Jump to content

Lukelufc's Big 5 Ratings...


lukelufc
 Share

Recommended Posts

I thought i'd do a little bit of scouting from 5 top European teams as it is the Easter holidays, so here it goes...

-Internazionale

-AC Milan

-Juventus

-Real Madrid

-Barcelona

Internazionale

Maxwell, LB. 22starts and 4 sub appearances 92-->93

Nicolas Burdisso, D. 16 starts and 4 sub appearances, 1 goal. 90-->91

Marco Materazzi, CB. 11 starts and 6 sub appeances. 92-->91/90

Walter Samuel, CB. 12 starts and no subs. 92-->91.

Dejan Stankovic, AM/LM. 15 starts, 2 subs and 1 goal. 94-->93.

Luis Figo, W/AM. 10 starts, 6 subs and 1 goal. 92-->91.

Patrick Vieira, CM/DM. 8 starts, 3 subs and 2 goals. 93-->92/91.

Olivier Dacourt, DM/CM. 6 starts and 3 subs. 90-->89/88.

Nuno Maniche, CM/RM. 3 starts, 4 subs, 1 goal. 91-->89.

Vitor Pele, CM/DM. 4 starts and 9 subs. 80-->85/86.

Mario Balotelli, F. 2 starts 3 subs and 1 goal. 80-->83/84.

Julio Cruz, CF. 16 starts, 6 subs and 10 goals. 92-->93.

Hernan Crespo, CF. 11 starts, 5 subs and 4 goals. 93-->92.

AC Milan

Kalac, G. 19 starts. 88-->89.

Marek Jankulovski, LB/LM. 10 starts and 1 sub. 92-->90.

Giuseppe Favalli, LB. 13 starts and 7 subs. 88-->89.

Serginho, LM/LB. 5 starts and 4 subs. 87-->85.

Massimo Oddo, RB/RM . 20 starts 3 subs and a goal. 91-->92.

Nesta, CB. 24 starts, 1 sub and 1 goal. 96-->95.

Kakha Kaladze, CB/LB . 25 starts subs. 92-->93.

Paolo Maldini, CB/LB. 14 starts and 2 subs. 91-->90.

Dario Simic, CB/RB. 2 subs totally 30minutes. 88-->84.

Massimo Ambrosini, CM/DM. 27 starts and 2 subs (arguably better than gattuso and pirlo this season) 92-->94/93

Emerson, DM/CM . 5 starts and 9 subs. 90 -->88/89.

Alexandre Pato, F. 13 starts and 1 sub. 7 goals (second best goalscorer joint with Gilardino who had played 743mins more) 87-->90

Luis Ronaldo, F. 4 starts and 2 subs (injury though). 92-->91.

Alberto Paloschi, F. 1 start, 6 subs and 2 goals, 300mins. 75-->82/83.

Filippo Inzaghi, CF. 7starts, 7 subs and 3 goals. 91-->90.

Juventus

Gianluigi Buffon, G. 28 starts, if you watch the Serie A you will know how excellent he has been and how he keeps Juve a few places higher in the table, easily best goalkeeper in the world should have increased last time but didnt. 96-->97

Giorgio Chiellini, LB/CB. 24 starts, 1 goal. 91-->92.

Cristian Molinaro, LB. 24 starts and 1 sub, 89-->90/91.

Alessandro Birindelli, RB. 4 starts and 3 subs. 86-->85.

Jorge Andrade, CB/DM. 4 starts. 92-->90.

Nicola Legrottaglie, CB. 25 starts, 2 subs, 2 goals. 89-->92/91.

Guglielmo Stendardo, CB. 1 start. 88-->85.

Mauro Camoranesi, RM. 12 starts, 4 subs, 4 goals. 91-->90/89.

Tiago, CM/AM. 7 starts and 8 subs. 91-->89.

Vincenzo Iaquinta, F. 8 starts, 14 subs, 8 goals. 92-->91.

Real Madrid

Gabriel Heinze, LB/CB. 12 starts, 3 subs, 1 goal. 92-->91.

