Jump to content

Rahul W's rating predictions


Recommended Posts

6 hours ago, Tharanidharan said:

 

Guerreiro plays a winger, so he might soon lose his LB position. Davies - I don't think he goes on attack much. More like a Full back than a Wing back. 

Guerreiro won't lose his LB position anytime soon, he still plays LB for dortmund sometimes and he does it regularly for the NT.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 30.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Sir Rahul

    3195

  • Kieran_S91

    1752

  • Milanista1

    1166

  • Soccahappy

    1012

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Hi all, As you have seen, I have not really been active over the past few months other than updating my preds. It's just been me phasing out of the forum. Now that the reviews are done, I can say

Just noticed this thread has crossed 1 million views, 23k odd replies, 930 pages.  I know this is 3 and a half years old but I never intended for this to monopolise the forum back then (I would h

Page 200- didn't think we'd get here when I started this casually- thanks all

Posted Images

4 hours ago, carl89 said:

hey all, just a random thing I'm posting up but does anyone have any problems dealing with managers when you have a highly sought after player? I have Mbappe and I'm trying to get deals done for various other players that they have but they refuse to negotiate with me unless I sell them Mbappe to them for a 2 for 1 deal where the player(s) I'm after is included in the deal. I feel that managers like this are killing the game and the transfer market in the respective setups. I have been with this club since 2006 and I've never had this problem before but now i have at least 3 managers doing this to me! have you got any tips on how to negotiate with these stubborn managers and any tips on how to revive a dead transfer market? 

 

For them surely you are the stubborn one for refusing to sell Mbappe and stagnating the market.

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Kev said:

Didn't know about this but looking up his stats he's gone down as AM(C) rather than M(C) on some stats sites so they probably won't change anything for now. Depends on soccerwiki input maybe?

1
5 hours ago, EnglishPirlo said:

 

I know he has been said to be CM in a 433, but that win against Mainz looked more like a 4141 with him and Havertz AMs, Bailey and Bellarabi on the wings and Aranguiz holding. It really doesn’t look like a 433 and Brandt isn’t a CM, but he was great wherever he was playing!


He definitely played deeper at times. Look at his heatmap:

qMkf9ww.png

 

Guess will see how it continues but for me there isn't a massive amount of difference between 4141 and 433 in that he would still be dropping into midfield even if he was higher up but from that heatmap it looks like a lot of his touches were deep.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Middle_Finger said:

For them surely you are the stubborn one for refusing to sell Mbappe and stagnating the market.

Maybe he is being a bit stubborn.

Selling K.Mbappe is a difficult decision to make even if you are offered a very good swap deal. I guess its dependant on who is offered to him and where his team need strengthening.

4 hours ago, carl89 said:

I've received an offer of Jerome Boateng and Frenkie De Jong for Van Dijk. Good deal? 

I would keep V. Van Dijk because I missed out on him myself. :( (he is the best CB in the PL in my opinion).

I see J.Boateng dropping now, if you can get F.D.J another way try that. Alternatively you could try and get A.Melo, H.Aouar, N.Dembele or K.Havertz (if its possible).

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, vitor_mfc said:

Guerreiro won't lose his LB position anytime soon, he still plays LB for dortmund sometimes and he does it regularly for the NT.

God bless you all for trying to help me pick the best choice for a new LB.

I am torn between R.Rodriguez and R Guerriero.I have decided to go with.......

R.Rodriguez.

R Guerriero and B.Davies are an option for the future, (if available) it's also dependant on how well B.Mendy's return to action goes..

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, carl89 said:

hey all, just a random thing I'm posting up but does anyone have any problems dealing with managers when you have a highly sought after player? I have Mbappe and I'm trying to get deals done for various other players that they have but they refuse to negotiate with me unless I sell them Mbappe to them for a 2 for 1 deal where the player(s) I'm after is included in the deal. I feel that managers like this are killing the game and the transfer market in the respective setups. I have been with this club since 2006 and I've never had this problem before but now i have at least 3 managers doing this to me! have you got any tips on how to negotiate with these stubborn managers and any tips on how to revive a dead transfer market? 

 

How dare they not roll over and give you their best players in exchange for pocket fluff and buttons.  Disgraceful behaviour.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, vitor_mfc said:

LOL, no he's not! he'll be a minimum of 92 in 12 months time, no less. Still not the best of deals though, Dijk can reach 95.

