Rahul W's rating predictions

[Floodstreet2017 265]

12 hours ago, tupac_healy said:

As good a time as any to bring back up that Joe Gomes vs Kimpembe debate....

 

Like I said, Kimpembe.... easy 

This is hilarious. Kimpembe was dreadful again last night 

[Floodstreet2017 265]

1 hour ago, Ersavitzs said:

Thauvin no rise?

I’m sorry but 91 for Thauvin is more than enough.No way 92 level does it against the  lower teams in. Ligue 1. Still do do anything of note for France or take a stranglehold of a big game on a regular bases.

 

[Jamichael_90 3,071]

Youcef Attal they kind of player who steps up his game in 0 seconds.Got reviewed twice in a day, attaboy 😎

Unfair rise for Tameze btw.

[AlfonDaddy 122]

15 minutes ago, Floodstreet2017 said:

I’m sorry but 91 for Thauvin is more than enough.No way 92 level does it against the  lower teams in. Ligue 1. Still do do anything of note for France or take a stranglehold of a big game on a regular bases.

 

He hardly gets an opportunity for France. Normally he sits on the bench. Compare his stats to other higher rated players in his position. Granted they play in tougher leagues but they also play for top teams in those leagues.....

[Sir Rahul 3,939]

On 10/25/2016 at 12:13 PM, Sir Rahul said:

FRANCE LIGUE 1

PSG:

Mbappe +1 to 93

Buffon -1 to 93

Rabiot +1 to 92

Kimpembe +1 to 90

Areola +1 to 90

Nkunku +1 to 87

Diarra -1 to 87

N'Soki +5 to 80

Diaby +5 to 80

Dagba +3 to 78

Weah +2 to 78

Bernede +3 to 76

 

Lille:

Pepe +1 to 88

Bamba +1 to 88

Fonte -1 to 88

Maignan +2 to 87

Xeka +2 to 87

Soumaoro +2 to 87

Mendes +1 to 87

Ballo Toure +3 to 86

Remy -1 to 86

Celik +4 to 84

Ikone +2 to 84

Dabila +4 to 82

 

Montpellier:

Aguilar +2 to 87

Laborde +2 to 87

Congre +1 to 87

Mendes +1 to 87

Lecomte +1 to 87

Delort +1 to 87

Oyongo +2 to 85

Le Tallec +2 to 85

Mollet +1 to 84

Cozza +1 to 78

 

Lyon:

Ndombele +1 to 89

Marcelo +1 to 89

Aouar +1 to 89

Mendy +1 to 88

Dubois +1 to 88

Morel +1 to 88

Rafael -1 to 88

Denayer +1 to 87

Ferri -1 to 87

Yanga-Mbiwa -1 to 87

Diop +3 to 83

Martins Pereira +2 to 80

 

Marseille:

Ocampos +1 to 89- yes

Amavi +1 to 89- yes

Sakai +1 to 88- yes

Sarr +1 to 88- yes

Abdennour -1 to 86- yes

Kamara +4 to 84- +3 to 83

Thauvin +1 to 92

Rami -1 to 89

Pele +1 to 87

Sanson +1 to 90

Gustavo -1 to 90

Caleta-Car +1 to 87

Radonjic +1 to 86

 

Saint-Etienne:

Khazri +1 to 89

Selnaes +1 to 88

Silva +1 to 87

Diony +1 to 86

Hamouma -1 to 86

Beric -1 to 86

Saliba +2 to 77

Debuchy +1 to 88

Lacroix -1 to 85

Tannane -1 to 84

Nordin +1 to 83

Intima +2 to 82

Honorat +2 to 80

Panos +3 to 73

 

Nice:

Herelle +2 to 87- yes

Sarr +2 to 87- yes

Boscagli +2 to 84- yes

Attal +4 to 82- yes

Tameze +2 to 87- +1 to 86

Maolida +4 to 84- +5 to 85

Lees-Melou +1 to 88

Benitez +1 to 87

Coly +1 to 84

Srarfi +2 to 85

Burner +1 to 83

Le Bihan -1 to 83

Sacko +2 to 82

Ganago +2 to 77

Perraud +3 to 76

 

Reims:

Mendy +3 to 85- yes

Oudin +2 to 84- yes

Konan +2 to 84- +3 to 85

Abdelhamid +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Chavalerin +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Cafaro +2 to 78- +5 to 80