Vieira Marcelo, LB. 19 starts. 89-->91/90.

Sergio Ramos, RB/CB. 27 starts and 4goals. 94-->95.

Michel Salgado, RB. 6 starts and 1 sub. 89-->87.

Pepe, CB. 11 starts and 2 subs. 92-->91.

Metzelder, 6 starts and 1 sub. 91-->90/89.

Balboa, RM/W. 4 subs totally 54 minutes. 86-->84.

Guti, CM/AM. 22 starts, 5 subs and 3 goals. 92-->93.

Fernando Gago, CM/DM. 16 starts and 10 subs, 90-->91.

Arjen Robben, W. 8 starts and 7 subs. 91-->90.

Mahamadou Diarra, DM/CM. 20 starts and 4 subs. 94-->93.

Julio Baptista, AM/F. (even though hes playing left wing!) 13 starts, 11 subs and 3 goals. 92-->91.

Raul, F/AM. 30 starts, 1 sub and 16 goals. 94-->95.

Javier Saviola, F. 3 starts, 3 subs and 2 goals. 91-->89/90.

Soldado, F. 1 start and 4 subs. 88-->86.

Ruud van Nistelrooy, F. 20starts, 1 sub and 12 goals. 96-->95.

Barcelona

Victor Valdes, G. 31 starts. 91-->92.

Pinto, G. No time. 88-->85.

Gianluca Zambrotta, RB/LB. 19 starts and 4 subs. 94-->93.

Puyol, CB/RB. 22 starts and 1 sub. 96-->95.

Rafael MÃrquez, CB/DM. 12 starts, 7 subs and 2 goals.94-->93.

Gabriel Milito, CB. 24 starts, 1 sub and 1 goal. 93-->94.

Iniesta, CM/AM. 28 starts, 2 subs and 3 goals. 94-->95.

Yaya Toure, CM/DM. 20 starts, 1 sub and 1 goal. 92-->93.

Edmilson, DM/CB. 4 starts and 2 subs. 90-->88.

Deco, AM/CM. 12 starts, 3 subs and a goal. 94-->92/93.

Ronaldinho, F/AM. 13 starts, 4 subs and 8 goals. 97-->96.

Ezquerro, F/W. 1 sub, 20mins. 87-->85.

Dos Santos Giovani, F/AM. 6 starts and 16 subs. 86-->88.

Krkic Bojan, F. 11 starts, 14 subs and 8 goals. (1 less goal than Messi in 500minutes less) 87-->90/91.

Players that i haven't mentioned, i feel are likely to stay the same.

I hope you find this useful in the next couple of weeks deciding who to buy and not to buy and who to sell and who not to sell.

Hope you enjoy my first bit of ratings analysising/scouting in about 4 months:) .

(2 hours later and i'm done :D )

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Lukelufc's Big 5 Ratings...

These are great Lukey mate....I don't rep predictions very often but I will rep you for these

I just hope Maldini gets to see his career out as a 91....He deserves that!!!

You really think Kaladze should be 93?

Will be good to see Julio Cruz rise but I don't think he will...

Don't think Bojan will be 90/91 yet...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Lukelufc's Big 5 Ratings...

So so predictions. I don't think SM will make that many changes as they're showing right now in this week's changes. Also, I think a few were off base like Ambrosini moving up, Buffon moving up, and Robben who has recently come back into the fold and is playing well (He aleady had a decrease recently and is playing well now). What's more, I think you missed a couple of people like Seedorf for AC Milan who surely should go down this season. Ryan Giggs is no longer a 93 and Seedorf is by no means a 94. He'll be at 93, at the highest, by the end of the changes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Lukelufc's Big 5 Ratings...

