Rahul W's rating predictions

[RI9 5]

21 minutes ago, Amar said:

Is it worth selling my Marco Asensio to purchase Bernardo Silva? What is Bernardo's potential at City? Will he just be a bit part sub player at Manchester City?

I have the following options at CM and I am thinking about bolstering my CM ranks for further depth so I can play 4-3-3 more regulary.

Current CM

Busquets Pogba Coutinho Dele Ali 

Current playable wide options

Salah Leroy Sane Coutinho Dybala Mbappe Gabriel Jesus

Cheers

Amar

bernardo silva does not work fine in a 4-3-3 system as cmf!....but you can try,,i hope you may find some luck

[RI9 5]

On 11/10/2018 at 2:59 PM, le Professeur said:

Best pick from these three (taking value into consideration) maybe best two out of them all?

 

Saul Niguez

Jorginho

Torreira

Rabiot

Arthur

torreira,arthur  if you have low budget...though they both have high potential

[Mickbor59 24]

Zielinski or Fabian Ruiz?

I think zielinski stay 90 and fabian Ruiz(89) +1

Sell zielinski and buy witsel?

[Mickbor59 24]

Just now, Mickbor59 said:

Zielinski or Fabian Ruiz?

I think zielinski stay 90 and fabian Ruiz(88) +1

 

[Sir Rahul 4,040]

5 hours ago, Cam Lucas said:

Elche, feat....

 

Lukaku

Chicharito

Arnautovic

Dembele

Pereyra

Valencia

Iheanacho

 

and more.

come join us!

5 hours ago, Cam Lucas said:

The only ones im qualifeid for really these days, i only watch every Arsenal game now due to kids, and just stat scout for the game (SM)

Iwobi +1 89

Holding +1 86

Auba stays, Ozil more likely to drop imo but they seem scared too. i love him but think he is a 93 rated player these days.

Emile S-R +3-+5

Guendouzi +5 to 85

Lichtsteiner -1 89? (might get benefit of a full season)

Torreira outside chance of +1 90 now, definately by end of season. get his man if you dont have him he is a pitbull.

Ramsey also in slim danger of a drop, been ass every since he got the 91, but dont think he will

Kolasinac could likey drop too

 

[EDIT] Giroud -1 to 91 unlikey XD I think he will stay (91)

mostly agree haha

2 hours ago, hesselink said:

Need help:

James R -1? %? And when? maybe

Saul Niguez +1? And when? decent chance

Matuidi back on 93? %? not yet imo

Lacazette 93 at the end of the season? really depends

SMS 92 not this season? no

 Keylor Navas -1? stay for now

Martial +1? too soon but might get it

Dybala 94 at the end of the season? maybe

Thanks 😎

 

1 hour ago, Amar said:

Is it worth selling my Marco Asensio to purchase Bernardo Silva? What is Bernardo's potential at City? Will he just be a bit part sub player at Manchester City?

I have the following options at CM and I am thinking about bolstering my CM ranks for further depth so I can play 4-3-3 more regulary.

Current CM

Busquets Pogba Coutinho Dele Ali 

Current playable wide options

Salah Leroy Sane Coutinho Dybala Mbappe Gabriel Jesus

Cheers

Amar

Bernardo as CM, maybe not

1 hour ago, thorgan lesar said:

Fernando Ovelar (14 years old) who scored in one of the most important derbies in South America is added in the SM database

mad

51 minutes ago, Mickbor59 said:

Zielinski or Fabian Ruiz?

I think zielinski stay 90 and fabian Ruiz(89) +1

Sell zielinski and buy witsel?

Zielinski

sure

[Soccahappy 4,757]

Leicester played Burnley yesterday 0-0 Draw Updated Leicester and added a few Burnley. Plus Injuries to rising players!