Doumbia +2 to 84- nope

Martin +1 to 83- nope

Fontaine +1 to 83- nope

Ojo +2 to 82

Ndom +2 to 80

 

Strasbourg:

Martinez +2 to 85- yes

Caci +8 to 78- yes

Lala +1 to 86- +2 to 87

Mothiba +2 to 85- +3 to 86

Da Costa +1 to 85- +2 to 86

Sissoko +4 to 84- +3 to 83

Zohi +6 to 76- +5 to 75

Mitrovic +1 to 86- nope

Carole +1 to 86- nope

Corgnet -1 to 84- nope

Thomasson +1 to 87

 

Nantes:

Sala +1 to 88- yes

Evangelista +2 to 85- yes

Sigthorsson -1 to 84- yes

Moutoussamy +4 to 80- yes

Kwateng +4 to 84- +2 to 82

Dabo +3 to 73- +5 to 75

Lima +1 to 87- nope

Krhin +1 to 86- nope

Miazga +2 to 85- nope

Pallois -1 to 85- nope

Nakoulma -1 to 84- nope

Toure +1 to 87

Mbodji -1 to 87

Boschilia +1 to 86

 

Bordeaux:

Kamano +1 to 88- yes

Pablo +2 to 87- yes

Lerager +1 to 87- yes

Kalu +2 to 86- yes

Tchouameni +8 to 78- yes

Youssouf +2 to 78- yes

Kounde +3 to 86- +2 to 85

Palencia +3 to 85- +1 to 83

Sankhare +1 to 88- nope

Poundje +1 to 87- nope

Plasil +1 to 86- nope

Lewczuk +1 to 85- nope

 

Rennes:

Sarr +1 to 88- yes

Ben Arfa -1 to 88- yes

Da Silva +1 to 87- yes

Gelin +1 to 86- yes

Del Castillo +2 to 84- +3 to 85

Lea Siliki +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Grenier +1 to 88- nope

Bensebaini +1 to 88- nope

Traore +1 to 88- nope

Mexer +1 to 87- nope

Tell +2 to 80

Nyamsi +2 to 78

 

Nimes:

Bernardoni +2 to 85- yes

Briancon +1 to 85- yes

Thioub +2 to 84- yes

Valls +2 to 84- yes

Bozok +1 to 84- yes

Alakouch +2 to 84- +3 to 85

Landre +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Bobichon +5 to 82- +3 to 80

Depres +1 to 78- +3 to 80

Ripart +2 to 85- nope

Paquiez +2 to 82- nope

Lybohy +2 to 82- nope

Savanier +1 to 85

 

Angers:

Santamaria +1 to 86- yes

Tait +1 to 86- yes

Bahoken +1 to 85- yes

Reine-Adelaide +3 to 83- yes

Ciss -1 to 83- yes

Kanga +2 to 78- yes

Manceau +1 to 86- nope

Butelle +1 to 86- nope

Traore +1 to 86- nope

Capelle +1 to 86- nope

Ndoye +1 to 85- nope

Bamba +1 to 85- nope

Pavlovic +1 to 84- nope

Toure -1 to 83- nope

 

Toulouse:

Reynet +1 to 87- yes

Amian +1 to 86- yes

Mbia -2 to 86- yes

Sangare +2 to 85- yes

Garcia +3 to 85- +1 to 83

Leya Iseka +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Moubandje +1 to 86- nope

Bostock +2 to 85- nope

 

Amiens:

Ganso -1 to 87- yes

Otero +2 to 84- yes

Gnahore +3 to 83- yes

Lefort +4 to 82- yes

Cornette +1 to 78- yes

Ghoddos +1 to 85- +2 to 86

Adenon +1 to 85- nope

Krafth +1 to 85- nope

Konate +1 to 87

 

Caen:

Armougom +4 to 77- yes

Samba +4 to 82- +5 to 83

Tchokounte +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Deminguet +1 to 77- +6 to 82

Oniangue +1 to 86- nope

Ninga +1 to 86- nope

Mbengue +1 to 84- nope

Peeters +1 to 84- nope

Diomande -1 to 83- nope

Djiku +1 to 87

Crivelli +1 to 86

Louis -2 to 78

 

Dijon:

Loiodice +3 to 80- yes

Coulibaly +3 to 76- yes

Rosier +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Runarsson +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Aguerd +2 to 75- +7 to 80