To be perfectly honest Luke, I know you have been out of the scouting game for a while but given your previous pedigree I think that is a pretty poor effort in truth! How often have you seen players just 3 pts from the high 80's before like you have down for several players including Legrottaglie who will not make 92, I can 100% assure you of that. Also you have more than 50% of Real Madrid's players moving in someway or another, when does that ever happen? The most popular change is no change and I suspect most of Madrid's players like Nistelrooy, Ramos, Diarra etc are more likely to stay the same. You also have Robben dropping which is unlikely given his current form, I think he will stay put too but if anything will get a increase back to 92. Bojan, 87 to possible 91, you seriously believe that? A jump of 4 pts is highly unlikely, I expect he will make 89 with the possibilty of 90 but higher would be over the top. I think Milan will get hit harder then you have predicted too, the likes of Gattuso, Pirlo, Seedorf etc should all be held accountable for Milan's poor form this season and I think SM will drop them. Maldini is highly likely to drop below 90 like you saw and I expect Ronaldo to fall to 90 too. I would be surprised to see Ambrosini hit 94, he could hit 93 possibly but I think staying at 92 is more realistic. Sorry for the criticism Luke, it's great to see you back in the scouting game but this is not one of your best efforts in my opinion mate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest melbguy1

Re: Lukelufc's Big 5 Ratings...

Good effort,

you missed out on Del-Piero who has to rise by 1, if not 2.

Kalac I think deserves more than a 89 being AC Milans #1 keeper

I think they'll give Camoranesi +1, he had 1 taken away for being injured last time

Julio Cesar MUST go up by 1 or 2

Age should not play a part in ratings imo and as Welshy said, Maldini should not go down.

Without knowing how SM ratings work, Sissoko may get a +1

The real Ronaldo should drop by more than 1

Burdisso's rating is based on stats, that guy is horrible, but on stats alone you may be right.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Lukelufc's Big 5 Ratings...

I actually like the effort. I agree with most of the Milanese. Perhaps Maniche to 90.

There is a lot of criticism coming into play when most newcomers make a scouting thread, and I agree that they should be doubted. However, when the Luke's, bestpay's and Perry's of the forum make a thread, more respect is needed I think. Surely we can ask their opinion without telling them they are wrong?

They have proved that they usually are right, so why all the negativity here?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Lukelufc's Big 5 Ratings...

Could you let me know what people think on the following:-

Nesta - Stay Same

Yaya Toure - Up 1/2

Kaladze - Up 1/2

Marquez - Stay Same

Pepe - ???

Gattuso - Stay Same

Cheers

Nesta - Stay the same or drop 1 maybe

Toure - Up 1 most likely

Kaladze - Up 1 doubtful 2

Marquez - Down 1

Pepe - Stay the same or down 1

Gattuso - Stay the same

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Lukelufc's Big 5 Ratings...

To be perfectly honest Luke' date=' I know you have been out of the scouting game for a while but given your previous pedigree I think that is a pretty poor effort in truth! How often have you seen players just 3 pts from the high 80's before like you have down for several players including Legrottaglie who will not make 92, I can 100% assure you of that. Also you have more than 50% of Real Madrid's players moving in someway or another, when does that ever happen? The most popular change is no change and I suspect most of Madrid's players like Nistelrooy, Ramos, Diarra etc are more likely to stay the same. You also have Robben dropping which is unlikely given his current form, I think he will stay put too but if anything will get a increase back to 92. Bojan, 87 to possible 91, you seriously believe that? A jump of 4 pts is highly unlikely, I expect he will make 89 with the possibilty of 90 but higher would be over the top. I think Milan will get hit harder then you have predicted too, the likes of Gattuso, Pirlo, Seedorf etc should all be held accountable for Milan's poor form this season and I think SM will drop them. Maldini is highly likely to drop below 90 like you saw and I expect Ronaldo to fall to 90 too. I would be surprised to see Ambrosini hit 94, he could hit 93 possibly but I think staying at 92 is more realistic. Sorry for the criticism Luke, it's great to see you back in the scouting game but this is not one of your best efforts in my opinion mate.[/quote']

I second this, quite harsh, imo half of them players you said will go down wont. Van Nistrerooy down? Come on. Look at his goals etc. Thats just 1 example. Good effort but i dont agree with many sorry.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...