Jump to content

Rahul W's rating predictions


Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, Cvilhete said:

Why do people insist on discussing matters they clearly know nothing about? 

Oh no, I'm sorry! You are one of those people who thinks 2nd place should get some sort of trophy? 

 

Nowhere near Juve means, although yes they have finished 2nd, they haven't laid a glove on Juve, it's you my friend that clearly knows nothing about actual football 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 41k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Sir Rahul

    4437

  • Kieran_S91

    3867

  • Soccahappy

    1738

  • Milanista1

    1469

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Hi all, As you have seen, I have not really been active over the past few months other than updating my preds. It's just been me phasing out of the forum. Now that the reviews are done, I can say

Just noticed this thread has crossed 1 million views, 23k odd replies, 930 pages.  I know this is 3 and a half years old but I never intended for this to monopolise the forum back then (I would h

Page 200- didn't think we'd get here when I started this casually- thanks all

Posted Images

Asked the question before but just curious for any more responses / changed minds

I have a lot of midfielders who I'll struggle to keep so if anyone could rank them / rate them out of 100 for long term potential I'd really appreciate it. 

Ndombele

Frenkie de Jong

Rodri 

Havertz

Aouar

Arthur

Fabian Ruiz

Neves

Thank you in advance!

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Toby S said:

I don't watch Napoli, any chance of an Allan +1 like Rahul has planned or no?

90% chance in a few hours

1 hour ago, HoochyKoochy said:

@rahul Fabian Ruiz ? not due a rise?

Will def get.

14 hours ago, errrrerrre said:

 

 

10 hours ago, Emy Ionescu said:

Hi guys,

Rodrigo de Paul + Sebastian Rudy for Maxi Gomez?

First 2 are mine.

Thanks!

I would. De Paul may end up at Fiorentina unlikely riser there.

2 hours ago, errrrerrre said:

O. Dembele +1 = 91? (36 milion price) ?
S. Niguez + 1?
José GIMÉNEZ +1?
Maxi GÓMEZ + 1?

Maybe the last 2 deserve. Niguez no reason to rise. Dembele stabbed by Barca but I guess has a chance.

On 7/1/2019 at 6:03 AM, Matthaios96 said:

Does anyone think that Cancelo could get a rise? Great breakthrough season at Juve and possible transfer to Man City

Thanks!

I wouldn't. Juve sold cause they can get better replacement. They might rise from hype

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Amar said:

If De Ligt moves to Juventus is that a good move SM wise?

Is it possible for him to become a 95 rated defender at Juventus?

Yes it is a good move as he has a strong chance of winning the league and cup there, then lets say in the PL. 

He has clearly shown he has a very high ceiling. 95, its a bit early to predict such a rating. First he should adapt/be consistent in Italy for seasons to come, and win a few trophies in order to reach such a rating, quicker. He certainly the potential! :)

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/2/2019 at 8:35 PM, tupac_healy said:

That's like saying it's not Pogba's fault Utd don't win anything and missed out on top 4, dead wrong, he has to shoulder a lot of the blame, the BIG players at these clubs have to stand up and be accountable 

 

How is it not Koulibaly's fault? He gets PAID to play for them! Surely if hes 'one of the best defenders in the world' they can win SOMETHING! they are in for about 4 trophies at the start of each season and are nowhere near Juve in the league in the last 5 or so years.....

 

Anyhow, you'll notice I said at the outset he's a top defender l, but for 94 you'd really want to be putting trophies on the table 

Koulibaly has probably been the best the defender in Italy for a few years now. 

His consistency, plus helping Napoli finish in the top 2 for the past few seasons i believe has got him a +1 to 94. Consider he is close to 30, so he wont have too many years at the highest level after that.

Koulibaly can't be blamed if Napoli's attack can't score enough to win games/see out games thus increasing their chances of winning a league title/cup. Napoli are not too far from Juve (you make them sound like a Fiorentina or some team of that level).

On the other hand Pogba has hit hot or cold since moving back to MU, at times he's been a real liability, such a player doesn't deserve a +1.

Although i do admit other players have also let MU down, but unlike Pogba they do not have the superstar talent that we know Pogba has. 

Edited by Milanista1
Added more
Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Toby S said:

I don't watch Napoli, any chance of an Allan +1 like Rahul has planned or no?

He deserves it

9 hours ago, HoochyKoochy said:

@rahul Fabian Ruiz ? not due a rise?

