Jump to content
Sir Rahul

Rahul W's rating predictions

Recommended Posts

53 minutes ago, Alfino said:

For the russian leage what are the players that from less then 1 M will grow more?

In my team the average is 84 and i have 4M budget so i would like to buy the best of

Refer to my first page please

45 minutes ago, thorgan lesar said:

Tomorrow more of Anderlecht. Doku played since december nearly every week, so possible he will rise tomorrow

Drops of Trébel, Gerkens, Srarfi en Oberlin were quite expected. Trébel played nearly nothing.. Same for Gerkens. Zulte Waregem has a cap of 84 and Oberlin played not so much and didn't perform. His drop is correct. Srarfi didn't perform either. He's just new (in the winter to Belgium) and I thought he was going to drop with - 1, but - 2 is also correct. 

But like I said.. Belgian predictions => my thread. 

Trebel - Transfermarkt says he has been injured for most of the season, on that basis it seems extreme to drop his rating by two.

Gerkens - Same as Trebel

Srarfi and Oberlin - limited gametime yes but in the past SM never used to drop young player ratings like this, -2s feel extreme to me. 

So yeah, would not call them expected. But hey.

I'm not the only guy who can predict ratings here, never have been, but kinda feels you're undermining the preds I do on this thread, that's all.

30 minutes ago, Alfino said:

No answers in other sections so i ask here:

how do i counter 433A? 1 rate stronger 

Tactics not my strong point, sorry

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
57 minutes ago, Sir Rahul said:

Trebel - Transfermarkt says he has been injured for most of the season, on that basis it seems extreme to drop his rating by two.

Gerkens - Same as Trebel

Srarfi and Oberlin - limited gametime yes but in the past SM never used to drop young player ratings like this, -2s feel extreme to me. 

So yeah, would not call them expected. But hey.

 

I'm not the only guy who can predict ratings here, never have been, but kinda feels you're undermining the preds I do on this thread, that's all.

Trebel is in a dispute with RSC Anderlecht and they don't let him play. That's why he isn't playing any more. He only played when everyone was injured. Trébel didn't perform either in his games.

Gerkens dropped with - 1 while he didn't play. That's no surprise. 

SM was previous year generous, now they aren't. These drops are correct in my opinion. I saw them playing, they didn't perform. Oberlin scored in the cup against Club Brugge, but for the rest he didn't do much.. . Srarfi got a - 1 from me, but a - 2 is at least understandable. 

 

And no. Your work is brilliant. It's just I'm week by week, day by day busy with Belgian football and I want to be the one with a prediction-list of my own country. If you are doing the top teams they won't go any more to my thread, because this thread is the most popular one and everyone comes to this thread. Like @Kierans91 is doing, is perfect for me. He gives his opinion and is doing brilliant work in this thread, but doesn't make a list because he knows there is someone who's making a list. There are still 15 - 30 countries you can focuse on. So no I'm not undermining your preds..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, NickTheBiz said:

What's everyone's thoughts on Carles Perez now he's moved to Roma?

Like the guy was getting going bit covid may holt that - a wait and see potential tops perhaps 91 but talking in years if he can stay in the team 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, NickTheBiz said:

Lot of interest in my GW in Kellyn Acosta too.  What's the deal with him?

Cant see nothing to why now 2019 January looked possible that he may move to the english championship maybe people have seen a club interested in him going up at a guess? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, thorgan lesar said:

Trebel is in a dispute with RSC Anderlecht and they don't let him play. That's why he isn't playing any more. He only played when everyone was injured. Trébel didn't perform either in his games.

Gerkens dropped with - 1 while he didn't play. That's no surprise. 

SM was previous year generous, now they aren't. These drops are correct in my opinion. I saw them playing, they didn't perform. Oberlin scored in the cup against Club Brugge, but for the rest he didn't do much.. . Srarfi got a - 1 from me, but a - 2 is at least understandable. 

 

And no. Your work is brilliant. It's just I'm week by week, day by day busy with Belgian football and I want to be the one with a prediction-list of my own country. If you are doing the top teams they won't go any more to my thread, because this thread is the most popular one and everyone comes to this thread. Like @Kierans91 is doing, is perfect for me. He gives his opinion and is doing brilliant work in this thread, but doesn't make a list because he knows there is someone who's making a list. There are still 15 - 30 countries you can focuse on. So no I'm not undermining your preds..

