Rahul W's rating predictions

[JAMancini 182]

Sell one:

Gaya

Ferland Mendy

Alex Sandro

 

[sirmarkhughes 24,738]

2 hours ago, JAMancini said:

Sell one:

Gaya

Ferland Mendy

Alex Sandro

 

Gaya

[Milanista1 1,094]

2 hours ago, JAMancini said:

Sell one:

Gaya

Ferland Mendy

Alex Sandro

 

Me saying Gaya as well.

A.Sandro is still at a high rating.

F.Mendy has done quite well with the few apps he's had so far (better defensivly then Marcelo, links up well with E.Hazard). .

Although right now F.Mendy is injured unfortunately (Nacho is filling at LB until Marcelo returns back first) I'm sure F.Mendy will get game time when he is soon fit again.

[TheRealGiles 16]

Sancho or Felix?

I'd play either as a winger so CF of Felix doesn't matter so much.

I feel like Sancho is closer to 91 at the moment but what are people's thoughts of their longer term potential?

Thanks.

 

[Milanista1 1,094]

On 10/1/2019 at 9:26 AM, TheRealGiles said:

Sancho or Felix?

I'd either as a winger so CF of Felix doesn't matter so much.

I feel like Sancho is closer to 91 at the moment but what are people's thoughts of their longer term potential?

Thanks.

 

Right now I would choose Sancho. 

J.Felix has not been performing well in A.Madrid last few games (was outshone/schooledby M.Odegaard in the game against R.Sociedad, and wasn't much of a threat to RM). 

I think Simone pressing game will have an effect on his energy levels which of course will effect his overall game, plus playing against better players/in a different country this season may also affect his confidence in big games. 

Nevertheless he is still a great young talent to have for any team, but as it is right now Sancho is ahead of him for me. 

In the long term:

J.Sancho can explode much like R.Sterling has done, (but will that be at B.Dortmund or at a bigger Club)?

J.Felix, right now I'm not too sure about him. If he does pick up, and does well he could become the Portuguese version of Kaka or if he fails and flops he could just well be another J.Pastore.

I'd give him a season or 2 to get a better idea. 

Edited October 3, 2019 by Milanista1
Very minor spelling mistake.

[TMCosta 1,564]

3 hours ago, Milanista1 said:

Right now I would choose Sancho. 

J.Felix has not been performing well in A.Madrid last few games (was outshone/schooledby M.Odegaard in the game against R.Sociedad, and wasn't much of a threat to RM). 

I think Simone pressing game will have an effect on his energy levels which of course will effect his overall game, plus playing against better players/in a different country this season may also affect his confidence in big games. 

Nevertheless he is still a great young talent to have for any team, but as it is right now Sancho is ahead of him for me. 

In the long term:

J.Sancho can explode much like R.Sterling has dome, (but will that be at B.Dortmund or at a bigger Club)?

J.Felix, right now I'm not too sure about him. If he does pick up, and does well he could become the Portuguese version of Kaka or if he fails and flops he could just well be another J.Pastore.

I'd give him a season or 2 to get a better idea. 

Nailed it

[jlammy 95]

Thiago or Pogba?

Big rise for Lodi of Atletico? 

[Milanista1 1,094]

21 hours ago, jlammy said:

Thiago or Pogba?

Thiago has started the season very well again for BM. I think if BM can win the CL or Thiago can play and win a Cup with Spain then he could reach as high as a 95+ in his SM career. 

PreMadonna-Pogba on the other hand needs to put his head down and perform much better (was one of United's worst player's against Arsenal). I don't think his agent helps his mental game to ($ogba reportedly asking for a huge contract).

Right now he has an (aggravated) ankle injury, and will miss the next 2 games. 

 

Big rise for Lodi of Atletico? 

He's not risen yet as you mentioned to me in the posts below: Should easily get a +3 or +4 in the next review. 

Nevertheless he has done well for A.Madrid so far, but of course at only 21 there's room for improvement.