Maybe 16 months, in three reviews he'll drop to 90 IMO, -1 each time. Once a staple of the Bayern defense, and nailed on starter, he now finds himself relegated to the bench more and more.

Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Damien1990 said:


He definitely played deeper at times. Look at his heatmap:

qMkf9ww.png

 

Guess will see how it continues but for me there isn't a massive amount of difference between 4141 and 433 in that he would still be dropping into midfield even if he was higher up but from that heatmap it looks like a lot of his touches were deep.

 

 

I'm not sure a heat map is likely to have much effect on how stats sites record a player's position. It'll more likely be the team sheet and formation. Whoscored has him down as M(C) but Transfermarkt has those games as AM(C). It'll all come down to how soccerwiki is updated. You need to judge everything the way SM/soccerwiki will rather than any other source. He could get M(C), but don't bank on it. Maybe one of the guys who knows the workings of SW will be able to help? 

9 hours ago, hesselink said:

Is there any chance to report manager(s) in GW where SMFA is switched off?

I had 2 unsuccessful attempts to report, whether to continue or not make sense?

How did you report the first 2 times? Are you reporting deals or multiple accounts?

3 hours ago, vitor_mfc said:

LOL, no he's not! he'll be a minimum of 92 in 12 months time, no less. Still not the best of deals though, Dijk can reach 95.

I think this is probably the most realistic. He dropped this winter and still starts most games for Bayern (missed some to injury), so I think he'll keep 93 in the summer review. Depending on what happens next season he might go to 92 in the winter review. Can't see him dropping to 90 in that time anyway! But like everyone else has said, I'd pick VVD over him. 

42 minutes ago, ombarcagunners said:

But I have Dembele, Martial, Mbappe as starters. I also have Pepe and Cengiz Under

Agree with the previous comment. He's worth keeping, but with that attack he'll just get concerns so sell. If it's a custom with no concerns then keep and sell after his next rise maybe!

Link to post
Share on other sites
20 hours ago, carl89 said:

hey all, just a random thing I'm posting up but does anyone have any problems dealing with managers when you have a highly sought after player? I have Mbappe and I'm trying to get deals done for various other players that they have but they refuse to negotiate with me unless I sell them Mbappe to them for a 2 for 1 deal where the player(s) I'm after is included in the deal. I feel that managers like this are killing the game and the transfer market in the respective setups. I have been with this club since 2006 and I've never had this problem before but now i have at least 3 managers doing this to me! have you got any tips on how to negotiate with these stubborn managers and any tips on how to revive a dead transfer market? 

 

Try to do deals with others than those 3 or you can still try to get their players by offering good deal to them

18 hours ago, carl89 said:

I've received an offer of Jerome Boateng and Frenkie De Jong for Van Dijk. Good deal? 

No

3 hours ago, Atkin92 said:

Wijnaldum or Henderson?

 

Wijnaldum

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 3/18/2017 at 12:48 PM, Sir Rahul said:

EFL CHAMPIONSHIP

Norwich:

Tettey +1 to 84

Steipermann +1 to 84

Zimmermann +3 to 83

Buendia +1 to 83

Onel Hernandez +1 to 83

Hanley -1 to 83

Pinto -2 to 83

Lewis +4 to 82

Cantwell +7 to 80

Jarvis -2 to 80

Godfrey +1 to 78

 

Leeds:

Clarke +10 to 75- yes

Phillips +2 to 84

Klich +1 to 84

Alioski +1 to 84

Roofe +1 to 83

Ayling +1 to 83

Cooper +2 to 82

Harrison +2 to 82

Peacock-Farell +5 to 80

 

Sheffield United:

Henderson +3 to 83- +2 to 82

Sharp +2 to 84

O'Connell +1 to 83

Egan +1 to 83

Fleck +1 to 83

McGoldrick +1 to 83

Stevens +2 to 82

Basham +2 to 82

Duffy +2 to 82

Freeman +2 to 82

Stearman -1 to 82

 

West Brom:

Barnes +3 to 83- yes

Adarabioyo +5 to 82- +3 to 80

Rodriguez -1 to 87

Livermore -1 to 87

Brunt -1 to 85

Morrison -1 to 84

Barry -1 to 84

Sako -2 to 83

Hoolahan -1 to 82

Townsend +2 to 80

Myhill -2 to 80

 

