The Fluffy Ligue 1 Ratings Thread

[Duncan 7,707]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Yep Believe it or not Bayern splashed 10M + on him (back in 2008 when money was way more valuable)

ye quite dumb, for arson i think it was

[Elohim 16,771]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Yep' date=' a bit similar to Breno (who's no more a footballer )

Not taking his job seriously enough (no denying his talent tho).[/quote']

Then you certainly know a hell of alot more about french football then me.

[vitor_mfc 3,862]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Then you certainly know a hell of alot more about french football then me.

he has an atitude problem, but comparing him to breno, is very untruthful. There is lots of top players with attitude problems that still manage to have good careers in football. That being said, balotelli is one of the most problematic players i have ever seen and plays for a top club in a top league, and for one of the worlds best national teams.

[frisky 4,731]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

he has an atitude problem' date=' but comparing him to breno, is very untruthful[/b']. There is lots of top players with attitude problems that still manage to have good careers in football. That being said, balotelli is one of the most problematic players i have ever seen and plays for a top club in a top league, and for one of the worlds best national teams.

I fully agree with this. Was too slow to think of any other names at that time so put Breno's.

Breno was an extreme case I give you that but from what I've heard about Ayew he too has got some major attitude problems like many of the young footballers like Taarabt, Balotelli etc. I think Balotelli would be counted as one of the best strikers in the world if it was not for his attitude and the same can be said about Taarabt, tremendous potential getting wasted (tho I've noticed a marked improvement in his attitude of late), so I can't really see Ayew leaving a mark on the game unless he changes his attitude.

[kev-nffc 171]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Will Montpellier still get rises for being league champions?

Normally you would expect a starting 11 rated mostly 87-89 get at least +1s throughout for winning the league. But as they dont seem to have started so good and are struggling in the champions league are any of their players still guaranteed a rise?

[abidicus 1,354]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Will Montpellier still get rises for being league champions?

Normally you would expect a starting 11 rated mostly 87-89 get at least +1s throughout for winning the league. But as they dont seem to have started so good and are struggling in the champions league are any of their players still guaranteed a rise?

they had their 'post champions of Ligue 1' review already. Any further review will take their on-going league form and position into consideration. So, for example, a regular and important player like Cabella will get a +1. A lot of members of the team will stay, if they continue in their current form.

[Hayden19 6,995]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

they had their 'post champions of Ligue 1' review already. Any further review will take their on-going league form and position into consideration. So' date=' for example, a regular and important player like Cabella will get a +1. A lot of members of the team will stay, if they continue in their current form.[/quote']

Cabella has 3 goals and 4 assists, pretty sure a 2+ is in order

[lincvillan 1,795]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Cabella has 3 goals and 4 assists' date=' pretty sure a 2+ is in order [/quote']

I hope so!!!!! Would help me out lots!!

[barnabyd 2,547]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

they had their 'post champions of Ligue 1' review already. Any further review will take their on-going league form and position into consideration. So' date=' for example, a regular and important player like Cabella will get a +1. A lot of members of the team will stay, if they continue in their current form.[/quote']

They haven't been reviewed since they won

[abidicus 1,354]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

They were reviewed in March, with 9 games left in the season. At that point , Montpellier were riding high, and players like Cabella got a +3. Since their 12/13 season has been sluggish, it's their league position that will prevent many rises other than small increments this time around. I would say Cabella has a mild chance of getting a +2. Was he called up to the French squad?

[Steven. M 10]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

They were reviewed in March' date=' with 9 games left in the season. At that point , Montpellier were riding high, and players like Cabella got a +3. Since their 12/13 season has been sluggish, it's their league position that will prevent many rises other than small increments this time around. I would say Cabella has a mild chance of getting a +2. Was he called up to the French squad?[/quote']

Level on points with PSG and four points clear of Lille is hardly riding high.

[-JMH- 8,575]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Level on points with PSG and four points clear of Lille is hardly riding high.

check ur history. for a club like montpellier, they were so much higher than expected they were getting nosebleeds.

it was kinda like wigan winning the prem....

