Jump to content
lukelufc

Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Recommended Posts

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Should I keep Weiser?

Rhetorical question mate' date=' you should do some research on him or state more info on your team eg if you sell are you able to get a better player etc.

i need a back up keeper:

cech or valdes?

2. ramsey,khedira or matic (in order)

I've asked the first question before and I was advised to take Cech, so I did so.

Matic

Ramsey

Khedira

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Personally I didn't answer...

It's not a lazy answer' date=' you posed many questions without mentioned the most important factor in the whole scenario...

Yaya is on the slide, big time, yes he is highly rated now but his complete lack of defending and his diminishing skills to open a defense (not forgetting he does not carry the ball nearly as well as he used to) will mean he will soon drop... could be a big drop too, so 30+ mil for a player on the slide is good business regardless of replacements![/quote']

His personal performances are irrelevant in terms of in game ratings. I will use Pique as an example. Kept his 95 rating for a heck of a long time because of honours won for club and country and nothing to do with being an outstanding CB.

Is Kompany playing like a 94 rated CB? RVP worthy of being rated 95 still? I guess this is also questionable. I am using such examples as it is evident that as long as a side is or has done well then the likelihood is players will maintain there ratings, though there is more call for RVP to drop than the the two City players.

So on a whole my original questions carry a whole lot more validity than your opinion does. If he does drop next time round it will likely only be a -1. So the question still remains if the money would strengthen his side do the deal. If he can get a player of similar ilk then do the deal.

Assuming the forumer in question is in an EC or a GC and again assuming (like we are) that Toure drops a -1 for arguments sake next time round that will still mean having a 94 rated player for between 3 and 4 in game seasons and as such still making him an extremely valuable player in terms of ratings.

Do try looking at the bigger picture.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Praet or Salvio?

I know Praet is talented but hes a good bit away from 90. I think Salvio should hit 90 soon and he is still only about to turn 25?

Very 50/50 on this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Carvajal or Azpilicueta ??

Dani Carvajal.

Hey Guys' date=' I've just been offered £30.5M for my Yaya Toure, I reckon I should accept but what do you guys think?[/quote']

Reject it.

Hi guys' date=' I'd appreciate any opinions on how to rank the following:

Pastore

Cuadrado

Willian

Callejon[/quote']

Pastore > Willian > Cuadrado > Callejon

how do u guys rank the following(for DC spot):

GONALONS

GARAY

OTAMENDI

Otamendi > Garay > Gonalons

Benatia for Rakitic? I'm Bayern in a new GW

Keep Mehdi Benatia.

Should I keep Weiser?

I would keep him. He's good.

i need a back up keeper:

cech or valdes?

2. ramsey' date='khedira or matic (in order)[/quote']

Cech.

Matic > Ramsey > Khedira

my 4mil and christoph kramer for nuri sahin?

Your 4M + Kramer

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Natcho, Manu and cash

Natcho (CSKA) + Pavicic/Manu + cash or Immobile?

keep Meyer and cash

Barkley=Meyer+6-8 mil ?

Should i get Barkley?

Would go for Praet' date=' but depends on what team you're trying to build/

Praet or Salvio?

I know Praet is talented but hes a good bit away from 90. I think Salvio should hit 90 soon and he is still only about to turn 25?

Very 50/50 on this

keep kramer and cash

my 4mil and christoph kramer for nuri sahin?

either one' date=' wouldn't matter in game, but cech, since he's moving this summer and will be no.1 at a pretty good club

Matic

Ramsey

Khedira

i need a back up keeper:

cech or valdes?

2. ramsey,khedira or matic (in order)

Gotze

Schmelzer + Koke or Gotze?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Rhetorical question mate' date=' you should do some research on him or state more info on your team eg if you sell are you able to get a better player etc. [/quote']

I had mentioned earlier that I was Bayern in a new GW...guess you missed it B)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Barkley=Meyer+6-8 mil ?

Should i get Barkley?

Keep Meyer.

Natcho (CSKA) + Pavicic/Manu + cash or Immobile?