Yes, he is a starter for Napoli

19 minutes ago, WeAreBlades98 said:

Are Napoli changes tommorow? Confused because koudibaly got a rise yesterday

Or tomorrow or the day after tomorrow, SM is reviewing really slow, tomorrow is for sure Atalanta's turn

 

P.S. I got surprise too by KK rise, but he is one of the best defensor in Italy, always one of the greatest in Napoli team, I'm happy to see they did even if the team hasn't won a trophy

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/25/2016 at 12:12 PM, Sir Rahul said:

ITALY SERIE A

Juventus:

Kean +2 to 84- +1 to 83

Szczesny +1 to 91

Costa -1 to 91

Khedira -1 to 91

Bentancur +1 to 90

De Sciglio +1 to 90

Cuadrado -1 to 90

Barzagli -1 to 88

 

Napoli:

Allan +1 to 92

Hysaj +1 to 91

Milik +1 to 90

Maksimovic +1 to 88

Malcuit +1 to 88

Chiriches -1 to 87

Meret +1 to 86

Ounas +1 to 86

Luperto +1 to 84

Koulibaly +1 to 94

 

Atalanta:

Zapata +1 to 90- yes

Castagne +1 to 87- +2 to 88

Hateboer +1 to 88

Masiello +1 to 88

Mancini +2 to 87

Gollini +2 to 87

Gosens +1 to 87

Djimsiti +2 to 85

Vido +1 to 83

Haas +1 to 83

Carraro +2 to 82

Melegoni +4 to 80

Asmah +2 to 78

Mallamo +2 to 75

 

Inter:

Nainggolan -1 to 92- yes

Politano +1 to 90- yes

Miranda -1 to 90- yes

Martinez +1 to 89- yes

Brozovic +1 to 92

De Vrij +1 to 92

D'Ambrosio +1 to 90

Karamoh +1 to 86

Mario -1 to 89

Vrsaljko -1 to 89

Barbosa +1 to 88

Candreva -1 to 88

Dalbert -1 to 87

Ranocchia -1 to 86

Emmers +2 to 78

Pompetti +3 to 73

Colidio +3 to 73

 

Milan:

Romagnoli +1 to 91- yes

Kessie +1 to 90- yes

Bonaventura -1 to 90- yes

Calabria +1 to 89- yes

Paqueta +1 to 89- yes

Biglia -1 to 89- yes

Bertolacci -1 to 87- yes

Montolivo -1 to 86- yes

Piatek +1 to 89- +2 to 90

Suso +1 to 91- nope

Bakayoko +1 to 90- nope

Musacchio +1 to 90- nope

Cutrone +1 to 89- nope

Reina -2 to 87

A. Donnarumma -2 to 80

Gabbia +3 to 78

Pobega +3 to 73

 

Roma:

Perotti -1 to 89- yes

Jesus -1 to 88- yes

Zaniolo +6 to 86- +3 to 83; +5 to 88

Cristante +1 to 90- nope

Olsen +1 to 89- nope

Pastore -1 to 89

Marcano -1 to 88

Peres -1 to 88

De Rossi -2 to 88

Ponce +2 to 85

 

Torino:

Izzo +1 to 89- yes

Aina +2 to 87- +1 to 86

Moretti +1 to 87- nope

Berenguer +1 to 86- nope

N'Koulou +1 to 89

Sirigu +1 to 89

Zaza -1 to 89

Lukic +2 to 85

Gustafson +2 to 82

Carlao -1 to 82

Rosati -1 to 82

Segre +5 to 78

Buongiorno +2 to 78

De Luca +2 to 77

Candellone +1 to 77

 

Lazio:

Felipe +1 to 86- yes

Acerbi +1 to 90- nope

Strakosha +1 to 90- nope

Radu +1 to 90- nope

Marusic +1 to 90- nope

Correa +1 to 90- nope

Patric +1 to 85- nope

Parolo -1 to 89

Badelj -1 to 89

Wallace -1 to 87

Basta -1 to 85

Vargic -1 to 82

Di Gennaro -1 to 82

Anderson +8 to 78

Neto +3 to 78

Jordan +1 to 78

 

Sampdoria:

