Jump to content

Rahul W's rating predictions


Rahul W

Recommended Posts

8 minutes ago, Milanista1 said:

No dont accept it, J.Boetang is only going down from here, and P.Kimpembe will probably take another 2-3 seasons to go up to a 93 (if he can hit that rating) plus he is not a definate starting CB for PSG at the moment T.Silva and C.Marquinos are.

Everything you said is right except that T.Silva and Marquinhos  are definite starter at CB while the former still plays CB, the latter doesn't .. Tuchel has converted Marquinhos into a DM and he's performing there... Won't be surprised if SMW changes his primary position to DM in the next few weeks, I don't see him losing his D(C) though 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, beekayem said:

Sell or hold onto Harry Winks. In a GW where money is tight. 

Definitely keep until the summer review at least. 

5 hours ago, congola said:

so my previously deal for jovic was rejected, guy went back on his word.

he has now offered jovic plus 30 mill/melo/goretka  for sandro or marquinos. 

i have Robertson to replace sandro, and marquionos is a back up to vvd and skrinair and manolas. 

should i make the trade and who to swap?

 

 

Go for it, and get rid of Marquinos if he's not a starter, he'll only get concerns. Either of the players he's offering are good, but maybe go for Goretzka, he's already got the high rating. Might be a year or 2 before Arthur gets there.

3 hours ago, Milanista1 said:

Do you guys think L.Modic can keep his 95 for a few years?

I have been offered 45M and L.Modric for my B.Silva. I'm thinking that I should accept the deal but I need to consider that i am selling to my strongest rilval,  i am slightly weakening in midfield (he also has S.Busquets, C. Ericksen and Kevin de bruyne) but could be strengthning him in years to come.  He may also pull out of the deal in a day or two, I never know with him.

What would you do?

Probably not for a few years, but I'd expect him to keep it for the next review. In a couple of years he might be 92 so still good...

2 hours ago, cropper said:

Hi

Been offered Jerome boetang and kimpembe + 15mill for my umtiti

 

 

Short term it would make sense, but Boateng is going downhill. What defenders do you have already?

2 hours ago, Toby S said:

Hi all, 

Rodri Hernandez, Melo Arthur, or Ndombele?

Or someone else for the midfield role who is young and promising, 20m or less

I'd get Rodri if you can. 

1 hour ago, Milanista1 said:

I have enough player options at the moment (will be selling some of them who are out on loan either this seson or next) its just I am concerned that L.Modric could drop to 93 in 2 sesons time whereas B.Silva could rise to 94.

I already have D.Silva, Verrati, T.Alcantara and T.Fabinho for midfield. I have A.Melo, F.DJ, Rodri, Kessie and L.Peligrini out on loan.

Available for less than 45: SMS, B.Matuidi, R.Firmino, A. Sanchez, Lukaku, N.Keita, G.Wijnaldum,  N.Matic....

...I think with the back up you have getting Modric is a great idea for now. Some of those guys you have will rise to take over for him. Firminho would be a good option too though depending on what attackers you have already. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Joshivic230 said:

Everything you said is right except that T.Silva and Marquinhos  are definite starter at CB while the former still plays CB, the latter doesn't .. Tuchel has converted Marquinhos into a DM and he's performing there... Won't be surprised if SMW changes his primary position to DM in the next few weeks, I don't see him losing his D(C) though 

Thank you for mostly agreeing with me, and for the knowledge you provided me with.

In PSG's last game I'm sure that both CB's were C.Marquinhos and T.Silva. P.Kimpenbe came on towards the end.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, Kev said:

Definitely keep until the summer review at least. 

Go for it, and get rid of Marquinos if he's not a starter, he'll only get concerns. Either of the players he's offering are good, but maybe go for Goretzka, he's already got the high rating. Might be a year or 2 before Arthur gets there.

Probably not for a few years, but I'd expect him to keep it for the next review. In a couple of years he might be 92 so still good...

Short term it would make sense, but Boateng is going downhill. What defenders do you have already?

I'd get Rodri if you can. 

...I think with the back up you have getting Modric is a great idea for now. Some of those guys you have will rise to take over for him. Firminho would be a good option too though depending on what attackers you have already. 

I will wait for a few more opinions (if they are aired) before making a final decision, thank you as always Kev.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Milanista1 said:

Godfred Donsah is the younger but has less apps than Lees Melou, P.L.M plays for a better team... hmmm

Is Ryan Fraser or N. Redmond not available?

The rating cap for purchases is 87.

I have Donsah, was wondering about trading him for Lees-Melou.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Milanista1 said:

I have enough player options at the moment (will be selling some of them who are out on loan either this seson or next) its just I am concerned that L.Modric could drop to 93 in 2 sesons time whereas B.Silva could rise to 94.

I already have D.Silva, Verrati, T.Alcantara and T.Fabinho for midfield. I have A.Melo, F.DJ, Rodri, Kessie and L.Peligrini out on loan.

Available for less than 45: SMS, B.Matuidi, R.Firmino, A. Sanchez, Lukaku, N.Keita, G.Wijnaldum,  N.Matic....

You have enough cover. I would do the deal and use the money wisely. Great options are available.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Damian said:

Thinking about midterm potential in the following questions  , maybe in 2 years from now :

 

Chelsea`s Kepa      or        Lazio`s Sergei Milinkovic-Savic  ?

 

Fiorentina`s Milenkovic        or         Chelsea`s Marcos Alonso ?

 

Positions doesn´t matter.

Thanks for your help.

Kepa and milenkovic

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Does anybody have a firm grip on the moments that trigger a change in value/potential of under 23yo players?

R.Sessegnon's value has dropped to 7M (from 10M). Looks like it was on the 18th of this month (his DoB = 18 May 2000). I've seen players having their value/potential adjusted on their birthday, the day itself, and when getting their rating reviewed but other moments too, like is the case with Sessegnon. Maybe it's each month (same day but of course not the same month as their birthday)? Or maybe it's a larger interval, like every 3 months starting from their birthday?

Don't mind the volatility but currently I'm having a look. Would be nice to have a better handle on it, similar to knowing there's a monthly depreciation of the value of +27yo players or the drop in value that happens on the first day of the month following the month in which a player turns 23, 25, etc. Any info or counterexamples (to Sessegnon's adjustment) are welcome.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...