Jump to content
Sir Rahul

Rahul W's rating predictions

Recommended Posts

1 minute ago, Fadi7 said:

He’s only selling Courtois as he has Donnarumma so he wouldn’t be interested in De Gea...

To clarify, Courtois and Odegaard are in two different clubs.

He wants Brandt in the swap deal with Courtois. Courtois is great goalkeeper, but Brandt is really important in Dortmund as well. If you really need a good goalkeeper, I will say do it, but first look to your squad if there aren't many other options. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Fadi7 said:

De Gea + Brandt or Courtois + Odegaard + one of (Bale, Alderweireld, Matip, Moura)

 

Courtois, Odegaard and Moura.

How Ole thinks De Gea is still the best keeper in the world is beyond me to much of a liability these days.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, NickTheBiz said:

This comment proves that the majority of GC1 read this thread.

I am disappoint :(

haha! I kinda regretted posting because @TMCosta is in one of my GWs... he bid for Robben already ;) :( 

15 hours ago, Nameless said:

The recent must buy Quaresma or Tapsoba. 

Tapsoba for me

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, thorgan lesar said:

If you have 7.09 million euros in your club available it's possible you can go for them. 1.9 million euros for Quaresma (maximum) and 5.19 million euros for Tapsoba (maximum). We don't know yet how far Quaresma his potential is going, but for Tapsoba 5.19 million euros is nothing. 

If both are available of course, but go for it, I'd say. :) 

It was a question primarily to understand the potential of Quaresma. They are both taken. 

In your thread you name a lot of young talents. In my GW they are all taken! Any player added to the database gets bids after bids. 

In conclusion I have gathered Quaresma (without watching him at all) is not as talented as Tapsoba. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Sir Rahul not sure if SM is still taking suggestions on improving the game. I have had this frustrating experience which, if possible, you could mention. 

I joined (more than half a season) this very old standard GW. So any player you can name are taken. 

I put a bid in for a player of another team and the manager countered. So I sold one of my best players to external to raise money and then accepted the bid. SMFA blocked it.

My complain is, I am at a double loss. I sold a player at least half a dozen will bid and I haven't got the new player. All because either the opposite number is black marked by SMFA or someone reported because they didn't like the deal. Happens a lot apparently. 

So shouldn't SM be clear that some managers are marked and then it's up to us if we want to risk dealing with them?

Like I mentioned I am at a double loss and having money means nothing. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Kierans91 said:

That article is an interesting read that’s for sure, I would guess that he would probably get a +1 based off those stats.

Levante are capped at 88 so he won’t go any higher than that, they are also mid table currently which could damage his chances of getting an increase.

An even more interesting as well as recent report regarding AITOR is this one https://totalfootballanalysis.com/player-analysis/aitor-fernandez-201920-scout-report-tactical-analysis-tactics
It is very well written .

PSxG+/- at this point in time (report is from 25/6) sais that he saved 12.5 more goals than he should have . Best in all top 5 leagues ... 

Even more impressive is it , knowing that he also faced some of the most difficult shots in all of Europe .

There is also a comparison with Cillessen , because seemingly Valencia is interested in him . Seems he tops Cillessen in almost every way . Cillessen is 90 rated .

I don't know how SW handles keeper ratings , but this is definately impressive to me and is deserving of a higher than 87 rating for sure even though he plays for a mediocre team .

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, topofthebilly said:

An even more interesting as well as recent report regarding AITOR is this one https://totalfootballanalysis.com/player-analysis/aitor-fernandez-201920-scout-report-tactical-analysis-tactics
It is very well written .

PSxG+/- at this point in time (report is from 25/6) sais that he saved 12.5 more goals than he should have . Best in all top 5 leagues ... 

Even more impressive is it , knowing that he also faced some of the most difficult shots in all of Europe .

There is also a comparison with Cillessen , because seemingly Valencia is interested in him . Seems he tops Cillessen in almost every way . Cillessen is 90 rated .

I don't know how SW handles keeper ratings , but this is definately impressive to me and is deserving of a higher than 87 rating for sure even though he plays for a mediocre team .

 

I think 88 will be the highest rating he can get at Levante but if he moves to Valencia then he would have a much higher ceiling and will probably move into the 90s if he continues his form.

Do you know if this is a one season wonder? I’m surprised it’s taken till he’s 29 to be performing this well. Or has he gone under the radar in the past?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will be selling Smalling, who should I buy with similar money that will provide cover to my central defense and also have a potential to grow? I am thinking of Dendoncker, is there anyone better?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all with brazilian league in review i thought I'd share brazilian youth players i have in my team that either did well in the U17 World Cup recently(ish) or were suggested for me to buy on here. I presume that some of them will get upgrades but can't confirm:

Talles Magno (18) - Vasco De Gama

Kai Jorge (18) - Santos

Damasceno Renyer (16) - Santos

Gabriel Veron (obvious one)(17) - Palmeiras

Vinicius Tobias (16) - SC Internacional

Miguel Silveira (17) - Fluminense

If anyone picks these guys up I hope they get upgraded :D 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, Arun said:

I will be selling Smalling, who should I buy with similar money that will provide cover to my central defense and also have a potential to grow? I am thinking of Dendoncker, is there anyone better?

