A new risers thread

[Monolithic 840]

2 minutes ago, hesselink said:

Add Kuchaev (20) - 78 (83) 

Will update Russia later in the season...

[thorgan lesar 880]

Is it possible to do Poland ?

[shangar 51]

@Monolithic

I'm looking at André Zambo Anguissa of Marseille.  I think he's heading for an 87 or 88 at the next review, but would be grateful if you could provide your opinion.

Cheers

[Monolithic 840]

6 hours ago, shangar said:

@Monolithic

I'm looking at André Zambo Anguissa of Marseille.  I think he's heading for an 87 or 88 at the next review, but would be grateful if you could provide your opinion.

Cheers

I concur. 

[Monolithic 840]

7 hours ago, thorgan lesar said:

Is it possible to do Poland ?

Yeah, will do it over the next week or so.

[Monolithic 840]

Poland

GK – Tomasz Loska (21) – 78 (80)

GK – Dominik Hladun (22) – 72 (76)

DRL – Zoran Arsenic (23) – 77 (80)

DRL – Lukasz Burliga (29) – 80 (82)

DRL/DMRL – Robert Gumny (19) – 77 (80/82)

DR/DMR/MR – Alan Czerwinski (24) – 77 (80)

DL/DML – Kamil Pestka (19) – 73 (77)

DRC/DMC – Maciej Ambrosiewicz (19) – 76 (78/80)

DC – Mateusz Wieteska (20) – 77 (80)

DC – Bartosz Kupacz (25) – 77 (80)

DC/DMC – Igor Lasicki (22) – 77 (80)

DMC/MC – Jaroslaw Kubicki (22) – 80 (82)

DMC/MC – Taras Romanchuk (26) – 82 (83/84)

DMC/MC – Jakub Zubrowski (25) – 78 (80)

MC – Szymon Zurkowski (20) – 75 (80)

MC – Damian Szymanski (22) – 77 (80)

MC/AMC – Sebastian Szymanski (18) – 76 (78)

MC/AMC – Filip Jagiello (20) – 77 (80)

AMRL – Konrad Michalak (20) – 75 (78)

AMC – Tibor Halilovic (23) – 73 (76)

AMRLC – Damian Kadzior (26) – 78 (80/82)

AMRLC – Przemyslaw Frankowski (23) – 82 (83/84)

AMRLC/FRL – Rafal Kurzawa (25) – 78 (82)

AMRLC/FRLC – Lukasz Wolsztynski (23) – 76 (80)

AMC/FC – Karol Swiderski (21) – 78 (80)

FC – Jakub Swierczok (25) – 80 (82)

FC – Jaroslaw Niezgoda (22) – 80 (82)

 

Gumny seems by far the best prospect in Poland. 

[Ciuzz 147]

3 hours ago, Monolithic said:

Poland

GK – Tomasz Loska (21) – 78 (80)

GK – Dominik Hladun (22) – 72 (76)

DRL – Zoran Arsenic (23) – 77 (80)

DRL – Lukasz Burliga (29) – 80 (82)

DRL/DMRL – Robert Gumny (19) – 77 (80/82)

DR/DMR/MR – Alan Czerwinski (24) – 77 (80)

DL/DML – Kamil Pestka (19) – 73 (77)

DRC/DMC – Maciej Ambrosiewicz (19) – 76 (78)

DC – Mateusz Wieteska (20) – 77 (80)

DC – Bartosz Kupacz (25) – 77 (80)

DC/DMC – Igor Lasicki (22) – 77 (80)

DMC/MC – Jaroslaw Kubicki (22) – 80 (82)

DMC/MC – Taras Romanchuk (26) – 82 (83/84)

DMC/MC – Jakub Zubrowski (25) – 78 (80)

MC – Szymon Zurkowski (20) – 75 (78)

MC – Damian Szymanski (22) – 77 (80)

MC/AMC – Sebastian Szymanski (18) – 76 (78)

MC/AMC – Filip Jagiello (20) – 77 (80)

AMRL – Konrad Michalak (20) – 75 (78)

AMC – Tibor Halilovic (23) – 73 (76)

AMRLC – Damian Kadzior (26) – 78 (80/82)

AMRLC – Przemyslaw Frankowski (23) – 82 (83/84)

AMRLC/FRL – Rafal Kurzawa (25) – 78 (82)

AMC/FC – Karol Swiderski (21) – 78 (80)

FC – Jakub Swierczok (25) – 80 (82)

FC – Jaroslaw Niezgoda (22) – 80 (82)

 

Gumny seems by far the best prospect in Poland. 

