Sir Rahul 3,987 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 On 10/31/2018 at 6:51 AM, jagerbob said: should I sell eric dier for adren rabbiot? both same rating, similar age. I think rabbiot might get a winter increase. but hes gonna leave PSG next summer according to reports. yes On 10/31/2018 at 4:47 PM, Mickbor59 said: Brozovic or zielinski? Brozo 23 hours ago, francesco said: Joe Gomez +2/3 ? check my preds 22 hours ago, EnglishPirlo said: Looks like Mexico will be reviewed after Brazil. nice 22 hours ago, Soccahappy said: I'll try to answer TL & MF:- My spreadsheet (1000 players+) has evolved over maybe 6/7years. It basically tries to predict how SM decides who gets rises and who doesn't. So I kept records of minutes played as percentage of the possible minutes to be played & noticed how much a 90 rated player needed as opposed to a 70 rated player ( and every rating in between). It wasn't exactly 100% correct but it was close. I then noticed that top clubs Real Madrid etc needed less minutes than say Huddersfield or even Everton (the Pecking Order) and I tried to simulate that too. This improved the predictions again but it is an evolving changing thing like Leicester might be near relegation 1 season & then Top the next, so it's variable by season to season. I have had a lot of success with it & my 3 clubs now have around 1.8 billion each and hit the maximum around 2.1Billion most seasons at some time b4 I start buying again (251Max). SM miss a lot every review like I know this player should definitely get a rise and they miss him. It almost seems like SM do it purposely to make it harder for such as us to make money buying & selling. Also minutes for players over 89/90 are less important than performances & winning titles, scoring goals, assists etc. I've recently started trying to add this to my spreadsheet in a small way but it is not as accurate as yet & might not be for years. The higher percentage in the last column is the final predictor about how safe it is, at this particular point in time but doesn't account for SM messing up or just missing some players altogether. Nothing is 100% but I try to improve each season.... I think such as Sir R & many others on here must work in a similar way, I'd be interested in their views but they may not be willing to share their secrets????? chief this is it 21 hours ago, jonhyscp said: When is the Eredivisie review? March 19 hours ago, EnglishPirlo said: Regarding that, anyone think there is a case for an out of schedule increase for De Ligt? He is massively underrated right now. always a chance of a random rise 18 hours ago, tupac_healy said: Can Sergio Asenjo get a 90 rating? Seems a good keeper at a relatively big club Villarreal are struggling, so no 18 hours ago, Gaelgoir said: Apologies for asking a transfer related question. But would people swap dybala and 39m to get a chance at signing mbappe. He will go for max (79m) in this competitive but low money world. yes 13 hours ago, th3stain said: @rahul Stefan Savic won't drop. He plays a lot for Atletico. Only reason he has few games this season so far is due to injury. He has started every game when he wasn't injured. noted 12 hours ago, Jh4rman said: Will Lukas Hradecky get 90? no 12 hours ago, Jh4rman said: Is there a chance Joe Gomez can go straight to 90? 89 first imo 10 hours ago, JAMancini said: Is Sergi Roberto in his maximum level? (91) yes 9 hours ago, Kev said: Is there much chance of Antonio Moya (Atletico Madrid) getting a rise? He made a couple of appearances for the senior side but seems to have disappeared. Keep or sell? sell 7 hours ago, The punch said: Nikola Milenkovic +3 ? see my preds 3 hours ago, Dasylver said: Tony lopes...keep or sell? Carlos soler....keep or sell? idk keep for now 45 minutes ago, Tharanidharan said: @Sir Rahul you didn't give preds for Barkley and RLC. What do you think? Both +1? for a few games? nope 1 3 Kev, Soccahappy, Gaelgoir and 1 other reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Sir Rahul 3,987 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 On 4/3/2017 