[barnabyd 2,547]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Is Bedimo's chance of rising gone dy'a think? I have him on 7777 and I might get rid of him but if he then rises it will be such a waste

[Steven. M 10]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

check ur history. for a club like montpellier' date=' they were so much higher than expected they were getting nosebleeds.

it was kinda like wigan winning the prem....[/quote']

His point was that they'd pretty much won the league, not that they weren't expected to. I'm well aware that it was a shock.

[MaoaM 9,865]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

You guys think Bastos' 90 rating is safe?

Started the season well before getting injured. Also any idea when he will be fit again

[Zakkoo 2,889]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Wouldnt mind hearing some opinions on N'Koulous possible rating for the up and coming changes from you guys?

[Singaporean Pundit 225]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Adrien Rabiot of PSG, in for a rise? A future world beater perhaps?

[Elohim 16,771]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Wouldnt mind hearing some opinions on N'Koulous possible rating for the up and coming changes from you guys?

I don't rate him as high as others tbh' date=' people say he's the best CB in Ligue 1 etc.[/color']

Not even close.

I can see him rising tho, if he continues to play like he has and if Marseille continues to perform good he'll rise.

Adrien Rabiot of PSG' date=' in for a rise? A future world beater perhaps?[/quote']

Yeah he'll get a smaller rise, not alot tho.

And it's too early to say.

[kdBz 3,232]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

You guys think Bastos' 90 rating is safe?

Started the season well before getting injured. Also any idea when he will be fit again

He'll be safe. Not sure when he'll return though.

Wouldnt mind hearing some opinions on N'Koulous possible rating for the up and coming changes from you guys?

Smal chance at +1' date=' unlikely though. End of season maybe, he's had some good and average games.

Adrien Rabiot of PSG, in for a rise? A future world beater perhaps?

I would like to think so, a +3/4 would suffice according to Elohim here. EDIT: he must play a lot though

Is Bedimo's chance of rising gone dy'a think? I have him on 7777 and I might get rid of him but if he then rises it will be such a waste

He's been average' date=' so no, I wouldn't say he'd rise.[/color']

[Arroto 1,098]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

anyone has any insights on neal maupay of nice? is he here to stay?

[abidicus 1,354]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Level on points with PSG and four points clear of Lille is hardly riding high.

Yes it is. And yes it was.

[Caleb 8,872]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Bar his injuries, is Lovren showing promise of reaching 90 by the end of the season?

Thanks.

[kdBz 3,232]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

anyone has any insights on neal maupay of nice? is he here to stay?

Not quite sure' date=' but if he gets some more games for them, I think maybe a small rise isn't out of the question..

Looks a decent boy though.

Bar his injuries, is Lovren showing promise of reaching 90 by the end of the season?

Thanks.

He has only really shown that promise in 2 games, the Ajaccio(amazing in that one) and a solid reliable performance in the Brest match.

Don't think he'll rise this season unless he (and Lyon for that matter) improves markedly and stops his poor discipline from overshadowing some good defensive showings.

[Caleb 8,872]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

He has only really shown that promise in 2 games' date=' the Ajaccio(amazing in that one) and a solid reliable performance in the Brest match.

Don't think he'll rise this season unless he (and Lyon for that matter) improves markedly and stops his poor discipline from overshadowing some good defensive showings.[/quote']

Thanks buddy sorry I got to spread first. Would it be wise to swap Rami for him? I believe Rami has peaked? My other defenders are Hummels, Sakho, Jones, Alaba, Yanga-Mbiwa. I play three at the back.

[kdBz 3,232]

Re: The Fluffy Ligue 1 Thread

Thanks buddy sorry I got to spread first. Would it be wise to swap Rami for him? I believe Rami has peaked? My other defenders are Hummels' date=' Sakho, Jones, Alaba, Yanga-Mbiwa. I play three at the back.[/quote']

Lol who cares about the rep? It's the thought that counts

Rami has obviously peaked, but based on performances i wouldn't do that. has been fairly decent though, exception being the Mallorca and Betis games. Plus Lovren is an injury crock, as you pointed out, and has only been marginally better then Rami.

However, for someone playing 3 at the back, 6 is already an awful lot of defenders.. I would try to swap Rami for a defender OTHER than Lovren or use him to strengthen another part of your squad.