What about Michal Helik? 

I think he could get 80.

Thanks

[Monolithic 840]

7 hours ago, Ciuzz said:

What about Michal Helik? 

I think he could get 80.

Thanks

It's possible. His side have struggled this season though...

[-JMH- 8,565]

Poland has many solid risers. Add:

Carlitos Lopez >82/83

Angulo >82

both definite big risers, but 30+ years 

Big connection at Gornik - Michal Koj, Lukas Wolsztyński, Dani Suarez, Wieteska, Zurkowski, Kadzior Kurzawa should all get decent rises - very impressive season. Kurzawa broken into NT, Wieteska & Zurkowski likewise U21. Alot of scouts watching Zurkowski. Pawel Bochniewicz joined on loan from Udinese in January and starting most game, may sneak to 80 too.

Jakob PIOTROWSKI U21 and regular for Pogon 75>78

Jakub WRABEL >80

Jose Kante hasnt ever had a rise, Stefańczyk, Kiełpin, Reca, Nico Varela All easily going 80+

Piotr Wlazlo 78 > 80, Frankowski & Romanchuk both should hit 84

[-JMH- 8,565]

Into the 7 games championship rounds now, could make a point or so difference to some of these guys

[Der Chefscout 169]

lol Ryan SESSEGNON only  83 ?

[swanseajack 11,238]

I think this is only for the players who made it in to the Team of the Season as a mini update before it's fully reviewed. I think 83 for the likes of Sessegnon and Maddison is fair for the minute, both of which have been performing at a similar standard and both of which should get to 84 when the league's reviewed properly. 

[andre.silvaduarte@hotmail.com 30]

1 hour ago, swanseajack said:

I think this is only for the players who made it in to the Team of the Season as a mini update before it's fully reviewed. I think 83 for the likes of Sessegnon and Maddison is fair for the minute, both of which have been performing at a similar standard and both of which should get to 84 when the league's reviewed properly. 

Do you think he's going to get new raise in Summer Review?

[swanseajack 11,238]

7 minutes ago, andre.silvaduarte@hotmail.com said:

Do you think he's going to get new raise in Summer Review?

Yeah, he'll get reviewed again and I think he'll get to 84. 

[433 1,052]

2 hours ago, swanseajack said:

Yeah, he'll get reviewed again and I think he'll get to 84. 

He should be 84/5 with his stats and Fulham's relentless rise.

[Monolithic 840]

Romania

FCSB

GK – Andrei Vlad (18) – 70 (76)

DR/DMC/MC – Ovidiu Popescu (24) – 82 (84)

DRC/DMC – Mihai Balasa (23) – 82 (84)

DC – Bogdan Planic (26) – 80 (82/83)

DC/DMC – Ionut Larie (31) – 82 (83/84)

AMRL/FRLC – Dennis Man (19) – 80 (83/84)

AMRLC/FRL – Florin Tanase (23) – 83 (85)

AMRLC/FRL – Daniel Benzar (20) – 73 (78)

FC – Harlem Gnohere (30) – 82 (84)

Cluj

DRC/DMR – Cristian Manea (20) – 82 (84)

FC – Billel Omrani (24) – 80 (82/83)

Craiova

DC/DMC/MC – Vladimir Screciu (18) – 77 (80)

FC – Andrei Burlacu (21) – 73 (77)

The Best of the Rest

GK – Bela Fejer (22) – 70 (75)

DL/DML – Marius Chelaru (21) – 73 (78)

DC – Denis Harut (19) – 70 (75)

DMC/MC – Kamer Qaka (22) – 78 (80)

DMC/MC/AMC – Razvan Oaida (20) – 70 (75)

MC – Romario Moise (20) – 76 (80)

MC/AMC – Alexandru Cicaldau (20) – 76 (78/80)

MC/AMC – Octavian Deaconu (20) – 75 (78/80)

MC/AMRLC – Cosmin Birnoi (20) – 73 (78)

AMC – Alexandru Matan (18) – 70 (75)

FC – Anatole Abang (21) – 76 (78/80)

FC – Darius Olaru (20) – 73 (78)

 

Dennis Man is the one player to buy from Romania. Already a first team regular and full international.

[-JMH- 8,565]

16 hours ago, Der Chefscout said:

lol Ryan SESSEGNON only  83 ?

If Fulham come 2nd he will rise again, just to close atm in the Championship right now, great to watch

( i hope Cardiff make it though)

[Yuasa 191]

11 hours ago, -JMH- said:

If Fulham come 2nd he will rise again, just to close atm in the Championship right now, great to watch

( i hope Cardiff make it though)

imo in the real review he'll gets another +2, so 85. 