Yeah Dendoncker is a good option, also Yerry Mina and Jules Kounde, Kounde should rise to 89 but is a much younger option at 21.

4 minutes ago, Toby S said:

Hi all with brazilian league in review i thought I'd share brazilian youth players i have in my team that either did well in the U17 World Cup recently(ish) or were suggested for me to buy on here. I presume that some of them will get upgrades but can't confirm:

Talles Magno (18) - Vasco De Gama

Kai Jorge (18) - Santos

Damasceno Renyer (16) - Santos

Gabriel Veron (obvious one)(17) - Palmeiras

Vinicius Tobias (16) - SC Internacional

Miguel Silveira (17) - Fluminense

If anyone picks these guys up I hope they get upgraded :D 

Cheers Toby 🙂

Talles Magno and Gabriel Veron should definitely both rise.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Nameless said:

Expected rise for Diveev and Hugo Guillamon please. 

When is the Russian review on a normal season? 

Igor Diveev - 77 -> 83

Hugo Guillamon - 76 -> 80 (only started playing for Valencia since restart, Valencia just sacked there manager so I’ve been a little cautious with my prediction.)

I bought Diveev about 3 months ago thinking it would before Argentina but I’ve not really got a clue now 😂

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Kierans91 said:

I think 88 will be the highest rating he can get at Levante but if he moves to Valencia then he would have a much higher ceiling and will probably move into the 90s if he continues his form.

Do you know if this is a one season wonder? I’m surprised it’s taken till he’s 29 to be performing this well. Or has he gone under the radar in the past?

He has been a goalie for teams in 3rd Spanish division , but never got much chance at Athletic Bilbao B apparently . 

In 2016 he went to CD Numancia in 2nd Spanish division (where he became pro) . Only in 2018 he got the chance to go to 1st Spanish division when UD Levante bought him for 1M . So this is only his second year on the highest level . He is only a professional since 2016 when he was around 25 years old . 
Not everyone has the chance/opportunity/goal to enter a youth academy for a big club , surely .

Previous season he played only 16 matches . So this is actually his first full season as a pro on the highest level and the numbers show he is doing superbly .

I took some info from an interview he gave in april https://www.hosoccer.com/en/aitor-fernandez-interview/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
24 minutes ago, topofthebilly said:

He has been a goalie for teams in 3rd Spanish division , but never got much chance at Athletic Bilbao B apparently . 

In 2016 he went to CD Numancia in 2nd Spanish division (where he became pro) . Only in 2018 he got the chance to go to 1st Spanish division when UD Levante bought him for 1M . So this is only his second year on the highest level . He is only a professional since 2016 when he was around 25 years old . 
Not everyone has the chance/opportunity/goal to enter a youth academy for a big club , surely .

Previous season he played only 16 matches . So this is actually his first full season as a pro on the highest level and the numbers show he is doing superbly .

I took some info from an interview he gave in april https://www.hosoccer.com/en/aitor-fernandez-interview/

Let’s hope he gets a move to Valencia or a team of that level, I suppose the good thing about him being a late bloomer is the fact that with him being a Goalkeeper he will have a longer life span at a higher level.

20 minutes ago, Wave_Dweller said:

Rank these to buy for LB:
Chilwell, Romagnoli, Kimpembe, L.Hernandez, Pereira, Klostermann

Pereira, Hernandez, Chilwell, the other 3 are generally CB’s for there club.

If I had to rank the CB’s I would go: Klostermann, Romagnoli, Kimpembe but in all honesty there isn’t much between the 3 in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Nameless said:

Do Kostic have a +1 in him this review? 

Same question for Digne and Barkley. 

I think they will all stay.

Barkley hasn’t played enough to reach 90.

Digne I think will stay at 90 forever at Everton, going to find it extremely hard to rise.

Kostic is a top player but Frankfurt have had a poor season, sold too many of there forward line in the summer and that’s resulted in a poor campaign unfortunately.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, Nameless said:

The recent must buy Quaresma or Tapsoba. 

Eduardo Quaresma has a $40 million release clause. (You can have him in the game for for $1 !) Has great future potential.

Tapsoba, on the other hand, is already performing very well. Got a +5 in January and is destined for +3 (according to a local fortune-teller who I trust completely)

Two different players at different stages. But yes, get 'em both while they are cheap

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have loads of midfield options but could do with lowering the age. I have De Bruyne, kroos, Kante, thiago, Verratti, pogba, rodri and De Jong. 

Would you trade Kante and Loftus cheek for Arthur? 

Is Arthur a good option for the future? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
46 minutes ago, RHugrakkur said:

Barnes or Orsolini?

Orsolini.

8 minutes ago, RhysMorgan said:

I have loads of midfield options but could do with lowering the age. I have De Bruyne, kroos, Kante, thiago, Verratti, pogba, rodri and De Jong. 

Would you trade Kante and Loftus cheek for Arthur? 

Is Arthur a good option for the future? 

Tough really, Kante should drop in the next review and Loftus Cheek is coming back from a long term injury.

I personally would go for Arthur, I would love to see him alongside Bentancur next season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...