Jump to content

New Topic Rating


alexmatfc
 Share

Recommended Posts

I dont no if it has been doing anyone elses head in but when you go onto the ratings and there old ones so i decided to do a new one for England

Goal Keepers -

Reina 93- 93/94

Van der sar 94 - 94

Almunia 91- 91/92

Given 91 - 92

Friedel 90 - 90/91

Schwarzer 89 - 90/91

Hart 89 - 90

Cech 95 - 95

Howard 90- 90/91

Defenders

Evans 86 - 88/89

Insua 80 - 83/84

Rafael 77 - 84

Fabio 75 - 79/80

O shea 89 - 90

Agger 89 - 90

Cole 93 - 93

Bosingwa 93 - 93

Clichy 92 - 91/92

Gibbs 78 - 84

Jagielka 88 - 90

Lescott 90 -90/91

Richards 90 - 90/91

Hangeland 87 - 89/90

Knight 87 - 88

Laursen 90 -89/90

Midfeilders

Barry 91 - 92

Young 90 - 92/93

Carrick 91 - 92

Ronaldo 98 - 97

Giggs 92 - 92/93

Scholes 93 - 93/92

Gibson 86 - 88/89

Park 89 -91

Benayoun 89 -91

Alonso 93 - 93

Macherano 94 - 94

Riera 91 - 92

Gerrard 97 - 97

Kuyt 91 - 92/93

Mikel 91 - 92

Lampard 95 - 96

Ballack 93 - 92/91

Deco 93 - 91/90

Malouda 91 - 90

Fabregas 95 - 94

Diaby 88 - 91

Ramsey 84 - 87

Wilshire 74 - 81

Walcott 89 - 88

Vela 87 - 88

Ireland 89 - 91

Collison 74 - 84

Forwards

Berbatov 93 - 93/94

Rooney 96 - 96/95

Tevez 94 - 95

Torres 96 - 96/97

Bedneter 88 - 91

Adebayor 93 - 92/93

Van Persie 92 - 92/93

Anelka 92 - 93

Drogba 96 - 95/96

Defoe 90 - 90

Crouch 90 - 91

Keane 91 - 91/92

Pavlechenko 91 - 91/92

Robinho 96 - 95

agbonlahor 89 - 91/92

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

I think your Aston Villa ones are a bit high, Young 90-92/93? More likely 91 slight chance of 92.

Also Agbonlahor 89-91/92 is too high, 90 could be alright for him.

I agree with Mikel and Kuyt though, not so much Carrick he has a chance of a 93.

Diaby wont go straight from 88-91 :eek:, more likely 89. Hart will most probably stay the same but could decrease as he isnt playing anymore since the arrival of Given at Man City.

Evans 87/88, 89 too high straight from 86. Ronaldo probably will stay the same, not the same Ronaldo as last season but still quality (hate to say that). Alonso should be in for a 94 whereas you put him as staying at 93. Don't agree with Ramsey, maybe a small increase to 85 but definitely not 87.

Bendtner definitely not 91, he is poor. Keane probably more 91/90 as he had next to no playing time at Liverpool.

Lastly, as I can't be bothered to do anymore, Robinho is already rated 95, he cant go down from 96 to 95 if he already is 95 mate. :confused:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

I'll just comment on strikers,

Berbatov no way to 94.

Likewise Tevez to 95 when he doesnt play.

Torres to 97 injured way too much.

Bendtner to 91, seriously dude, i don't know if i should even give a response to this one.....:confused:

Pavlyuchenko to 92 not good enough.

Finally Robinho has to actually get to 96 before he can decrease.....:rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

I dont no if it has been doing anyone elses head in but when you go onto the ratings and there old ones so i decided to do a new one for England

Goal Keepers -

Reina 93- 93/94

Van der sar 94 - 94

Almunia 91- 91/92

Given 91 - 92man city poor form means he will probably stay

Friedel 90 - 90/91

Schwarzer 89 - 90/91

Hart 89 - 90given now first choice so i dont think any chance of increase especially due to being left out NT

Cech 95 - 95

Howard 90- 90/91

Defenders

Evans 86 - 88/89

Insua 80 - 83/84

Rafael 77 - 84

Fabio 75 - 79/80probably wont rise this time round

O shea 89 - 90

Agger 89 - 90

Cole 93 - 93

Bosingwa 93 - 93

Clichy 92 - 91/92will stay won't drop !! most minutes out of any arsenal defender i think so wont drop

Gibbs 78 - 84

Jagielka 88 - 90no way 90 !! 89 possible but straight to 90 i think it is unlikely

Lescott 90 -90/91not really a 91 player more like 90

Richards 90 - 90/91more chance of a drop to 89 than a rise so 89/90 not 90/91

Hangeland 87 - 89/90how would he rise from 87 -90 ?? unlikely

Knight 87 - 88

Laursen 90 -89/90

Midfeilders

Barry 91 - 92

Young 90 - 92/93more like 90-91 no way ever a 93

Carrick 91 - 92 91 >92/93

Ronaldo 98 - 97why would he drop :| ???