 

 

 

[vitor_mfc 3,862]

12 hours ago, TheRealGiles said:

Sancho or Felix?

I'd play either as a winger so CF of Felix doesn't matter so much.

I feel like Sancho is closer to 91 at the moment but what are people's thoughts of their longer term potential?

Thanks.

 

Sancho for sure. Felix is a season of top level experience behind Sancho and should not be 90 rated.

[jlammy 95]

1 hour ago, Milanista1 said:

Big rise for Lodi of Atletico? 

I think he had a rise only recently, should get another at the end of season, if he doesnt get one in the Winter then I'd expect one to be in the mid/big range rise dependant on his performances and where A.Madrid finish.

Nevertheless he has done well for A.Madrid so far, but of course there's room for improvement.

 

Lodi is currently 82 (!!) and as far as I'm aware hasn't had a rating change.

As Atletico's starting LB, and with the way he's been playing, I'm expecting high-80s in the next review? 

[TheRealGiles 16]

3 hours ago, jlammy said:

Thiago or Pogba?

Big rise for Lodi of Atletico? 

Thiago easily at the moment.

Yes he'll get a big rise if he carries on playing. Probably +4/5 at the Christmas review (assuming they wait that long to rise him).

[Cvilhete 597]

On 9/29/2019 at 11:01 AM, Cvilhete said:

if by some miracle Reece James is still available in any of your setups i'd snap him up straight away, he'll probably be a full fledged starter after the international break and he's going to be a big player for the future.

Tomori too

[Milanista1 1,094]

28 minutes ago, jlammy said:

Lodi is currently 82 (!!) and as far as I'm aware hasn't had a rating change.

As Atletico's starting LB, and with the way he's been playing, I'm expecting high-80s in the next review? 

Yes indeed I now see that Lodi hasn't had a random rise like others got. I got mixed up between him and Carvalho Reinier, who got a +3 in September. I thought it was Renan Lodi (sorry for error). 

I do struggle with Neurological fatigue, that's where my mistakes can sometimes come from.

 

[sirmarkhughes 24,738]

1 hour ago, jlammy said:

Lodi is currently 82 (!!) and as far as I'm aware hasn't had a rating change.

As Atletico's starting LB, and with the way he's been playing, I'm expecting high-80s in the next review? 

Yeah he has been bagging decent minutes. I have him over on the 50 to follow. Would guess 82-85 mid season rise.

Here are the few that are standing out early doors (eight games#) with decent minutes.

Ansu fati 76 (£1.6M) La Liga 5 games-172 mins-2 goals/1 assist/CL 1 game-90 mins
Dejan Kulusevski 76 (£320k) Serie A 6 games-505 mins-1 goal-3 assists/Cup 1 game-90 mins
Aaron Ramsdale 75 (£1m) EPL 7 games-630 mins
Axel Disasi 78 (£1.2m) Ligue 1 -  8 games-720 mins
Rayan Ait-Nouri 73 (£400k) Ligue 1 - 7 games-590 mins
Bafoud Diakite 78 (£600k) Ligue 1- 6 games-531 mins
Mason Greenwood 73  (£1m) EPL 5 game-63 min/EL 1 game-90 min-1 goal/Cup 1 game-90 mins-1 gl
Joe Willock 78 (£1.2m)EPL 6 game-293 min-EL 1 game-72 min-1 gl/cup 1 game-90 min-1 goal
Eduardo Camavinga 80 (£4m) Ligue 1 -8 game-699 mins/EL 1 game-18 min/Cup 1 game-90 min
Carles Perez 80 (£2.4m) La Liga 6 games-403 mins-1 goal-3 assists
Laszlo Benes 80 (£2.4m) Bundi 5 game-306 min/EL 1 game 90 mins
Domagoj Bradaric 82 (£2m) Ligue 1-7 games-524 mins-1 assist/CL 1 game/90 min/Cup 1 game/61 min
Renan Lodi 82 (£2.8m) La Liga 6 games-463 mins/CL 2 games-166 mins

 

 

[crvena_zvezda 128]

With some countries having been reviewed recently, any future risers coming up? For a setup limited to buying players rated 85 and below.

