Jump to content
KKohler

Keep all or sell some?

Recommended Posts

I started to manage BRISTOL ROVERS in div5 and have worked it to div1 within 4 seasons. My team was initially worth approximately 15M (value + cash) and I have managed to buy and sell young talents and have currently the team below. What do you think about my team and do you think that I should sell someone in near future.

91 A.LACAZETTE
91 G.XHAKA
90 M.ICARDI
90 N.KANTÉ
90 S.SAVIĆ
89 L.KURZAWA
89 V.VAN DIJK
88 I.WILLIAMS
88 C.TOLISSO
88 M.ALONSO
88 R.GUERREIRO
88 A.ARÉOLA
87 N.KEÏTA
87 E.BAILLY
87 R.KLAVAN
86 T.LEMAR
86 A.CHRISTENSEN
85 O.DEMBÉLÉ
85 G.MARTINS
85 H.LOZANO
85 E.MAMMANA
83 T.MAIA
83 A.SILVA
83 J.VALLEJO
82 E.ÜNAL
82 R.BENSEBAINI
80 A.ISAK
78 B.HENRICHS
76 A.HARIT
75 M.MARA
65 V.THILL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
41 minutes ago, KKohler said:

I started to manage BRISTOL ROVERS in div5 and have worked it to div1 within 4 seasons. My team was initially worth approximately 15M (value + cash) and I have managed to buy and sell young talents and have currently the team below. What do you think about my team and do you think that I should sell someone in near future.

91 A.LACAZETTE
91 G.XHAKA
90 M.ICARDI
90 N.KANTÉ
90 S.SAVIĆ
89 L.KURZAWA
89 V.VAN DIJK
88 I.WILLIAMS
88 C.TOLISSO
88 M.ALONSO
88 R.GUERREIRO
88 A.ARÉOLA
87 N.KEÏTA
87 E.BAILLY
87 R.KLAVAN
86 T.LEMAR
86 A.CHRISTENSEN
85 O.DEMBÉLÉ
85 G.MARTINS
85 H.LOZANO
85 E.MAMMANA
83 T.MAIA
83 A.SILVA
83 J.VALLEJO
82 E.ÜNAL
82 R.BENSEBAINI
80 A.ISAK
78 B.HENRICHS
76 A.HARIT
75 M.MARA
65 V.THILL

No one I'd actually sell here, maybe Klavan. Solid squad!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, KKohler said:

I started to manage BRISTOL ROVERS in div5 and have worked it to div1 within 4 seasons. My team was initially worth approximately 15M (value + cash) and I have managed to buy and sell young talents and have currently the team below. What do you think about my team and do you think that I should sell someone in near future.

91 A.LACAZETTE
91 G.XHAKA
90 M.ICARDI
90 N.KANTÉ
90 S.SAVIĆ
89 L.KURZAWA
89 V.VAN DIJK
88 I.WILLIAMS
88 C.TOLISSO
88 M.ALONSO
88 R.GUERREIRO
88 A.ARÉOLA
87 N.KEÏTA
87 E.BAILLY
87 R.KLAVAN
86 T.LEMAR
86 A.CHRISTENSEN
85 O.DEMBÉLÉ
85 G.MARTINS
85 H.LOZANO
85 E.MAMMANA
83 T.MAIA
83 A.SILVA
83 J.VALLEJO
82 E.ÜNAL
82 R.BENSEBAINI
80 A.ISAK
78 B.HENRICHS
76 A.HARIT
75 M.MARA
65 V.THILL

Was it a game world with about 5 managed teams in it though ? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Initially there were something like 10-15 managed teams and currently there's 22 managed teams. I'm currently thinking about selling Inaki Williams+Ragnar Klavan and considering buying CARRASCO, MANE or RABIOT. Which of the 3 would you buy?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, KKohler said:

Initially there were something like 10-15 managed teams and currently there's 22 managed teams. I'm currently thinking about selling Inaki Williams+Ragnar Klavan and considering buying CARRASCO, MANE or RABIOT. Which of the 3 would you buy?

All are worth the buy, personally Carrasco

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I see someone’s list, so I thought. I want to ask what you guys will sell of this enormous squad. I’m now 2 weeks coach of this team. I already sold 10 players.

