia b.) Wilshere c.) Lanzini d.) Cutrone e.) Dolberg Thanks in advance ☺ 5 hours ago, Tharanidharan said: Who are all expecting -1/-2 in winter review? Kindly provide "YES/NO" and if YES, "-1/-2/-3" for each player. 1.) Miranda -1 2.) Felipe Luis stay 3.) Dani Alves -1 4.) Milner stay/+1 5.) Iniesta -2 whenever they review 6.) Rossi doesn't matter tbh 7.) Fernandinho stay 8.) Robben -1 9.) Zlatan no winter review for him 10.) Giroud -1 Thanks in advance ☺ 5 hours ago, EvaGreen said: why China stop updating? idk 5 hours ago, TMCosta said: Hahaha nice...care to justify? On another team (buffon, carvajal, varane, koulibaly, ...., casemiro, verratti, o. dembele, mertens, di maria, firmino): This are my LB: Hector Kolasinac Bernat Max Saracchi Firpo Ballo Touré What to do? I clearly need an update...Anyone of this list is going 92+ in a near future? Marcelo and Alex Sandro are almost impossible...currently im trying M. Alonso... none of those are 92+ to me 4 hours ago, JAMancini said: Marcos Alonso or Gaya? Alonso 4 hours ago, Mickbor59 said: Courtois stay 93? If it's yes sell courtois and buy becker(+1?) Or moraes(+1) or kepa(+1)??? yes, Allison stay, Ederson +1, Kepa stay for now 3 hours ago, liamgriff said: Papu Gomez or Vardy? Papu 2 hours ago, Middle_Finger said: More than 1 answer would be great. If you could buy only one - Gaston Pereiro(PSV): Dutch league will get reviewed some time around Feb-March so a wait of 4-5 months(that's 1 season in SM). Ascacibar(Stuttgart): Getting good hype but his club is languishing at the bottom. Tousart(Lyon): Seems it's the season of Ndombele. Haven't watched a great deal of him. GRILLITSCH(Hoffenheim): Club not doing well and didn't see him play. correct 2 minutes ago, Divir said: What about Hakimi? will see later 3 TMCosta, Middle_Finger and Soccahappy reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Sir Rahul 4,041 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 Mawson or Gunter? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nofoff 195 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 5 hours ago, TMCosta said: Hahaha nice...care to justify? On another team (buffon, carvajal, varane, koulibaly, ...., casemiro, verratti, o. dembele, mertens, di maria, firmino): This are my LB: Hector Kolasinac Bernat Max Saracchi Firpo Ballo Touré What to do? I clearly need an update...Anyone of this list is going 92+ in a near future? Marcelo and Alex Sandro are almost impossible...currently im trying M. Alonso... I would say that out of your options Max and Firpo have the highest ceiling long term. I would definitely keep hold of the pair of them. Alonso is a good shout if you want someone who's a probable 92 this season 4 hours ago, JAMancini said: Marcos Alonso or Gaya? Alonso 3 hours ago, liamgriff said: Papu Gomez or Vardy? Maybe Vardy by a hair but both good options for older forwards 2 hours ago, Middle_Finger said: More than 1 answer would be great. If you could buy only one - Gaston Pereiro(PSV): Dutch league will get reviewed some time around Feb-March so a wait of 4-5 months(that's 1 season in SM). Ascacibar(Stuttgart): Getting good hype but his club is languishing at the bottom. Tousart(Lyon): Seems it's the season of Ndombele. Haven't watched a great deal of him. GRILLITSCH(Hoffenheim): Club not doing well and didn't see him play. Ascacibar or Tousart for me although I have to admit I haven't seen much of Pereiro at all 8 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said: Mawson or Gunter? Was going to ask which Gunter but I'd choose Mawson regardless 1 2 Sir Rahul, Middle_Finger and TMCosta reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Middle_Finger 657 Report post Posted October 17, 2018 1 hour ago, Sir Rahul said: Mawson or Gunter? Mawson 1 Sir Rahul reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
tuanjakn09 4 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 Is Panagiotis Retsos worth buying? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TMCosta 1,192 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 15 hours ago, Abdul Rahman Khalifeh said: Ludwig's a full Swedish national team player, his team is currently in the Bundesliga top 4. He's two years younger than Tagliafico and is already on the radar of a number of prem clubs. I'm not big THAT big on Tagliafico. I'd get rid of Hector and Kolasinac. Bernat has a chance to hit 91 given that he's starting for PSG with Kurzawa out for the year. Probably the closest one to Bernat. Alonso and Mendy probs hit 92 end of year. Robertson and Gaya will rise, obvs not to 92. Kolasinac? I still have faith in him...he is injured right? Will he drop? 12 hours ago, Middle_Finger said: More than 1 answer would be great. If you could buy only one - Gaston Pereiro(PSV): Dutch league will get reviewed some time around Feb-March so a wait of 4-5 months(that's 1 season in SM). Ascacibar(Stuttgart): Getting good hype but his club is languishing at the bottom. Tousart(Lyon): Seems it's the season of Ndombele. Haven't watched a great deal of him. GRILLITSCH(Hoffenheim): Club not doing well and didn't see him play. Tousart for me 2 Soccahappy and Middle_Finger reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Beatz 12 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 Andreas pereira for Tanguy Ndombele? What is the potential for both these players? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TMCosta 1,192 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 2 minutes ago, Beatz said: Andreas pereira for Tanguy Ndombele? What is the potential for both these players? Ndombele no doubt 2 1 nofoff, Beatz and Middle_Finger reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Beatz 12 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 Also have barella who is available. So barella or Tanguy Ndombele? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mister keegan 111 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 Which of these 89 rated goalkeepers has the best chance of going to 90 next? Perin, Strakosha, Gulácsi, Neto I have Strakosha. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nofoff 195 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 29 minutes ago, Beatz said: Also have barella who is available. So barella or Tanguy Ndombele? Still Ndombele 18 minutes ago, mister keegan said: Which of these 89 rated goalkeepers has the best chance of going to 90 next? Perin, Strakosha, Gulácsi, Neto I have Strakosha. Strakosha for me 7 hours ago, tuanjakn09 said: Is Panagiotis Retsos worth buying? Looked great to me a year or so ago and was very good in the Bundesliga last season. There was a lot of hype about him a while back but he seems to have gone totally off the radar recently. Was thinking of selling him myself as there are probably players who are more sure to rise in the near future but for some reason I still kept hold of him. As far as I can tell he's made 0 apps this season (no idea why) so I may look elsewhere if I were you. On a related note, does anybody who's deep into German football actually know why he (RETSOS) isn't playing? Tried to google it myself but can only find old google articles and no news about injuries etc. TIA 3 1 TMCosta, Beatz, Middle_Finger and 1 other reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
JAMancini 162 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 Nicolas Pepe or Saint-Maximin? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nofoff 195 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 15 minutes ago, JAMancini said: Nicolas Pepe or Saint-Maximin? Pepe 2 Middle_Finger and TMCosta reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Soccahappy 4,761 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 1 hour ago, nofoff said: Still Ndombele Strakosha for me Looked great to me a year or so ago and was very good in the Bundesliga last season. There was a lot of hype about him a while back but he seems to have gone totally off the radar recently. Was thinking of selling him myself as there are probably players who are more sure to rise in the near future but for some reason I still kept hold of him. As far as I can tell he's made 0 apps this season (no idea why) so I may look elsewhere if I were you. On a related note, does anybody who's deep into German football actually know why he (RETSOS) isn't playing? Tried to google it myself but can only find old google articles and no news about injuries etc. TIA Hi All, It was back in August Retsos got injured and it's past the 6weeks they forecast at the time:- "The youngster suffered a heavy blow to the quadriceps during pre-season training with Bayer Leverkusen and according to the initial medical evaluation, he was diagnosed with tendonitis in the right thigh. The injury is expected to sideline the defender for at least six weeks." 1 nofoff reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nofoff 195 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 1 minute ago, Soccahappy said: Hi All, It was back in August Retsos got injured and it's past the 6weeks they forecast at the time:- "The youngster suffered a heavy blow to the quadriceps during pre-season training with Bayer Leverkusen and according to the initial medical evaluation, he was diagnosed with tendonitis in the right thigh. The injury is expected to sideline the defender for at least six weeks.@ Brilliant, cheers for that mate 1 Soccahappy reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
thorgan lesar 812 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 Are you guys absolute sure Leon Bailey can be 92+ in the future ? Be honest please. I stil have a doubt to sell Oyarzabal (when he plays in my team he has always a goal or an assist...) ... 😕 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
AlfonDaddy 129 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 48 minutes ago, thorgan lesar said: Are you guys absolute sure Leon Bailey can be 92+ in the future ? Be honest please. I stil have a doubt to sell Oyarzabal (when he plays in my team he has always a goal or an assist...) ... 😕 Quite difficult to guarantee that about any player really but if he maintains his steady development and gets a “big”move then 92 is realistic I’d say. Be at least a year and a half, probably longer to actually get there tho 1 TMCosta reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
thorgan lesar 812 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 43 minutes ago, AlfonDaddy said: Quite difficult to guarantee that about any player really but if he maintains his steady development and gets a “big”move then 92 is realistic I’d say. Be at least a year and a half, probably longer to actually get there tho I already know that I'm going to sell Youri Tielemans (was my first choice for the position "8"). So I made that choice. I know it's difficult to say that. I know Bailey from KRC Genk, but I didn't saw Oyarzabal playing enough to make that choice. I can't make that choice just by watching some videos. So if there is a guy from Spain here that can give his opinion I would be glad. Or someone who follows Oyarzabal very closely… Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TMCosta 1,192 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 27 minutes ago, thorgan lesar said: I already know that I'm going to sell Youri Tielemans (was my first choice for the position "8"). So I made that choice. I know it's difficult to say that. I know Bailey from KRC Genk, but I didn't saw Oyarzabal playing enough to make that choice. I can't make that choice just by watching some videos. So if there is a guy from Spain here that can give his opinion I would be glad. Or someone who follows Oyarzabal very closely… Oyarzabal needs a move...and i dont see that happen in a near future (maybe never). Bailey will leave first and problably will raise first. Meanwhile was a sub in the last game so...wait for the next one. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
thorgan lesar 812 Report post Posted October 18, 2018 @TMCosta How are SL Benfica, FC Porto and Sporting Lissabon this season ? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