[TheRealGiles 16]

Thanks for your replies guys. There has been a development. The manager of Sancho has countered me Felix + Camavinga.

I feel like maybe this is too much given Camavinga's promise. What do you think?

[TheRealGiles 16]

10 hours ago, crvena_zvezda said:

With some countries having been reviewed recently, any future risers coming up? For a setup limited to buying players rated 85 and below.

Check these guys out. I'll try help by giving my predictions of where they'll be by the end of 2019 (on their current trajectory - obviously still early to say for sure):

 

• Mohamed SIMAKAN 19 73 -> 80/82
• Bafode DIAKITE 18 78 -> 82/83
• Benoit BADIASHILE 18 82 -> 85
• Marash KUMBULLA 19 70 -> 78/80
• Nehuen PEREZ 19 78 -> 82/83
• Killian SARDELLA 17 73 -> 80
• Rayan AIT-NOURI 18 73 -> 80/82
• Domagoj BRADARIC 19 82 -> 85
• Renan LODI 21 82 -> 85/86
• Gustavo ASSUNCAO 19 73 -> 80/82
• Aurelien TCHOUAMENI 19 82 -> 85
• Eduardo CAMAVINGA 16 80 -> 83
• Orkun KOKCU 18 76 -> 82/83
• Gaetano CASTROVILLI 22 82 -> 85
• Dejan KULUSEVSKI 19 76 -> 80/82
• Dominik SZOBOSZLAI 18 82 -> 85
• Bukayo SAKA 18 73 -> 80
• Ansu FATI 16 76 -> 80/82
• Mason GREENWOOD 18 73 -> 80
• Aleksandr SOBOLEV 22 78 -> 82/83
• Anderson SILVA 21 74 -> 80

 

I've tried to be on the conservative side with these predictions. I won't be surprised if the likes of Fati, Greenwood, Saka e.g. are higher than what I've put here. It depends if they continue to get plenty of minutes and whether SM decides to rise them in between full league reviews (or just hype rise them). Hope this helps.

 

 

 

Edited October 2, 2019 by TheRealGiles
Kulusevski rating wrong

[zsp2 513]

1 hour ago, TheRealGiles said:

Check these guys out. I'll try help by giving my predictions of where they'll be by the end of 2019 (on their current trajectory - obviously still early to say for sure):

 

• Mohamed SIMAKAN 19 73 -> 80/82
• Bafode DIAKITE 18 78 -> 82/83
• Benoit BADIASHILE 18 82 -> 85
• Marash KUMBULLA 19 70 -> 78/80
• Nehuen PEREZ 19 78 -> 82/83
• Killian SARDELLA 17 73 -> 80
• Rayan AIT-NOURI 18 73 -> 80/82
• Domagoj BRADARIC 19 82 -> 85
• Renan LODI 21 82 -> 85/86
• Gustavo ASSUNCAO 19 73 -> 80/82
• Aurelien TCHOUAMENI 19 82 -> 85
• Eduardo CAMAVINGA 16 80 -> 83
• Orkun KOKCU 18 76 -> 82/83
• Gaetano CASTROVILLI 22 82 -> 85
• Dejan KULUSEVSKI 19 73 -> 80/82
• Dominik SZOBOSZLAI 18 82 -> 85
• Bukayo SAKA 18 73 -> 80
• Ansu FATI 16 76 -> 80/82
• Mason GREENWOOD 18 73 -> 80
• Aleksandr SOBOLEV 22 78 -> 82/83
• Anderson SILVA 21 74 -> 80

 

I've tried to be on the conservative side with these predictions. I won't be surprised if the likes of Fati, Greenwood, Saka e.g. are higher than what I've put here. It depends if they continue to get plenty of minutes and whether SM decides to rise them in between full league reviews (or just hype rise them). Hope this helps.