 

94 G.Higuain (just bought)

94 M.Reus (just bought)

93 B.Matuidi (just bought)

93 X.Alonso (just bought)

92 H.Mkhitaryan (just bought)

91 J.Vertonghen (just bought)

91 T.Alderweireld (just bought)

91 J.Henderson

91 P.Dybala (just bought)

91 D.Sturridge (want to sell, but I'm not sure)

90 S.Mignolet

90 A.Laporte

90 M.Sakho

90 N.Clyne

90 J.Milner

90 A.Lallana

90 S.Mané

90 R.Firmino

89 D.Lovren

89 J.Matip

89 A.Moreno

89 H.Bellerin (just bought)

89 E.Can

89 G.Wijnaldum

88 L.Karius

87 M.Dahoud (just bought)

87 D.Origi

86 J.Flanagan

86 A.Halilovic

85 A.Diawara (just bought)

85 M.Dembélé (just bought)

84 W.Ndidi (just bought)

84 M.Grujic

83 J.Gomez

80 S.Ojo

80 C.Pulisic (just bought)

77 B.Chilwell

76 T.Awoniyi

76 F.Passlack (just bought)

76 H.Wilson

75 A.Paulinho

75 O.Ejaria

75 R.Pedro (just bought)

70 C.Masterson

67 K.Grabara

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, thorgan lesar said:

I see someone’s list, so I thought. I want to ask what you guys will sell of this enormous squad. I’m now 2 weeks coach of this team. I already sold 10 players.

 

94 G.Higuain (just bought)

94 M.Reus (just bought)

93 B.Matuidi (just bought)

93 X.Alonso (just bought)

92 H.Mkhitaryan (just bought)

91 J.Vertonghen (just bought)

91 T.Alderweireld (just bought)

91 J.Henderson

91 P.Dybala (just bought)

91 D.Sturridge (want to sell, but I'm not sure)

90 S.Mignolet

90 A.Laporte

90 M.Sakho

90 N.Clyne

90 J.Milner

90 A.Lallana

90 S.Mané

90 R.Firmino

89 D.Lovren

89 J.Matip

89 A.Moreno

89 H.Bellerin (just bought)

89 E.Can

89 G.Wijnaldum

88 L.Karius

87 M.Dahoud (just bought)

87 D.Origi

86 J.Flanagan

86 A.Halilovic

85 A.Diawara (just bought)

85 M.Dembélé (just bought)

84 W.Ndidi (just bought)

84 M.Grujic

83 J.Gomez

80 S.Ojo

80 C.Pulisic (just bought)

77 B.Chilwell

76 T.Awoniyi

76 F.Passlack (just bought)

76 H.Wilson

75 A.Paulinho

75 O.Ejaria

75 R.Pedro (just bought)

70 C.Masterson

67 K.Grabara

I would try to sell:

Sturridge, Mignolet, Sakho, Moreno, Flanagan, Awoniyi, Masterson, Grabara

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 minutes ago, thorgan lesar said:

@KKohler: thank you for the answer. I'm curious why you want to sell Alen Halilovic.

When thinking about it, it's 50/50. Will see how much minutes will he get once the injury is over. He has been great talent for sure. Not sure yet, if the move away from Barcelona was a good or bad thing for him.


http://int.soccerway.com/players/alen-halilovi/270136/
http://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/alen-halilovic/profil/spieler/226074
https://www.whoscored.com/Players/120151/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Spiderl4nd said:

Hi guys, my squad is composed by something like 180 players, so i really think i have to sell someone :)

 

If i post the team here someone will be so crazy to help me? :D:D

Provide the list of all 85+ players at first and lets see what you have there...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, KKohler said:

Provide the list of all 85+ players at first and lets see what you have there...

Perfect!

So, this is the above 85:

 

  • 94 G. Bale
  • 94 A. Griezmann
  • 93 P. Aubameyang
  • 91 J. Oblak
  • 91 P. Evra (my team is youth but i bought him cause his value is olnly 2.8M)
  • 91 R. Lukaku
  • 90 K. Koulibaly
  • 90 C. Casemiro 
  • 90 S. Roberto
  • 90. N. Kanté
  • 89 J. Stones
  • 89 E. Dier
  • 89 D. Alli
  • 89 C. Immobile (i think he will raise up in the next review, after that i will sell him)
  • 88 A Areola
  • 88 D. Rugani
  • 88 J. Weigl
  • 87 V. Lindelof
  • 87 N. Sule
  • 87 M. Dahoud
  • 87 J. Brandt
  • 87 M. Asensio
  • 87 M. Niang
  • 86 M. Pjaca
  • 85 G. Donnarumma
  • 85 F. Wallace
  • 85 J. Meré
  • 85 A. Diawara
  • 85 A. Zivkovic
  • 85 L. Bailey
  • 85 S. Driussi
  • 85 M. El Haddadi
  • 85 G. Jesus
  • 85 O. Dembélé

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10.12.2016 at 11:07 AM, Spiderl4nd said:

Perfect!