Keita +5 to 75- +7 to 77

Ciman -1 to 85- nope

Marie -1 to 84- nope

Sammaritano -1 to 84- nope

Sliti +1 to 87

Bouka Moutou -1 to 82

 

Monaco:

Jovetic -1 to 89- yes

Aholou +1 to 86- yes

Sylla +4 to 80- yes

Mboula +2 to 78- +4 to 80

Diop +8 to 78- +6 to 76

Benaglio +1 to 87- nope

Barreca +1 to 87- nope

Grandsir +1 to 86- nope

Serrano +1 to 77- nope

Glik -1 to 90

Golovin +1 to 89

Subasic -1 to 89

Raggi -1 to 86

Cardona +4 to 80

Tormin +2 to 78

Fernandez +1 to 77

Etienne +3 to 76

Nguinda +2 to 75

Panzo +3 to 73

Isidor +3 to 73

 

Guingamp:

Rebocho +1 to 85- yes

Thuram +1 to 85- yes

Fofana +1 to 83- yes

Eboa Eboa +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Rodelin -1 to 85- nope

Deaux -1 to 84- nope

Tabanou -1 to 84- nope

Julan +2 to 82- nope

Sorbon -1 to 85

Petric -1 to 82

 

[AlfonDaddy 122]

I have data for Douglas Costa, Willian and Di Maria but it won’t let me upload it at this time for some reason. None of them even come close and they got 93,92 and 94. I think 92 would be fair but no higher until he achieves trophies/move/international stats

[Sir Rahul 3,939]

57 minutes ago, JAMancini said:

Sell Saint-Maximin?

I think that he is in his maximun rating playing in Nice.

yeah for a good deal

1 hour ago, Joshivic230 said:

I personally think they are not yet done with Marseille

tomorrow as well

1 hour ago, Ersavitzs said:

Thauvin no rise?

hopefully tomorrow, deserves it

2 hours ago, 1000dB said:

Based on previous winter reviews and there are plenty of new BuLi edits on soccerwiki.

yep should be Bundesliga

11 hours ago, tupac_healy said:

Just out interest....

 

Why would they skip Matic and defiantly drop Sanchez?

 

EDIT... My money is Matic does a Mata, 93-91, anything else is a disgrace 

yeah

11 hours ago, Lukke said:

MD,M,MA(C)

T.NDOMBÉLÉ

Olympique Lyonnais

10.0M

88

21

MD,M,MA(C)

F.GRILLITSCH

Hoffenheim

8.0M

88

23

 

which safer to rise?

Ndombele tomorrow

12 hours ago, Kev said:

Swap Matic for Jose Gimenez? Bit concerned Matic might drop, plus I have Casemiro and Veratti anyway. Gimenez not playing too much though. Is that just down to injuries?

Matic should drop to 92, Gimenez it is

12 hours ago, tupac_healy said:

As good a time as any to bring back up that Joe Gomes vs Kimpembe debate....

 

Like I said, Kimpembe.... easy 

i'm on the fence

13 hours ago, shangar said:

A quick question regarding Golovin's +1 to 89.  Do you guys think this was purely based on his World Cup performances, or was there something in his club form?

mainly world cup, Monaco's struggles shouldn't have gotten him an 89

13 hours ago, Agar84 said:

Douglas Costa stay or drop?

stay

16 hours ago, lgierberg said:

Lo Celso +1? 50/50?

don't think so yet

17 hours ago, mateusrb said:

Pique or Godin?

Pique

17 hours ago, TMNT said:

It makes absolutely no sense mate lol. Pointless not to give him his full update when you're changing his rating just 20 days before! He's not went up six points in that time, and they probably already had the exact upgrade he ended up with in mind then. Maybe if it was a few months prior then I could get behind it as making the database more accurate but it's just misleading. 

yeah

17 hours ago, TMNT said:

Auba's scored goals prolifically in recent years so that wasn't why people thought he should drop, he's simply over rated. He should be 94, he fits in better with the other 94s, he's easily the worst 95 in the game (IRL). 

truth

6 minutes ago, Jamichael_90 said:

Youcef Attal they kind of player who steps up his game in 0 seconds.Got reviewed twice in a day, attaboy 😎

Unfair rise for Tameze btw.

hahaha

Tameze should have gotten 87, yes

[Yuasa 170]

50 minutes ago, Floodstreet2017 said:

This is hilarious. Kimpembe was dreadful again last night 

I'm reading he takes 6.5 valutazion last night

[TMCosta 1,075]

+1 Sanson

+1 OCampos

+1 Amavi

Why? Or its just me? They are 5th.....