at 11:26 AM, Sir Rahul said: BRAZIL SÉRIE A Sao Paulo: Militao +3 to 85- yes Caio -1 to 88 Reinaldo +1 to 86 Hudson +1 to 86 Anderson Martins +1 to 86 Arboleda +1 to 86 Alves +3 to 85 Sidao +2 to 85 Regis Souza +2 to 80 Liziero +8 to 78 Palmeiras: Henrique +1 to 87 Melo +1 to 87 Scarpa -1 to 87 Carlos +3 to 86 Barbosa +1 to 86 Dracena +1 to 86 Vanderlei Jean -1 to 86 Jailson +2 to 85 Thiago Santos +1 to 85 Guerra -1 to 85 Hyoran +3 to 83 Gremio: Kannemann +1 to 87 Everton Soares +1 to 87 Cicero +1 to 87 Cortez +1 to 86 Maicon +1 to 86 Leo Moura +2 to 85 Bressan +2 to 85 Jael +2 to 84 Leonardo Gomes +1 to 77 Internacional: Rithely -1 to 85- yes Guerrero -2 to 87 Dourado +1 to 86 Pottker +1 to 86 Moledo +1 to 86 Nico Lopez +1 to 86 Patrick +2 to 85 D'Alessandro -2 to 85 Camilo -1 to 84 Uendel -1 to 84 Iago +10 to 83 Leismann Fabiano +1 to 83 Flamengo: Paqueta +3 to 86- +5 to 88 Rodinei +2 to 86 Rene +1 to 86 Cuellar +1 to 86 Arao -1 to 86 Romulo -1 to 85 Duarte +7 to 84 Ederson -1 to 82 Thuler +2 to 77 Jean Lucas +5 to 75 Atletico Mineiro: Welison +2 to 80- +4 to 82 Gedeao Luan +1 to 86 Franca Gabriel +1 to 85 Iago Maidana +5 to 83 Aparecido Emerson +10 to 80 Blanco +3 to 80 Cruzeiro: Sobis -1 to 86- yes Manoel -1 to 85- yes Raniel +4 to 82- yes Dede +1 to 86- +2 to 87 Rafinha +1 to 86- -2 to 83 Leo +1 to 87 Egidio +1 to 87 Robinho +1 to 87 Romero +1 to 87 Silva +1 to 87 Edilson +1 to 86 Cabral +1 to 86 Mancuello -1 to 86 Fred -1 to 86 Ezequiel +1 to 84 Santos: Alison +1 to 86- yes Verissimo +1 to 86- yes Ruiz -1 to 87 Sasha +1 to 86 Mota +1 to 85 Copete -1 to 85 Rodrygo Goes +2 to 84 Pituca +5 to 83 Guedes +1 to 83 Corinthians: Ralf -1 to 86- yes Pedrinho +5 to 85- yes Mantuan +7 to 80- yes Santos +3 to 80- yes Vital +2 to 84- +3 to 85 Henrique +1 to 88 Avelar +1 to 86 Henrique +1 to 84 Walter +1 to 84 Sheik -2 to 80 Augusto +2 to 75 Fluminense: Gilberto +1 to 84- yes Richard +6 to 83- yes Ayrton +5 to 83- yes Pedro +5 to 83- +7 to 85 Jadson +2 to 84- +1 to 83 Alessandro +1 to 78- +5 to 82 Ibanez +6 to 76- +10 to 80 Everaldo +1 to 76- +5 to 80 Dyego +1 to 76- +5 to 80 Cesar +2 to 85 Atletico Paranaense: Pablo +2 to 85- yes Heleno -1 to 85- yes Gusmao Guilherme -1 to 85- yes Santos +6 to 83- yes Renan +6 to 82- yes Ivaldo +5 to 82- yes Marcinho +2 to 82- yes Veiga +2 to 84- +1 to 83 Pereira +2 to 80- +4 to 82 Guimaraes +8 to 78- +10 to 80 Nikao +1 to 86 Botafago: Matheus Fernandes +3 to 85- yes Rabello +2 to 85- yes Lindoso +1 to 85- yes Moises +4 to 82- yes Fernando +2 to 84- +1 to 83 Lima -1 to 84- -2 to 83 Marcinho +5 to 83- +4 to 82 Saulo +8 to 78- +10 to 80 Bochecha +1 to 76- +5 to 80 Carli +2 to 85- nope Valencia +1 to 84- nope Jefferson -1 to 84- nope Fernandez -1 to 84- nope Bahia: Rafael +1 to 86- yes Clayton -1 to 85- yes Nilton -2 to 85- yes Vinicius +1 to 84- yes Allione -1 to 84- yes Friedrich +1 to 83- yes Pele +2 to 84- +1 to 83 Edson -1 to 84- -2 to 83 Gregore +7 to 80- +9 to 82 Brumado +3 to 73- +8 to 78 Everson +2 to 75- +8 to 78 Antonio +3 to 73- +6 to 76 Mena -2 to 85- nope Fonseca +1 to 84- nope Elton +1 to 84- nope Jackson -1 to 82- nope Vasco da Gama: Motta -1 to 84- yes Desabato +1 to 83- yes Gustavo +2 to 82- yes Castan -2 to 85- -1 to 86 Pikachu +1 to 84- +2 to 85 Fabricio -1 to 84- -2 to 83 Andrey +3 to 78- +5 to 80 Bruno Silva +2 to 78- +4 to 80 Graca +7 to 76- +8 to 78 Cosendey +3 to 73- +6 to 76 Augusto -1 to 85- nope Rios +1 to 84- nope Wagner -1 to 84- nope Maxi Lopez -1 to 84- nope Kelvin -1 to 84- nope America Mineiro: Moura -1 to 83- yes Wesley -1 to 83- yes Paulao -2 to 83- yes Juninho +2 to 82- yes Ricardo +1 to 82- yes Messias +3 to 83- +2 to 82 Jory +5 to 75- +6 to 76 Marquinhos -1 to 82- nope Aderlan +2 to 80- nope Vitoria: Arouca -2 to 83- yes Kanu -1 to 82- yes Ronaldo +8 to 78- yes Rios -2 to 83- -1 to 84 Rodrigo Andrade +1 to 78- +3 to 80 Jefferson +1 to 83- nope Ramon +1 to 83- nope Wallyson -1 to 82- nope Andre Lima -1 to 82- nope Ceara: Renan -2 to 83- yes Otavio +4 to 82- yes Richardson +4 to 82- yes Fabinho -1 to 82- yes Arthur +4 to 80- yes Ricardinho +1 to 80- yes Lucas +2 to 78- yes