Quagliarella +1 to 90- yes

Audero +2 to 87- yes

Colley +1 to 87- yes

Andersen +2 to 88- +1 to 87

Defrel +1 to 89- nope

Murru +1 to 88- nope

Ekdal +1 to 88- nope

Sala +1 to 87- nope

Saponara -1 to 87- nope

Sau -1 to 85

Barreto -2 to 85

 

Bologna:

Pulgar +1 to 88- yes

Sansone -1 to 88- yes

Santander +1 to 87- yes

Mbaye +1 to 86- yes

Orsolini +2 to 85- +3 to 86

Skorupski +1 to 88- nope

Palacio +1 to 87- nope

Soriano -1 to 87- nope

Dijks +1 to 86- nope

 

Calabresi +2 to 84- nope

Donsah -1 to 86

Lyanco +3 to 85

Avenatti +2 to 85

Da Costa -1 to 83

Crisetig -2 to 83

Rizzo -2 to 82

Michael +5 to 80

 

Sassuolo:

Magnani +2 to 85- yes

Sensi +1 to 87- +2 to 88

Demihral +2 to 85- +4 to 87

Rogerio +2 to 87- +1 to 86

Bourabia +3 to 86- +2 to 85

Boga +1 to 84- +2 to 85

Lirola +1 to 88nope

Ferrari +1 to 88nope

Peluso +1 to 86nope

Djuricic +1 to 86nope

Consigli -1 to 87

Babacar -1 to 87

Lemos -1 to 86

Matri -2 to 83

Bandinelli +2 to 82

Frattesi +2 to 80

Broh +1 to 78

Pierini +1 to 78

Tripaldelli +3 to 76

 

Udinese:

Teodorcyzk -1 to 87- yes

Musso +3 to 86- yes

Troost-Ekong +1 to 86- yes

Wilmot +2 to 77- +3 to 78

Fofana +1 to 88- nope

Lasagna +1 to 88- nope

Mandragora +1 to 88- nope

Larsen +1 to 87- nope

Nuytinck +1 to 86- nope

D'Alessandro +1 to 85- nope

Ter Avest +1 to 83- nope

Opoku +2 to 82- nope

De Paul +1 to 89

Machis +1 to 85

Hallfredsson -1 to 85

Badu -1 to 84

Iniguez -2 to 78

 

SPAL:

Fares +1 to 87- yes

Vicari +1 to 86- yes

Bonifazi +3 to 85- yes

Cionek +1 to 86- nope

Antenucci +1 to 86- nope

Schiattarella +1 to 86- nope

Gomis +1 to 86- nope

Valoti +1 to 84- nope

Paloschi -1 to 86

Viviano -1 to 86

Regini -1 to 85

Valdifiori -2 to 83

Djourou -2 to 83

Finotto +2 to 82

Floccari -1 to 81

Esposito +3 to 73

 

Parma:

Sepe +1 to 86- yes

Bastoni +3 to 83- yes

Barilla +2 to 85- +1 to 84

Iacoponi +3 to 85- +1 to 83

Gagliolo +1 to 86- nope

Siligardi +2 to 85- nope

Stulac +1 to 85- nope

Scozzarella +1 to 84- nope

Biabiany -1 to 84

Machin +3 to 83

Dezi -1 to 83

Gobbi -1 to 83

Dimarco +2 to 82

Galano -2 to 82

 

Cagliari:

Pellegrini +1 to 78- +3 to 80

Pedro +1 to 88- nope

Ionita +1 to 87- nope

Ceppitelli +1 to 87- nope

Pisacane +1 to 86- nope

Barella +1 to 90

Cragno +1 to 89

Castro -1 to 87

Klavan -1 to 86

Birsa -1 to 86

Padoin -1 to 86

Walukiewicz +4 to 80

Oliva +2 to 80

Ragatzu -2 to 78

 

Fiorentina:

Milenkovic +1 to 89- yes

Lafont +1 to 88- yes

Fernandes +2 to 87- +1 to 86

Biraghi +1 to 89- nope

Gerson +1 to 88- nope

Hugo +1 to 88- nope

Ceccherini +1 to 86- nope

Saponara -1 to 87

Mirallas -1 to 86

Thereau -3 to 83

Ranieri +9 to 82

Hancko +2 to 82

Vlahovic +1 to 78

Sottil +2 to 77

Gori +3 to 76

 

Genoa:

Rolon +2 to 82- yes

Romero +4 to 84- +6 to 86

Koaume +2 to 87- +1 to 86

Biraschi +2 to 87- +1 to 86

Radu +3 to 86- +2 to 85

Lazovic +1 to 87- nope

Bessa +1 to 86- nope

Pereira +2 to 84- nope

Gunter +2 to 82- nope

Sturaro -1 to 87

Lapadula -1 to 86

Zukanovic -1 to 86

Veloso -1 to 85

Jandrei +1 to 83

Marchetti -2 to 83

Spolli -2 to 83

Valietti +3 to 76

Zennaro +3 to 76

Zanimacchia +2 to 75

 

Empoli:

Caputo +1 to 86- yes

Dragowski +1 to 83- yes

Rasmussen +2 to 82- yes

Di Lorenzo +1 to 85- +3 to 87

Bennacer +1 to 86- +2 to 87

Traore +2 to 84- +3 to 85

Veseli +2 to 85nope

Provedel +1 to 84- nope

Krunic +1 to 87

Silvestre -1 to 86

Acquah -1 to 85

Pajac +1 to 83

Capezzi -1 to 83

Maietta -1 to 83

Buchel -2 to 83

Antonelli -3 to 83

Lollo -1 to 82

Brighi -2 to 80

Meli +3 to 73

 

Frosinone:

Beghetto +1 to 84- yes

Pinamonti +2 to 82- +3 to 83

Dionisi -1 to 84- -2 to 83

Chibsah +1 to 85- nope

Capuano +1 to 85- nope

Maiello +1 to 85- nope

Zampano +1 to 85- nope

Sportiello -1 to 87

Molinaro -2 to 83

Ariaudo -2 to 83

Sammarco -1 to 82

Brighenti -1 to 82

Iacobucci -1 to 82

Matarese +1 to 76

Trotta -3 to 83

Besea +2 to 75

Volpe +2 to 75

Gori +2 to 70

 

Chievo:

Depaoli +1 to 85- yes

Leris +3 to 80- +5 to 82

Vignato +2 to 75- +5 to 78

Barba +1 to 85- nope

Rigoni +1 to 85- nope

Jaroszynski +1 to 83- nope

Hetemaj -1 to 85

Sorrentino -1 to 85

Giachherini -2 to 85

Obi -1 to 84

Pucciarelli -1 to 84

Andreolli -2 to 83

Tomovic -2 to 83

Djordjevic -1 to 82

Seculin -2 to 80

Rodriguez -2 to 80

Yamga +1 to 78

Rigione -3 to 77

Burruchaga +5 to 73

Isufaj +3 to 73

Grubac +3 to 73

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Milanista1 said:

 Koulibaly has probably been the best the defender in italy for a few years now. 

The consistency, plus helping Napoli finish in the top 2 for last few seasons i believe has got him a +1 to 94. He is close to 30, so he wont have too many years at the highest level after that. Koulibaly can't be blamed if Napoli's attack can't score enough to win games/see out games thus increasing there chances of winning a league title/cup.

On the other hand Pogba has blown hot and cold since moving back to MU, at times he's been a liability, such a player doesn't deserve a +1. 

Again..... the point I was making, gone way over your head.........

In very basic simple terms, my point is Koulibaly got 94 on the back of a load of hype, which is true as he doesn't have the trophies to back it up, so again MY POINT WAS TROPHIES DON'T MATTER... 

 

I was not arguing who deserves what rise, for the love of god, I've never disagreed that Koulibaly ain't world class, and I used Pogba to MAKE MY POINT, again, I agree that Pogba 100% shouldn't get a rise, in fact i argued in this thread he was closer the drop! But again, he, Lingard and even VVD, HYPE! Yes VVD won 1 champions league, fair play.. 92-93 would have been fine for that, he got that +1 on HYPE! 

 

That's the ONLY point I've been making, Koulibaly is top drawer (IMO 92-93 max without trophies) same for Pogba, same for VVD.... 

 

Again, I stress the importance of winning trophies has been take  out of the ratings system, it used to matter but obviously not anymore.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, congola said:

does anyone think skrinair has a chance of rising? marquions & koulaby got rises

Yes, but i see it more possibly in the next review because he has not played at a consistent, high level long enough (a couple of seasons) for an increase. 

The two you mentioned play for a better team than Inter, and usually finish in the top 2 of their league. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
56 minutes ago, vitor_mfc said:

Well De Gea got to 95 at a very subpar Man Utd because he's quality, or was, so i don't see why a player like Koulibaly can't rise in quality alone.