Middlesborough:

Tavernier +4 to 77- +3 to 76

Mikel -1 to 87

Braithwaite -1 to 86

Flint +1 to 84

Assombalonga +1 to 84

Hugill +1 to 84

Fry +3 to 83

Saville +1 to 83

Fletcher +2 to 82

Gestede -1 to 82

Wing +8 to 78

Wood +3 to 70

 

Bristol City:

Kelly +5 to 80- yes

Dasilva +2 to 80- yes

Pack +1 to 83

Brownhill +1 to 83

Eliasson +1 to 83

O'Dowda +1 to 83

Webster +2 to 82

Maenpaa +2 to 82

Taylor +2 to 80

Smith -2 to 80

Fielding -2 to 80

Walsh +2 to 75

Morrell +2 to 75

O'Leary +3 to 73

 

Derby:

Wilson +3 to 83- yes

Tomori +3 to 83- +2 to 82

Bogle +10 to 75- +13 to 78

Mount +1 to 85

Huddlestone -1 to 85

Johnson -1 to 84

Davies -2 to 84

Waghorn +1 to 83

Ledley -2 to 83

Marriott +2 to 82

Anya -1 to 82

Holmes +2 to 80

Olsson -2 to 80

Bennett +1 to 78

Roos +2 to 77

 

Birmingham:

Mahoney +3 to 80- +1 to 78

Adams +3 to 83

Jutkiewicz +1 to 83

Morrison +1 to 83

Pedersen +1 to 83

Maghoma +1 to 83

Gary Gardner +1 to 83

Camp +2 to 82

Craig Gardner -1 to 82

Kuszczak -2 to 80

Harding +2 to 78

Lakin +3 to 70

 

Nottingham Forest:

Soudani -2 to 85

Robinson +2 to 84

Grabban +1 to 84

Yacob -2 to 84

Carvalho +1 to 83

Osborn +1 to 83

Guedioura +1 to 83

Lolley +4 to 82

Darikwa +2 to 82

Cash +2 to 82

Dawson -1 to 82

Bridcutt -1 to 82

Henderson -2 to 80

Fuentes -2 to 80

 

Aston Villa:

Bolasie -2 to 87- yes

Tuanzebe +4 to 82- yes

El Ghazi -1 to 86

Elmohamady -1 to 85

Jedinak -1 to 85

Grealish +1 to 84

McGinn +1 to 84

Adomah -1 to 84

Whelan -1 to 84

Bjarnason -1 to 84

Samba -2 to 80

Richards -3 to 80

 

Swansea:

Bony -2 to 86- -1 to 87

James +6 to 76- +8 to 78

Fer -1 to 86

Naughton -1 to 85

Olsson -1 to 85

Narsingh -2 to 85

Nordfeldt -1 to 84

Celina +1 to 83

Routledge -2 to 83

Dyer -2 to 83

Montero -2 to 83

Roberts +5 to 82

Grimes +5 to 82

McBurnie +2 to 82

Rodon +10 to 80

Byers +3 to 75

Dhanda +2 to 70

 

Hull:

Grosicki -2 to 85

Bowen +2 to 84

Kane +1 to 83

Irvine +1 to 83

Kingsley +1 to 83

Burke +4 to 82

De Wijs +2 to 82

Stewart +2 to 82

Mazuch -2 to 80

Batty +8 to 78

McKenzie +7 to 75

 

Blackburn:

Graham +1 to 83

Bennett +1 to 83

Evans +1 to 83

Raya +2 to 82

Lenihan +2 to 82

Bell +2 to 82

Dack +2 to 82

Armstrong +2 to 82

Smallwood +2 to 82

Nyambe +2 to 80

Rodwell -2 to 80

Rothwell +1 to 78

Travis +6 to 76

Nutall +2 to 75

 

Preston:

Nmecha +4 to 80- +2 to 78

Barkhuizen +1 to 83

Browne +1 to 83

Davies +1 to 83

Hughes +4 to 82

Johnson +2 to 82

Ledson +2 to 80

Moult +2 to 80

Maxwell -2 to 80

Storey +7 to 77

 

QPR:

Cameron -1 to 84

Hemed -1 to 84

Freeman +1 to 83

Bidwell +1 to 83

Eze +4 to 82

Lynch +2 to 82

Lumley +7 to 80

Furlong +2 to 80

Hall -1 to 80

Baptiste -2 to 80

Ingram +2 to 77

Kaykay +2 to 77

 

Sheffield Wednesday:

Forestieri -1 to 84

Palmer +2 to 82

Fox +2 to 82

Matias +2 to 82

Hutchinson -1 to 82

Boyd -1 to 82

Pudil -1 to 82

Lee -1 to 82

Westwood -1 to 82

Hooper -2 to 82

Dawson +5 to 80

Jones -2 to 80

Abdi -2 to 80

Winnall -2 to 80

Thorniley +5 to 78

Penney +5 to 75

Baker +5 to 75

Preston +3 to 68

 

Stoke:

Williams -1 to 85- yes

Allen -1 to 88

Butland -1 to 87

Martins Indi -1 to 87

Shawcross -1 to 87

Bojan -1 to 85

Fletcher -1 to 85

Diouf -2 to 85

Woods +1 to 84

Adams -2 to 83

Afellay -2 to 83

Federici -1 to 82

Haugaard -2 to 80

Edwards +2 to 78

 

Brentford:

Mepham +3 to 83- yes

Maupay +1 to 84

Sawyers +1 to 83

Bentley +1 to 83

Watkins +1 to 83

Barbet +1 to 83

Jeanvier -1 to 83

Konsa +5 to 82

Forss +3 to 73

 

Wigan:

Robinson +3 to 80- yes

James +7 to 80- +5 to 78

Morsy +2 to 82

Walton +2 to 82

Evans +2 to 82

Dunkley +2 to 82

Pilkington -2 to 82

Kipre +4 to 80

Naismith +3 to 80

Gibson -2 to 80

McManaman -2 to 80

Fox -2 to 80

Clarke -2 to 80

Olsson -2 to 80

Jones +1 to 77

 

Millwall:

Wallace +1 to 83

Skalak -1 to 83

Romeo +4 to 82

Meredith +2 to 82

O'Brien +2 to 82

Archer +2 to 82

Cooper +1 to 82

Gregory +1 to 82

Leonard +2 to 80

Wallace +2 to 80

Pearce -2 to 80

Elliott +1 to 78

 

Rotherham:

Rodak +4 to 80- +2 to 78

Mattock +2 to 82

Ajayi +4 to 80

Vaulks +3 to 80

Smith +3 to 80

Williams +3 to 80

Taylor +3 to 80

Robertson +2 to 80

Towell +1 to 80

Jones -3 to 80

Vyner +5 to 78

Raggett +1 to 76

 

Reading:

Meyler -3 to 80- yes

Edwards -3 to 80- yes

Barrow -1 to 83

Oliveira -2 to 83

Yiadom +2 to 82

Kelly +2 to 82

Aluko -1 to 82

O'Shea -1 to 82

Mannone -1 to 82

McShane -1 to 82

Meite +3 to 80

Jaakkola +3 to 80

Popa -3 to 80

Walker +1 to 77

Richards +1 to 77

McNulty +1 to 77

Rinomhota +10 to 75

Loader +5 to 70

 

Bolton:

Williams +2 to 80- yes

Olkowski -1 to 83

Lowe +2 to 82

Beevers +2 to 82

Wilson -1 to 82

Alnwick +2 to 80

Noone +2 to 80

Taylor +2 to 80

Magennis +1 to 80

Grounds -2 to 80

Murphy -2 to 80

Dyer -2 to 80

 

Ipswich:

Chalobah +7 to 80- +5 to 78

Quaner -1 to 83

Judge -1 to 82

Walters -1 to 82

Pennington +2 to 80

Edwards +2 to 80

Nolan +2 to 80

Gerken +2 to 80

Huws -2 to 80

Adeyemi -2 to 80

Collins -3 to 80

Downes +4 to 77

Jackson +3 to 77

Donacien +1 to 76

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, KERSPALT! said:

Maybe 16 months, in three reviews he'll drop to 90 IMO, -1 each time. Once a staple of the Bayern defense, and nailed on starter, he now finds himself relegated to the bench more and more.

Honestly, what are you talking about? He's not the fundamental piece of BM that he once was, but he still plays a lot when fit. And i think he'll probably move next summer anyway.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Kev pinned this topic

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...