Natcho + Pavicic + cash

Schmelzer + Koke or Gotze?

Gotze

OSPINA or Claudio BRAVO?

Claudio Bravo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Benatia for Rakitic? I'm Bayern in a new GW

Benatia

League just started' date=' so I have cover. Sadly no one wants Dante after the Porto debacle. :rolleyes:

Should I sell Gaudino for 1.5mil?[/quote']

Keep him

i need a back up keeper:

cech or valdes?

2. ramsey' date='khedira or matic (in order)[/quote']

Petr Cech

Matic, Khedira, Ramsey

my 4mil and christoph kramer for nuri sahin?

Keep Kramer

Praet or Salvio?

I know Praet is talented but hes a good bit away from 90. I think Salvio should hit 90 soon and he is still only about to turn 25?

Very 50/50 on this

Salvio

Barkley=Meyer+6-8 mil ?

Should i get Barkley?

Nope' date=' keep Meyer

Natcho (CSKA) + Pavicic/Manu + cash or Immobile?

Natcho + Manu

Schmelzer + Koke or Gotze?

Gotze

OSPINA or Claudio BRAVO?

Bravo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Schmelzer + Koke or Gotze?

I prefer Gotze' date=' tbh.

Barkley=Meyer+6-8 mil ?

Should i get Barkley?

Max Meyer, personally.

my 4mil and christoph kramer for nuri sahin?

Keep Kramer, imo.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Sorry for this spam like post but I am trying to raise awareness of the Prizemoney not being paid issue, this is happening to us all everytime we win a cup, shield, smfa game etc The prizemoney you earn is not being added to your funds as there is a bug that makes SM deduct the prizemoney you earn from your starting balance meaning you are not getting it paid.Check your starting balance before you play a cup tie and you will see this is a fact(or you can check out the thread below and see by the screenshots that this is happening).Go to your club finance page and check prizemoney whatever amount it says you have earned this is how much you have been ripped off by SM this season, we need to get together and make SM take notice. Thanks for listening.

http://forum.soccermanager.com/showthread.php?t=173029

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Jetro willems or Lucas silva +1.5m

Hmm, I am inclined to take the Madrid player because if he does make it (at Real), it will be a very good deal. Willems is more of a safe choice where he is playing regularly at a top club but I, personally, don't see him becoming a superstar-like player at Real, Bayern or Barca

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Hey Guys' date=' I've just been offered £30.5M for my Yaya Toure, I reckon I should accept but what do you guys think?[/quote']

If its a gameworld where cash is meaningful take it because its the best youll get. If you cant buy much reject it

i need a back up keeper:

cech or valdes?

2. ramsey' date='khedira or matic (in order)[/quote']

Cech

Matic > Ramsay> Khedira

my 4mil and christoph kramer for nuri sahin?

Kramer

Praet or Salvio?

I know Praet is talented but hes a good bit away from 90. I think Salvio should hit 90 soon and he is still only about to turn 25?

Very 50/50 on this

Praet

Barkley=Meyer+6-8 mil ?

Should i get Barkley?

Keeper Meyer

Natcho (CSKA) + Pavicic/Manu + cash or Immobile?

The players + cash

OSPINA or Claudio BRAVO?

Bravo short term' date=' Ospina long term

Benatia for Rakitic? I'm Bayern in a new GW

Rakitic

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Aguero is way better than Cavani despite the same rating. And he's younger. And should get an increase. And is more consistent. Enough said.

Danilo, Azpilicueta, Coleman.

Tough choice, I would go for Mata but maybe Sanchez as he's more consistent.

My Cavani for Aguero?

My Zabaleta for Caravjai? Or any better RB suggestions?

My Mata for Sanchez?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re: Help With Deal(s) Thread...

Jetro willems or Lucas silva +1.5m

Jetro Willems.

My Cavani for Aguero?

My Zabaleta for Caravjai? Or any better RB suggestions?

My Mata for Sanchez?

Aguero.

Get Carvajal.

Sanchez.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...