PlydMins	OutOf	Perc%	Name	Club			How	Safe?
1080	1080	100.00%	Chilwell	Leicester10th	England	49.3%	50%	54.3%
893	1080	82.69%	Maddison	Leicester10th	England	34.2%	70%	41.2%
927	1080	85.83%	H Maguire	Leicester10th	England	14.4%	20%	16.4%
640	1080	59.26%	D Amartey	Leicester10th	England	7.6%	50%	12.6%
810	1080	75.00%	N Mendy	Leicester10th	England	7.0%	30%	10.0%
1080	1080	100.00%	Ndidi	Leicester10th	England	13.3%	10%	14.3%
624	1080	57.78%	D Gray	Leicester10th	England	-9.3%	30%	-6.3%
875	1080	81.02%	RicardoPereira	Leicester10th	England	-5.4%	10%	-4.4%

 

PlydMins	OutOf	Perc%	Name	Club			How	Safe?
900	1080	83.33%	C Taylor	Burnley	England	19.4%	50%	24.4%
973	1080	90.09%	J Cork	Burnley	England	8.1%	10%	9.1%
927	1080	85.83%	Tarkowski	Burnley	England	3.8%	10%	4.8%

 

3 Leicester players missed the match all risers:- Amartey Ankle / foot, Maddison and Maguire BOTH Knee injury projected return 24^th November.

[hesselink 219]

Rodrigues RAMIRES after transfer rumours - value from 400k to 1,8M!

[jagerbob 20]

Are they likely to start reviewing the big 5 leagues soon?

I noticed the other day one French league player got a rating change. Caci I think from 70-72.

Does this mean the rest of the French league is coming in the next few days?

[Soccahappy 4,757]

3 hours ago, jagerbob said:

Are they likely to start reviewing the big 5 leagues soon?

I noticed the other day one French league player got a rating change. Caci I think from 70-72.

Does this mean the rest of the French league is coming in the next few days?

Last year SM reviewed Lille on 16 Nov 17, so on the same basis it might start in 5days

On 11/9/2018 at 2:58 PM, hesselink said:

@Soccahappy
Any chance Leverkusen table? 😀

As promised hesselink  😊

Leverkuson have lost their last 2 games by 3-0 & 1-4 and are 13th. Remember SM start to use performances etc as a guide for risers at 89 & over rather than just minutes. Wendell & Tah fall into this category. SM have denied Wendell a rise since May 2016 even tho he had 2121 mins in 2017/18 season. Is he due? I'd feel better if Leverkusen were a higher in the table.

[KERSPALT! 107]

Real Madrid struggling in La Liga but Odriozola getting game time with Carvajal out. Outside chance of a +1 to 90? Don't think so myself but hopefully.

 

I asked about Akanji earlier for a +2, I wasn't sure before but back from injury and BVB beat Bayern last night... Chances are getting better and better now for a +2 I think

[Soccahappy 4,757]

On 11/9/2018 at 10:14 AM, Soccahappy said:

I can't choose between them TBH Middle Finger, but I have looked at Bordeaux and Udinese IF it helps:-

Obviously Pablo, Sankhare, Poundje, Lasagna, Opuku could go either way safer with the higher figures above them. BUT a good test to see where SM are pitching there rises when they review. If it was critical to choose guess I would go for RDP, but both Kamano & RDP should rise. On the other hand Kamano is 22yo with more time and scope. 😕

Update:-

Same comments as above

 

[Ersavitzs 121]

22 minutes ago, KERSPALT! said:

Real Madrid struggling in La Liga but Odriozola getting game time with Carvajal out. Outside chance of a +1 to 90? Don't think so myself but hopefully.

 

I asked about Akanji earlier for a +2, I wasn't sure before but back from injury and BVB beat Bayern last night... Chances are getting better and better now for a +2 I think

Odriozola doesn't deserve +1

[jagerbob 20]

5 hours ago, Soccahappy said:

9 hours ago, jagerbob said:

Are they likely to start reviewing the big 5 leagues soon?

I noticed the other day one French league player got a rating change. Caci I think from 70-72.

Does this mean the rest of the French league is coming in the next few days?

Last year SM reviewed Lille on 16 Nov 17, so on the same basis it might start in 5days

On the subject of Caci, I notice another thread called him a random out of review riser, and suggested he might get another increase when france is reviewed fully. It does seem that a guy who has played the most minutes and percentage of available minutes for a 70 rated youngster in the whole French league would only get an increase of +2. So maybe the 78 or 80 rating could still happen.