So, this is the above 85:

 

  • 94 G. Bale
  • 94 A. Griezmann
  • 93 P. Aubameyang
  • 91 J. Oblak
  • 91 P. Evra (my team is youth but i bought him cause his value is olnly 2.8M)
  • 91 R. Lukaku
  • 90 K. Koulibaly
  • 90 C. Casemiro 
  • 90 S. Roberto
  • 90. N. Kanté
  • 89 J. Stones
  • 89 E. Dier
  • 89 D. Alli
  • 89 C. Immobile (i think he will raise up in the next review, after that i will sell him)
  • 88 A Areola
  • 88 D. Rugani
  • 88 J. Weigl
  • 87 V. Lindelof
  • 87 N. Sule
  • 87 M. Dahoud
  • 87 J. Brandt
  • 87 M. Asensio
  • 87 M. Niang
  • 86 M. Pjaca
  • 85 G. Donnarumma
  • 85 F. Wallace
  • 85 J. Meré
  • 85 A. Diawara
  • 85 A. Zivkovic
  • 85 L. Bailey
  • 85 S. Driussi
  • 85 M. El Haddadi
  • 85 G. Jesus
  • 85 O. Dembélé

Not much to sell indeed - most of the players are young and talented. Some of the players that I'd consider selling in case there are decent replacements available in that game world:

91 P. Evra (I understand the rating vs value thing, but I personally am not a fan of old players and like to keep my teams' average age as low as possible to keep the total value of the team constantly increasing)
91 R. Lukaku (He is young and talented, but Everton is not the best club in Premier League and he might stay at the same level for quite a while and lose value just by ageing)
90 C. Casemiro (doesn't get very many minutes in Real Madrid)
88 D. Rugani (Rugani has played only in 4 matches)
87 M. Dahoud (young and talented, but is currently having tought start of the season. This could be temporary of course)
85 A. Zivkovic (don't know much about him, but has only 6 minutes recoderded in Liga NOS this season)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the advice,

Rugani anyway plays for Juve and i wouldn't sell him in any case, i really think he will be one of the best CB in the world in just few years. :)

Zivkovic seems to be a youngster, but effectively hasn't play in this season, i will consider if sell him for someone better.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 minutes ago, KKohler said:

Not much to sell indeed - most of the players are young and talented. Some of the players that I'd consider selling in case there are decent replacements available in that game world:

91 P. Evra (I understand the rating vs value thing, but I personally am not a fan of old players and like to keep my teams' average age as low as possible to keep the total value of the team constantly increasing)
91 R. Lukaku (He is young and talented, but Everton is not the best club in Premier League and he might stay at the same level for quite a while and lose value just by ageing)
90 C. Casemiro (doesn't get very many minutes in Real Madrid)
88 D. Rugani (Valencia is currently at 17th place in La Liga + Rugani has played only in 4 matches)
87 M. Dahoud (young and talented, but is currently having tought start of the season. This could be temporary of course)
85 A. Zivkovic (don't know much about him, but has only 6 minutes recoderded in Liga NOS this season)

Really? could have sworn I seen Rugani get 2 bullet headers for Juve in the past 2 games????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My bad, I have no idea why I wrote Valencia, he's in Juventus for sure. 

30 minutes ago, Spiderl4nd said:

Rugani anyway plays for Juve and i wouldn't sell him in any case, i really think he will be one of the best CB in the world in just few years. :)

 

 

Sry, mixed the club name there some how, but my opinion remains the same. Based on current game time and performance I'd consider selling him if there's some good replacement available in the game world.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Spiderl4nd: Damn, Lindelöf. I already saw him at 76 and sold him at 78. I thought he wasn't that special. I know he had talent, but that good ? :(;) Do you mean Fortuna Wallace ? Yeah, he is playing in the defence. He doesn't look like someone who will play for a big club. I'm not convinced by him. Andrija Zivkovic. I know him since he was 19 years old. He was a great talent, but his developpment is stopped in SL Benfica. I would sell him now, because now you will get more money then in 2 months for him. M'Baye Niang from AC Milan I would sell him also. He is a one season wonder. He is struckling years actually. Just this year would not help a lot. And Sergi Roberto is not so good anymore like 2 or 3 months ago.

 

Jorge Meré I don't know. For the rest I would keep them. You have a squad of 150 players ? Wow :) . I had 2 weeks ago with Liverpool 61 players, now I have 26 in my first team and 16 in my youth team. Sold 19 players :).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

By the way guys

Daniele Rugani is not from Valencia (do you mean Joâo Cancelo ?). He is playing recently for Juventus, you need to be long-term with him. Just keep him. He played with Juventus against Dinamo Zagreb and also scored. Of course in Juventus there is Benatia, Chiellini, Bonucci and Barzagli. So he played 5 games and made 2 goals.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...