Jump to content
lukelufc

Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Recommended Posts

Riferimento: Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Jan VERTONGHEN or Holger BADSTUBER

Vertonghen is the better player but Badstuber could reach the higher rating playing for B.Munich IMO, it depends by Guardiola's rank at Bayern...

Anyway, I'd go for Vertonghen at mo.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Alvaro Arbeloa or Gregory Van Der Wiel ?

Neither but if I had to choose' date=' VDW.

Drogba+Cabaye=Coutinho?

Too much for Coutinho, it's not like he's at a top 5 club. I'd prefer the duo.

Badstuber+Tevez=Falcao+Richards?

I am getting the right side

Plz aswer the other question too :)

Right hand side.

Jan VERTONGHEN or Holger BADSTUBER

Vertonghen - Badstuber is out for 10 months.

Bastian Schweinsteiger or Claudio Marchisio + Gregory van der Wiel ?

Their potential ratings ?

Schweinsteiger for me. (>95)

Marchisio (-92)

VDW (-90 /<89)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Sven Bender or Yann MVila?? I have MVila and Lars bender and plan to buy Sven.. Will it be right to sell Yann?? I mean he is young but he is becoming another Joey Barton!!! Also who is better Lars or Sven?? Oh I also have Javi Martinez and Gundogan in that DM position!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Sven Bender or Yann MVila?? I have MVila and Lars bender and plan to buy Sven.. Will it be right to sell Yann?? I mean he is young but he is becoming another Joey Barton!!! Also who is better Lars or Sven?? Oh I also have Javi Martinez and Gundogan in that DM position!!

Bender easily.

Lars > Sven

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Sven Bender or Yann MVila?? I have MVila and Lars bender and plan to buy Sven.. Will it be right to sell Yann?? I mean he is young but he is becoming another Joey Barton!!! Also who is better Lars or Sven?? Oh I also have Javi Martinez and Gundogan in that DM position!!

Martinez > Gundogan > Lars > Sven > M'Vila > Barton :P

I'd say you don't need many more DM's. but Sven over M'Vila certainly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Sven Bender or Yann MVila?? I have MVila and Lars bender and plan to buy Sven.. Will it be right to sell Yann?? I mean he is young but he is becoming another Joey Barton!!! Also who is better Lars or Sven?? Oh I also have Javi Martinez and Gundogan in that DM position!!

you dont need to buy sven bender you got gundo and javi already and lars just sell m'vila he wont get higher than 91 looking at his team.sell yann and buy someone you need hope i've helped:)

my question: would mata get 94

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

you dont need to buy sven bender you got gundo and javi already and lars just sell m'vila he wont get higher than 91 looking at his team.sell yann and buy someone you need hope i've helped:)

my question: would mata get 94

Would - maybe.

Should - yes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

you dont need to buy sven bender you got gundo and javi already and lars just sell m'vila he wont get higher than 91 looking at his team.sell yann and buy someone you need hope i've helped:)

my question: would mata get 94

Would = no

Should = no

;)

Ash you'd place Mata on equal terms to players like Ozil and above Gotze/Di Maria/Bale?

Chelsea team lacks real creativity and thus Mata looks better than he actually is. Put him in Spain XI and he's virtually invisible :o

So I should sell Yann or keep him?? Also how do you rate these guys??

Javi Martinez ' date=' Yann MVila , lars bender, Gundogan.. And Sven[/quote']

Sell Yann

1. Martinez

2. Gundogan

3. Lars

4. Sven

5. M'vila

Thiago Silva or Kompany + De Sciglio?

Only Silva/Kompany would start.

Ped are you back - again? Thought you'd left ;):P

Kompany and De Sciglio, should get 89 soon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Thiago Silva or Kompany + De Sciglio?

get the duo... bare in mind thiago is better than company' date=' de sciglio just sweetens the deal;)

Only Silva/Kompany would start.[/quote']

So I should sell Yann or keep him?? Also how do you rate these guys??

Javi Martinez ' date=' Yann MVila , lars bender, Gundogan.. And Sven[/quote']

sell and buy someone you need or a position you need;)

javi and gundo is superb max rating probs 94

sven and lars good not sure about their future rating

yann ok he was better at he's old club

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

So I should sell Yann or keep him?? Also how do you rate these guys??

Javi Martinez ' date=' Yann MVila , lars bender, Gundogan.. And Sven[/quote']

1. Javi

2. Gundogan

3. Lars

4. Sven

5. M'Vila

Bastian Schweinsteiger or Claudio Marchisio + Gregory van der Wiel ?

Their potential ratings ?

Schweinsteiger by some distance. I can't see the other 2 getting close to him rating wise.

Jan VERTONGHEN or Holger BADSTUBER

I prefer Vertonghen.

Badstuber+Tevez=Falcao+Richards?

I am getting the right side

Plz aswer the other question too :)

Nice deal, definitely do it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Riferimento: Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

So I should sell Yann or keep him?? Also how do you rate these guys??