Everson +4 to 82- +5 to 83 Carvalho +1 to 78- +3 to 80 Pires -1 to 82- -3 to 80 Valdo +1 to 77- +2 to 78 Valoura Juninho -1 to 82- nope Alves +2 to 80- nope Bueno -2 to 80- nope Elton -2 to 80- nope Reina -2 to 80- nope Ken -2 to 80- nope Arnaldo -2 to 80- nope Romario -2 to 80- nope Chapecoense: Douglas -1 to 85- yes Bruno Pacheco +2 to 82- yes Osman -1 to 82- yes Junior Santos -1 to 82- yes Apodi -1 to 84- -2 to 83 Marcio Araujo -1 to 84- -2 to 83 Helio Neto -2 to 80- -4 to 78 Canteros -1 to 84- nope Jandrei +1 to 83- nope Thyere +1 to 83- nope Carlos Eduardo -1 to 83- nope Sport Recife: Bastos -1 to 85- yes Ernando -1 to 84- yes Sander +1 to 83- yes Rogerio -1 to 83- yes Durval -1 to 82- yes Neto Moura +2 to 80- yes Ortiz +1 to 77- yes Hernane -2 to 82- -1 to 83 Jair +1 to 76- +2 to 77 Marlone -1 to 84- nope Parana: Carlos -1 to 83- yes Maicosuel -1 to 83- yes Eduardo -2 to 83- yes Ortigoza -2 to 80- yes Junior +2 to 78- yes Rayan +1 to 78- yes Santana +4 to 77- yes Thiago Rodrigues +3 to 77- +4 to 78 Grampola +1 to 77- +2 to 78 Jhonny Lucas +3 to 76- +4 to 77 Caio Henrique +2 to 82- nope Reis -1 to 82- nope Itaperuna -2 to 78- nope Jesiel +1 to 76- nope some big rises these few days Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Sir Rahul 3,987 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 On 10/25/2016 at 12:12 PM, Sir Rahul said: ITALY SERIE A Juventus: Szczesny +1 to 91 Benatia -1 to 90 Barzagli -1 to 89 Napoli: Hysaj +1 to 91 Albiol +1 to 90 Rui +1 to 89 Milik +1 to 89 Chiriches -1 to 87 Luperto +1 to 84 Inter: Brozovic +1 to 91 Miranda -1 to 91 D'Ambrosio +1 to 90 Politano +1 to 90 Mario -1 to 89 Valero -1 to 89 Ranocchia -1 to 86 Lazio: Acerbi +1 to 90 Strakosha +1 to 90 Leiva +1 to 90 Marusic +1 to 89 Wallace +1 to 89 Patric +1 to 85 Felipe +1 to 84 Milan: Romagnoli +1 to 91 Suso +1 to 91 Donnarumma +1 to 90 Kessie +1 to 90 Calabria +1 to 88 Bakayoko -1 to 88 Bertolacci -1 to 87 Fiorentina: Pezzella +1 to 89 Milenkovic +2 to 88 Hugo +1 to 88 Biraghi +1 to 88 Lafont +1 to 88 Gerson +1 to 87 Mirallas -1 to 87 Fernandes +2 to 85 Dragowski +2 to 84 Sampdoria: Defrel +1 to 89 Murru +1 to 88 Barreto +1 to 88 Ekdal +1 to 88 Audero +4 to 86 Andersen +3 to 86 Roma: Under +1 to 89 Olsen +1 to 88 Jesus -1 to 88 Kluivert +1 to 86 Zaniolo +2 to 78 Pellegrini +2 to 77 Sassuolo: Ferrari +1 to 88 Marlon +1 to 87 Rogerio +4 to 86 Lirola +1 to 86 Peluso -1 to 86 Bourabia +2 to 85 Magnani +4 to 84 Torino: Belotti -1 to 90 Meite +1 to 88 Soriano -1 to 88 Moretti +1 to 87 Berenguer +1 to 86 Ansaldi -1 to 87 Aina +3 to 85 Genoa: Piatek +4 to 87 Biraschi +3 to 86 Kouame +3 to 86 Spolli +1 to 86 Veloso -1 to 86 Lapadula -1 to 86 Radu +3 to 83 Pereira +2 to 82 Gunter +2 to 82 Cagliari: Ionita +1 to 87 Romagna +1 to 87 Klavan -1 to 87 Bradaric +1 to 86 Cigarini -1 to 86 Andreolli -1 to 85 Parma: Alves -1 to 87 Sepe +1 to 86 Gagliolo +1 to 85 Iacoponi +2 to 84 Stulac +2 to 84 Barilla +1 to 84 Biabiany -1 to 84 Atalanta: Masiello +1 to 88 Hateboer +1 to 88 Gollini +3 to 86 Gosens +1 to 86 Mancini +2 to 85 Barrow +3 to 83 SPAL: Gomis +1 to 86 Cionek +1 to 86 Fares +1 to 86 Vicari +1 to 86 Schiattarella +1 to 85 Valoti +1 to 84 Udinese: Samir +1 to 88 De Paul +1 to 88 Fofana +1 to 88 Larsen +1 to 87 Scuffet +1 to 86 Nuytinck +1 to 86 Troost-Ekong +2 to 85 Machis +1 to 85 Badu -1 to 85 Bologna: Destro -1 to 87 Santander +1 to 86 Dijks +1 to 86 Mattiello +2 to 85 Calabresi +2 to 84 Svanberg +2 to 82 Okonkwo +2 to 80 Empoli: Caputo +1 to 85 Antonelli -1 to 85 Di Lorenzo +2 to 84 Krunic +1 to 84 Zajc +1 to 84 Bennacer +1 to 84 Buchel -1 to 84 Terracciano +3 to 83 La Gumina +1 to 83 Rasmussen +2 to 80 Traore +1 to 77 Frosinone: Sportiello -1 to 87 Campbell -1 to 86 Chibsah +1 to 85 Zampano +1 to 85 Ciano +1 to 85 Maiello +1 to 84 Ariaudo -1 to 84 Dionisi -1 to 84 Sammarco -1 to 82 Chievo: Stepinski +1 to 86 Giaccherini -1 to 86 Hetemaj -1 to 86 Rigoni +1 to 85 Pucciarelli -1 to 85 Depaoli +2 to 84 Bani +1 to 84 Djordjevic -1 to 84 Meggiorini -1 to 84 Pellissier -1 to 84 Cesar -1 to 84 Jaroszynski +1 to 83 Leris +2 to 77 done 7 2 Dandie, Lowco, siminho83 and 6 others reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