That's fair enough, will not share my Belgium preds for the remaining time then. No problem, and I do appreciate the work you do. Much more detailed preds than I do. 🙂

Will help by putting your preds in the right section.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Krooss25 said:

Do we feel ben yedder should get at a +1 

50/50, somehow been denied the golden boot in Ligue 1 even though he’s scored the same amount of goals as Mbappe.

11 minutes ago, Nameless said:

If your first GK is 89 and your 2nd GK is 83. Will the second GK grow concern?

I wouldn’t think so but I agree with @Id rather be in SW19 play him in the odd cup match.

4 minutes ago, thorgan lesar said:

Upamecano or Skriniar ?

I know you like your youth players, players for the future so I would go for Upamecano. Signed a new deal with Leipzig recently which I don’t think is great for his rating in this game.

But he’s performing well though so he’s only getting better, would of liked to see him at a Liverpool/Man City or Barca and play first team, Would probably be 92/93 by the end of next season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, Kurt angle said:

So if Russia seems to be one of the next leagues to be reviewed who seems to stand out as the best buys?

 

Looks like Barinov and Shapi Suleymanov to me.

Diveev, Normann and Safanov

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Krooss25 said:

Do we feel ben yedder should get at a +1 

92 at Monaco, unlikely

7 hours ago, Nameless said:

If your first GK is 89 and your 2nd GK is 83. Will the second GK grow concern?

Don't think

7 hours ago, thorgan lesar said:

Upamecano or Skriniar ?

Skriniar for me

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, thorgan lesar said:

Depends on the deals of course...

Are they all between the same managers? are they as Thorgan is suggesting possibly one sided? Or do you share a PC with the person that the deals are being done with as that can cause issues, ie it would look like two "managers" were one person.

SMFA wouldnt block a deal just because someone reports it, they prefer to let the game flow, it has to be a blatent set of "bad deals" for them to reverse deals, then block transfers from or to a manager. 

How many game worlds does the manager have? how long have they been playing the game? what is their reputation level? all of these will be helpful signs to see if they are the problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally thought Jérémy Doku deserved 82 in this review but I guess 80 is fair seen as him and Sardella have both followed the same route in there ratings.

Both broke through into the first team this season playing similar amount of minutes (Doku did get a few of games last season all be it sub appearances)

Could say SM have been consistent for once in this instance 😏

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Id rather be in SW19 said:

Are they all between the same managers? are they as Thorgan is suggesting possibly one sided? Or do you share a PC with the person that the deals are being done with as that can cause issues, ie it would look like two "managers" were one person.

SMFA wouldnt block a deal just because someone reports it, they prefer to let the game flow, it has to be a blatent set of "bad deals" for them to reverse deals, then block transfers from or to a manager. 

How many game worlds does the manager have? how long have they been playing the game? what is their reputation level? all of these will be helpful signs to see if they are the problem.

That’s valid. But in scenario of cheating. I have had deals blocked by SMFA for no reason whatsoever.  I’m talking two or three in the 9 years I’v been playing. The only common denominator was if I remember correctly, first attempts with other managers. But eventually I do remember concluding a deal in one scenario for sure. There used to be a statement somewhere that if you aren’t active and don’t do deals then you may be removed from a GW. I always suspected it was to do with that because they were GWs where not many deals took place so inactivity was high (mostly cos everyone was in debt). Just the way the algorithm worked.  But I am talkin between 2010-2015.  Not experienced that myself last few years, only witnessed some shortlisted players deals collapsing befor competition. Fair deals too. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Kierans91 said:

Personally thought Jérémy Doku deserved 82 in this review but I guess 80 is fair seen as him and Sardella have both followed the same route in there ratings.

Both broke through into the first team this season playing similar amount of minutes (Doku did get a few of games last season all be it sub appearances)

Could say SM have been consistent for once in this instance 😏

Fair point in consistency. But Doku just like Plentickx has gone down in vakue despite the rise. By like 200k. 
 

Really hope @Soccahappy is healthy and well.  He would be the right person to comment on values as he tracked them well. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sczcesky (or however it's spelled), Juve GK hit his max rating? 

Will Lloris drop in this coming review? Rahul hasn't predicted a drop. 

Who is more likely to retain their current rating longer?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...