[TMCosta 1,075]

6 minutes ago, Yuasa said:

I'm reading he takes 6.5 valutazion last night

From whoscored? Forget it...try floodstreet.com hahahaha

[Cam Lucas 10,085]

I doubt Matic will go -2. I can see Matic getting a -1 maybe as united are poor, Alexis on the other hand is surely in line for a -2. As a Gooner - this pleases me.

[AlfonDaddy 122]

11 minutes ago, TMCosta said:

From whoscored? Forget it...try floodstreet.com hahahaha

 

9 minutes ago, Cam Lucas said:

I doubt Matic will go -2. I can see Matic getting a -1 maybe as united are poor, Alexis on the other hand is surely in line for a -2. As a Gooner - this pleases me.

Yeah Sanchez -2 and Matic -1 for now then another -1 each in summer if they don’t pick up

[Floodstreet2017 265]

2 hours ago, AlfonDaddy said:

He hardly gets an opportunity for France. Normally he sits on the bench. Compare his stats to other higher rated players in his position. Granted they play in tougher leagues but they also play for top teams in those leagues.....

Think he has about one goal in all this time against a team in the top 4 in France. No joke.

1 hour ago, Yuasa said:

I'm reading he takes 6.5 valutazion last night

And what?? 😂

[Floodstreet2017 265]

1 hour ago, TMCosta said:

From whoscored? Forget it...try floodstreet.com hahahaha

Maybe we should all just base our opinions on what who scored says 🤣🤣

[Soccahappy 4,721]

15 hours ago, shangar said:

A quick question regarding Golovin's +1 to 89.  Do you guys think this was purely based on his World Cup performances, or was there something in his club form?

Definitely not Monaco as its already been said, deservedly WC Performances.

15 hours ago, tupac_healy said:

As good a time as any to bring back up that Joe Gomes vs Kimpembe debate....

 

Like I said, Kimpembe.... easy 

Joe Gomez for me by a mile at the moment.

14 hours ago, Lukke said:

MD,M,MA(C)

T.NDOMBÉLÉ

Olympique Lyonnais

10.0M

88

21

MD,M,MA(C)

F.GRILLITSCH

Hoffenheim

8.0M

88

23

 

which safer to rise?

Ndombele again by a mile now, later & probably forever

3 hours ago, 1000dB said:

Balotelli is on 90 (+1 last summer).

 

Usually the next day they continue with the last team that was reviewed the day before. In this case that was ASSE. OM seems to be completed and Thauvin won't get more than 91 playing for OM.

I agree with 1000db We'll know tomorrow for sure, but my pennyworth ... No Rise for Thauvin. Saint-Maximin possibly tomorrow. Unlikely tho it seems I'm hoping...

[Sir Rahul 3,939]

2 hours ago, Cam Lucas said:

I doubt Matic will go -2. I can see Matic getting a -1 maybe as united are poor, Alexis on the other hand is surely in line for a -2. As a Gooner - this pleases me.

hah

[Sir Rahul 3,939]

Saint-Maximin had a position change today so won't rise

[Sir Rahul 3,939]

Calhanoglu and Mario Gaspar or Thauvin?

[Damien1990 112]

Looking like Boateng is pretty certain to drop. My current CB options are: Ramos (32/95), Boateng (30/94), Stones (24/90), Christensen (22/90), Elvedi (22/88), Zouma (24/88), M. Sarr (19/87), Retsos (20/87), Lyanco (21/82), Mavropanos (20/82). Retsos, Lyanco and Mavropanos have been injured fairly often and don't seem to be in their teams' plans at the moment. Zouma is  Zouma and Christensen is frozen out at Chelsea so I need a decent replacement - preferably one capable of hitting 94 in the future.

My team currently is:

De Gea (28/95)

Kimmich (23/92) Ramos (32/95) Boateng (30/94) Alaba (26/93)
Eriksen (26/93) Pogba (25/93)
Mbappe (19/92) Kroos (28/95) Isco (26/93)
Griezmann (27/95)

I've got Sterling and Dele Alli too so am comfortable throwing Isco in the mix with Boateng to get a CB of a decent age with a good future. My game world is pretty competitive so it'll be tough getting a replacement - any 2 or 3 name recommendations?