JAMancini 162 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 37 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said: done I would add Nicolo Barella 89 in Cagliari Insigne not 93? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Ersavitzs 121 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 Thauvin or Suso? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Soccahappy 4,740 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 Is the rise safe shows at this point in time, who is most safe for their rise. For instance if you were going to buy Sanson or Amavi (similar minutes) at Marseille, it would be prudent to buy Amavi & see if Sanson continues to play 90mins or misses a few games B4 SM review. More to come hopefully, Cheers Socca Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
AlfonDaddy 122 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 32 minutes ago, Ersavitzs said: Thauvin or Suso? Thauvin 1 1 Middle_Finger and Ersavitzs reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
siminho83 3 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 Mario Rui or Tagliafico? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Grembo 1 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 Who would you go for? Thilo Kehrer or Presnel Kimpembe? I am selling Unai Nunez (not getting his game for Athletic) and looking for a replacement. Budget is around 12m. I am also open to any other suggestion if theyre better than Kehrer or Kimpembe... Thanks Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
JAMancini 162 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 9 minutes ago, Grembo said: Who would you go for? Thilo Kehrer or Presnel Kimpembe? I am selling Unai Nunez (not getting his game for Athletic) and looking for a replacement. Budget is around 12m. I am also open to any other suggestion if theyre better than Kehrer or Kimpembe... Thanks Matthijs de Ligt. He is 86 right now but he will be one of the best defender in the world. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Soccahappy 4,740 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 The interesting things here are that JB Larsen need not play any more minutes this season and his rise would be less but still maybe +5 as opposed to +7. Main reason being 75rated playing for a top team. Max Phillip on the edge(-0.1) & could be down to performance wether SM give him a rise depending also on minutes from now to the review. Similar with Dahoud. Sancho upwards seem pretty sure of deserving a rise I would have thought. Edit: I see Akanji has an injury thought to keep him out while 9Nov . If he's back then it will NOT STOP him getting a rise 🙂 I notice Maruis Wolf is in for a +1 in the first page of Sir Rahul's predictions. It's still so early for stats that if he played 180minutes in the next 2 matches his Safe rating would rise to +1.2. If he doesn't play then each game his rating will get worse, as he hasn't played since the 22nd of Sept 😟 5 Liverp00l, shangar, Middle_Finger and 2 others reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jagerbob 20 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 4 hours ago, Sir Rahul said: some big rises these few days was that really worth quoting the entire brazillian prediction thread? 2 TMCosta and Middle_Finger reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Soccahappy 4,740 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 17 minutes ago, jagerbob said: was that really worth quoting the entire brazillian prediction thread? was that really worth posting once even twice Jagerbob? It's Sir's thread afterall, The Big Boss even 😉 1 Sir Rahul reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jagerbob 20 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 no, 2 minutes ago, Soccahappy said: was that really worth posting once even twice Jagerbob? my reply didn't quote an entire leagues predictions, for just one line reply. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jagerbob 20 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 Dani Alves? Will he not drop? It doesn't look like he had played a single minute this season for PSG Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Middle_Finger 620 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 22 minutes ago, jagerbob said: was that really worth quoting the entire brazillian prediction thread? If you don't like it don't visit! You don't come to Rahul's house and tell him what to cook. You either eat what he cooked or just leave. 1 Sir Rahul reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Middle_Finger 620 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 11 minutes ago, jagerbob said: Dani Alves? Will he not drop? It doesn't look like he had played a single minute this season for PSG I am sure ppl will reply to you now. 1 1 TMCosta and Soccahappy reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
AlfonDaddy 122 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 27 minutes ago, jagerbob said: was that really worth quoting the entire brazillian prediction thread? I see your point. It did take me a whole 2 seconds of my precious time to scroll down it 🤣 2 Sir Rahul and TMCosta reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jagerbob 20 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 9 minutes ago, AlfonDaddy said: I see your point. It did take me a whole 2 seconds of my precious time to scroll down it 🤣 it took me 3.5 seconds, my computer is slow, my scroll button isn't good. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jagerbob 20 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 14 minutes ago, Middle_Finger said: If you don't like it don't visit! You don't come to Rahul's house and tell him what to cook. You either eat what he cooked or just leave. bad analogy. if I went to his house and he cooked like he predicted, then it would be amazing. I certainly wouldn't need to ask him to recook everything, just for me to tell him it was good. 1 Middle_Finger reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Middle_Finger 620 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 4 minutes ago, jagerbob said: bad analogy. if I went to his house and he cooked like he predicted, then it would be amazing. I certainly wouldn't need to ask him to recook everything, just for me to tell him it was good. Did you even understand the metaphor? "he cooked like he predicted"? "recook everything"? Do you even know what you asked/told Rahul? I see at least you tried. Here's a lollipop I am sure you will grow to become a very successful man. Until then Adios kiddo(rubbing your tiny head with my hand while I leave). 1 Sir Rahul reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Ersavitzs 121 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 3 hours ago, Grembo said: Who would you go for? Thilo Kehrer or Presnel Kimpembe? I am selling Unai Nunez (not getting his game for Athletic) and looking for a replacement. Budget is around 12m. I am also open to any other suggestion if theyre better than Kehrer or Kimpembe... Thanks Kimpembe Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
tsigalkos 10 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 Aleksandr EROKHIN +1? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Soccahappy 4,740 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 Immobile is Capped at 92 unless SM change it. Strakosha is a GK and SM are VERY HIT and MISS with GK's. I already have Strakosha so I'll buy Marusic first as the safest. Fortuna Wallace is teetering on the edge so I'll leave him teetering. Sir H has Acerbi for a +1 and I can't disagree but I prefer them the younger the better, as there isn't as much profit for older guys. Patric played 90mins on the 20 Oct but that was his first game since 26 Sep. I'll post more when I can, if it's of interest.... 6 FDTV, Liverp00l, Sir Rahul and 3 others reacted to this Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
hesselink 217 Report post Posted November 1, 2018 @Soccahappy sry, can you explain table rows? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