[WeAreBlades98 12]

SM have done updates on players from Leauge 1 ( Oxford, AFC Wimbledon) in England does this mean the premier leauge updates are coming soon!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[hesselink 219]

13 hours ago, Soccahappy said:

Last year SM reviewed Lille on 16 Nov 17, so on the same basis it might start in 5days

As promised hesselink  😊

Leverkuson have lost their last 2 games by 3-0 & 1-4 and are 13th. Remember SM start to use performances etc as a guide for risers at 89 & over rather than just minutes. Wendell & Tah fall into this category. SM have denied Wendell a rise since May 2016 even tho he had 2121 mins in 2017/18 season. Is he due? I'd feel better if Leverkusen were a higher in the table.

Appreciate mate! 

[TMCosta 1,174]

On 11/10/2018 at 11:33 AM, ce4sc said:

some time ago, there were people who said that mustafi is better skriniar, are you still convinced tm costa? XD

Lol did i said that??? 3 years ago? Skriniar is getting reputation but he didnt do anything yet (was he playing against Atalanta? for the best CB in the world...conceded 4 goals LOL) 

[Lukke 18]

PL update just starts?

[TMCosta 1,174]

 

On 3/14/2018 at 2:38 PM, TMCosta said:

Dont have to...91 germany international > 89 inter player...

BUT...ask me again in 1/2 years

Jesus did u mark in your calendar? LOL Did u sleep meanwhile? LOL

Still 4 months to go....

 

[Soccahappy 4,757]

Hope French review starts soon .... Rennes:-

[Lukke 18]

Just now, Soccahappy said:

Hope French review starts soon .... Rennes:-

Where do you get this information?
 

[Soccahappy 4,757]

5 minutes ago, Lukke said:

Where do you get this information?
 

 

On 10/31/2018 at 11:26 AM, Soccahappy said:

 

I'll try to answer TL & MF:- and Lukke

My spreadsheet (1000 players+)  has evolved over maybe 6/7years. It basically tries to predict how SM decides who gets rises and who doesn't.

So I kept records of minutes played as percentage of the possible minutes to be played & noticed how much a 90 rated player needed as opposed to a 70 rated player ( and every rating in between). It wasn't exactly 100% correct but it was close.

I then noticed that top clubs Real Madrid etc needed less minutes than say Huddersfield or even Everton (the Pecking Order) and I tried to simulate that too. This improved the predictions again but it is an evolving changing thing like Leicester might be near relegation 1 season & then Top the next, so it's variable by season to season.

I have had a lot of success with it & my 3 clubs now have around 1.8 billion each and hit the maximum around 2.1Billion most seasons at some time b4 I start buying again (251Max). SM miss a lot every review like I know this player should definitely get a rise and they miss him. It almost seems like SM do it purposely to make it harder for such as us to make money buying & selling.

Also minutes for players over 89/90 are less important than performances & winning titles, scoring goals, assists etc. I've recently started trying to add this to my spreadsheet in a small way but it is not as accurate as yet & might not be for years. The higher percentage in the last column is the final predictor about how safe it is, at this particular point in time but doesn't account for SM messing up or just missing some players altogether. Nothing is 100% but I try to improve each season....

I think such as Sir R & many others on here must work in a similar way, I'd be interested in their views but they may not be willing to share their secrets?????

 

[Sir Rahul 4,040]

2 hours ago, WeAreBlades98 said:

SM have done updates on players from Leauge 1 ( Oxford, AFC Wimbledon) in England does this mean the premier leauge updates are coming soon!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

28 minutes ago, Lukke said:

PL update just starts?

no

[Lukke 18]

Just now, Sir Rahul said:

 

no

But huddesfield and cardiff have up today

[Sir Rahul 4,040]

4 minutes ago, Lukke said:

But huddesfield and cardiff have up today

they are doing League One

[vitor_mfc 3,818]

1 hour ago, TMCosta said:

Lol did i said that??? 3 years ago? Skriniar is getting reputation but he didnt do anything yet (was he playing against Atalanta? for the best CB in the world...conceded 4 goals LOL) 

Some random youth players farts on the football field for a couple of games and he's suddenly "the next big thing", a while ago some dudes said that Jonathan David, Mboula and Riqui Puig were the best thing since sliced bread, and yet, their endeavors were left on the pre-season or the few odd games in the beginning of the season.

Players don't need to prove themselves nowadays to be considered good players. In the words of Luca Toni "Strikers just need a good instagram to be considered good nowadays", i'll say that applies for every player really.