Agreed but should he really be the best rated keeper. I'm not disputing he is one of the best but is oblak maybe not on par? Seems harsh that De gea can get 95 at United because of their status despite their form when he can't 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, RhysMorgan said:

Agreed but should he really be the best rated keeper. I'm not disputing he is one of the best but is oblak maybe not on par? Seems harsh that De gea can get 95 at United because of their status despite their form when he can't 

De gea gets more attention because united defence is not as good as atletico and he performed really well for several seasons compared to one not so good season. De gea at 95 is OK for me.

In term of skill, I believe oblak and even allison are not below de gea. I think allison also has more attention compared to oblak seeing number of clean sheets he had this season, several crucial saves to win the UCL and performes well in copa america so I will not really surprised if allison gets 95 faster but due to hype rather than better in skill than oblak.

Sadly oblak just not getting enough attention to reach 95, not to mention his national team way below the other two

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, samfarrow said:

Asked the question before but just curious for any more responses / changed minds

I have a lot of midfielders who I'll struggle to keep so if anyone could rank them / rate them out of 100 for long term potential I'd really appreciate it. 

Ndombele

Frenkie de Jong

Rodri 

Havertz

Aouar

Arthur

Fabian Ruiz

Neves

Thank you in advance!

I'd definitely keep De Jong, Havertz, Arthur and Rodri. All have massive potential and at big clubs/moving to big clubs. 

Ruiz, Neves and Aouar have potential but at smaller clubs so less opportunity to rise...If I had to sell one it'd probably be Neves.

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, samfarrow said:

Asked the question before but just curious for any more responses / changed minds

I have a lot of midfielders who I'll struggle to keep so if anyone could rank them / rate them out of 100 for long term potential I'd really appreciate it. 

Ndombele

Frenkie de Jong

Rodri 

Havertz

Aouar

Arthur

Fabian Ruiz

Neves

Thank you in advance!

Not easy to rank some of these players by any means: 

K.Harvetz - For me he is the best young midfielder in the world right now. Love watching him play!

FDJ/Rodri 

Ndombele/Arthur

Aouar

Neves

F.Ruiz

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/3/2019 at 10:22 AM, tupac_healy said:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
7
5 hours ago, tupac_healy said:

Again..... the point I was making, gone way over your head.........

In very basic simple terms, my point is Koulibaly got 94 on the back of a load of hype, which is true as he doesn't have the trophies to back it up, so again MY POINT WAS TROPHIES DON'T MATTER... 

 

I was not arguing who deserves what rise, for the love of god, I've never disagreed that Koulibaly ain't world class, and I used Pogba to MAKE MY POINT, again, I agree that Pogba 100% shouldn't get a rise, in fact i argued in this thread he was closer the drop! But again, he, Lingard and even VVD, HYPE! Yes VVD won 1 champions league, fair play.. 92-93 would have been fine for that, he got that +1 on HYPE! 

 

That's the ONLY point I've been making, Koulibaly is top drawer (IMO 92-93 max without trophies) same for Pogba, same for VVD.... 

 

Again, I stress the importance of winning trophies has been take  out of the ratings system, it used to matter but obviously not anymore.

Dear Tupac_healy,

"Look, Koulibaly as fine a defender as he is, and let's face it, he is..... is a complete farce at 94"! Your words seem to underate KK as a defender.

"I was not arguing who deserves what rise".  We are talking rating, and rises here.

Look I don't think your point is over my head. I agree with you that many players deserve to rise if their team wins trophies/cups during the season, and if that player is playing consistently well during the season. I agree SM seem to be ignoring the trophy element beofre rising some players (which i think is kind of good for players like KK).

I also agree with you that SM have fast tracked a few players to a higher rating (such as the likes of Allison, Neres, FJD and Lingaard).

I must STRESS :) that I believe it's unfair for a player like Koulibaly not to ever reach to a 94 (someday) in his SM lifetime (whether he wins a trophy or not), just because those ahead of him can't score enough goals/see out games in order for him to actually win a title/cup. 

Say If he played for a Juventus, Liverpool or M.City we probably wouldn't be having this conversation. 

I only disagree with you in that i don't think KK was hyped to his rating. He deserves it whether he plays for a Napoli or a Arsenal, because of his years of consistency at the highest level.

Good day Tupac_healy.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...