 

 

 

Kulusevski is 76😉, I think he will have a +6 like SM did last year with H. Traorè.

Thanks for your prediction

[sirmarkhughes 24,738]

12 hours ago, sirmarkhughes said:

Yeah he has been bagging decent minutes. I have him over on the 50 to follow. Would guess 82-85 mid season rise.

Here are the few that are standing out early doors (eight games#) with decent minutes.

Ansu fati 76 (£1.6M) La Liga 5 games-172 mins-2 goals/1 assist/CL 1 game-90 mins
Dejan Kulusevski 76 (£320k) Serie A 6 games-505 mins-1 goal-3 assists/Cup 1 game-90 mins
Aaron Ramsdale 75 (£1m) EPL 7 games-630 mins
Axel Disasi 78 (£1.2m) Ligue 1 -  8 games-720 mins
Rayan Ait-Nouri 73 (£400k) Ligue 1 - 7 games-590 mins
Bafoud Diakite 78 (£600k) Ligue 1- 6 games-531 mins
Mason Greenwood 73  (£1m) EPL 5 game-63 min/EL 1 game-90 min-1 goal/Cup 1 game-90 mins-1 gl
Joe Willock 78 (£1.2m)EPL 6 game-293 min-EL 1 game-72 min-1 gl/cup 1 game-90 min-1 goal
Eduardo Camavinga 80 (£4m) Ligue 1 -8 game-699 mins/EL 1 game-18 min/Cup 1 game-90 min
Carles Perez 80 (£2.4m) La Liga 6 games-403 mins-1 goal-3 assists
Laszlo Benes 80 (£2.4m) Bundi 5 game-306 min/EL 1 game 90 mins
Domagoj Bradaric 82 (£2m) Ligue 1-7 games-524 mins-1 assist/CL 1 game/90 min/Cup 1 game/61 min
Renan Lodi 82 (£2.8m) La Liga 6 games-463 mins/CL 2 games-166 mins

 

 

Ansu fati 76 -82/83
Dejan Kulusevski 76 -82
Aaron Ramsdale 75 -82
Axel Disasi 78 (-82
Rayan Ait-Nouri 73 - 80/82
Bafoud Diakite 78 -82/83
Mason Greenwood 73- 80/82
Joe Willock 78 -82
Eduardo Camavinga 80 -83
Carles Perez 80 -83
Laszlo Benes 80 -83
Domagoj Bradaric 82 -85
Renan Lodi 82 -85

I have added what I think the half season predictions of the players will be if the average minutes continue. All are worth picking up as they will no doubt get both the mid/end of season rises. I will do a proper predict on all 50 at end of November as more will be known by then.

[jlammy 95]

Klosterman or Kehrer?

[vitor_mfc 3,862]

Arsenal logic:

Let go Gnabry for 5M€ gets Pepe for 80€

I think Pepe is a very good player, but Gnabry talent was always visible. Nurture the talents you already have and spare yourself a few millions.

 

[ombarcagunners 546]

 .

 

[ombarcagunners 546]

3 hours ago, sirmarkhughes said:

Ansu Fati 76 -> 84
Dejan Kulusevski 76 -> 82
Aaron Ramsdale 75 -> 82
Axel Disasi 78 -> 82
Rayan Ait-Nouri 73 -> 82
Bafodé Diakite 78 -> 82
Mason Greenwood 73 -> 80
Joe Willock 78 -> 82
Eduardo Camavinga 80 -> 84
Carles Perez 80 -> 83
Laszlo Benes 80 -> 83
Domagoj Bradaric 82 -> 85
Renan Lodi 82 -> 85

 

[Hfazil 194]

On 9/30/2019 at 12:05 AM, Hfazil said:

Kovacic or SMS?

.

[ombarcagunners 546]

Rafael Defendi to 85?