[Yuasa 170]

1 hour ago, Floodstreet2017 said:

Think he has about one goal in all this time against a team in the top 4 in France. No joke.

And what?? 😂

Someone said yesterday he was terrible

[Floodstreet2017 265]

25 minutes ago, Yuasa said:

Someone said yesterday he was terrible

Two goals over last season and this season against a top team in France.

1 versus PSG last season

1 against Lyon this season.

Regularly disappears against the big teams then pops up against Amiens, Caen etc not sure why he should get a 92?

Very generous from SM if he does. 

[nofoff 195]

9 minutes ago, Yuasa said:

Someone said yesterday he was terrible

I don't think anyone said Thauvin was terrible...

I said Kimpembe was awful (because I actually watched the PSG-Liverpool game and he had one of his worst games)

I'm with @Floodstreet2017 on this. Just because Whoscored gave a player a 6+ rating really has very little bearing on how well they actually played.

Their formula is completely stat based and doesn't take into account a number of key things. To use yesterdays game as an example Kimpembe might have played 20 successful passes (hypothetically speaking) back to his GK meaning Whoscored thinks his passing was great. (Mustafi last season is another example of how deceiving WS can be, especially for defenders)

However it completely ignores the fact that Thiago Silva came to his rescue at least 6 times and he that was caught out of position on multiple occasions. He also decided to dribble the ball in his own penalty area more than once when he could have just cleared the danger immediately.

Whoscored CAN be a great tool but I feel like way too many people put too much weight on their ratings without watching the players themselves. 

NB: Not calling anyone out, just wanted to put my OPINION out there

[Floodstreet2017 265]

3 minutes ago, nofoff said:

I don't think anyone said Thauvin was terrible...

I said Kimpembe was awful (because I actually watched the PSG-Liverpool game and he had one of his worst games)

I'm with @Floodstreet2017 on this. Just because Whoscored gave a player a 6+ rating really has very little bearing on how well they actually played.

Their formula is completely stat based and doesn't take into account a number of key things. To use yesterdays game as an example Kimpembe might have played 20 successful passes (hypothetically speaking) back to his GK meaning Whoscored thinks his passing was great. (Mustafi last season is another example of how deceiving WS can be, especially for defenders)

However it completely ignores the fact that Thiago Silva came to his rescue at least 6 times and he that was caught out of position on multiple occasions. He also decided to dribble the ball in his own penalty area more than once when he could have just cleared the danger immediately.

Whoscored CAN be a great tool but I feel like way too many people put too much weight on their ratings without watching the players themselves. 

NB: Not calling anyone out, just wanted to put my OPINION out there

He gave the ball away at least three times where Liverpool could have capitalised. Having now checked Who scored he actually got one of the lowest ratings for PSG so not sure if that’s something to brag about? 

[Cvilhete 417]

12 minutes ago, nofoff said:

I don't think anyone said Thauvin was terrible...

I said Kimpembe was awful (because I actually watched the PSG-Liverpool game and he had one of his worst games)

I'm with @Floodstreet2017 on this. Just because Whoscored gave a player a 6+ rating really has very little bearing on how well they actually played.

Their formula is completely stat based and doesn't take into account a number of key things. To use yesterdays game as an example Kimpembe might have played 20 successful passes (hypothetically speaking) back to his GK meaning Whoscored thinks his passing was great. (Mustafi last season is another example of how deceiving WS can be, especially for defenders)

However it completely ignores the fact that Thiago Silva came to his rescue at least 6 times and he that was caught out of position on multiple occasions. He also decided to dribble the ball in his own penalty area more than once when he could have just cleared the danger immediately.

Whoscored CAN be a great tool but I feel like way too many people put too much weight on their ratings without watching the players themselves. 

NB: Not calling anyone out, just wanted to put my OPINION out there

Watching the football is always more credible than looking up stats, I understand with a game like SM stats are a major thing but a lot these guys giving opinions on players they haven't even watched play. In other words blind leading the blind

[nofoff 195]

8 minutes ago, Cvilhete said:

Watching the football is always more credible than looking up stats, I understand with a game like SM stats are a major thing but a lot these guys giving opinions on players they haven't even watched play. In other words blind leading the blind

Couldn't agree more mate. That's why I don't answer half the questions on here. They are either too obvious to answer, have already been asked 1000 times, or I don't know a player well enough to comment. No point giving an opinion if you've just checked on transfermarkt/whoscored