[TMCosta 1,267]

On 10/04/2018 at 10:36 AM, Monolithic said:

Romania

FCSB

GK – Andrei Vlad (18) – 70 (76)

DR/DMC/MC – Ovidiu Popescu (24) – 82 (84)

DRC/DMC – Mihai Balasa (23) – 82 (84)

DC – Bogdan Planic (26) – 80 (82/83)

DC/DMC – Ionut Larie (31) – 82 (83/84)

AMRL/FRLC – Dennis Man (19) – 80 (83/84)

AMRLC/FRL – Florin Tanase (23) – 83 (85)

AMRLC/FRL – Daniel Benzar (20) – 73 (78)

FC – Harlem Gnohere (30) – 82 (84)

Cluj

DRC/DMR – Cristian Manea (20) – 82 (84)

FC – Billel Omrani (24) – 80 (82/83)

Craiova

DC/DMC/MC – Vladimir Screciu (18) – 77 (80)

FC – Andrei Burlacu (21) – 73 (77)

The Best of the Rest

GK – Bela Fejer (22) – 70 (75)

DL/DML – Marius Chelaru (21) – 73 (78)

DC – Denis Harut (19) – 70 (75)

DMC/MC – Kamer Qaka (22) – 78 (80)

DMC/MC/AMC – Razvan Oaida (20) – 70 (75)

MC – Romario Moise (20) – 76 (80)

MC/AMC – Alexandru Cicaldau (20) – 76 (78/80)

MC/AMC – Octavian Deaconu (20) – 75 (78/80)

MC/AMRLC – Cosmin Birnoi (20) – 73 (78)

AMC – Alexandru Matan (18) – 70 (75)

FC – Anatole Abang (21) – 76 (78/80)

FC – Darius Olaru (20) – 73 (78)

 

Dennis Man is the one player to buy from Romania. Already a first team regular and full international.

			N.FOTA	D,MD(E)	21	75		380mil	-
-			I.STOICA	M(C)	15	70		280mil	-
-			I.VINA	MO,A(DE)	23	78		400mil

 

Nothing for this guys?

[Monolithic 840]

2 hours ago, TMCosta said:

			N.FOTA	D,MD(E)	21	75		380mil	-
-			I.STOICA	M(C)	15	70		280mil	-
-			I.VINA	MO,A(DE)	23	78		400mil

 

Nothing for this guys?

Not enough for me to bother to list them. 

[TMCosta 1,267]

29 minutes ago, Monolithic said:

Not enough for me to bother to list them. 

heehheeh fair enough

[hesselink 230]

#Romania

Dennis Man jumped on 8th april this year. His rating is 80 now.

[Monolithic 840]

15 hours ago, hesselink said:

#Romania

Dennis Man jumped on 8th april this year. His rating is 80 now.

Yes, I did list him as being rated 80.

[hoochy koochy 51]

There is no system or method to SM ratings and reviews now.... I know its all free and for us to play unless we buy membership. Although i never renewed mine in last two years! Does anyone have any insight?

 

Thanks Mono - smashing it up as always

[1000dB 391]

On 17-2-2018 at 4:01 AM, Monolithic said:

Belgium

...

At the top end, like the Netherlands, the review should really be fairly cautious due to the abject failures in Europe.

Good argument, I love the bit about Europe.

Granted both Holland and Belgium had a nightmare in Europe this year. Yet Eredivisie clubs have been dire in Europe for almost the entire decade (sure there wasn't much between these two this year but for so many years it was a lot). From 2012 onwards they've been massively outperformed by Belgian clubs. When your argument is that Belgium's review, at the top end, should really be fairly cautious due to the abject failure in Europe why not be consistent and say Eredivisie players should already have been rated a fair bit lower compared to those in Belgium? Currently that's not the case. Quite the contrary, even if Belgium's upcoming review were a generous one for a change.

Just look at the massive gap between Holland and Belgium on the 2017/18 ranking. That gap won't be closed any time soon. So will it take decades (plural) for it to be reflected in the player ratings? For 2018/19 there's even the possibility that none of the Eredivisie clubs reach the CL or EL group stage while at least three Belgian clubs are guaranteed to be in the group stage. Belgian clubs could be outperforming Dutch ones in the next decade as well but I wouldn't be surprised if Eredivisie players are still being rated higher. For years Belgian clubs have been deserving of a more generous review. I'd say the time is more than ripe for ratings to reflect where Holland and Belgium place in the country rankings.