Javi Martinez ' date=' Yann MVila , lars bender, Gundogan.. And Sven[/quote']

If you need to sell a Dm, then sell M'vila.

He have not a better potential than S.Bender cause he's in Russia...

Gundogan

J.Martinez

L.Bender

S.Bender

M'vila

Thiago Silva or Kompany + De Sciglio?

Only Silva/Kompany would start.

I'd go for T.Silva, if he'll move to barca he could reach 96 in a season.

If De Sciglio doesn't start for you, then try to get the better player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Would = no

Should = no

;)

Ash you'd place Mata on equal terms to players like Ozil and above Gotze/Di Maria/Bale?

Chelsea team lacks real creativity and thus Mata looks better than he actually is. Put him in Spain XI and he's virtually invisible :o

Sell Yann

1. Martinez

2. Gundogan

3. Lars

4. Sven

5. M'vila

Ped are you back - again? Thought you'd left ;):P

Kompany and De Sciglio' date=' should get 89 soon[/quote']

If you wanted to mark the difference between the players...I hope its a joke.Gundogan is better then Martinez quite easily,well on SM they're at least on par.And in what way is Lars better then Sven?Sven is more of a DM who does his job absolutely perfectly with no mistakes.He's essential in big games as he blocks pretty much everything.Lars is more of an offensive player...

Whoever watched Gundogan this season in pretty much all games..would realise about what I am talking about.Such a sublime player..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Ginter or Shaw?

Now... Unlike most British hype-ists I dislike calling someone a top prospect when they really aren't proven (like Sterling, Wickam, Barkley etc).

But Shaw is really something special... every time I've watched him he's been composed for just a 17 year old. He's decent defensively but the main thing that catches the eye is his ability to bomb down the left flank like Cole and Evra. And unlike either of them, he tracks back when Southampton lose the ball.

I actually don't want him to move to Chelsea or even to us (United) because I just know he'll be one of many talents wasted in our reserves.

I don't watch Ginter on a weekly basis for 90 mins, only the highlights on ITV here, but from what I've seen he's also a fine talent, good passer of the ball.

It's tight but probably because I follow him more, I'd pick Shaw.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

I'd go for Ginter as Shaw is yet to deem a first team spot yet he'll be a sub player for another 2 or 3 years.

Shaw is not a starter? I don't know what Premier League games you've been watching mate' date=' he's started 90% of the games he's been fit for, but he's been injured at least 3x this year.

If you wanted to mark the difference between the players...I hope its a joke.Gundogan is better then Martinez quite easily,well on SM they're at least on par.And in what way is Lars better then Sven?Sven is more of a DM who does his job absolutely perfectly with no mistakes.He's essential in big games as he blocks pretty much everything.Lars is more of an offensive player...

Whoever watched Gundogan this season in pretty much all games..would realise about what I am talking about.Such a sublime player..

Yes Gundogan stands out more, but that's because his midfield doesn't consist of Schweinsteiger and Kroos. I'm not saying that he's not a fine player - to the contrary I think he's as good as Kroos. But I rank Martinez above either of them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Shaw is not a starter? I don't know what Premier League games you've been watching mate' date=' he's started 90% of the games he's been fit for, but he's been injured at least 3x this year.

Yes Gundogan stands out more, but that's because his midfield doesn't consist of Schweinsteiger and Kroos. I'm not saying that he's not a fine player - to the contrary I think he's as good as Kroos. But I rank Martinez above either of them.[/quote']

Oh I suppose only watched like two games of Southampton and it was near the end of the season and didn't see him playing but now you said he was injured.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

SCHWEINSTEIGER or Claudio Marchisio + Gregory van der Wiel ?

Their potential ratings ?

SCHWEINSTEIGER

Jan VERTONGHEN or Holger BADSTUBER

Jan VERTONGHEN

Badstuber+Tevez=Falcao+Richards?

I am getting the right side

Plz aswer the other question too :)

Falcao+Richards

Drogba+Cabaye=Coutinho?

Drogba+Cabaye

Alvaro Arbeloa or Gregory Van Der Wiel ?

Alvaro Arbeloa

Can rank this ?

Dragovic' date=' Kaya, Sokratis, Ruiz, Martins Indi, De Vrij, Inigo Martinez, Savic, Aurtenexte

Who has more potential ?[/quote']

1. Martins Indi

2. Martinez

3. De Vrij

4. Savic

5. Ruiz

6. Sokratis

7. Dragovic

8. Aurtenexte

9. Kaya

Sell Willian for 25.mil?

Current strikers:

Lewandowski

Muller

Reus

Destro

Mata

Higuain.

Sell him

lewandowski or agueroo

Lewy

vidal or fellaini who will get the higher rating

Vidal

Sanchez = Moreno Rodrigo' date=' Illaramendi + Luiz Danilo[/color'].

or

Sanchez= Moreno Rodrigo, Illaramendi, Cabella + Inigo Martinez?

Which one, or neither?

Moreno Rodrigo + Luiz Danilo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...