Giggs 92 - 92/93stay wont rise

Scholes 93 - 93/92drop to 92/ 91

Gibson 86 - 88/89

Park 89 -91probably a rise to 90 first not 91.

Benayoun 89 -91again 90 first not 91

Alonso 93 - 93

Macherano 94 - 94

Riera 91 - 92

Gerrard 97 - 97

Kuyt 91 - 92/93

Mikel 91 - 92

Lampard 95 - 96

Ballack 93 - 92/91

Deco 93 - 91/90

Malouda 91 - 90

Fabregas 95 - 94should stay not drop !

Diaby 88 - 9188>89/90 possibly no way a 91 !

Ramsey 84 - 87

Wilshire 74 - 81

Walcott 89 - 88

Vela 87 - 88

Ireland 89 - 91no chance 91 but a 90 yes.

Collison 74 - 84

Forwards

Berbatov 93 - 93/94

Rooney 96 - 96/95why /95 would he drop ?? i think not

Tevez 94 - 95NO CHANCE OF A RISE !!! SO MUCH MORE LIKELY TO DROP !!

Torres 96 - 96/97injury means wont rise.

Bedneter 88 - 91ARE YOU CRAZY NO WAY A 91 !!!!

Adebayor 93 - 92/93

Van Persie 92 - 92/93

Anelka 92 - 93

Drogba 96 - 95/96

Defoe 90 - 90

Crouch 90 - 91

Keane 91 - 91/92

Pavlechenko 91 - 91/92

Robinho 96 - 95 already a 95

agbonlahor 89 - 91/92

will only go to 90 IF THAT not a 91 !!!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

I'm not being funny pal but I think it will frustrate people more that you've created a new one - there's plenty of threads like this out there already.

Plus some of your predictions are way of the mark. For example' date=' Hart, Fabio, Young, Deco, Bendtner.[/quote']

Lmao all i say is HAHAHAHAHHA

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

why isnt der a ''minus rep'' button???!!! :P:p:p:p:p

Why should anyone get a "minus rep" for giving their opinion on an open forum which is free for debating :confused:. Feel free to give your opinions on the post and debate the ratings suggested, but such comments are derogatory and unnecessary as well as not adding anything constructive to the thread. Regardless of whether it was intended as a joke or not, it clearly is not called for. If you don't have anything useful to add to the thread, stay away, there's plenty of other threads for you to engage in :rolleyes::mad:

EDIT: That also goes for anyone else wishing to comment on the amount of EPL rating threads. If you don't want to read it, then don't :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

why should he drop ??

there have been many threads on this before and most agreed ronaldo should not drop

Well' date=' everyone is entitled to there opinion but the facts are his form has dipped badly in comparison to last season therefore his rating should drop.

He looks like he doesn't even want to play for Man U half the time.

Prefer Ribery to Ronaldo.

If he was gonna drop which he won't it would be 97 how on God's green earth could he drop by 2

He hasn't played half as good as he did last season. Fair enough 96 is a bit extreme but he should definately drop to 97.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

You have to remember that Man Utd have won two trophies since the last rating changes. With SM very keen to reward players who win individual and club awards, that will be taken into account. Of course he hasn't been as good as last season - it would be nigh-on impossible to replicate that sort of form. I think he'll stay, he's not doing that badly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

Well' date=' everyone is entitled to there opinion but the facts are his form has dipped badly in comparison to last season therefore his rating should drop.

He looks like he doesn't even want to play for Man U half the time.

Prefer Ribery to Ronaldo.

He hasn't played half as good as he did last season. Fair enough 96 is a bit extreme [b']but he should definately drop to 97[/b].

How should he definitly drop, in that case Kaka should be due a -3 drop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

He hasn't played half as good as he did last season. Fair enough 96 is a bit extreme but he should definately drop to 97.

if he played as well as last season a 99 would be on the cards but i am sure nobody can say ronaldo will drop: stats every possible game when fit

still scoring plently and top scorer for a club top of premier league, and previous champions league and premier league winners :

cannot see a drop if i am honest.

it would be as ridiculous as gerrard dropping to 96

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: New Topic Rating

What do you mean Ronaldo should drop, Worlds Best Player should be the best player in the game. He isn't even playing poorly and is doing everything a WINGER should do and despite being a winger he still is one of if not the top scorrer for his team right now. He was like Superman last season and straight away one season after you want to drop him? Not now, if he performs like this next season maybe then year, but not now. Look how long Kaka kept his 98 despite his team not even playing in the Champions league. The people saying he should drop just hate Cristiano Ronaldo and are jealous. Just because he is not playing the best it dosen't mean he should drop, he still is the current FIFA World Player Of The Year. This is how it should be: Kaka take Messi's place with 97 and Messi take 98 and Ronaldo stay. Just like Ronaldo rised and Kaka stayed with Ronaldinho dropping. 98 and 99 are ratings for the best players in the world.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...